what are the prices for this place even? the advertised whiteboard price $6 doesn't match the menu price 4.5/slice. and when I was rung up it was $11 dollars for two slices and got a drink I didn't ask for. my non confrontational nature stopped me from saying anything but like.. why? read more

Ordered BBQ chicken wings and a Margarita pizza with pepperoni added to half. The wings were pretty burnt so we had to rip off a lot of the burnt parts, and they also messed up on our pizza and made it 1/2 Margarita and 1/2 pepperoni instead. We ordered on a Saturday around 3:30 PM and there was one table inside when I picked up so I'm not sure how they could mess up our order. read more

We ordered dinner from Old Town Pizza for the second time and the pizza here is great! We ordered the Old Town Special and the BBQ chicken pizzas, along with an order of cheesy bread sticks with marinara sauce. We loved how both pizzas were tasty, and not greasy. The crust is thin and crispy but still has a good chewy texture. Both pizzas came with a good amount of toppings, and was not salty. The cheesy bread sticks had a good amount of cheese inside and on top. The staff here is friendly and helpful, we will definitely be coming back. read more

Horrible avoid at all cost overpriced mediocre pizza ,place is run down!. Ordered Flavorless chic wings very small ! Ordered an X-Large more like medium and an order of wedges witch were not at all potatoe wedges that tasted like they cooked in the same tray as the wings ! Spent 80$ won't ever be back ! read more

Pizza is good! But 3 star because we ordered a pizza and wings and got a pizza and potato wedges. To make it worse the potato wedges were soggy and cold. read more

Old Town Pizza - Combo Pizza and Potato Wedges. - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

Update! Pizza is still delicious! Thank you all for an amazing pizza and great customer service. I caught myself comparing every pizza I try to this one. read more

Very friendly staff awesome pizza never disappoint Evan at the last minute they always come through thanks guys we really appreciate all you do serving our community here in Monrovia read more

This place is so dope and the pizza is incredible!!! We are here just checking the town out and while deciding where to eat we dont realize how late it is. Fast forward 20 mins and it is now 10:04 PM and we are starving and smell pizza but they closed at 10. GRRRRR right?!?!?! WRONG!!!!! I poke my head in and there are Roberto, Melissa (maybe Alyssa?), and Veronica having a few closing words with each other about to close the doors. I ask if they have a few slices they could just sell us and they smile and say "sure!" The pizza comes out, I go to pay...NOPE! WRONG AGAIN! FREE PIZZA! The pizza is soo good too and I'm eating it while typing. THANK YOU FOR THE KINDNESS GUYS AND I HOPE PEOPLE SUPPORT YOU IN RETURN FOR ACTUALLY CARING ABOUT CUSTOMERS! (that was a long winded yell but I did it) read more

Old Town Pizza - FREE Pizza Always Tastes Better! - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

I wasn't going to post this review but after not receiving a refund I was promised, here goes... On March 2nd, I ordered the same gluten free Hawaiian pizza I always order. Today for the first time, the crust was burnt around the edges and raw in the center, I mean pasty raw... I called and was told that's the way it comes from the company.. I wasn't sure if she meant burnt or raw. I explained to her Ive ordered this many times before and that this was the first time it was like this. Then she says to me, are you just trying to get a discount? I said no, that I'd be happy to bring it back but was told I couldn't do that. I asked for it to be remade but was told no they wouldn't... Melissa said the owner would issue me a refund but that's it... Just wow... Fast forward to today, still no refund. Pizza went in the trash and I ordered tacos from El Picosito, delish! read more

Old Town Pizza - Mmmmm burnt on the edges, raw in the center.. Straight into the trash. - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

I know pricing has gone up for everything, but when you pay well over $60 for 1 XL specialty pizza & a 1-top MED pizza, there's something wrong. I get it's a small business, but they're not even trying to compete with other pizza places. Add in that the quality has gone down and pretty quickly you'll realize that it's time to find a new place. Delivery fee is $4 as of this review for my location (under 1 mile). Did attempt once to place an order for delivery at a specific time (it allows you to do this), yet my order arrived ASAP, so don't count on that feature. As far as I know, you can place an online order directly from their website as listed on Yelp or by using the Slice website, which charges you more. I really want to keep supporting a local small business, but sadly I'll be needing to find another pizza joint. read more

We are always on the lookout for great piizza. This place has wings and other menu items. Nice older establishment, and pretty clean. They have a porch where you can sit back from the sidewalk and still enjoy a nice breeze. The pizza is made with gOod quality cheese. We ordered pepperroni and combo pizzas. Both weee good. We rEcommemd order extra crispy crust. Wings were pretty good also. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Pizza is amazing here!!!! Thank you Eric for the great service, kept checking up on us at the table. Thank you for the free brownies and the apple juice! Will defiantly come back again. read more

Honestly we're not going to be buying anything from this restaurant ever again. The place was messy. Chairs and tables were scattered so much that I couldn't even walk to the register. I placed an order over the phone and was told the price was $45. Once I get there, I used a local coupon for $5 off. The price was still $45. I noticed I was charged for an extra topping. I shouldn't have been charged extra because it was a one topping pizza. I was overcharged, the pizza was bad quality, and cold. It just seems like they tossed a frozen pizza in the oven and called it a day. I'm truly disappointed. I used to love this place. Nothing tastes the same. read more

Ah, Old Town Pizza. They have great lunch specials and satisfy my craving for an American pizza when Blaze, as good as it is, just won't do. Something about the thick crust here and cheesy pizza just keeps me coming back. This is not the most amazing pizza place ever, but I like their BBQ Chicken Pizza, which is just right. I also like their calzones since they are enormous and I usually add mushrooms with my pepperoni for 50 cents, which is totally worth it. The crust for the pizza can get harder when cold or for leftovers (more so than other places), but overall everything is not too salty. Service is always spectacular but overall this is a 3.5 star place. read more

See all

To me this Pizza was 2.2. I was expecting more and better tasting pizza considering the new owner work at Village Pizzeria from Sierra Madre. The pizza dough wasn't even close to pizza dough. It was like regular beard dough. The cheese taste like monterrey jack cheese and maybe some mozzarella cheese, the sauce was terrible (absolutely no flavor). The cook in back was the same cook from the previous owner. Sorry new owner, but good luck. read more

I came into the restaurant with high hopes. However it deeply disappointed me. The server was extremely rude and not helpful whatsoever. The pizza i got was burnt and had strands of hair in the slices. Also with such a high price i expected a much better meal. Overall this restaurant is unsanitary, extremely expensive for a pizza, the service is terrible and the food is flavorless. I will never come here ever again read more

Two orders in a row have been incorrectly made. The last order was done through a meal delivery service and rather than make the pizza to my specifications, or calling to make adjustments, they cancelled the pizza and sent only salad and garlic bread with my driver. Why would anyone want that and be satisfied with that when ordering an extra large pizza, family sized salad and several orders of garlic bread? read more

My husband loves their pizza and I find myself craving their chicken salad all the time! I'd try their other items, but that salad calls my name every time. read more

Cancelled our to go order after not only accepting it but making us wait a hour before cancelling. Gave no explanation.

Terrible service! We came specifically because some reviewers mentioned vegan cheese. I called the day before and asked and they confirmed they offered it.We walked in today and asked about what kind it was, just because we wanted to know. The guy manning the counter shrugged and said "I don't know" in a really annoyed tone, walked off to the back, came right back out and showed us the cheese in a metal container, and shook his head and said "That's the best I can do for ya." He seemed so aggravated over a simple question. If he was at least nice about it, we probably would've been okay with him not knowing, and would've taken the chance and tried it. I feel pretty bad about how we were treated, there was no reason for such a snotty response. read more

This place is better than the outside looks. It was so fresh and delicious. I recommend this place and they have slices to go!!!! read more

Came in with 35 people 15 kids 20 adults at 3pm. Flooded the place with drink and food orders for a an army of hungry baseball players and parents. The guys worked their booties off to get everything out. Food and service was great! read more

I've been ordering here for years and the food is always consistent and good. Pizzas are cooked perfectly. The meatballs are wonderful whether alone or on pasta or a sandwich. Pastas are great and the portion is plenty for two. The salads are yummy too. Really good and local which I love. Delivery people are always very nice and polite. I highly recommend read more

Came here after wanting to try for two years! Came for lunch with my husband and came the same day to share with my parents. Really good food! And both workers who took our orders in the afternoon and dinner time had excellent costumer service. Definitely coming back read more

Old Town Pizza - 2 Pizza Slices and Canned Drink Express Lunch - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

I updated my review after speaking with the store manager Albert and he explained the circumstance to me. I am still knocking some stars because the customer service of it all sucked. If the girl on the phone explained like Albert did we wouldn't be here! But thanks Albert for speaking with me! Tried to order pizza from this place first they wouldn't answer the phone so I went online and it says cannot place orders online. I called back because my kids want pizza for dinner then the girl that answered says "my kitchen is closed we have other orders" wtf the hours say open until 8pm! We use to love coming to old town pizza now it's like pulling teeth to order from them! Never again I guess we will stick to Monrovia Pizza Co!! read more

Not sure about the pizza but the ordering system and calling them is completely 2 separate entities. Call the restaurant doesn't help. They know nothing about the ordering system. You would have to confirm more than once with the Live person. NOT VERY EFFICIENT!!!! The person answering the phone needs some CUSTOMER SERVICE CLASSES!!!!! IDK the pizza might be good but will not order from them again DUE TO A LOW LEVEL OF CUSTOMER SERVICE AND CUSTOMER MANAGEMENT... read more

Decent pizza but a 12" 2 ingredient pie and single lasagna for $40+ is a little over the top.

Food is excellent, we order from OTP a couple times per month. We love all of the pizzas and order chicken salad often.

Excellent Pizza with truly fresh ingredients. Fast friendly service I highly recommend this local pizzeria. read more

Open right now. Super nice establishment and the pizzas are made to order and the ingredients are fresh. Just splurge and tried the Works. So delicious and you can see all the fresh ingredients. I truly enjoyed the pizzas here and will continue to support them. read more

Old Town Pizza - The Works Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

See all

I will not to be ordering from here ever again! We waited over an hour for delivery and then called to ask about our order and they said they never received it. The girl on the phone wasn't apologetic at all and when I asked if they could refund my credit card which had already been charged she said to call back later! Worst customer service ever! read more

Old Town Pizza - Confirmation of order that never came - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

I used to live in Monrovia and this was always a good spot for pizza. I ordered online to have a lunch special ready for pickup during my break and when I got there 25 mins later to pick it up nothing was ready. Also they told me when I showed up that they didn't have Alfredo sauce to make the pasta I ordered. Understandable, but please let your customers know before they show up 30 mins later for their order which added additional waiting time. The older man was being very mean to the guy working the register, I heard him yelling at him. Be patient with your workers, I will not be back here. Bad management! The sandwich was a 2/10 bread was hard at the ends. read more

I love coming to Old Town Pizza. It's such a beautiful view of the Monrovia library if you choose to sit in there front outside patio. I love the lunch specials they have during the week. Perfect bite for a fair price! Pizza is delicious, and I love the garden salad with Italian dressing. Support local. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza and salad special - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

Am updating an old review. I keep trying to find better pizza in the Monrovia area, as I am originally from Chicago and I love Chicago-style pizza which I've decided is really impossible to find in So Cal, so I've pretty much given up on that. Anyhow, I've tried many local pizzas and I keep coming back to Old Town because it is the best all-around pizza place that delivers. I only wish it wasn't so expensive. The flavor and crust is pretty good, and the wings are also not bad. If not for the cost, I'd give it 5 stars. read more

Just ordered a delivery of pizza and wings from Old Town Pizza. SOOOO good! The new owners are doing a great job! It was delivered before the estimated time and was excellent. Fresh toppings and the sauce is great! Will be ordering again for sure!! :) read more

Came in after they shut down and asked to buy a bottle of water. They didn't hesitate and just gave me a bottle and refused to take payment. Great people and kind service read more

mama mia... what a fantastic service from that beautiful soul in the front counter...she was so nice and a true friendly person... on the top of that the pizza was so tasty and crunchy...I will have you in our prays ! Love J.C and Lily read more

I decided to check this place out because Domenico's in Monrovia is closed on Mondays. I was craving some antipasto salad. Sadly, it was nowhere near as good as Domenico's. I ordered a large. Only a little bit of each of the toppings were given. Though I will say they were very generous on the pepperoni & salami. The mushrooms were missing. There was only 3 cherry tomatoes! I had only a little of the salad & decided I would take the rest home so I could add more toppings on my end later. will say that I enjoyed the calzone. It was very cheesy. I'll probably go back to try other menu items. The staff was nice & helpful. But I don't recommend the antipasto salad if you're craving Domenico's instead. read more

Old Town Pizza - Full Calzone and Antipasto Salad - Pizza Near Me - Monrovia, California

Does this place have the best staff? does this place have the best pizza? Does this place have the best beer? Two out of three works for me.

For some odd reason, we have not ordered pizza takeout in a long time. We decided pizza would be perfect while watching the Dodger game. Old Town Pizza has good reviews, so we decided to give it a try. We like to support local small businesses. We ordered a pepperoni with olives and mushrooms. We called and were happy with the friendly, polite person taking the call. We were told that the pizza would be ready in 25 minutes and it was. The pizza was great, and the olives, mushrooms, and pepperonis were plentiful. From our experience, we can recommend this establishment. A good pizza is heaven! read more