Tough day for the pickle men. You order with one person. They relay the info to second person that adds the toppings and condiments and a third person rings you up. But it's not like Chipotle where you go station to station. You order with person A. They put the meats cheeses on and send it through the toaster. He shouts to person B. Small Veggie no mayo add mustard. Regular BLT as is. Gets to person B. Huge scoop of chicken salad. Not sure how that cross up came about. But his instinct was to scrape it off and just add the mustard. No. No meat. No mayo. And you just soaked the bread in all of that. Re make it. They do. But during the interim. He adds mustard to the BLT. Cus you know. He heard mustard. Meanwhile, I've already been rung up. So now I just gotta wait as this train of incompetence rolls to a stop. Never again pickle man, never again. Stop making your employees play telephone and fix your broken system. read more

Top tier. Loved every bite. The workers were helpful and explained the sandwich options very well. Cute artwork and very clean. Loved everything about our visit. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Number #1 Turkey Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Not the first time eating here. Everything was clean and in good condition. Sandwich was awesome. Good service by the employees. Definitely will return. read more

What a great place. I was craving a sandwich so I stopped in for a quick lunch. I got the Italian and it was perfect! I also loved the way it was toasted. The staff was supper friendly and gave me some advice for my next time in. Apparently and according to others at my job, the tomato soup is to die for. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - ##11 Italian Club Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Look Picklemans - I love your damn #9 Italian Beef Sandwich. So much that I eat it maybe once a week because I live close. And every time I order it without peppers. They always repeat it back. It's on the receipt. So why oh why do I wind up with these peppers 75% of the time?!? Is it that hard? This one had sooo many peppers and despite opening it in the parking lot and finding a couple (it happens) it wasn't until I got home that I found the other 46297491 peppers completely melded into the cheese hiding under the beef. Don't make me quit you - I don't wanna quit you. But I want you to get my order right more often than not and right now, it's a big fail. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - 3684158482 Giardiniera Peppers - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

These subs stand apart from any subs in the city we had the Italian and the smokehouse we wanted to try different things and I must say overall the Italian was the best. The Italian flavors were so tangy and had a good flavor with every bite it was so flavorful. The smokehouse was good but can't compare to the Italian . The service was quick and the place was clean. Went right before lunch before it started to get crowded. Also had the pizza(not pictured) cut in little squares so it's easy to handle. Also recommend trying the chocolate chips cookies. A little pricey but definitely worth trying at least once for good quality subs. read more

See all

After reading a Yelp review on Pickleman's Chicago style, Italian beef dip I had to give Pickleman's a try. You order and pay at the counter, while your sandwich is being made. My hubby and I both ordered the Italian beef dip,mine without spicy the spicy Giardiniera; the thinly sliced beef was tender and very tasty and the roll held up to the delicious Au jus. Without leaving Oklahoma City, I can enjoy a delicious Chicago style Italian beef dip. Friendly customer service, ample seating. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - the entrance - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

This place had the best service & perfect for a late bite to eat. The pepperoni pizza was a safe choice for us but now I wish we would've tried something different, it was delicious though! The lemonade was also super sweet too, very nice place & we'll be returning when we get back in town! Keep in mind we came when the store was very quiet, but the guys serving us really did a great job. Nice space. read more

See all

Really enjoyed this place. Cool vibe, clean, nice staff. Food was great. Love the toasted subs, very Quiznos. Italian sub was great, salt and vinegar chips were great and the chocolate chip cookie was great. Definitely recommend read more

Awesome sandwiches and pizzas in a cool interior with posters featuring local OKC hotspots and monuments / notable neighborhoods. Great cookies as well. They made the sandwich I got (the works or hodgepodge it was called) and it was pretty amazing. Highly recommended! I didn't even know this place existed until driving by it on May Avenue! read more

See all

It was a good sandwich. Very clean casual atmosphere. All you need for lunch. Glad to have them in the area.

besides the asiago chicken sandwich tasting sour and putrid, drive through service was incredibly slow. Very much a one and done try for me.

The food way amazing. It was our first time coming here and they gave us free cookies for it being our first time coming. The employees were nice and directed us through how to order here. I recommend this place i will come again!! read more

My pizza barely had any red sauce and it was cold. Not cool man :/ I come here all the time

I love Pickleman's so much and so glad it's much closer to the city instead of having to drive all the way to Norman. This location even has a small patio to dine outside and a spacious interior for larger groups. You can grab a salad, sandwich or pizza. There's something for everyone. I really love "The Hog" and their Greek salad. It's seriously the perfect thin crust pizza. read more

See all

Expensive price for mediocre food. Restaurant was very clean and the staff were very friendly. I ordered a cheese pizza. Sauce tasted canned, thin cracker like crust that was completely limp. Only reason I ate it was because I was so hungry, but I would never order the pizza ever again, and looking at their prices not sure I'd return for much else. Pizza came in a box, wasn't given the option for dining in, so I just sat and ate it from the box, but the trash can was difficult to throw the box away. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Most overpriced sandwich in Oklahoma City area (Yukon store). Two people can't eat here for less than $35 And that's a sandwich, chips and a drink. I normally get my sandwiches at Jersey Mike's but for some reason their app was down. we drove to Pickleman's which is about the same distance. We had been there before and sandwiches were somewhat mediocre. This day I got the #2 Ham sandwich. What a joke. I opened it up and all it had was 1 (one) piece of thinly sliced ham on it folded in half ( I'm sure to make it look like you got more). Couldn't even taste the ham because it was loaded up with so much lettuce and mayo. So basically a mayo sandwich. Probably won't be back to this place any time soon. Goin to Jersey Mike's where you actually get your money's worth. read more

Delicious! Staff was super helpful to us first timers and we loved our food! I didn't take food pics- everything was wrapped up. Restaurant was clean, amazing staff and my wife loved the lemonade. Wifey tip: do the pick two and try two different sandwiches! Also the tomato bisque soup is great to dip any sandwich in! read more

I was trying to make my decision on what to order and Jeremy helped me through it with great enthusiasm. He sold me on the Italian Club and add peppers. It was absolutely fantastic! Exceptional customer service and you could tell he really cared. I will undoubtedly be back! read more

Always looking for a quick lunch spot and was hoping to love Pickleman's. I ordered two lunch sandwiches with chips. Drove all the way back to my office and one was made super wrong. The sandwiches were good, I'd definitely dine in person but it's too expensive to get take out and have it be wrong. Bummer read more

Love the cookies and their catering for a large group is really easy. The Italian club is my all-time favorite, add the peppers!

The food is fantastic, my wife and I keep coming back. However, the service at the May location is horrible. Every time we have gone the workers seem completely disinterested in the customers, and are often bickering between one another. We usually have to ask for someone's attention even though we have been standing at the counter for a few minutes. Several times they have gotten the order wrong. It's a small thing, and we always get to go so we never stay in the restaurant. If you can get past the rudeness and negativity of the workers, and make sure to check your order, the food is fire. read more

Exceptional chicken salad sandwich with fantastic bread. Great friendly service. The only ironic aspect is that its called pickleman's but the sandwiches dont come with a pickle, but its simply ironic not a deal breaker by any stretch. read more

Absolutely worst sandwich I've ever had !!! No meat !!! And why not offer a pickle with your sandwich !!!!

Went through the drive thru and maybe that was the mistake but I wasn't impressed really at all with their food. I got a turkey sandwich and a small serving of the tomato bisque. The sandwich was ok but awfully small for 10 bucks. The soup was ok and I think it was a better value but honestly the wait and prices that I experienced I probably wouldn't go back read more

The ordering process was confusing. The menu with what comes on the sandwich is down by where you order so when you get to the veggie part, you don't know what comes on the sandwich and neither do the kids that work there, lol. I will probably come back because the food was good but some kinks do need to be worked out. read more

i usually eat at the one in Norman and always love it. I tried the North May location for the 1st time and wasnt as impressed. Decided to order a small avocobb salad with grilled chicken. It was the most underwhelming $13 sald Ive ever had...look at the supposedly fresh avocado that came in it. After taking a few bites of that mess I ordered my usual #11 Italian sub and it was pretty dry compared to the ones I get in Norman... read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - slice of avocado in my salad - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Good food, small amounts, way overpriced. The portions are much smaller than expected. The food quality is why they get a 3 rather than a 2... read more

The place was clean, and if you want to hang there to work on your computer, there are lots of outlets. The chairs aren't long-term comfortable though. Food-wise, the sandwiches are on the thin and skimpy side, but they were tasty. Most sandwich places give you a small pickle spear, but here, you have to buy an entire half a pickle instead on say, 1/8th or 1/6th of a pickle. And with a name like "Pickleman's", I truly expected much more of a pickle theme and a far wider choice of pickles than just one kind of pickle and a jar of one kind of giardinera. It was an OK pickle, but not worth $2 for a half pickle. I was truly expecting a lovely pickle experience - a nice variety of pickles (sours, half sours, dills, koshers, sweets, maybe a bread-and-butter pickle and maybe some gherkins), but just ONE kind of pickle? And just 1 kind of giardiniera? Such a deep pickle-lack. Since this is a chain, I doubt changes will be made. I regret the serious lack of pickle. But - the sandwiches were good (get the full sized, because a half is **very** tiny), the soup was good, and the service was good, the place was clean, parking was easy. I didn't try the salad or the pizza, and may return for those, but the sadness of the pickle-lack may be too great. read more

Everything I have tried at picklemans has been great. Have tried multiple sandwiches and pizzas. I got the regular pizza crust but they also offer a gluten free crust. They also let me sample the spicy pork Mac N Cheese last time I went in and I will be getting some next time. Only thing I would change if I could is the location but it's worth going out of my way for the food and service. read more

The service was good & quick. It was my friend and I's first time in there and the food didn't disappoint. He wanted soup & Im not a fan but I found this place. He ended up getting the "pick 2" with the Italian Beef sandwich & tomato bisque and he enjoyed it. I got Chipotle Chicken sandwich and spicy dill pickles chips (amazing btw) and it was really good. I will say half a sandwich is pretty small so if you're on the hungrier side I'd get a full one. But overall the experience was good, great customer service, good lighting, clean store & bathroom. I'd recommend if you want something quick. read more

The tomato soup was really good. The counter staff was rude and condescending. I will give it another try because of the soup and drive through connivence. read more

So me and the Mrs. hit up Pickleman's (my first time...her second) and man oh man did I finally find a spot in OKC with a legitimate Italian Beef Sandwich! I have tried others and none in OKC have come close to what I used to eat when I lived in the Windy City (Chi-Town) back in the early 90's! Enter Pickleman's! They hit the mark with this one, but be warned the size was smaller than expected. Still, if you want a proper portion sandwich this is it! Their Italian Beef includes a somewhat spicy giardiniera blend (which I like), delicious broth for dipping, and I had them add mozzarella and onions on mine. This SAM'ich (yes Bruh man, fif-flow, SAM'ich) was the biddness! LOL...That's how good it was. Reminded me of being back in the Chi! Anywho, they offered a pickle and I was like sure. While I was expecting a couple of dill slices, little did I know that they'd be serving up a full size jumbo pickle like the ones you get at concession stands. I ate half of it with my Italian Beef paired with spicy dill kettle chips and a lemonade. Hey Pickleman's...I'm impressed! I'll be back! read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Real Italian Beef w/ spicy giardiniera and dip - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

We have ordered here a couple of times and the first time was just as they opened and they got our order wrong but we figured it was because they were just getting the hang of things. This last visit was wrong as well. We ordered to sandwiches with extra mayo and they both were made for us dry. No mayo at all. Ok Pickleman's... read more

sandwiches are delicious!! the bread toasted is phenomenal!! sometimes the service is weirdly slow. like the person making the sandwich i order every single time with her struggles to make it right. but since it's so good i keep coming back!!! read more

I have Aiden to a lot of bad places This in my book is the worst place I ever ate at sandwiches was terrible And the pizza was horrific I think a Dollar General pizza for five dollars would be better that I make at home it cost me $50 for two sandwiches and a pizza And one of the sandwiches only had one piece of turkey when it was a turkey sandwich absolutely horrible please do not go because you will get better food at the dollar store I have to put a star because it won't let me post this review if I don't but I would have preferred zero stars read more

I tried two different sandwiches and they didn't have much flavor and we're bland. And too over priced.

I know they just opened so i'm trying to cut them some slack for sure but to forget EVERY modification to my sandwich and forgetting my sides is annoying. read more

Our first time here and I'll just say it's pretty good. So many reviews complained that the sandwiches are too small and they're not huge but with a bowl of soup, it was enough for us to split. We got the Italian beef with their gardinere and au jus and tomato basil chowder. We thought the sandwich was skimpy on meat and cheese. But the funny thing to us was that although it's called Pickleman's and the theme is dill pickles, they do not give you a pickle with your sandwich! If you want a pickle, you have to buy it for $2.00! With so many other options in the area, we probably won't be back. read more

Wouldn't waste my time returning, so don't waste your time stopping into this place. Sandwich I had was the Italian Beef, and it was sad compared to the picture they advertise. Meat was lacking, bread was soggy, and taste was lacking. Spent $30 on 2 full-size sandwiches, 2 bags of chips and one tea. Overpriced! Will not return, or recommend. read more