We enjoyed our experience at Old Bay Cafe! This little waterfront gem is exactly what you hope to find when you're craving fresh seafood in a relaxed, no-frills setting. The menu is simple and done right -- fresh catch fish served as sandwiches, tacos, and salads. Everything tasted incredibly fresh and flavorful. You can tell they focus on quality over fuss, and it absolutely works. The divey, laid-back vibe just adds to the charm. It feels unpretentious and welcoming -- the kind of place where you can show up in sandals, grab a cold drink, and stay awhile. The waterfront location makes it even more fun, especially on a pretty day. Service was friendly and attentive without being overbearing. read more

See all

Love this place! Loved the kind, attentive staff! Unpretentious, simple spot right at a marina that focuses on the quality of the food not the showy tourist trap distractions. I had the 6oz Grouper sandwich. Fresh, generous and flavorful, not overly dressed, tasty pickle too. Nice choice of local brews on tap. This is what I was hoping for (agh I wish they had grilled shrimp!) read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Grouper sandwich - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

A terrific place to have a meal on the water. We had a very nice meal and the server was very attentive. I had a Grouper dinner which was fixed just right. My wife had a Grouper sandwich which was delicious. read more

See all

Really cool casual vibe seafood joint at the marina. Service was friendly and timely and I appreciated the no reservation policy. We timed it perfectly as we got to see the wonderful sunset right as we sat down. All of us had great meals. My grouper platter followed by a delicious piece of key lime pie was a perfect meal. Try it! read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Grooper platter - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

A little gem on the marina in Dunedin. Outdoor & shaded deck right on the water , lovely views and soooo relaxing . Great fresh caught seafood , long list of draft beers . Very attentive wait staff. We had amazing salad ( key lime dressing yum!- they should sell it) , poke bowl with Asian noodles and chowder !! read more

I loved Olde Bay Cafe! It was the perfect spot to grab a rum cocktail, some fresh peel & eats, & a delicious authentic key lime pie to finish. The outside was quaint & cozy, the service was attentive, friendly, and efficient. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Great servers, nice view, good simple food. Great peel and eat shrimp. For a tiny spot the servers really get around.

The location was very nice, right on the water. I stopped in for lunch while visiting Dunedin for the weekend. The wait staff was very friendly snd even came over to give my dog a treat. The food was just ok. I ordered a crab roll and it was tiny, my wife had a burger and said it was fine but it was well done and she wasn't asked how she wanted it cooked. It stop in again for drinks just for the location and friendly staff. read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Outside seating. - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

It's always busy here and for good reason! Staff is friendly and amazing views. We usually sit in the back at the small bar so we don't usually have to wait. Our go to is the tuna with noodle appetizer read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Tuna and noods - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

Came here for dinner. We shared three appetizers: corn and shrimp Soup, ahi Poke Bowl, and crab stuffed avocado. Usually three starters is too much. This time we ordered the haddock Tacos. Everything was delicious, but small. The service was Johnny-on-the-spot. And the vibe was great. read more

Great location right on the water with outdoor seating. I had the Southwestern Salmon wrap and it was amazing! All the waitresses were friendly!!!! read more

See all

I just swung in for a quick pickup to take a snack to the Marina to sit and read awhile. I forgot to take pics but because I'm gluten intolerant, I just ordered a Shrimp Cocktail with horseradish and a green salad. Honestly, I wasn't expecting a lot because it was just a quick snack. The bartender was super friendly and happy doing her job! She made a few suggestions to accommodate my GF needs so I'll have more ideas for next time. I really enjoyed both the simple salad with key lime vinegarette and my shrimp cocktail was cold and fresh! It was a great lite lunch! I'll do it again! Sorry no pics. read more

Wow Had a great Sat morning Vibe going, could go anywhere with in an hour drive..... We picked Olde Bat Cafe because we saw it looked deserving of a visit....Took out the new Car with the wife and drove the hour there, got there at 11:00 as we like to pick a nice place to park the Brand new SUV. Parked got out of car walked to the restaurant, it seemed like we might of been first there..... instantly the Karen there told me that I parked incorrectly, asked me to mive my car... I asked where she was Parked and of course it was a huge spot right in front guaranteed not to get a door ding... I only parked in the spot I did because she had taken the only good spot ip front Weird Usually employees park in the back, anyways at that point my wife slipped back into the car as the Mornings Vibe was totaled... We had a nice Brunch 100 yds away that was delightful and actually on the water..... So I couldnt tell you how their food was as Karen didn't even let me in the Door!!!! Thanks Karen....won't be going to your establishment ....ever! Should change name to Olde Karen Cafe...... read more

Several times we have enjoyed Fish Camp and looked forward to eating at Olde Bay. HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT I'm sad to say. There were 5 in our group and no one was happy with their food. Burger was blah. Haddock was dry overcooked crab cake not good. Scallop wrap was okay. The service was good. Ambience was good. Paid for it. But it's first and last for us. Wanted to try safety harbor location but won't. I'm sure we will go back to fish camp in the future but will be skeptical. Fool me once shame on you! read more

Old Bay Café is a downtown Dunedin institution and never disappoints; fresh, delicious food, friendly service, and the coziest vibe. Highly recommend! read more

I've had their crabcakes their pork sandwich their salmon wraps they have a good groupie sandwich I love their beer, my favorite is dead Pete, so good and FYI one of the best soups is the shrimp corn potato chowder out of this world and the view. The ambience of the water overlooking the marina is breathtaking to watch the sunset. The staff is fun. They have games that you can play on the TV trivia on your own phone so you just download the QR code on the television and play away and have fun with your friends and the staff the service is wonderful the waitresses and the bartenders the chef, the cooks the runners off fabulous great sense of humor knowledgeable of the surrounding areas. Fun beautiful place. read more

See all

Get the peanut butter pie for dessert! The view, service and ambience is great, but you will finish that pie and instantly want another slice! It's soooo good! read more

Great location in charming town. Great sunset views. Food and drinks uncomplicated and filling. Try the grouper!

Great food and service. We had to wait a bit - place was full! But it was worth it. Food quality, good music on the background, great water view. First time. Will be back! read more

As locals, we decided to take a bike ride along the trails and stopped at Olde Bay Café for a quick lunch and a cold drink. We were not disappointed! The shrimp tacos were delicious, and the mahi sandwich was perfectly cooked and flavorful. It was the perfect spot to refuel and relax while enjoying the waterfront views. We'll definitely be back! Staff were friendly and did an excellent job! read more

See all

Very cute place on the water and best kept secret to come here after the crazy Dunedin parades as it's a short walk away and never a long wait but shhhhh don't tell anyone. They make great drinks too like a margarita highly recommend. I got the burger wrap and I've gotten the Cuban sandwich before too. Both are amazing and I always ask for more of their dijonaise on the side. Good prices, pretty atmosphere on the water with lights at night and good music if you like alternative. read more

Olde Bay Cafe - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

It's okay. My snapper tasted fine but had six bones in it. My husband said his grouper was dry. For a $75 lunch I hoped for better. The location however is great. read more

Went for lunch and got a seat along the railing overlooking the water. We put our name in as they were full, but our seats opened up within a minute or two. Good selection of beer and wine and menu selections of seafood and non-seafood items. I got the 6 oz. Mahi sandwich, and it was a beautiful chunk of fish with a great sauce and fresh veggies. Definitely needed my fork and napkins. My wife got the Shrimp Salad Wrap, and she said it was delicious. The dijonaise was a great accompaniment. The servers checked in 6-8 times, and the patio had a very casual and fun vibe. read more

See all

Amazing view in Dunedin. The grouper and tripletail were delicious. Seafood was very fresh and the server was friendly and attentive.

Food here was fresh and served fast. Ordered the crab cake. Good sized patty. Well seasoned. The extenders was not overpowering. The salsas was fresh and a good balance. Did not need dressing. Price was on the higher end. The best part about this place is the location. Right by the water, relaxing, and chill. Our server was engaging, friendly and fast. read more

See all

Great location for this little mostly outdoor seafood establishment. I've been told they also own the fish camp in town, the food and the sides, and the view and the waitresses, and the cook, the cleanliness of the establishment, the freshness of the seafood. why would you go anywhere else? read more

See all

Located right at the Dunedin Marina, literally a stone's throw from the Best Western Hotel, this was a wonderful spot for a quick, convenient, casual meal and/or lazy afternoon cocktails. We ate there twice, once as a group of nine and then as a smaller group of four. Both times, our orders were taken quickly and efficiently, wonderful service with a smile. Nothing "gourmet deluxe," but a PERFECT option if you're in the area and want a reasonably priced, DELICIOUS, locally-sourced (I assume...) meal. Give 'em a try if you're in the area!! read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Scallop wrap - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

This is one of my favorite places to go. The staff is excellent and attentive. They work as a cohesive unit. The food is also excellent and consistent. I'm gluten free which can be a pain however they are very accommodating. The view and prices are hard to beat in Florida. It's dog friendly too. My pup runs up the stairs to see his awaiting fans. This is our go to place to bring guests when they visit. read more

Olde Bay Cafe - View from the restaurant - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

Very friendly staff. Good seafood. Great views. Had shrimp tacos and crab and corn chowder read more

Stopped in here and sat at the outside bar. The view was beautiful! I ordered the haddock tacos. The fish was grilled and had good flavor! It was topped with a key lime flavored slaw and a fresh slice of avocado. The side was kettle chips. read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Haddock tacos - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

This is a great little seafood spot right on the water in Dunedin. They have mostly outdoor seating in a few spots on the inside of this cozy dining establishment. Food is fresh and there are no fryers so don't expect any kind of fried foods, but the food you will get our delicious! Great selection of draft beers to wet the pallet, as well as some wines and sangrias as well.cocktails are also available as I do have a full liquor bar. This place is a little bit on the small side. You may have to wait a little bit, but that just gives you a reason to walk around the pier area while your table is prepped. read more

See all

i love this place. the food is always fresh and tasty, the service is always friendly, and the casual waterfront experience can't be beaten. i've eaten here several times and brought several out-of-town guests... it's so nice to be able to eat right on the water without paying an arm and a leg or getting fancy tiny entrees. everything we've tried has been delicious, particularly the grouper: it's fresh-caught, and you can tell for sure. it's so good. most recently, i also had the shrimp tacos, and i could literally eat them every day they were so tasty. the key lime slaw was like a little flavor bomb on top of the seasoned shrimp, and the avocado on top was the perfect hit of creaminess. so filling, so yummy. drinks are a bit expensive, but not necessary to enjoy the meal. this has been one of my favorite finds downtown and i'm happy to keep coming back. read more

See all

Been here twice now with locals and its overpriced, poor quality and surly service. Note there is another listing of Dunedin Fish Market & Olde Bay Cafe which is the same place. I get why locals bring guests here, you can sit on the water and have food and drinks. They do have a good happy hour from 2-5 with a dollar off beers, and a nice taplist, but that's it for positives. On the first visit last year I got the market stone crab (I've had it at Joes in Miami so I know its expensive) and it was OK. The service was terrible, no refills, no splitting of checks for our group of 10, and really we only wanted 3 checks. We were handed a bill and a pencil and told we could figure it out ourselves and pay with one CC. Note they also charge exorbitant CC fees and don't tell you (it is on the bill I believe). While we were scrambling to total our bill the server stopped by twice to ask what was taking so long to pay! I'm 100% serious. Second visit last week (see pic). I got the market Mahi with Asian Noodles and vegetable. Mahi was cold, dry, rubbery, overcooked. As other recent reviews have noted the fish is not as fresh as it used to be. Vegetables were completely bland. no seasoning, no butter and also cold. Asian noodles were the highlight. Our server kept saying she would bring us waters but never did until well after the food was served. In summary, come here for the view or a beer but expect to overpay for mediocre food and harassing service. read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Mahi platter - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

Great place on the marina to eat. The clam chowder was yummy but the grouper burrito was just ok. The server was a tentative. Being by the water was great but the smell was from the debris in the water made it not so good of an experience read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Grouper burrito with chips - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

Took out of town friend there for food. The appetizer was serviced straight up with a bag of vending machine sized pita chips. At least dump them onto a plate for presentation! LOL The stone crab was okay- better than most local spots but nothing to write home about. This was a few years ago. Needless to say, we never returned nor have desire to. Oh well read more

Olde Bay was recommended by staff at the Dunedin visitor center so I gave it a try. It's a great location in the marina that's casual and has great views. My view came with a manatee that was also enjoying the area. Old Bay has a nice drink menu and I can recommend the vodka Paloma. Perfect on a hot day! Many fish dish options and I went with the blackened scallop wrap. It was excellent. Enjoy a walk around the marina and Main Street for an awesome day. read more

See all

First time here and love this place!!! Service is top notch and so far had the fish spread, shrimp wrap and both were on point. Here for the weekend and will be back. Great beer selection and nice covered outdoor seating overlooking the marina. Yay for this place!!!! read more

Olde Bay Cafe - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

We chose this restaurant because it is pet friendly. I had the shrimp salad wrap and my husband had the salmon wrap. Both wraps were excellent. The potato salad is definitely worth trying. It could have used a tad more salt, but liked that it was made w red skin potatoes. The staff was exceptionally welcoming to our dogs. read more

Great grouper sandwich. Another open-air restaurant where it was quite nice to eat outside under a canopy. Very friendly and fast service. read more

Olde Bay Cafe - Grouper sandwich. - New American Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

Not sure why it has such low ratings but I definitely enjoyed Ole Bay Cafe! Apparently, they're known for the peel-and-eat shrimp with garlic butter so highly recommend it! You have the option to select cold or hot but definitely get hot! We were able to sit outside with a view of the dock. read more