Not bad NY Style pizza in the SGV area....boss ordered a bunch for the office and everyone seemed to like it... Smelled good tasted good and fresh... I always get no cheese on a pizza nowadays so I know it isn't what you would consider a "pizza" and no meat...all veggies.... Would eat and order again but it isn't my first choice of pizza joints but better than the CHAIN ones... read more

See all

I placed a telephone order, and there were a couple of mix-ups with the address and the toppings for the half pizza. However, the pizza itself was really good and ended up being a hit at our potluck. It disappeared so fast lol. I would definitely order again! The 18-inch pizza was pretty big, so I was wondering if it's possible to request more cuts instead of the usual 8 slices next time. read more

Omar's is banging. 18" with extra cheese + any toppings is a surefire way to a delicious pie. I don't know what it is about the cheese they use but it's the main reason I keep coming back. I think it might have lower moisture but it has a sort of bite to it. It's not just melted amorphous goo but has some structure and chew which I really enjoy. The bake on the pies is floppy - you aren't going to get a crunch on the slices except for maybe the crust. They also tend to be a bit saucy - similar to VPN margherita pizzas. Some may dock points for lack of crunch or for the sauce level but for me, it works incredibly well together. If you want any adjustments or a longer bake, I am sure the staff would oblige. The topping distribution is always appropriate. Never have I felt like they skimped or overwhelmed the pie. I've only had the pepperoni and italian sausage and both are as you would expect. Their pricing overall is competitive versus other joints in the area but it is really the taste of the pizza that brings it over the edge for me. To bring the entire experience together, the staff is also incredibly warm and endearing. They treat you like family and after just a few visits will remember your name and order. read more

We ordered a large meatball and green pepper pizza. Very disappointed. There was maybe half a meatball on the entire pizza, though plenty of peppers. The crust was the worst. Obviously not made fresh - it had holes in it sort of like crackers do and tasted like crackers. Apparently pre-made frozen and unacceptable. read more

I've been here on and off since their original location in north Arcadia. I don't think it's particularly that special of a pizza restaurant but I actually really enjoy it because they sell by the slice. I typically order the Omar's Special or Brooklyn Special. The venue is not big but it's bigger than it needs to be. Feels a little old but it's maintained and clean. Plenty of seating for what has usually felt like few customers (nowadays I think most people take pizzas to go and don't really sit in to eat) and the staff are very nice. Parking is basically the street parking in front of the store. The menu is quite large and part of it is the fact that any pizza can also be made into a calzone. I mostly only come here to get the 2 slice special: 2 slices and a drink for about $10ish. Sometimes they have more slices than are on display, and honestly it's possible they're reheating some in storage, but it tastes fine to me so I'm cool with it. Just an easy way to get that pizza fix without ordering a whole pie, which I think is not something to be overlooked. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - 2 slices of brooklyn and 1 of Omar's. - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

The ordering process online for pick up is a bit odd as it does not send any kind of confirmation, but I am hopeful because I use to come here while I was in school. It was the best place for a vegetarian pizza and I am not even vegetarian! The service was great, we received our order when we arrived! The shop give us a diner feel. It's nostalgic. There weekly deals are not bad either! Their slices are huge! read more

My first time here and it was great. The pizza was delicious, fresh, and full of flavor. The customer service was friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. I'll definitely be back. read more

Been a returning customer for years. Great taste, fast service and a cozy place to chill. They also make a great Gluten free pizza!

Great pizza, good salad - nicest people ever! Here for the Rose Bowl - Go IU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ordered a brooklyn special 18", buffalo wing, antipasto and caesar salad. For 4 adults and 3 kids... tho the kids didnt eat too much of it. It was a lot of food and kind of on me that we over ordered. However i got to try a good variety of things because of that! The brooklyn special was kind of nice. It was a thinner crust and had that nice toasty,charcoal flavor on the bread. Im not a pizza expert, so not sure if theres a term for that. The wings were good but there were still feather on some of them. The buffalo sauce was on the side, might just be the way we ordered it, but oh man was that sauce spicy. Good thing it was on the side. Both the caesar and anitpasto salad were solid and just nice to have with all the carbs and protein in the other dishes. read more

Prompt delivery. Pizza was good but even bad pizza is good. I'd order again in a pinch.

It's very friendly and family feeling here! So welcome and nice, the food was very good I was very satisfied !!!! I really enjoyed the lasagna , garlic bread , and cookie it was made very well!!!! Very good and loved eating there read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

the sandwich and pizza was delicious i highly recommend checking this place out. can't wait to return

I've heard good tings about Omars and finally tried it. I called as I wanted to place a half half pizza and didn't see that option available online. 5 piece boneless wings (bbq): the boneless wings were all different sizes so there weren't really 5 of them. I didn't like the bbq sauce as it didn't taste like bbq sauce and was hard to say what flavor it was. garlic knots: they come looking very seasoned however I thought the garlic was on the bland side. the knots however were a nice consistency. 18" half bronx half garlic chicken: overall pizza was okay. I thought the crust was good and slices were large. Overall just okay. read more

See all

We absolutely loved this place! Pizza and wings were great. The service was lovely and staff were very sweet! Ambiance was nice! read more

This location was an old pizza place some years ago and I decide to try it all over again. Glad I did ! Had the popular Brooklyn special loved the thin crust enjoyed all the toppings just needed more pieces of sausage. Really enjoyed the Baked ziti has all the right flavors,good size serving portion along with a tasty garlic bread. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Brooklyn pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

Straight to the point customer service. Had a regular pepperoni pizza. Good was good. I'd come back again.

Easily my favorite pizza in the East LA area. We've tried a bunch of their toppings and they've never disappointed. Perfect for those nights when we don't feel like cooking, and the leftovers are always bomb. read more

I placed an order for a pie and one topping was misread (Artichokes instead of anchovies). It happens. I only called to make them aware of the mistake but they sent a whole new pie with the correct toppings. Amazing and unexpected customer service! The pies were also very tasty and well cooked. 5 stars! read more

Great new York style pizza. I really like this place. Although it can be inconsistent.

Omar's Special Large size pizza comes in clutch on those weekend nights when you don't feel like going out but you also don't want to cook. I've had the Omar's special probably more than 10 times now. In fact, I've never had any other pizzas from Omar's. Why would I? It gets the job done every time. They probably make plenty of different flavours though. Take out preorder by phone works quickly but be ware they might not pick up the phone if they are busy. It happened to me once. That's kind of annoying. Ps: you can make your pizza 50/50 if you wanted to. read more

Pizza is sooo yummster omgg. It is thin and has a crispy crust. If you like thin pizza then you will like this place. Best lunch ever! Service was excellent nice and quick. The place is cute and chill they even have a Pokémon plushie vending machine. 10/10 Would recommend coming here since the cost is very affordable. I want to try the calzones omg read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Chef's Special Pizza slice with olives added - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

I came by on a Sunday and ordered the family special two large pizzas. My favorite is mushroom with double the mushrooms plus the other pizza was a peperoni. The pizzas looked great but that was about it, because they tasted bland and the dough was of poor quality. I usually devour the whole pizza including the crust but not this time. The service is quick and I only had to wait about 15 minutes for the fresh pizzas. I will give them another try in the future but it will only be for their premade single slices that they offer. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Sunday Pizza Day OCT2023 - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

The staff was extremely friendly and I placed the order late but the pizza still turned out extremely well. Both my girlfriend and I were extremely pleased by their cheese pizza and the works pizza. Unlike many pizza places the pizza bite after bite is drenched in oil and grease. Somehow, the pizza stayed as is and no extra grease than what ot was used to make the pizza. Secondly, if it's a weekend and you want a quick sit down with your date. It is quiet inside read more

Came to this place while on work break, saw a sign for a 2 slice special with a drink for 8.99 what a deal! When I walked inside, the clear display only had half of a cheese pizza so I figured the slices were made recently or fresh to order. I got my food withing 5 minutes which I thought was odd but figured they had some ready to go. I got to my work truck to eat and when I opened my box I could not believe what I got. What looks to be old pizza from the night before, reheated with melted mozzarella on top. It looked like the type of pizza 7-11 has on display. Old, nasty pizza. Couldn't even eat it and tossed it out to the trash. Very disappointed to waste time and money supporting a local business. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Old pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

Was craving some New York pizza with ricotta and found this spot. Unassuming location doesn't do the food justice. The pizza was great! Very reasonably priced. I've got the menu handy on my fridge for the next craving. We preordered using the online service which was quick and easy. Food ready when we got there. Could see going and sitting in just to get a quiet moment away from more crowded spots. They have a great lunch special for under $10. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Ricotta and Supreme. FAB! - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Thank goodness I haven't seen roaches in the restaurant like some Yelpers did; their pizzas are delicious! Just so you know, they have jumbo 20-inch pizzas that aren't on the menu! read more

See all

I had a strange experience here. As an employee handed me the order, he showed me his phone and told me to watch a video. I noticed above the video he told me to watch was me. It dawned on me that he was recording me and without my consent while tricking me to watch a video. I asked him why he was doing this, but didn't give much of an answer. I told him to delete it. I'm not sure he did, but hopefully he did. I told him he needs to ask permission. He then claimed that by having the video visible above was him being transparent and asking, which of course is not acceptable. I have no idea what his intentions were, but it was creepy and totally inappropriate. I wouldn't recommend this business solely on this encounter. Go support another business that won't video you with their personal phone. read more

Very mediocre pizza. Mostly, the crust tastes insipid and cheap. It's as if it hasn't been allowed to rise properly and also the cheese is very bland. Very disappointing, especially since when this pizzeria first opened as Uncle Red's pizzeria, the crust was fantastic, the cheese was stringy and flavorful, and the ingredients were top-tier quality and taste. Then they rebranded as Omar's pizzeria and at that point the quality and taste of the pizza immediately took a dive. We have had frozen pizzas just as good as this pizza. read more

Delicious! New York style full of flavor and perfect crust. Fast delivery after placing my order. This will be my only pizza from now on.

Good pizza NY kinda style but not quite. It's a place we go sometimes after golfing at Santa Anita

We ordered from Omar's over the phone for delivery. The food was very good, very fairly priced, and the delivery guy left it at our hotel door when I thought I'd have to go down and get it at the front desk. Would order again! read more

When this place opened back when I was in high school, it was fantastic. Loved the white pizza with ricotta. Omar has since sold the business and moved on - he's no longer affiliated with this Omar's Pizza establishment. Seems like the new management has cut corners a bit. I also used to be a big fan of Omar's meatball pizza, with thick, round, meaty slices of meatball on top. Now it's a bunch of chopped up little cube specks of mystery mince meat on top like a Totino's pizza from the freezer aisle. It's not a terrible pizza, but nothing like it used to be. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Meatball pizza now looks like mincemeat pizza. Back in the day used to have thick round slices of meatball on top, like a thicker pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

I love pizza. And I love Omar's. This is a no-frills NY-style pizza place. I buy these pizzas in bulk. Awhile back I got 8 pizzas for a party. A few weeks ago I bought 6 pizzas at one time to bring to another friend's party. Yesterday I ordered 2 to bring to yet another party. Every party I bring these pizzas to, everyone loves it -- And asks me where I got it from. It's Omar's in Arcadia. You can order pizza at the regular size, or the larger size. For value, I always get the larger size. Comes out to about $25-30 per specialty pizza, no matter what pizza you get. You can order online via their website, or use the Slice app. If you do bigger orders, better to order via Omar's website because the rewards cash back makes more sense than the Slice app rewards program. There's different guys working the place whenever I go. Not always super friendly, even when I pick up 6 or 8 pizzas in one order. Sometimes they open the pizza boxes for me to confirm the order, sometimes they don't. Even though it's not all that friendly with these guys, nor do they seem to appreciate it when I spend $170 to $260 (includes tip) at a time on pizza....I still give them 5 stars because I really do love their pizza. Totally recommend them for the food. Only you can decide if you can overcome the I-don't-care-if-you're-a-good-customer attitude. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Picked up 6 large pizzas yesterday. $25 each. So worth it and everyone loved them! - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Great quality and reasonable prices. The taste of the sauce is good and they are generous with the toppings. We order from here whenever we are in the area. read more

Veronica was nice, but the delivery guy is not reliable, he was late for more than 20mins. And when we opened the boxes of pizzas, the pizzas are all messed up. I should trust the reviews ‍. It is so sad, the pizzas are for the middle school just 2mins away from Omar. I should had just pick them up myself . They Charges $4 for delivery and I gave them $5 tips too. I really can't believe I got this level of service back. We are so disappointed, we won't come back again. read more

Still Amazing. Also a Go-To for the Fam. My 2 boys can eat the whole jumbo pepperoni by themselves. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Half Bronx, Half Works - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

If you buy lil Ceasars and reheat it up in an Air Fryer, it tastes better than this. Honestly, idk if it's better than lil Ceasars as is. The dough was pretty bland, this place tastes like a slightly better digiorno's pizza. read more

Meh, another mediocre pizza joint in the SGV pretending to be NYC. Cheap ingredients and blah taste. I especially agree with those who say the crust is bland (poor quality- likely cheap dough)--not to mention it chewed like a Michelin tire. The red sauce tasted like it came out of a Prego jar (sweet and ick). Better stick with DiGiorno's in aisle B12 at Target. read more

Omar's used to be the best pizza in town. NO MORE! The mushroom, olive, pepperoni pizza had hardly any pepperoni and almost no mushrooms. It was heavy on canned slice olives and tasted like cardboard. We also ordered an Italian salad that had fresh romaine lettuce and that's about all except for a few very grey sliced tomatoes. We had loved this pizza place for 20 years but WE'RE DONE! read more