Patsys is a New York staple. For the ones who know, they know. This location isn't the original but it's still great. Service was kind, clean, and efficient. We ordered the pizza and it never misses. Prices weren't cheap but were pretty standard as far as New York goes. Decent portions. Flavors overall are great, typically American Italian cuisine, nothing too crazy but still worth the bite. Calzones and other pastas are pretty passable for the same description provided earlier. One of my first dates was at this location and it was memorable for multiple reasons. I may be biased but Patsys does great with providing great food while making you feel like a valuable customer. read more

Not sure why this doesn't have a higher rating but I think it's because it's New York and it's just too hard to admit that pizza is good. Standards are too high, maybe? For us, it was delicious and I loved that the pasta and the pizza. The ambiance was what we were looking for. Cozy, loud but not crazy and family friendly. So good. Service was good too. read more

Love love love Patsy's pizza - of course the Patsy's in Harlem is the most infamous but this one is just as great and for me, conveniently closer. I've been going to Patsy's for years and over that time it's only grown in popularity. As they've changed around the interior, there are more large booths fit for larger groups and it's common to walk in on a Saturday evening and see the place packed with families sharing a meal. Of course known for their pizza, there's so much more on the menu that's terrific! Would recommend the ravioli, zucchini and eggplant chips with garlic yogurt, baked ziti - honestly, I could go on. Would definitely recommend a reservation for the busy weeknights and weekend evenings. Otherwise I would say you could expect to wait maybe 20-30 minutes if walking in at a busy time. read more

See all

Found this spot on Yelp because we were at the nearby hospital waiting for a friend to be discharged and it was getting a bit late. Overall, a good Italian meal but nothing stood out. Pizza and pasta was solid for a classic NYC neighborhood restaurant. read more

Patsy's is our family's favorite get together dinner place and every time we go, it's an amazing experience. Food is awesome, service is wonderful, special shout out to Bernard (hope I'm getting his name right) for being our helpful and accommodating server. Looking forward to many more dinners there! read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Do not order take out from this restaurant. We ordered a large margherita pizza and some zucchini chips. After calling the restaurant after no delivery after 45 mins, we were assured the food was on its way. It arrived 15 mins later, utterly ice cold. The zucchini chips were a congealed inedible mess. We called the restaurant and asked for a refund. They told us we had to call ChowNow. We called ChowNow and then they call the restaurant to confirm the problem. They refunded the charges. There are too many good pizza places in the area that get it right to deal with this kind of lunacy. Eat at the restaurant. It's good. The take out is a clown show. read more

We left MSK testing and found Patsy on first ave and 68th . Pizza was great as was our dishes. read more

See all

If you want pizza, go in person. It is only good for around 15 minutes out of the oven. It is good at the resto, cooked in a blistering hot oven makes the crust crispy on the outside it nicely soft on the inside. The tomatoes in the salad were surprisingly unripe service was just okay read more

The ambiance of this place is remoantic and relaxed. It was pretty empty when we came on a Tueaday night at 8pm. They have both interior and outside seating. The service was poor. The waitress came over took our orders and came back one time. I had to go to the bar and ask for another drink, this was after we had made eye contact numerous times she continued to sit at the bar folding napkins. When I got to the bar she did not even move then. we received more attention from the bus boy then we did from the waitress. If you asked me the manager and the waitress have something going in but that's only speculation on my part, lol. The food was very good and enjoyable and has nice flavors the portions were perfect size. We had to ask for bread and never even asked if we wanted cheese on our food. Dessert was very good. The manager came over and did apologize and paid for my glass of wine. read more

See all

The pizza is always amazing at Pateys. Fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, and perfect crust. The penne vodka was cooked perfectly as well. The vodka sauce tasty and filling. The only reason for the 4 stars----no hot bread with the pasta. That should've been an automatic. But the place was nice, the service was excellent, horrible parking but a nice place to eat. read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Cannoli - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Such a great place to get authentic simplistic Italian food. Great music, calm environment. Beautiful decor. The veal parmigiana was amazing. Crispy, great cut, the sauce was delicious. And the star of the show, the fried zucchini and eggplant chips with garlic Greek yogurt dip. Just. Get. It. That's it just go and eat. Great service read more

See all

We love coming here on our usual Tuesday afternoon! This is the best spot on 1st Avenue to have lunch; right on the corner of 69th street and 1st avenue. Who doesn't like pizza? With a side of salad. Nothing beats it. Their ingredients are fresh and the taste of everything is just delicious. Our server was so patient and made good recommendations for us. We ended up settling on a large old fashion margarita pizza and two insalatas; one mista and one Siciliana. They Definitely have the best pizza, salad and service for lunch in the city! read more

See all

Top 5 pizza in Manhattan. I miss when you were allowed to eat your slices inside. Grab a plain slice and you won't be disappointed but definitely grab two. It's real old school bring cash read more

The pizza was extremely flavorful and filled with lots of mozzarella, I do wish there was some sliced tomato on top but that's just what I'm used to when it comes to a Margherita pizza; the mozzarella sticks were good but I paid like $12 for 3 so I recommend NOT doing that lol, lots of seating and plenty of topping options! Great place to be in and out! Service was quick! read more

See all

One of the OG pizza places of NYC!! Consistent in quality, service, and taste. We got the 17" margherita pizza and added pepperoni and it was plenty of good for 3 people or 2 super hungry people. The sauce is slightly sweet, the mozzarella is generous and chewy, and the crust is flavorful. Definitely a go-to pizza place in the area. read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Old-Fashioned Margherita Pizza with pepperoni - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

A group of us went in the late afternoon.. We asked for separate checks and were told they couldn't do it: "checks are done by tables." ??? Also, we could only use no more than 2 credit cards to pay: we were 8 people. The rest has to be cash. One person in our group had to leave the store to go to an ATM machine to get cash. We gave them the drink order and then the food order. it took forever for Bread.to come, and when it did, the basket was never replenished. By the way, there was only one other customer in the store: an older couple sharing a pizza. The food was as good, as the other Italian restaurants in the area. I expected better service. I was a regular Customer several years ago and the service was outstanding, they did separate checks, and the wait staff was friendly, attentive and accommodating. It seems like it's a different place today. I miss the old place. I guess it's true when they say, "You can never go back!" read more

A popular spot for the local hospital. Service was a bit slow for salads but the pizza was hot and fresh. Cappucino was great and the shrimp pasta in white wine sauce was good. Appreciate the serving of shrimp! Music is a little loud in there but overall good for the upper east side. read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Every time I come here, I feel the experience is worsening. We were stuck in a booth in the back and then they forgot about us. After I found a waitress and she came to take our order, the food came out pretty quick. We then did not see our waitress again for about twenty minutes. Eventually, when the waitress came back, my grandmother ordered a coffee. She was given a black coffee. We asked for cream. The waitress came back ten minutes later with my fathers third drink and no milk or cream. Super silly but I felt we were ignored for most of the dining experience. Food is just mediocre. Also the entire time we were sitting, a light outside(attached to restaurant) kept turning on and off repeatedly. Super annoying read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Old-Fashioned Margherita Pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We ordered take out from here and the pizza is delicious! They made the pizza pretty fast and were friendly! It is pricey though, so I don't see myself ordering from here a lot, maybe special occasions. The inside looks nice though, pretty lights! read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

*** 3.5 Stars *** Currently Patsy's has an overall 3.5 star rating and that is totally correct. It is better than "just okay" but it's also not somewhere I'd go out of my way to return to or recommend to anyone. What is good about it is that it is a sit down pizza place and there isn't a long wait for a table, and while the pizza is good, this is NYC and it's definitely not able to compete with even Joe's especially when you consider the price. The white pizza was at least interesting. The caesar salad and calamari were basic and forgettable, but did the trick. It worked well for our occasion - we had a group and wanted to be able to sit down and eat pizza, and somewhere in the UWS - but it's not somewhere I'd go out of my way to return to. read more

After visiting at nearby hospital, Saturday night and rainy. Stopped in for quick meal. Husband ordered seafood pasta. Although tasty it only had two claims and three shrimps and the smallest scallops I have ever seen for $31.00. I had chicken Milanese over arugula salad, tasty but not the best. Service was good and pleasant. Food came out fast b/c it wasn't crowded at all. Will try another restaurant next time. read more

Conveniently located near MSKCC hospital, we were in the mood for some pizza. There are quite a few Patsy's Pizzeria so their website is Patsyspizzerianyc.com. We wanted a quick dinner so we shared a small Fried Zucchini and Eggplant Chips which was enough for the 3 of us and large Margherita pie. They were all very good! It wasn't busy for late Sunday evening maybe because a lot of residents are returning home from out east. Service was friendly and efficient. It is a quaint neighborhood restaurant. Recommend coming here if you want delicious pizza! read more

Winter Beer and I came here for a birthday dinner. We heard good things about the restaurant so, we decided to give it a go. When we entered the restaurant, it was pretty much empty and we were able to sit where we wanted. There was no hostess on staff so, we did have to wait a few minutes for our presence to be acknowledged. Our waiter was fun and entertaining when he did stop by to take our orders. However, the service was very non-existent because you had to flag someone down. Even though the place was very empty, no one came to check in on you and you were left to your own devices. WB ordered an old fashioned margherita with pepperoni ($23) and loved it. It had the perfect amount of sauce, flavor, and grease. I ordered the plain old fashioned margherita ($19) and found it to be flavorful and tasty. The sauce was a bit on the sweeter side but, I still found it to be yummy. We ordered a chicken parmigiana($22) to share and we thought the pasta was cooked to perfection. The flavor profile hit all the right notes and was delicious. I believe they used the same sauce in both the pizza and pasta. WB ordered three vodka and club and thought they were okay. I ordered a NY style cheesecake ($8) and Chocolate Mouse cake ($8). They were both tasty without being overly sweet. While the food was tasty, I felt like the prices were a bit high and the service to be lacking at times. However, if i am in the area and craving pizza, I would stop by. read more

See all

RUDE! I ordered a pick up order and yes, I added a tip. Walk in and the "host" says hi, and then I guess that was too much exertion for him as he didn't speak after that. I said I was picking up an order, he hands over the bag silently, and I double check it and inform him a couple of items are missing. Instead of apologizing and being gracious, he hands over my beverage (again, not speaking). I also tell him I had requested a bread roll...he hands over one to me without speaking. The level of rudeness was really shocking. read more

Food is AWESOME! We had a pizza and the penne with vodka sauce . Mmmmmm! You met and exceeded my expectations.

Got food delivered. Eggplant Parmesan was really not good. Eggplant was undercooked and tough and flavorless. The garlic bread was just bizarre. And the beet salad was lifeless and flavorless. No go. read more

This is about their pizza only. Good pizza, taste like they holding an Italian grandma against her will with her passport in the basement while she makes dough & sauce. The plain pizza was great, the ones with toppings were just good. Price is reasonable for the quality & probably the best pizza that side of Manhattan. If you like good pizza, you should def check this spot out & I think they have at least 2 other location. read more

I always order from the first Avenue location. The pizzas are delicious. Their salads are also very nice and they're very good about delivering promptly . read more

Excellent customer service, food was great as expected and the ambiance was relaxing. Will certainly be back here. read more

See all

Mhm, what's the difference between Trader Joe's frozen pizza and Patsys Pizza? I'll tell ya the answer - "NOTHING". This pizza tastes EXACTLY like Trader Joe's frozen pizza. Look, I'm no 'Portnoy' but for someone who grew up on CT New Haven Pizza, this was disappointing (given the hype). I get it, this review sounds harsh, but when DAVEY leaves a good review, I TRUST him. Perhaps this may be his most MISLEADING review ever?? - He must have been really high... Needless to say, my expectations were very HIGH and the result was poor - JUST LIKE THE NEW YORK JETS. STAY AWAY! read more

Ok! I have not had All of the pizza in New York City but this place nails it. A cozy little corner joint with a little bar in the back. I ordered a personal pie, half plan half pepperoni and a Brooklyn logger and they grand slammed it out of the park. Give me a fuckin pillow and a nap read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Despite the food still being quite good, the service at this place has gone from bad to worse. A few months ago, they completely messed up my order, and today, they made a similar mistake. When I called, they assured me the order had been corrected and was on its way. I called again later, only to be told it was still en route. After waiting for two and a half hours (the restaurant is 10 blocks away), I decided to cancel the order, realizing it wasn't coming. I never received a follow-up call or any explanation, and ended up eating lunch three hours later. No apologies. Nothing! Definitely not a reliable place for delivery!!! read more

I popped in on my way home from the hospital to buy a pie (cut my finger last night, so just hungry and tired at this point). This was a pie to go, because I'm in jeans and a hoodie, obviously not trying to linger or dine-in when I want to be in bed. The owner literally asked the waitress what I was doing there after I ordered... I pay and sit down to wait, so he goes to the back to rush my order in Spanish. The pizza appears a few minutes later and the waitress hands it to me and he quickly says, "Goodbye." I say "gracias" so he'd know I understood (Puerto Rican here, so come on).... Your huge restaurant was dead and only had one customer other than me. This Patsy's SUCKS, but others are great. read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious pizza and chicken parm, it was a hit. I took out but the wait staff was very accommodating and kind. Great midtown location. I had an issue with them not having pizza by the slice but I understand that it's family style oriented read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pie and Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Service was terrible. Ordered 3 pies. Two classic & one buffalo chicken. I guess they were out of chicken and only put buffalo chicken sauce on the pizza. Will never eat at anyone of their locations. read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken pizza without chicken. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I work in the area for 19 years now and have been going to patsy's since but as of today my colleagues and I will not return. For the last couple of months it has been very disappointing, from the service to the food. We had to wait almost 15 minutes for the waitress to finally get our order while the place was empty. I always ordered the Baked Ziti it was delicious, but the last couple of times it is not the same, definitely a different recipe. My colleagues had the lunch sandwiches and they said the same., lacked salt among other things. Then we had to wait 20 minutes to get the check while she sat by the bar talking to the manager and we are on a LUNCH BREAK. Today we saw a new manager and the waitress was not there but the food was still a NO. read more

I ordered take out from here last week. The take out containers were much different than usual - and the portions for my two dinner entrees were TINY. It appears they put my dinner orders in the containers they use for left over meals that customers take home with them. I was charged the full price for two dinner entrees - and received what amounted to two appetizers. I called the restaurant and the "manager" acknowledged that the containers were different than usual but insisted - over and over - that the portions were the same (because the chef told him so). The "manager" refused to offer a partial discount or any other courtesy. I was told that someone would call me the following day to address the issue but not surprisingly no one reached out. As far as I'm concerned, this place is scamming customers. I am never going back. To follow up - the "manager" from this establishment - "Morgan" - sent me a private message. The message was entirely unhelpful. Just like her colleague, Morgan refused to acknowledge any issue and the continued to make false claims regarding the take out containers. I reiterate - this place is scamming customers. I am never going back. read more

Reputations last with the last pizza sold. What was once a joy now needs quality control. The Owner must once again step in and regain control. My visit produced under cooked sauceless carboard. Whatever happenef to coal char. What a shame. read more

I wanted to love everything about this pizzeria especially after I took that first bite of my white pizza. That first bite. That crispy crusted pizza dough. That wonderful blend of ricotta and mozzarella. That mix of spices and the fresh basil. All of that was wonderful. We ordered a small pie 13", $19! What! That's really overpriced. They got the order wrong, even though the waitress was beyond nice and offered to take he pie back. We decided to keep it because we were soooo hungry and didn't want to wait for the pie we actually ordered. Instead we picked off veggies we didn't want to eat. The salad we ordered, $11.50 was drenched in dressing and the tomatoes were not fresh, they were old and mushy. The rolls they served were warm and very good. That helped immediately to take the edge off of our hunger. We arrived midshift as most of the staff were leisurely enjoying a meal in anticipation of the evening rush. So the place only had a few customers. The waitress was friendly and gave us plenty of space and time to enjoy our meal. We appreciated that very much. Seems like we were paying for the legacy of Patsy's since 1933. I real wages, the dollar was probably worth more than. I don't I could eat there regularly at those prices, even though I would enjoy every bite of that pizza. read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Wish they used paper only - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Wow we are so glad we came here. Truly one of the best NY pizzas we've had! The crust was perfect coming out of their coal fired oven - a little bit thicker than the usual thin crust and not soggy at all. Loved that we could make the pizza half and half too, it was truly some of the best. read more

Patsy's Pizzeria - Half pepperoni with ricotta, half sausage with ricotta - Italian Near Me - New York, New York