The pepperoni pizza is in my top 3 and I've had and greatly appreciate NYC, New Haven and Boston/Regina's pizzas. Top quality ingredients and a high level of care has gone into creating the items on this menu. Don't miss ordering the meatball on polenta. read more

Tremendously good pizza, especially the pepperoni which has a delicious smoky taste. The atmosphere is nice, too. We love this place and recommend it to anyone. read more

Quick Slice, Cold Beer, Good Vibes Stopped in with my dad for a quick bite and were pleasantly surprised. The pizza hit the spot! Crispy crust, great flavor and the beer was cold and refreshing. Perfect little stop for a no fuss meal. Friendly staff and laid back atmosphere made it even better. We'll definitely swing by again next time we're in the area. read more

Not on my list as a place I will return.... the pizza is overpriced, the staff is not friendly. We also ordered breadsticks and when I say the one's from Papa John's are way better. Drive on by read more

A treasure awaits in Barre! Great pizza, beer, atmosphere, location, with an awesome Italian store to bring home delicious provisions. Stupendo! read more

Amazing pizza, daily specials that are awesome, and the owner has some great wine and cocktail selections.

Great food and our server was excellent. I plan on going every other weekend because the food is delicious and the atmosphere is fairly good. read more

Pearl Street Pizza - My friend ordered the deepdish and loved it. - Italian Near Me - Barre, Vermont

See all

Barre was well known for excellent Italian cuisine for decades. AR Trattoria and Pearl St Pizza have done an amazing job rekindling the love for authentic, traditional Italian food, sometimes with a modern twist. I ended up at the pizzeria two nights in a row, which i wouldn't normally do, but it was a: that good and b: I was attending two events. The first night was a VICA (Vermont Italian Cultural Association) Italian conversation event for beginners to native speakers. It was pretty awesome to hear so much Italian spoken and two of the guests were playing Italian folk music live the next evening, so I had to come back. That's probably TMI and not about the food. So here's what you really came to read: The first night, I split a slice of the grandma pepper and onion pizza (thick, Sicilian square style like my family makes) with a friend. The slice was that big that two people could eat it. It was perfectly crisped on the bottom, with thick soft dough covered in a beautiful homemade tomato sauce, cheese, charred onions and peppers. It was fantastic. The next night, I wanted the grilled shrimp speidini, but they'd were out of it, so I ordered a traditional 14 inch Margherita pizza, with a Neapolitan thin crust. I felt like I was back in Italy: everything about it was perfect: the crust was crispy and thin, not too chewy (which I've found to be an issue with some other brick/stone oven local pizzas. The sauce was heavenly: light and fresh. Topped with fresh mozzarella, basil and good olive oil. I had to restrain myself from eating the whole pie in one sitting. The outdoor seating is great. The menu as a whole looks fantastic: limited and seasonal, which is what I prefer. It's well worth the drive. I can see this becoming a regular visit. read more

See all

We organized a large group dinner of 30 people for dinner ahead of time and Uriel the manager went above and beyond to help accomodate us. The food was amazing and everyone loved it. It was the perfect spot for our group dinner. Thank you Uriel! read more

Great food; great service in a very nice atmosphere. Gluten free pizza tastes great. Food is always really good!

Delicious food, fast service and good vibes. We had the seasonal burrata salad and ham and pea special pizza.

Love, love, love this place! They have hosted several private events for us, and catered both on and offsite for office dinners. The food always hits just right and the staff are great about suggesting new items we may enjoy. The restaurant is perfect for groups between 25-35 people, and the food options cater to any and all special requests we've submitted (dairy-free, gluten-free.) The gluten-free pizzas are surprisingly delicious and even our gluten-loving colleagues love it! The staff, though, really makes the experience - from the cocktails and mocktails to the food and the follow-up...you really can't beat this place! read more

Great bartender. Great margarita. Great ziti. Service was much appreciated. Looking forward to the next visit! read more

Looking for food to satisfy that rumble in my belly, this place hit the spot. I placed my order to go when I arrived and had a drink at the bar while I waited. Once I saw the wood fired oven, I knew my food was going to be amazing. I placed an order for a simple pepperoni pizza with hot honey sauce. For a starter I ordered the wings. My food was ready in less than 20min. I stole a quick glance and let's just say There was instant mouth water! Staff here were all very friendly and helpful. The bartender was great! Overall, great experience! I look forward to a return visit in the future. read more

See all

The BEST Sicilian pizza in Vermont. I highly recommend this restaurant. Nice dining experience.

One of the best pizza places in the country! Everyone there is simply awesome. Humble and down to earth, this place is a must try. Try the white pizza special! Or the grandma style pepperoni hot honey, UNBELIEVABLE!!! Will be recommending this place for years to come! read more

Pearl Street Pizza - Their amazing oven!!! - Italian Near Me - Barre, Vermont

This is the best pizza we've had in Vermont, and that's saying a lot. We also tried their "pasta of the week" which changes weekly, tonight it was Arriabata Chorizao - phenomenal! We sat at the bar and got a "grandma's style" 1/4 pizza "slice" as well too share, it's a deep dish style. We opted for Prosciutto as a topping, highly recommend adding this to the cheese pizza! The drinks were also incredible. You can tell they put a lot of thought into the menu. The atmosphere was lovely, very romantic lighting. I would highly recommend this spot for a date night. The staff was very knowledgeable, and the owners checked in with us to see how everything was. We will definitely be back and recommending this spot to everyone we know. read more

Pearl Street Pizza - The Mule at the Bar - Italian Near Me - Barre, Vermont

Amazing food and amazing service. Such a gem for the community. Come for trivia on the first and third Thursday of each month! read more

Pearl Street Pizza - Trivia night at Pearl St - Italian Near Me - Barre, Vermont

What an experience! Got to sit in front of the brick oven and learn how to pronounce Barre (Barry) VT. One of the owners was working the oven (one of a few in the US which came from Naples) and gave us some of his delicious garlic bread to try. What a GEM of a pizza place in a quaint, downtown area. Will be back the next visit with my pizza expert wife!!! read more

Pizza was ok...but 17 dollars for THREE WINGS? Absolute ripoff!!! Will never come back.

We really wanted to like this place after all of the stellar reviews. Finally ordered takeout... A wood fired pizza and garlic bread. Maybe it was a fluke because the place was packed, but this was a letdown. read more

Pearl Street Pizza - Look at the crust. Under side was also black. - Italian Near Me - Barre, Vermont

See all

This pizza joint/ market is so fabulous. We happen to stumble upon it on a crappy weather day when nothing else was open. We are from California with a large wood pizza oven like the one here, so we are very familiar with pizza. This is the best pizza I have had in a while. It's almost identical to the ones we make at home. Wonderful Ingredients and staff. A+ service, the best food and people. And the market is amazing as well. I wish I could take this business back with me to California! Thanks guys! read more

See all

Great pizza friendly staff little pricey that's what's stop me from returning entrance is confusing to get into restaurant

Even though it is all downhill once you pass the Hilltop Inn, it is well worth the drive. Finely crafted cocktails, excellent pizza, and fine attention to detail; cup and char roni, Bayley Hazen crema for the wings , and of course extra napkins for the wings. Easily in the top 3 pizzerias in Vt. read more

Awesome Pizza. I highly recommend the grandma pie style. As good or better than the best NYC & NJ pizza. 5* read more

This place.....EXCELLENT. Nice atmosphere, helpful staff, and wood baked pizza that's the best I'e ever had. And a store off the restaurant that sells locally sourced items and organic prepackaged food. Bar menu has locally made beer and alcohol as well. I can't say enough about it. We got in without reservations on a Saturday afternoon at 4:30 but I wouldn't suggest trying that again without making a call for seating, it's busy. As far as I know there are no online reservations, you must call. Try it, you'll love it. Also try the other sister shop, Morse Block Deli, just up the street. Fantastic sandwiches and soups. read more

Pizza was ok- I just got one with sauce and cheese ( next time try something else) like special pizza place was really cute small intimate small bar FYI read more

This place was okay, but really not much on the pizza.... slightly disappointing. We got takeout.

Absolutely delicious food! Ordered the pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and it's by far one of the best pizza I have tasted in VT. The quality of the ingredients is impressive and well worth the price. Highly recommend read more

Nice new addition to the Barre restaurants--now you can get grilled octopus in Barre! In door wood fired pizza oven delivers great qualities pizza made by the owner. City type cocktails we'll mixed and a grea changing beer list including some great locals and some harder to find Herman beers. Nice small plates as well. read more

Pearl Street Pizza - Pizza Bar! - Italian Near Me - Barre, Vermont

4* isn't really fair. I'm being conservative and also thinking- I was there on Day1, and it's going to get EVEN better. It was great. Real wood fired pizza oven, awesome ingredients: they're not messing around. I got the pepperoni and it was the best pizza I've ever had in VT. Not exaggerating. Good selection of appetizers too. My friend raved about the muscles. The prices are really good for the quality of the food. I recommend going now because I think the prices are going to have to go up. I saw an order of the Homemade Meatball on Polenta that looked phenomenal @ 8 bucks! We were making plans for what we'd order next time before we got out the door. You're going to want to make reservations because when word gets out, it going to be packed all the time! read more

Didn't like what i ordered service 10/10 Very friendly people I'd recommend this place the bar is very nice too. read more

best margarita pizza we've ever had! my husband and I felt like we were back in Italy.

I've been here several times since it opened last year, and every time we say the same thing-- the food is great, the service is terrible. Food is served as it is finished- last time we got our pizza 10 minutes before our salads. We were unable to eat our salads because our server hadn't brought us silverware. We flagged down another server and asked for (and got) silverware. Staff doesn't check in regularly and still, after nearly a year, seems flustered by their ordering system (tablet based). It is beyond ridiculous. The food, on the other hand, is phenomenal. The pizza, pastas, big meatball, salads-- I've never had a meal here that wasn't absolutely delicious. But after a year, it is time to get the service to the same level as the food. read more

Dined here recently, and overall, the pizza was amazing, and the service was really good. I'd also give bonus points for being original with the chicken wings. They cook them in the pizza oven and get a slight char on them, when mixed with the sauce is excellent. We went with the spicy Calabrian Chili Sauce. An order is six wings. Get the crema. Love that they are a connected wing and drum. - I gave a 5-start because the food and service was excellent, but I'd suggest a couple of things for true excellence. 1st get a foot pull on the bathroom doors or move the waste basket or put a second one near the door. In a perfect world everyone washes their hands. We know we don't live in a perfect world. 2nd, in lieu of the 1st suggestion, wear culinary gloves when sprinkling finishing touches on the pies. Knowing the bathroom door handles can be dirty, and there is no wash station where pizzas are made, and seeing an employee top your pizza after coming out of the bathroom, well you get it. I am a bit of a germaphobe. These are suggestions because overall, the place is very clean as well. read more

Holy amazin' friggin' food! These guys and gals nailed it. I hate to even leave a review because I feel like I want this place all to myself, at all times, because IT IS THAT good! Had the wood-fired octopus(scrumptious!), shared the garlic bread(), white pizza special, and took home 2x grandma pizza slices(cheese & veggie). Wanted to have more but saving options for next time. Sooooo worth the drive and will also be our new "take out" pizza spot. Bottom Line: Pearl Street Pizza -- the new gold standard for pizza in Vermont...New England, really. Sorry, one more thing--the price point for the dishes and pizza is absolutely perfect--please do not increase prices! read more

Most delicious margherita pizza I've ever had, and the garlic bread is sincerely amazing. I can't wait to go back and try more menu items!

Food, drinks, ambiance done right. High quality ingredients and friendly service. Must try.

GREAT pizza in a classy, relaxed venue. Pricey, but worth every penny. While you're there, grab some of Pete's Vermont Salumi, which is the best assortment to be found anywhere near here. read more

Best Pizza in the area .... Keep up the awesome work..... and thank you for that wood fired oven