I expected a little more from a high end steak restaurant. I ordered a medium well steak. It came out bleeding. I asked to have it returned for a medium well. They clearly cooked the same steak, burned the outside and half was well done and half still medium well. I asked to have it returned. The "general manager" came over, I say manager in quotes because he didn't even introduce himself or say a word because he just took my plate and walked away. I had to ask my waiter who he was. I expect more out of a steakhouse. This isn't a typical neighborhood steak place, this is supposed to be a high end steak restaurant. On a side note, our waiter was fantastic, my complaint is with the food and the manager not the wait staff. read more

This restaurant's strong point is its interior design, atmosphere & Architecture! It is so unbelievably romantic. As I said in my tip is an ideal place for a proposal. There is also plenty of space for large groups. Very Art Deco. Dim romantic lighting design. The bar is articulated with yellow light accents. It reminds me of a larger fancy more modern day Bookbinders of Philadelphia. Very classy and extremely upscale. The staff was friendly and attentive. The interior is a A+++. The food is also good I would rate it B+/A- as far as creativity and taste. I am a little hard to please as I live in the culinary capitol of the world, Philadelphia and I also am into many very complex spices. I eat a ton of exotic Asian dishes usually. But if you like American and Steak houses it is pretty awesome. I am also posting a bunch of photos because if you read my other reviews I am very into photography and like picking restaurants for their interiors. Well at the time of this posting there was only one interior pic. So here you go I am posting more! read more

See all

The food was just ok. I had certain requirements and request which were never fulfilled. Obviously a disconnect between hotel and restaurant. I noticed other people's reservations disappear when they arrived. Some even had email reservations and their spots were lost. I'm not impressed with this place. read more

American Cut is not what it used to be. They don't prepare the Caesar Salad tableside anymore. The $14 salad that arrived at the table was soggy and almost devoid of flavor. The manager took it off the bill. Then, our steaks came out. The porterhouse, and both NY strip steaks, were overcooked. In addition, the porterhouse was completely under seasoned. The manager gave us free desserts. We didn't want dessert. So, I ordered a Glenfiddich 12. Instead, I was given Johnny Walker Red. The whole experience was very disappointing. We've visited American Cut since the Revel opened. It's now off our list. Spend your money elsewhere. I wish I had read the recent reviews before we went. I wouldn't have wasted $500. read more

Had a nice dinner there last night with my coworkers. Server was very attentive and the steak and apps were very good. Would dine there again in the future read more

See all

Good atmosphere, chopped salad and tuna appetizers were very good. Entrees took quite a while to come to the table. Not worth the wait, 8oz filet, and NY strip, pretty awful. Barely above room temperature, no taste. Left more than half uneaten. Waiter did ask if there was anything we wanted done, but wasn't really happy we were complaining. Literally dropped the bill on the table. Manager adjusted the price after I asked to speak with him. Too many better choices to dine at in the area. read more

Disappointed in this place. Stayed at Ocean Resort and went here for a Saturday night dinner. Can honestly say I don't think in 30 years I've ever sent back a meal. We are not picky people. Girlfriend's steak was startlingly cold to the touch. It felt like it had been sitting out for some time. My steak was ordered medium rare and was so raw?/undercooked in the middle that the waitress even seemed appalled. I'm even fine with rare steak but it legitimately looked like raw, uncooked meat. The server did work quickly to get the meat cooked further (microwaved?) but it just wasn't the quality that is expected of a $50+ steak. We also didn't even get anything comped from our bill. Most likely because we were polite and nice about it. A shame that you have to be rude and loudly complain to be offered a comp or anything for bad service! Will not go back. read more

The service was ok at best. The steaks however, were not up to standard. The tomahawk steak I wanted medium rare, it was basically medium well. It was tasteless, bland, and definitely not worth the price of $130. On top of that, it is advertised as 40 oz (the bone is more than half) and good for two, I could have eaten two myself. Unfortunately, I would not recommend this place. Go to Applebee's or Chili's for a better steak. read more

DISAPPOINTING.. if I can write this review w no stars I would .. I normally only give great reviews and it takes alot to disappoint me... Highlights were bread (that took so long to get after asking 5x) delicious French Fries - very good Cocktails-- if the service was good I could of had more but since the service was so horrible , I couldn't.. even get refills. My steak was COLD .. for 58.00 it should not be cold .... and had no flavor... for 58.00 a steak .. and the service should be good even after speaking to the Manager nothing changed . He reheated my steak so the inside was ice cold and outside was warm On a Wednesday night at these prices everything should of been good at least ... not horrible.. dont waster your time ... Amada is so much better , even Dolce Mare is excellent.. going here is a huge disappointment.. I will never return there are so many other places to spend that kind of money read more

Arrived at six for a meal before the 8 pm B52's show. I had made a reservation unforts it was for the night prior. The maitre'd graciously sat us in the lounge with full dinner service. Nicky was our server and meal service began well. We ordered raw bar, apps, salads and dinner along with 2 rounds drinks. After ordering all service seemed to cease. Nicky essentially disappeared. Our raw bar order arrived 30 minutes in. That was the fastest portion of the meal to arrive. Some apps never appeared. The tables all around us were never bussed and we sat surrounded by others filth. After over 90 minutes I had to seek out Nicky to remind her we had a show to make at 8 and could we please get our food. The rest was rushed, the food had obviously sat in the kitchen for awhile. No one asked how my steak was cooked. My surf and turf filet minion was ordered medium rare and came medium well. Then the server said my cc was declined despite my cc stating no charge was presented to them. I paid cash for the $351 bill and will never return. Do not eat here. read more

Service? Stellar. Food? One star. I likely could have had more satisfaction from taking a wad of hundreds out of my wallet and lighting them on fire. Oysters-meh; lobster bisque-absolutely the worst I've ever had (a can of Campbell's would have been a better bet). Steak-was supposed to be medium but was well done. Mac and Cheese Du Jour- don't even ask. Even the cocktails sucked. Either they need to revamp the menu/chef or I don't see how it survives other than by luring first time suckers like me. read more

food was God Awful. The lobster bisque was the worst I've ever tasted, there was no flavor, please save yourself the money and don't order this. Both myself and my spouse ordered the filet mingon...both were burnt flavorless prices of meat. To top it off, the Mac and cheese was one of the worst I've ever tasted...it was a dry mouthful of breadcrumbs...God Awful. We've had better diner food than what was presented to us. We regret ever booking a reservation at this restaurant. Please don't make the same mistake we did. read more

Excellent dining experience. We sat at the bar (super comfortable) which has floor to ceiling windows and sweeping views of the Atlantic Ocean. Perfect for a date night. The managers and bartender were friendly and attentive -- and they made the perfect drink/dinner recommendations for us. Left super full and happy; will definitely be back. read more

We love steakhouses and figured we would try American Cut since we were staying at Ocean Resort. We arrived on Friday night, and the place was almost empty (bad sign). First, we ordered steak tartare. It was very good, but they topped it with a hard-boiled egg instead of the traditional raw egg yolk. This is really a rookie move for a real steakhouse, but OK. We ordered a filet and a strip for dinner. The filet came out OK. Flavor was bland. The strip was supposed to be black and blue, topped with blue cheese crumbles. They forgot the crumbles and the steak was nearly cooked to medium. We didn't send anything back because we were starving. Also, sending back a black and blue steak to add melted crumbles would ruin it, assuming that it had been prepared properly in the first place, but it wasn't. Shame on me for assuming that. The experience wasn't terrible, but when you're paying $300+ for two people, it'd better be good. I would go to Vic and Anthony's, Chart House, Gallagher's or even Mortons before coming here. read more

$105 for a price fix menu that includes about 4 ozs of steak and a split appetizer, no dessert. Basically the worst deal I have ever experienced at a restaurant. Servers were really polite but otherwise feel ethically obligated to tell people to run away like it is the plague. Worst deal in town. Any other chain steak house will provide you the same quality meal with a greater quantity. Don't go here. read more

I wish I could rate this restaurant less than one. Awful awful awful. We are here 5 years ago and had an amazing meal. There were 4 of us tonight - we ordered the hot/cold seafood tower, which was decent. Then ordered the porterhouse 40oz flambé style. The first steak was well done. Awful. Sent it back. The next steak came out cooked correctly however no seasoning at all. The chef was obviously insulted and took a page out of Hell's Kitchen and penalized the customer. They comped some of it but we still walked out - hungry and $300 later. Even the staff here is embarrassed to work here. Not worth the money. There are so many other places to eat in AC. The peanut m&ms and Doritos I bought in the gift shop earlier are sounding amazing right now. read more

While the food is very good and the restaurant lovely with a nice ocean view, the clientele is appalling . If I am spending $50 on a steak ( not even with sides) , in a restaurant that has a dress code of business casual, I should not be subjected to other customers in bathing suits and wife beaters dropping foul language at the top of their lungs . Needless to say they have lost this customer and any of our friends . The waiter was very nice and apologetic however the manager could not be bothered with our concern. He barely looked up from his ipad. More than disappointed i am furious . Completely ruined what was supposed to be a nice birthday dinner out. read more

I do not write reviews of restaurants (Good or Bad), but this is one i could not let go due to the lack of care and fundamental errors that were made. From the moment we checked in with the hostess, this meal turned out to be the worst dining experience I have probably had. Upon checking in at our reservation time at 8.30pm we were told our table was just being finalized and it will be a couple of minutes and take a seat. So took a seat next to the hostess stand, however, 15 minutes later and after 3 more reservations who arrived after us had been sat, I inquired further as to where our table was (the table we were actually sat at had been free since we sat waiting), we were again told it would be a couple of minutes. We were eventually sat at 8.50pm (a full 20 minutes after our reservation). There was no apology from the hostess, and in fact we were made to feel like we were in the wrong. We would have happily sat at the bar enjoying a a drink if we had been forewarned of a wait by the hostess staff. It didn't get any better. Upon seating at our table it took our waiter just shy of 10 minutes for us to receive our menus which is unacceptable, which was in full view of management staff who lurked nearby at the end of the row (just location where they congregated). My partner and I both ordered steaks medium. Whilst my partner's steak was cooked nicely, my steak had been grossly overcooked, but more so the center of the steak had a mulch texture which suggested it was a poor cut of the meat or even worse might have expired. I have never sent food back, and in this experience i didn't, however, in hindsight i made a mistake and the food should have sent back. Whilst the appetizer and my partners steak was to standard, the service again faltered. To add further insult to our experience, we sat at our table for over 15 minutes with our finished plates at our table. Our waiter had looked pre-occupied all night, and at this time it was clear to see why as he was setting up for a table of 20 guests who had not arrived. However, if our waiter is busy, i would still expect (for a level of restaurant they are trying to pitch themselves as) that a bus boy or another waiter would help out. We also had two different senior members of the staff (e.g. management) come up to our table and ask how our meal was when we were finished and still neglected to clear the plates, and due to our location This restaurant has a long way to go to live up to the lofty expectations it sets itself. Management do not know how to run a restaurant, waiter staff are too busy and lack care particularity for a table of 2, and the hostess staff need to be properly trained in hospitality. Go to this restaurant at your own risk, it is not worth the money. Even if the service had been impeccable, the prices charged are equivalent of dining at Peter Lugers or Wolfgangs in Manhattan, however, the standard is nowhere near. Much better options elsewhere in the hotel (such as Amada) and nearby outside of the resort. read more

Food was OK but over priced. Reservation was for 9 and food came after 11. Ladies bathroom was disgusting. Didn't have mint for mojito. Very noisy. Overall mediocre experience at premium price. read more

Went with a group of 6. Ordered a bone in rib eye medium. Got it basically raw and chewy to the point where you couldn't swallow a bite. Ended up eating dinner at the snack shop. Another person in the group ordered a lobster tail that had to be returned due to being undercooked as well. Going to old homestead next time. read more

Worst steakhouse on the East Coast. 3.5 hours for a horrible steak and utterly disappointing experience. Waiter also spilled a full Martini on our friend and his Australian sweater (although that was funny and the bright spot of the meal). One steak was sent back twice to get cooked properly, sides were cold and steak was just bad. I don't normally write Yelp reviews but owe it to the community to post this. Not even out of the restaurant and posting this based on such a poor experience. read more

Extremely slow service! Food was ok, think it was a bit overpriced for what you get at other steakhouses

If I could give zero stars I would. This restaurant is dressed up as upscale / fine dining, but in reality it would be hard to find another restaurant with such a poor kitchen. I've never been as upset to pay for a meal as I was with this place. The service was not the issue. If you know good food avoid this place like the plague. read more

Where should I begin? A creepy male waiter who literally blocked me from the bathroom? Another waiter who told me the oysters were frozen? A completely gross and unseasoned steak that me and my husband got sick from? AVOID AVOID AVOID read more

Very disappointed. My husband and I stayed at Ocean for two nights for our anniversary. We decided on American Cut for our anniversary dinner . We ordered the table side prepared porter house steak ( 120$) , twice baked potato , lobster Mac n cheese and Caesar salad . The Caesar salad was so soaked in a bitter dressing it was non edible . We sent the salads back and they took it off the bill . The steak and sides were brought out and placed on the table at the same time the table side preparation began ...... the waiter prepared a sauce with some spices and herbs which was cool to see but the food was getting cold while he was doing that . Once he was finished and we began to eat, the steak was cold . Apart from the steak being cold, it was not seasoned at all and was overcooked ( we ordered medium well) . We both asked for salt and pepper to season it ourselves . The twice baked potato was just ok . It required salt as well and the lobster Mac n cheese was also very bland . Our waiter Adem was very nice and attentive . The only good part of the meal was the bread and vegetable cream cheese spread . Overall it was a disappointment and we definitely would not recommend this restaurant . read more

CUSTOMER SERVICE - We made rezzies for three, 3 weeks ago for 7pm because 8pm wasn't available. Online showed the place was booked up so we called and they confirmed 7pm was all they had, so we took it. The day of dinner (last night) we again call during the day to explain to them that my brother was in a big meeting and changing the dinner to 8pm would help tremendously. They again reiterated that the place was booked solid and they can only do 7pm, so we accepted. If the place is booked, its booked. I totally understand. We get there at 6:55 and the place has about 8 tables booked. They seat us. We look at each other and all think the same thing. If this place isn't filled up by 8pm we are going to have a word with them. Just as we thought, 8pm came. We let another 15 minutes go by and this place is still only at about 15-20% capacity. We could have been sat at 8pm with a party of 40 if we wanted to. My brother called over the hostess and explained to her how we tried over and over again about getting in at 8 and they assured us there was nothing they can do, now take a look around. You could have shot an arrow through that place and wouldn't have hit anyone. So the girl says, ill have my manager Randy come over. About 5 minutes later, some guy walks over to the table and says is everything ok? We say yeah. He continues to look at us. We look at him. Never introduces himself. He then says, do you guys have a complaint or am I just here for small chit chat? Turns out this guy was the manager she sent over but it wasn't Randy. He was a different manager. He had a beard. Anyhow, we explain to him the deal and he says, yes he's aware of an issue that the system is telling people that the place is booked when its really not. He said the computer shows full capacity when only 20% is full. So if they are aware of this, when we call and speak to an actual person, why wasn't this rectified? Why didn't they manually override the glitch to accommodate us? Ill tell you why. Because he is full of sh_t. They just want to keep prime time for dining open for walk ins while the suckers who booked a month ahead of time are locked into a time they don't want nor never wanted. Complete nonsense. This guy was unprofessional, he was arrogant and rude. And despite that, if he sent over a round of drinks as an "oops we messed up", I wouldn't be on Yelp writing anything bad. I'd be giving him a better review. I know mistakes happen, but when they do, you make up for it. FOOD - Food was sub par. Steak was ok, Lamb chops were ok. Certainly not enough meat. Asparagus, boiled and tasteless. Needs to be blanched. Mash potatoes were ok. Biscuits were tasteless. Drinks were again just blah. Didn't order dessert because nothing else was great so why take a chance. AMBIANCE- Ambiance was lacking. Had no feeling to this place. A funeral home would have been a better place to eat this dinner. SERVICE - The one good thing about this place was our waiter. His name was Joe N. He was super knowledgable about the menu, recipes, ingredients, wine, etc. He was great at his job, professional, accommodating and super nice. This place just opened a month ago in a new casino but this isn't their first rodeo. They better shape up and they better do it soon or else they are in for a rude awakening. read more

Disappointment doesn't begin to describe the food. It's overpriced for mediocre quality. Had to send our steak back twice because it was too overcooked and then came out almost raw. They restricted reservation times but when we got there the place was half empty. read more

My wife and I went here for nice dinner. We ordered a tomahawk steak for two, a vegetable, and a large potato. We ordered the steak medium rare. The potato and vegetable came a few minutes before the steak. The potato for a $12 potato was a tiny mini potato. The beers they served were completely flat. They had zero carbonation. They were likely very old. The steak eventually came out, and the steak was all cut up and it was completely raw. The middle dark purple and ice cold. The waiter saw this and said "that's raw." 15 minutes later, the steak came back colder and just as raw. At this point, the tiny potato and terrible tasting vegetable were done. We were left staring at a cold, purple, raw chunk of overpriced $135 meat sitting on the table even less appealing than the first time it came out. Not only this, but had we been able to eat this gastrointestinal distress inducing raw meat, we were only given butter knives to attempt to cut through it. I would expect something like that from a rundown Perkins, but for a premier 5* Steakhouse, this is completely unacceptable. read more

You've gotta try there complimentary everything biscuits and cream cheese/ butter. Delicious! Our serving team were very attentive and nice. Food was excellent. Yes prices are a little high but if you split it it's not bad. Especially the sides. They're huge! Plenty to share with. read more

The service here was exceptional. The bread was absolutely delicious, we decided to order the French fries and asparagus as sides/appetizers. The fries alone, were really good. Could potentially be the best fries we've ever had (also came with a special sauce). My friend ordered the tuna and said it was very good, not fishy, perfectly seared, and "like butter". I ordered the Ny strip steak which was absolutely delicious. Full of flavor,& perfectly cooked to the requests medium-well. However, the outside of my steak was a bit burnt, but I still enjoyed the overall taste of it despite the burnt taste, which was a little overruling by the end. I also ordered one king crab leg, and I wasn't thrilled, I always taste seafood before putting it into butter, and felt that this crab wasn't enjoyable without the butter. The butter mixture was a huge comeback bc it was absolutely delicious with it. However despite the burnt steak & not so tasty bare lobster, I really enjoyed my meal, the good overruled the bad! My date completely agreed, so amazing job and would be back again! read more

This review is for location at Atlantic City. I hope owner/chef Mark Forgione see this review because ac location definitely need some change.. I won't write long review.. short and simple.. blond girl working as hostess is very friendly but dumbest hostess I ever seen.. black hostess definitely has attitude problem. Manager name Randy was so frustrated to the point I saw him telling customer straight up nothing he can do with gesture of pulling his hair.. when we sat down at 11:20ish pm with 10:30pm reservation, drinking glasses all smelled very fish... even our waiter agreed and changed to new set.. on to the food.. looks like chef Mark Forgione is very proud of their steaks.. well guess what?? One of the worst steak I ever had.. ordered porterhouse for two..American cut's porterhouse can not be compared to peter Luger.. American cut's porterhouse steak was 1 out of 10. My girl and I didn't eat half the steak.. ny sirloin... chewy as hell.. fillet mignon was okay I guess according to friend.. $90 appetitizer sampler for two.. such a waste of money.. best thing I had at this establishment was Their French fries with sauce which came with it and Fiji water.. bill was little over $400 with tip.. this meal was not even worth $10. Never will come back to this place ever again!! read more

Food was just ok and the service was poor. Much better choices to choose from.

Steaks were well done (ordered 1 rare and 1 black and blue). When asking for a manager he whispered an apology and before we could say anything, darted off and never returned. Good ambiance for drinks only - would not recommend for dinner to anyone. read more

Very disappointing. My review would have been 0 but the service was attentive and I cannot blame the servers for the food. The steak was bland (if I have to use steak sauce on a $52 NY strip you know there's a problem). The lump crab Mac and cheese didn't have any lump crab and was super salty. However they offered a new one which was better. The apps were just okay. I won't go back read more

Horrible! The service and food equally suck. The manager couldn't manage a Burger King.

The people giving this place one or two stars must have an agenda because I've eaten here several times and the service and food have been fantastic. I've eaten here both when it was the Revel and now the Ocean and my experiences have all been the same: great! read more

This is the first time I have been there since it opened. Last time I was there it was the revel. At that time everything was terrible. This time the service was good very attentive. I had the bone in rib eye not bad , but for the size and money you will do better at the Capital grill read more

One of the worst meals we have ever been served! Pastrami steak not as described by waitress. Veal chop awful. Not sure how wa cooked but It wasnt grilled and at best 10 oz.. it was cold on delivery as were everything but fries. Do not order the carrot side. It is a single carrot for $16. We do not mind the price if food is deserving. The food was bad, they lied about portion size which was ok cause the food sucked. Also charged more than was indicated on the menu. Did I mention the food was aweful! read more

This place was not the best for one reason only which unfortunately gives it 2 stars for me . The employees ! I'll get to that in a second but want to first say food was good . I had the filet mignon , bf had the ny strip . Nothing out of the ordinary steak house but still good . Now as far as employees I have never seen so many miserable people in one place . Their attitudes were very poor , unfriendly and honestly put somewhat of a damper on the entire experience. It's like they did not want to be there and it wasn't just our waiter it was every single person that we encountered . On top of this they were very slow . I personally think what makes a place outstanding has to do with the service you receive and the way the person or people waiting on you make you feel . Please give them the proper customer service training , no one should have to be around such negative energy on a night out that's meant to be fun . read more

The worst steak house ever period! Avoid at all costs, the steak was over cooked and lacked any flavor. We also ordered 2 seafood towers that was not fresh at all. read more