This pizza is the closest thing to true NY/NJ pizza that I have had since moving to Kentucky! The dough is perfect. The cheese is almost there. The sauce is delicious, but there just is not quite enough of it. I am not someone who likes a lot of sauce, but this was just enough to know it was there without it really standing out. It is a great sauce, it just needs a little more of it to bring everything together. One other suggestion would be to offer the option of adding extra Italian herbs and spices during cooking. That would take an already excellent pizza to the next level. Overall, this is hands down one of the best pizzas I have had in Kentucky, and I will definitely be back. read more

This was exactly the pizza I wanted tonight - thin, flavorful pepperoni, red sauce. When my husband found himself near the restaurant, I was excited about the suggestion to pick it up. We added on 4 meatballs with a lot of cheese and sauce, plus a cheesesteak sandwich. After ordering, we were given a 35 min pick up timeframe. The pizza does cool on the way home. If you do takeout you might consider warming it back up in the oven prior to serving. read more

See all

It's not fair for a native New Yorker to give a review of pizza outside of NYC, however when the name of your establishment is Old School NY Pizza we have to be brutally honest. This is not NY Pizza. The slice is too small to be called a NY slice. Secondly, the sauce lacked flavor. No oregano, not even garlic powder in the sauce. It was bland. The crust was a little thick and doughy. Definitely room for improvement. If you're not from NYC, you may enjoy this pizza. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Slice of pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

In town visiting, and had a pizza craving. Great Pizza! Great Service! What could be better?? LOVE IT!! read more

I was very impressed by this place! I was in the area for work and I heard they have a great lunch special. I've been meaning to check this place out and I'm glad I finally got a chance to. I got the lunch special, which is two slices and a drink. Next time I think I'll just get two (maybe three!) slices, I don't think I need the drink. I really loved the pizza! The taste was great and the texture was better, with that wonderful crispy crust. All the slices I tried were delicious, and I'm sure they're bound to have something you'll like. The staff was friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was pretty basic, but in a non-pretentious great way. I can't wait to be back, and I highly recommend! read more

We ordered takeout online. I liked their online ordering feature because it was easy and intuitive to navigate. Additionally, it offered the ability to get half speciality pizza--they charge half the price of the whole specialty item. I thought that's very fair; just glad they didn't try to up charge just to get half / half of specialty pizzas. Overall, pizza was good. But, we were disappointed in the amount of toppings on our pizza. We got half Hawaiian / half deluxe. There was hardly any pepperoni on our deluxe. read more

Incredible!! Garlic knots incredible! Great atmosphere! Service was great! Definitely recommend

Service was horrible told me I couldn't get the pizza I wanted because it wasn't already made and my dads spaghetti looked like it was thrown together and cheese not even melted. Used to love this place but it's awful now. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

Good pizza, Service was great, large restaurant with plenty places to sit and watch the game if you want to eat in. I ordered carryout and took it to go. if I had to do again, I would've ordered it well done . Crust could've been a little thinner. I would call it more of a bar pizza than New York style,:overall I would say 6.9 read more

I had been eying this place for a while and had a chance to stop by for lunch one day. We decided to get the two slice combo that comes with a drink since it was a good deal. My sister and I decided on the pepperoni pizza and a slice of the BBQ. They warm it up for you. It's a pretty quick process. Staff was nice. Not sure if it was the owner we met. The BBQ was delicious! It's one of the best BBQ pizzas I've had. I'd come back again for lunch. Prices aren't bad for what you're getting. There's also lots of seating if you want to dine in. read more

I can't believe this is my first review for Old School! We love coming here, specifically to this location. The staff is always super nice & outgoing. It's never too crowded. So we are always able to find a seat at the bar in front of their TVs to watch basketball or football. It has a very chill pizza joint vibe. The pizza is always delicious. You can get by the slice - they always have 6+ pizzas available for their "by the slice." We love to get order an 18" pizza - half & half. Their BBQ pizza is AMAZING. Definitely recommend trying this place out! read more

See all

Always a great place to stop in for a quick slice or two of pizza. The staff is friendly and food is served warm and quality is great.

Having heard good things about Old School NY Pizza, I had a chance to stop by one day durning lunch. I took advantage of their lunch special, 2 slices of Pizza and a Drink (I wanted 2 slices and a beer but was on the clock :) ) Being by myslef I set a the bar to enjoy my lunch. The staff was friendly and answered my questions with entuhsasim. When my slices of the All Meat pizza came out, they were hot and loaded with toppings. I was even happier when my tastebuds agreed with my eyes that this was going to be some good pizza. I finished off the slices, wishing I could eat more, settled my tab and left knowing I would return whenever I was close by. I also know they have serval pie offerings that I am looking forward to trying in the near future. read more

Better than Domino's, Pizza Hut, Papa John's. I've always played it safe with Papa John's or Domino's, but Old School NY Pizza has them beat. Best pizza I have ever had. Just heard of them this year and have had them 7 times or so since then. Have tried a different pizza types every time I've gone and they're consistently amazing. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Meat lovers and another one - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

Best NYC style pizza. Foldable, fresh and delicious. Very friendly staff and were so helpful. Skip the chains, go real NYC pizza!

The pizza was fantastic. I love thin crust. And the Greek salad was the best. I'd highly recommend this place. The waitress was informative, and initiative to our needs. read more

I could eat this all day every day! The pizza has GREAT flavor! If you're looking for floppy delicious pizza- ya gotta go here!!!!!!!!

MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE. Pizza is always hot and good. Service is always lovely and the ambiance is very family oriented. MUST TRY read more

Old School NY Pizza - 18" Cheese Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

Hi, stop by and wanted to get a slice of pizza to give this spot a try. I walked in I was greeted counter. I ordered one pepperoni slice. It was four dollars and some change which I thought was rather expensive for just a slice of pizza. I have been in New York and I've had many of their dollar slices that were bigger and just as tasty. The pizza itself was good. I did enjoy it but I'm gonna give it a three stars because as I said, I think for the price it's not gonna do the job read more

See all

Amazing food every single time, the PBR is heaven on a plate. The service is typically decent and quick, the Ambiance is so old New York pizza shop style I adore it! read more

This is THE go-to place when you're looking for New York style pizza in Louisville. It's sold by the slice here (a few topping options in the case) and the size, crust, grease, and bake of these slices is just right *chef's kiss* You can of course get whole pizzas if desired. Keep in mind this isn't the Neapolitan style pizza that's also popular in New York, but rather the more native, ubiquitous New York style that you get when you aren't "going out to eat" there but instead just grabbing a slice casually. There isn't much ambiance here, but who needs it when the slices are this good. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Pepperoni slices - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

I'm from Connecticut & you just can't find a good pizza in Ky. These guys make fresh dough pizza New York style. We go there often!

Best pizza around. I've been coming here for years and nothing tops it. I always see myself coming back time and time again!

I absolutely love Old School NY Pizza. The two slice and a drink option is great for a quick lunch as you choose your two slices from many prepared options and then they move it to the oven to finish the cook. The result is a hot and perfectly crisp pizza for you to enjoy. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Buffalo chicken slice and all meat slice - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

We were in the mood for pizza and wanted to try somewhere new. I can't say that I've had New York-style pizza before (and if I have I never realized it.) It had a thin crust and was gigantic...and was really, really good! For pizza this big I'd prefer to get it by the slice, but we ordered takeout so we opted for a full pie. It was a great deal for how much we got! You can easily order online with them. They have different specialty pizzas, but you can also select different toppings/sauces individually. Once we ordered, the website quoted us a 60 minute wait, but the store immediately called us and let us know it would only be about 25 minutes. Let me tell you... for the two of us being the type that could down 3-4 pieces easily, we could hardly finish two! And it was great. Even for my plain self just ordering cheese on my half, I loved it. If you're near the PeeWee Valley area looking for pizza, Old School NY is your place. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Half cheese - Half buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

Our favorite pizza joint! We've loved everything we ordered from here and not been disappointed! read more

Yes I am a pizza lover and still haven't found another pizza I really enjoy eating . Thank you old school for great pizza pie. So we had a pizza rehearsal dinner here and it turned out great thank you your service and letting us you your facility's all the guest loved the variety of pies . Thank you again read more

See all

This place is awesome! Lunch special of a good sized slice of pizza, a small salad which isn't that small, and a beverage for 11.50. An extra $1 to make that salad Greek! Their Greek salad is the bomb, with chopped romaine, sliced onion, feta cheese chunks, Kalamata olives, and croutons. Choice of dressing but I really like their House vinaigrette. It's just right! The slices of pizza are visible in a case to choose from and they slide it into the pizza oven to warm it up. There's always fun music playing and the workers are all friendly, helpful and seem to be enjoying themselves! Lots of open seating. Clean place. You cannot miss here! read more

Showed up less than ten minutes before close. I actually called ahead to try to get some slices set aside but they said call aheads are for full pizzas only. So my Uber driver dropped me real quick and I grabbed four slices for me and a slice for my driver. I couldn't believe how cheap it was. I asked for ranch and red pepper and they tossed in some plates and I was out the door in minutes. I heated the slices up in the oven at 350 for about 5 min. Delicious. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Four slices to go - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

Awesome place. The reviews are legit. Give this place a bite! Good service too!!! Would have taken a picture of pizza but it was quickly devoured. read more

Food is good but I dont understand why managers allow employees to go on break in the bar and then let them have their phones on speaker so it interrupts the whole atmosphere because you have to listen to someone else conversation. When I brought it to the manager he just starred at me and did nothing. This is the last time I'm coming here. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Person on speaker in the bar. - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

THIS is a delicious New York style pizza. Nothing fancy. Just delicious pizza done right.

This is my new favorite pizza restaurant in Louisville. I had seen all the great reviews so I figured it would be good. The only thing I didn't like was that there isn't a big menu. They had one small paper menu at the counter. I'm assuming most of the business is from regulars who know what they want. I ordered a slice of pepperoni and garlic knots. It was $8. They have lots of combo deals that make it even cheaper. All the pizza is already cooked and they just throw it in the oven to heat it back up. You couldn't tell at all that it was reheated. The garlic knots were to die for. There was probably a centimeter of garlic butter at the bottom of the pan. It came with 20 small knots and I ate almost all of them. It comes with sauce but they taste best with the garlic butter. The pepperoni pizza was fantastic. The crust was super thin and crispy. The crust was really good dipped in the garlic butter from the knots. I'll definitely be coming back her. I just wish it wasn't so far away. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

I've worked at Ford truck plant for 4 years and just now tried this place for lunch - I've been missing out! The staff was beyond friendly, there were 12 different pizzas to choose from ready for the oven, and the lunch combos were amazingly priced. For $7 you get 2 giant slices of pizza and a drink, or for $7.50 you get 2 slices, a drink, and a salad. I ordered a slice of the cheeseburger pizza, a slice of the ham and pineapple pizza, and the drink (Coke products). We also ordered the garlic knots and they were delish. I'll definitely be a regular here, they're doing great things. Reminds me of the old Sbarro pizza you could get at the mall. Thin, crispy crust, fresh toppings, and quick. Thanks so much! read more

Old School NY Pizza - Cheeseburger and ham and pineapple slices. - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

One of the best pizza places in Louisville . They got the best pizza that you can buy in town and I will definitely recommend it A+.

Awesome NYC thin sliced style pizza. I mean - it couldn't be even closer to grabbing slice in midtown Manhattan! Highly recommended

Crispy, fresh, soooo good! We had the all meat and buffalo slices. Love the two slice and a drink deal for $9 and some change. Kids spaghetti was also great! Friendly atmosphere that is kid friendly, bar in the back. We will be back! read more

This is my family's fave pizza place. It's low key, the staff is always friendly and smiling and it's super convenient if you live nearby. The pizza is classic NY style, really delicious and I would choose it over any chain. There's a great family atmosphere here and they are super sweet to the kiddos! read more

I have been wanting to try this place for a while. Glad I finally did, even though it was carryout. The pizza was really good. Similar to The Post. Really nice crust, that was soft on the inside but not flimsy on the outside. The pepperoni was delicious. Cupped up real nice. Cant wait to eat here again. Next time we will dine in! read more

Great place to grab a slice of pizza. They usually have 6 or so varieties ready but you can also order whole, custom pies. The pizza itself is solid, and the atmosphere is super casual. Two slices and a soft drink is like $7, so the price is right and they have a moderate amount of seating and since the place isn't usually busy, you won't have an issue getting a table. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky