Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Paul E’s Pizza

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 10:00 PM
    Updated 1 month ago

    Order Paul E’s Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Paul E’s Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Paul E’s Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 days ago

    Don't forget to add a cookie to your order, best cookies in St Matthews, arguably the state.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    27 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Paul E’s Pizza

    Danny Mac's Pizza - 12" Combo Pizza

    Danny Mac's Pizza

    4.5(227 reviews)
    3.3 miClifton Heights
    $$

    Danny Mac's has great food and service. The quality of the pizza is consistently excellent and…read moresets it apart from other pizza places. I have dined in and carried out pizza and pasta and we have never been disappointed. The bread sticks are soft and slightly chewy, a real standout. I love the pizza crust. I tried pasta for the first time recently and while I prefer the pizza, the baked spaghetti I ordered was also quite delicious. The interior of the restaurant is a fairly small space without frills but comfortable. The courtyard at the Mellwood arts center where it is located is a great place to eat outdoors in good weather. Danny Mac's has single act and small ensemble live music occasionally which is a nice touch. Ample parking in the arts center parking lot.

    I wanted something delicious and easy for my birthday dinner with my family this year. So I thought…read moreof my favorite pizza in Louisville, Danny Mac's! And for the first time, we sat in the courtyard just outside its main doors at Mellwood Art Center. On a warm fall night, this was delightful. The kids had enough room to run around a bit, having fun looking at the big art pieces that surround the space, while we could sit, drink beer and eat pizza. The Cracksticks continue to be my absolute favorite. Even if it's just my small family eating dinner from Danny Mac's, these are a carb-filled, dripping-in-garlic must. And we got a basic pepperoni pizza, though the Hawaiian, Chicken Bacon Ranch and Meats pizzas are also delightful. From the crust to the toppings, everything is consistently perfect. Danny Mac's also has decent beer on tap, or you can get a bottle of Ale-8. A true Louisville food staple. So thankful for it.

    Photos
    Danny Mac's Pizza
    Danny Mac's Pizza - Sausage & Pepperoni pizza

    Sausage & Pepperoni pizza

    Danny Mac's Pizza - Menu side 2 -- December 2023

    See all

    Menu side 2 -- December 2023

    Impellizzeri's Pizza

    Impellizzeri's Pizza

    4.0(238 reviews)
    3.3 miHighlands- Cherokee Triangle, Bardstown Road
    $$

    Typically I focus more on the food (because obviously) however this time I'm highlighting the…read moreservice. My book club met at Impellizzeri's this week, and upon discovering several of us have dietary limitations, the server and kitchen staff went above and beyond to accommodate our needs and ensure our ongoing health. A wonderful kitchen wizard ventured out into the dining room to talk to us personally, and confirmed that all the traditional pizza doughs, pastas, and red sauces are vegan. He offered to create a custom pasta dish with a variety of vegetables (spaghetti pomarola with garlic, spinach, and mushrooms), and ensured that the breadsticks that accompany the pasta dish (traditionally made with garlic butter and cheese) were vegan, prepared in a separate location in the kitchen to ensure no dairy contamination. For those with other food allergies and intolerances they ensured every detail was correct, even noticing that a pizza that was inadvertently prepared with an offending food item, and remaking it before it was even finished baking. Pricing is incredibly reasonable for the quantity and the truly excellent service, which is what truly made the experience special. My pasta dish was tasty. Is it the best pasta I've ever had? No - but it wasn't trying to be. What Impellizzeri's does well is serve good food at reasonable prices, in a location and with people who have an eye for detail and a passion for excellent customer service. Well done.

    We ordered the pizza card, a fundraiser for the Crusade for Children. For $49 , you get one large,…read moreone topping pizza at 10 establishments in the Kentuckiana area. This is a terrific deal, plus it makes us get out of our rut at eating at our favorite place all the time. I will be honest, I have not been to Impellizerri's in years. We've been to Italy and Italian Switzerland many times and love their very thin, fold in your hand pies which have fresh tomato sauce and flavorful local cheese. I was hopeful- Impelliizeris had a thin crust option! Unfortunately, it was as disappointing as I remember. The crust is too doughy, the sauce is bland and the cheese was thick and tasteless. We didn't even eat our leftovers. I don't understand why so many like this, perhaps I should order something else if I return. Just a no from us!

    Photos
    Impellizzeri's Pizza - Sign and side view

    Sign and side view

    Impellizzeri's Pizza
    Impellizzeri's Pizza

    See all

    Paul E’s Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...