Absolutely fantastic... pleasant service and a clean open eating area. But the shinning star are the bagels which are made on premises. I wish I would have supplied a pic but I ate the bagel up in a flash. You can't go wrong by coming here. read more

My first time actually dining in at Old bagel. It has never let me down. I'm not sure when I started to really get into bagels but this place definitely helps lol. I will be back! read more

See all

The staff is so helpful. The food is consistently very good. Cinnamon rolls are very good.

Ruben is banging. Quick service. Bagels almost $2 each, kinda pricey, but people always in there so must be good. Lots of parking. Minimal aesthetic. read more

huge fan of old school bagel but this location is extremely disappointin. I ordered a DoorDash and my sandwich had old smoked salmon on it, the meat was literally brown. I will not be coming back. read more

Love the service and the food. But good grief we have a Wednesday meeting at 6 every week and they always open later than 6. Today it's 6:20 and no sign of opening. The sign says 6. Oh well they lost 6 peoples business. read more

Had some time to kill and wanted a delicious bagel sandwhich so stopped into this chain. I had a basic breakfast bagel with sausage, egg and cheese on a jalapeno cheddar bagel. It was tasty. Nothing spectacular but still good. The egg part is kinda weird and tastes a bit spongy and fake but the deliciousness of the jalapeno cheddar bagel made up for it. I also tried a white chocolate mocha and got the big one because the girl at the counter said it has 4 shots of espresso in it. I'm not sure about that because it did not give me that much of a buzz. The taste was just okay, not great. I would not order coffee there again. Overall okay experience. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Inside - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

Who called these the best bagels in Oklahoma and who said they were old school? When you do a hand rolled, boiled bagel, the outer shell has a glossy, egg shell texture. In this case, the outer shell of the bagel is soft. The flavor is okay but if you take a plain bagel and just eat it as is, it doesn't have that specific flavor that a true NY bagel has. Toppings are sparse. There is nothing wrong with these bagels. They beat buying them at a grocery store or Dunkin Donuts. If you are in OKC and want a bagel, they will suffice. I wouldn't declare these the best in Oklahoma. There are a couple of places in Tulsa that are better. I would actually drive for that bagel. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Everything Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

I love bagels and this is a great place hidden in northern OKC that makes them fresh and good! If you love bagels, this is the place to go. Ambiance isn't terrific but they tried. Great breakfast sandwiches too. read more

Torn between 3-4. My son and I both agreed on the 3 for this reason...... everything is premade and slapped into a microwave.......I think there are 6 of those.....A foodie/junkie wants some cooked fresh food..... The bagels mine you were good... I had the breakfast. Has ham egg and cheese but slap in that microwave and it gets a greasiness...... workers super friendly and I do love a strong Nicaraguan coffee..... read more

See all

They're generally very friendly and helpful. The bagels are pretty close to the standard Jersey/NY bagel. Just make sure they don't throw it in the microwave. Yes, that's happened. read more

I'm just so over ordering a toasted bagel and getting a limp, doughy, untoasted bagel. I love old school and have come here for YEARS, but it is just so lacking in consistency and it is really irritating. read more

Really mediocre. In spite of specifically requesting my bagel with lox and cream cheese be toasted, the bagel was microwaved into a spongy blob. Stingy with the cream cheese and the capers were all concentrated on the middle, not even distributed. I had to pull the sandwich apart to adjust. read more

If I could give them 0 stars but I can't When I ordered online there was no option to not order with out cream cheese the option says pick cream cheese or select none that's what I did they put so much on my sandwich and don't offer to REMAKE IT OR GIVE ME MY MONEY BACK SHE LITERALLY TOLD ME I HAD TO KEEP IT I WILL NEVER COMBE BACK HERE OR ORDER HERE AGAIN THIS IS NOT ACCEPTABLE. I also spoke to a manager who was very rude and not understanding at all! Now I'm stuck with food I'm not gone eat and they have my money if you want to order here make sure you go in because they don't care about their customers at all. NEVER RETURNING!!!!!!! Ok Never coming back here read more

Came in for a quick lunch and everything was so good. Quality, good ingredients and tasted awesome.

Bagel was hard to enjoy because I prefer to put butter on my bagel and they only had margarine. GROSS! Coffee was good. Clean environment. Probably would not go back because of the margarine and butter situation. Even Panera has REAL butter... read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Great selection - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

I've always loved Bagel Cafe. It's long been a favorite of my family and friends. However, my experience today was beyond disappointing. Not only was my entire order incorrect (ordered 5 bagels), but my food was inedible because the bagels were burned so bad. I didn't even want my bagel toasted to begin with! See attached pictures. The staff at the time were incredibly young and incompetent. I could barely understand the boy who answered the phone. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone with the current staff. When I went to pick up my order, there was a customer yelling at one of employees for messing up his order. Another lady complained that she had been waiting on a bagel for 1 for over 30 minutes. I hope the Bagel Cafe I love takes the time to evaluate their employees and do better. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Best bagels in Oklahoma. With numerous locations available, there should be one near you. The bagels are made fresh daily and there is an array of tasty cream cheese options to accompany them. They also have a great lunch menu filled with sandwiches. Hands down my favorite bagels are the Everything and the Asiago Cheese. Gently warmed they are absolutely delicious plain, toasted or with cream cheese. The Cowboy Club is our family favorite for lunch. Stop by and give it a try. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

What in the hell did I pay for? the picture might cause confusion because I ordered a toasted everything bagel with cream cheese.... Left with this. I suppose I will chalk this up to a donation and will never return. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Toasted everything bagel with cream cheese? - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

It was just "ok". I visit Old School Bagel in Tulsa and love it. Even with ordering a toasted bagel it wasn't warm and the ham on it was placed on basically half of it. I'd try them again just to see if it was an off day. read more

Haven't been to this location in years. The remodel is fun. Very open. Cute seating areas by the fireplace. Workers were nice and helpful. Wish there was Saturday football on the TVs instead of the Roku fish tank. Employees said that's all they are allowed to show read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - the inside of the restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

I have a been a fan of this restaurant for years. I have never been to this location. The interior is really big and had a nice crowd. It took about 5 minutes for my order which is longer than other location. However it is is just as yummy. I can NOT wait for the location on N. Penn to open read more

To say things have gone downhill at this location would be a grave understatement. 9 times out of 10 the cream cheese I order on my bagel is too little or completely forgotten. The bagels are smaller than they've ever been and such poor quality. Dying for us to get another bagel shop or at least something else to choose from. Give us anything with BETTER bagels & BETTER cream cheese. Dying for Shug's in Dallas to come here or even a fkn Einstein's. Dear Lord anything else. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - The smallest thinnest non looking and feeling (can't wait to eat ) bagel. This picture is too good to even express how trash it tasted. - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

How does a bagel shop not know how to toast a damn bagel??? How they manage to burn it and yet it's cold is beyond me. Very disappointing as I would happily stop in for a bagel twice a week if they had a clue. What a waste of money. read more

2 slices of Turkey on an Old Smokey bagel...pathetic. There should be at least 6 slices for the price charged. Extremely disappointed! read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

I have never eaten at this place before today, I had to order it on-line, along with the rest of our office. I am going to tell you right now, I will not eat here again. If their website is this Fked up. I don't want to deal with these people anymore. Why don't they just have a freaking menu option that says MENU. WTF, it's just not good business. I don't want to have to jump through hoops to order a fking bagel. Geez. Plus all the pictures, and and all the stories about yourselves, thats fine to a point but it's in the way, how about you guys get back to your business, and get a new website creator to straighten out your pathetic site. I don't want to go through your entire history, plus your locations are all thrown into one confusing pile. Good Luck with your business, but I will not deal with you people ever again. read more

I usually love this place. They are friendly enough but the last two sandwiches I got to go, had cheese and lettuce no turkey at all. Bread, cheese, soggy lettuce and Mayo. Yummmmmmmmmm, not. What a waste of money. Further, you can't even write in or contact anyone about an incorrect order. Won't be going back. read more

Large, open dining area with tables spaced out abs plenty of space for crowded lunch rushes. Decals in the floor ensure people will keep their distance instead of breathing down your neck, because that crap STILL happen in December during a pandemic. There is also a cozy seating g area that I will consider occupying once I'm comfortable being indoors with strangers, so *maybe* this time in 2021? Ordered our bagels to go and to toast at home. Always delicious, right amount of chewiness and plenty of flavor, even without the yummy cream cheese. But really, why would you eat a bagel without cream cheese??‍ This location is not near my house or my work, but it was on the way home and I'm so glad I stopped. Will return! read more

these bagels are delicious and coming from New York City, I must profess they are like home. The newest location is on Penn off of 150th in Oklahoma City! Enjoy! read more

Nasty! This place has gone downhill. The bagels were gross and the place was dirty. The bathroom was so gross and they were too lazy to even put toilet paper or paper towels in the dispensers. They just had the toilet paper on the ground. Disappointing it's gone downhill. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe has a nice ambiance, with cute armchairs next to an electric fire and lots of seating. However, I ordered a breakfast bagel sandwich and it was not good. I couldn't bring myself to finish it, and for me, that says a lot. The bagel was just ok. I like bagels with a nice crispness on the outside and fluffy on the inside. My bagel was all fluffy, almost mushy. The egg portion was gross. It was worse than mushy, it disintegrated in my mouth, and NOT in a good way. It really threw me off. But, I didn't try any of their other dishes so maybe those are better! read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

I went to college in NYC and lived on the Upper West Side around corner from the original 24-hour H&H and a big Zabar's. Old School is as close as you can get to these classics in OKC (for that matter, outside of NYC). Don't bother going elsewhere. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner recently outside the shop, and he shared his family's close ties to NYC which led to the recognition OKC needed a really good bagel place. Good food, good people, fair prices and local. Can't get better than that in my mind. Skip all the chains that surround it. You won't be sorry!! read more

New location opened near my home. The service was excellent and they answered all my questions as a first time customer. Food was excellent and fresh. Service was very quick. I felt appreciated by the staff. read more

Love love love this place! Always fresh and hits the spot when I need a bagel. They don't bat an eye when I create a bagel creation with many requests! Wish this was closer to my house! read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - everything bagel hallowed out and toasted, scallion cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots, jalapeños...yum! - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Old school must be bleeding money. They just closed another location on broadway in Edmond. No surprise. Overpriced bagels.

Great for busy mornings! I get the gluten free bagel and it is delicious. My favorite is the avocado sunrise.

This is my second chance review after the first experience being similar. I waited in the drive thru line this morning for 40 minutes. The car in front of me got offered a free cookie for their wait but I didn't get offered anything... which really kind of rubbed me the wrong way. I get home with my food after waiting that long and the bagel is burnt and the meat, egg, and cheese are cold. Literally how is that possible? I won't be back. read more

Been coming to Old School at this location since it started. Also was a part time employee while I was in college. Over the last year, the service at this location and quality of product has been abysmal. Today, I went in for a Bricktown that I frequently order and got fatty, slimey, awful meat. This isn't the first time that the experience has been bad, but I think it's going to be the last. I can toss a grocery store bagel in the toaster at home and get the same result. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Worst sandwich meat I've ever had. Took one bite and threw it away. - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

Let me say I rarely leave a review, but felt like I needed to today. This is just one story in a list of mistakes. This location sure has gone way down hill. Went today for a sooner club and an old smokey togo. Asked for no tomato on my sooner club. Shouldn't be too big an issue right? I get home and it has no lettuce and quite a few tomatoes. Also, it has no bacon on it. It's a club. Bacon is one of the main ingredients in a club! Wife opens up her old smokey and it has maybe and I say maybe a teaspoon of cream cheese. Why does your computer system demand a tip when you can't get an order correct. Too Insure Proper Service. That's what tip stands for. Definitely didn't get that. 23rd location is still great. Maybe your employees should go over there for some better training. Highly disappointed! read more

Supper disappointed! I ordered a pizza bagel and this is what I got....Minimal sauce and cheese and slapped together. This cost me $4+ and I expected a little more. Maybe I can wipe some of the sauce of 3/4 of the bagel and salvage it. Staff was friendly and that is the only thing that saves this review. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Pizza bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all