Always great food! Good Italian dishes with excellent ingredients and large portions. Delivery is on-time and friendly.

They don't know stuffed shells from manicotti. What a shithole. I'm over it. Oh. But it's the same price so, yeah. Idiots. Seriously though... they want to tell me "but the price is the same". BUT that's not what I ordered. Nothing. No "we can fix this" just, "the price is the same". pffft read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - NOT a stuffed shell. - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

I used to go here all the time. I loved the food. The last 3 times I went it was disgusting. A harsh word but my husband had veal Parm and it was hard and old. My sausage and peppers was nasty. I had pizza last time and it was over cooked (burnt) The time before that it was under cooked. Where's the old cook? Are you hiring new people that don't care? Get it together before you lose more customers. I won't be back read more

We love the quality and quantity you get for the price. The dinners are usually enough for two! Good authentic Italian flavors. Pizza and wings are really good as well. They have the meatiest wings in the area. It's a modest atmosphere with a nice outdoor area. Nice family restaurant for casual donning. read more

Bread is horrible... dry no oil and vinegar and I don't even see the mayo. Barely have any onions on it. Totally disappointed and spent a lot of money. Should of eaten somewhere else. SMH read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - Italian Combo Hero - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

Having lived in Gardiner quite a while this is our go to place to eat. The food is always good as well as the servers. I do think that they should do something about the ladies room. It's just awful. The paper towel dispenser is open and filthy and the room needs some renovation. read more

Found this place by accident while passing through the area and had a very good meal. I had the meatball parmigiana hero and my wife had the Italian Trio panini. Both were fresh and tasted great. My hero was decent sized, hot, and had a generous amount of sliced meatballs and melted cheese. My wife's panini was large, on ciabatta bread baked fresh in the restaurant, and had an appropriate amount of meat. The gentleman that waited on us was exceptionally polite and pleasant, something generally in short supply these days. All in a a great experience, would highly recommend! read more

Lemme tell you sumtin, you ain't f***ing lived until you've tried this place. Busy, poppin, NYC style SLAMMIN pizza. The actual dinner style food is also *chefs kiss* You HAVE to get the garlic knot chicken parm/meatball parm sliders. Dont sleep on the dessert either‍ read more

Can't wait to come back ! Our group of 8 were seated promptly. The service is wonderful and everyone was so pleasant. Our group ordered pasta, sandwiches and pizza , and everything was excellent. We are from out of state , but hope to visit again when we are back in the area. read more

I got a ribeye steak here and despite being way overcooked for my liking, it was AMAZING! It was on the dinner special and simply spiced to perfection. While dining, the smell of pizza was calling me. I've been back twice for pizza, just this weekend alone, on my mountain bike via the rail trail. I get pepperoni, extra cheese, green peppers and mushrooms. ABSOLUTELY AWESOME PIZZA! Atmosphere is great too! read more

Love the margarita Pie! Highly recommend that pie. Good flavor led sauce. Try either location. read more

Thoroughly devoid of flavor. Add chocolate milk and it'll be like you're back in elementary school.

We had found a driving tour of the Hudson Valley and it said that Gardiner had cute shops and restaurants. When we got to Gardiner, we were hungry and we didn't see many restaurants. Pasquale's had a nice patio so we stopped. They have a large selection of pizzas by the slice. The pizza was good and the patio was pleasant. read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - Grandma Thin Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

Stopped in on the way home from New Paltz (we live about 20 mins from the restaurant), grabbed a few slices (margarita-soooo good, meatball and bbq chicken ranch with pepperoni-hubby said they were both ok, he thought they'd be more flavorful) and I also had the eggplant parm slider which was amazing. The service was quick and they were super friendly and helpful. We also got 2 sodas and the total bill was about $22, imo that's a bargain! I'd def stop in again. read more

Friendly and helpful staff. Can sit indoors or enjoy the quaint outdoor courtyard to dine. Generous servings. Been here several times and have enjoyed every dish. The large Caesar salad is served with or without chicken, is delicious and easily shared. Many pizza selections. read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - Large chicken Caesar salad with fresh grated Parmesan. - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

My friends and I are staying in Gardiner for the weekend and decided to order Pasquales for delivery last night. We were hungry, and despite the negative reviews for slow delivery, we decided to order from here anyway. Unfortunately the reviews were true. Delivery was slow and even though we were only a 6 minute drive from the restaurant, the food was all cold and needed to be reheated. Now for the food, I ordered the chicken parm sub and mozzarella sticks. I really wasn't a fan of the mozzarella sticks. The cheese wasn't stretch like I like it and the outer breading was oily. But maybe this was due to me needing to reheat the food in the microwave? The chicken parm was pretty standard. It wasn't anything special but it tasted fine. Overall, the delivery was slow and the food was just ok. I'm not sure I would order delivery again but maybe I would try something else on the menu if I stopped into the actual restaurant next time I'm in Gardiner! read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - Chicken Parmigiana Hero - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

See all

We just picked up a large cheese pizza and it's even better than I remember! Perfectly charred crust, the right proportion of sauce to melty cheese. What more can you want from pizza? read more

I think this place deserves better than 3 stars. I didn't even look at these reviews before going, thankfully. We sat outside (I didn't realize you had to actually go inside to be seated... they might want to put up a sign if that's an official thing), love those concrete tables with the umbrella! Our waitress was really sweet and accommodating. The pizza was exactly what I was craving... I was really happy with it. Believe it or not, even better than that was the sautéed broccoli. That was done perfectly... soooo good. Even the house salad with House Italian dressing was very good. A strong vinegar flavor but pretty unique. I liked it. I'd go back if I lived around there. read more

Was in the new paltz area and my dude insisted we stop here for a slice bc it is his fave spot from the college years- count me in for pizza anyday! Popped in and everything was so clean with an array of choices in the case for slices. We each picked something and I wasn't sure what slice I had but it was dope regardless! Seemed like Marsala slice w red onions and some other jazzy goodness. Will def be back when I'm in the area read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - Thought this was mushroom but it was a tasty mystery - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

The pizza is great and not bad I love to go when they have the 2 gourmet slices and a drink for about $9. The pizza is pretty solid and the service is quick! So for 2 slices that are pretty big portions and a drink it's well worth the value! read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - Margarita Pizza and Meat Lover's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

Place is situated nearby Minnewaska state park & has both indoor & outdoor seating. The staff is friendly & attentive & even provided us with free WiFi when we asked. The portions are generous & some meals come with soup or salad. Pizza always hits differently after a hike and the Margherita pizza we ordered was so GOOD, but would definitely taste good anytime. The Stromboli I ordered was HUGE and really delicious which you can customize; I got chicken & broccoli. My boyfriend ordered the chicken Marsala combo with shrimp & the sauce was amazing. The only thing I did not like was the lasagna fritters or the tortellini soup. The fritters didn't taste like lasagna, which I don't really mind, but the filling was under seasoned and pretty bland. The tortellini soup was too salty for my taste, and for $3.95 I expected maybe a bit more soup. Both the fritters & soup were cold, which could be due to the fact that it was a bit chilly outside, but I'm not sure if that was the case. Overall, I would probably come back here for the pizza & Stromboli but I would skip the fritters & soup next time, or maybe order a salad because I saw many people order it & the portions were HUGE. read more

See all

The service was amazing, super kind and friendly. We got a big amount of food and fountain drinks and our total was very acceptable and honestly suprising of how low it was. The food tasted great, the pizza, knots, greek salad, and cheesecake was phenomenal!! The perfect restaurant to take your kids, parents, or whoever to. 100% recommend. read more

Amazing pizza!!! Even the gf is fantastic! Have been ordering out for years here. The delivery takes about an hour, so plan ahead.

Quick delivery. Great quality. Good portions. My go to for local delivery.. Nice eat in too. read more

We love stopping in for a slice or two. Delicious, great service, friendly. Pretty solid.

No pictures because we hiked in Minnewaska and showed up RAVENOUS. This place is awesome! Quiet, outdoor seating, nice music, this was exactly what we needed after ignoring trail markers and needlessly adding 4 miles to our hike. The cheese and white-broccoli slices were perfectly cooked and delicious. Our group also downed some mini meatball sliders and a slice of BBQ chicken (which was pretty robust but flavored very well) read more

This is my Most Favorite Place to have very good Italian Food. I'm Italian and very picky I might add! I have to say Their Grandma's Pizza is The Best I've ever had!!! It's also my Favorite!!! I grew up on the Lower East side and I lived in the Hudson Valley for 32 years!! I've experienced pizza all around. They are Hands down the Best. The Chicken Quesadillas are out of this world too. The Shrimp Parmesan is very good & baked stuffed Shells. Salads are fresh too. The Cobb Salad is huge. The Ingredients they use for their pizza are quality cheeses and sauce . The staff That Cooks it's all up are good at what they Do. Service is Very Good. They Do get very busy at times especially in the summer when the patio gets packed! you just have to be a little patient . It will be worth it. Prices are reasonable. I Highly recommend it , in the most Beautiful Town I think, in The Hudson Valley. This Restaurant, Trattoria is a Gem within it. I felt compelled to review it because I think it deserves more than 3 stars. read more

Way off there mark. One small pizza cold and the other came with noting on it. Waited another 20 mins. 2 people in the place?? Second pizza came out semi warm. Hope they get it together or we are out! read more

Ordered here last night, the pizza pie we got tasted horrible. I'm very surprised and disappointed that I paid over $20 for a terrible medium pizza pie. Don't come here just look for another spot within the area read more

Love their food and the service! Delivery guy is always quick to deliver with a smile

Best pizza around. Even better then some place's in Brooklyn where I grew up. Service was great. I ordered to go.

Pasquale's in Gardiner has been our go to pizza joint for years. Sadly, the manager who brought life to the place ( Chris) is no longer there. It has been awhile since he left, but the difference in the atmosphere is still palpable. The wait staff are wonderful, however, Chris used to make the rounds of the dining room , greeting customers, joking etc. After all this time, I'm still not sure who is in charge when the owner isn't present. ( an owner who has never acknowledged our existence btw). The music is played so loudly at times I can not hear what we are talking about. So the negative aside, the pizza is wonderful. Consistent, hot, crispy. The menu is varied with something for everyone. The garlic knots are large , really garlicky, soft and delicious. Service is fast as is the kitchen. No complaints there. I will say with the loud music and how cold they keep the dining room , we don't go as often, but I do recommend it. read more

My husband and I love this place!! We have never had a bad meal here. We order at least once a week. From their heroes to their dinners, everything is delicious and hearty, never skimping on any ingredients. Even those who answer the phone are always polite, friendly and professional. Definitely would recommend! read more

Five years ago this rating would have been at least a four, maybe higher. about a year ago the quality of the pizza started to decline. We bought a takeout pie last week which made the national chain pizzas look good. The base of the pie was thick and chewy, sauce was flavorless, toppings were sparce as well as being somewhat overdone. There are two other restaurants locally by the same name which I would assume are owned by the same company. After finding that the Gardiner location has hit rock bottom the others will bask in the same reputation. Time to give up on Pasquale's. read more

They only care about there favorite customers, would be in line, skip to the next person

it's solid. that's all there is too say. you won't be upset. i'm not over the moon about it but i'm never disappointed

these plain slices are just embarrassing compared to the specialty slices. I'm not sure how you can be okay with serving baby chuck e cheese slices. two of these plain combined is like the average slice. Should have just paid for 3 slices read more

Pasquales Pizza & Restaurant - these plain slices are just embarrassing. I'm not sure how you can be okay with serving baby chuck e cheese slices. - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, New York

Never Heard of a Italian restaurant Using chicken fingers Instead of chicken cutlets In a penne vodka dinner Literally terrible read more

Previously gave 2 stars. (Went here years ago and was extremely disapointed in my visit. It was expensive and the food was a huge let down.) Not sure if new owners or staff but... UPDATE: Out of necessity I ordered from here on New Years day, had guests over and they had to be fed. Called and placed an order for a pizza and a large antipasto salad. They delivered within 30-40 mins as they stated. The salad was very large and delicious. The pizza was flavorful and crisp. With just these 2 items we were able to have about 6 plates of food. The prices are fair for the the portions. We have gone back 2 times since. read more

Food is good. Would of given 4 stars if not for the service. Very rude and unprofessional. You cannot handle money and then food. Also must learn how to politely answer a phone and take an order. Losing business over simple fixes. Hopefully owner will take note. Act professional! Training and supervision is needed. read more