This was my fifth time dining at this restaurant, and unfortunately, it was my worst experience yet. On March 21, we had a reservation, but when we arrived, no one addressed us for about 20 minutes. When we finally spoke to the "hostess", she mentioned that we were assigned a table "out back," which sounded unappealing (though it turned out to be fine). She then informed us that it was really busy and "it could be a while". I said back to her "well, that's a bad start", she said "I know". The whole restaurant had a strong fishy smell, which shouldn't happen with fresh seafood. No one came over to greet us until we decided to go to the bar to find a server. It was the same server who was attending to the table next to us, and she only acknowledged us after we spoke up. She didn't take our drink orders or offer us water. After we finally ordered drinks, we waited 20 minutes only to discover our drinks sitting at the bar--our martinis had already become warm. As for the food, the Rib Eye steak was perfect, but the Shrimp and Scallop Scampi was terrible, and the other pasta dishes with lobster were just okay. Overall, it was a disappointing experience with mediocre food and inattentive staff. I will not be returning to this restaurant again. read more

For being inside a hotel, I had low expectations. This restaurant blew me away. Started with the most phenomenal service and ended with the one of the best steaks I have had in my life! So flavorful, tender and juicy. Mashed potatoes were great and they had carrots as the veggie that day which I love! All good things to say here. I can't wait to come back! read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Filet Mignon - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

We stopped here for breakfast (7-10:30a): the steak & eggs breakfast was perfect, as was the Full breakfast. Service was very good. read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

Came back after a Norwich graduation. I have been here before the renovation and remember the food being good. Our server Arturo was very friendly and knowledgeable. However, glad we came in earlier because this place was filling up. Drinks were strong but very tasty, i enjoyed the elderflower martini. We had the ceaser salad and sticky chicken. My only issue was the salad was too peppery. We both had steaks mine the filet mignon and my husband the ny strip.both cooked well and very tender. Desserts were also a hit; i recommend the carrot cake and my husband loved the creme brulee. Great spot when celebrating a special Occasion. read more

See all

This a change of owners! Not sure it is as amazing as before. However it is better than most in the area read more

Ambience was lovely; perfect for conversation with a party. Servers for both food and drink were attentive and prompt. The chef was willing to work with my food allergies and replaced pasta with risotto in the shrimp and scallop scampi. The J Morgan Burger was also tasty. Crème brûlée was delicious, as was the fruit that came with it. Highly recommend! read more

Our work group (8 people) chose J. Morgan's for our holiday lunch and made reservations weeks in advance. I truly wish we hadn't. The most concerning issue was that there was no heat in the building. When we arrived, it was freezing. An attendee from a conference in another room told us their space was 40 degrees when they arrived and had only warmed to about 60. The waiter did bring over a small heater, but it barely helped. At the very least, the restaurant should have called ahead to alert us that the heat was down so we could decide whether to tolerate the conditions or choose a different restaurant. (Spoiler: we would have chosen differently.) Service-wise, our waiter was very kind but seemed unprepared. He didn't know if there was a soup of the day. When we asked for tea, he brought a tea box but no sugar or honey. Several salads arrived without dressing. I asked for water with no lemon and got lemon. None of these are catastrophic on their own, but all together, especially in a freezing dining room, it added up. For a restaurant with J. Morgan's pricing, the food needs to be better than "fine." A $30 macaroni and cheese with grilled chicken should be delicious, not just okay. Our group unanimously agreed we won't be returning, and we wouldn't recommend J. Morgan's to others. read more

This was our first time eating at J Morgan's after being acquired by the new owner. The ambience is completely changed from the original J Morgan's, and was very nice, but not as cozy as it was before. We were there early, at 5:30, and Service was excellent. Our waitress was friendly, attentive, and very accommodating. With that said, I only gave three stars in that the food was average at best. I had the chicken piccata which was dry, tough, and needed a lot of salt. My daughter had a hamburger which also was average. The fries were pretty good. In that the food was only average, I have to say that it was overpriced for what we were getting. read more

This is where local politicians and lobbyists rub elbows with tourists staying in the hotel and locals splurging on special occasion meals. There are upholstered booths, tables for larger parties, and an upscale bar for walk-ins. Reservations highly recommended on weekends and any day of the week if wanting to eat at the local standard dining time of 6pm. The menu is typical steakhouse fare with a Vermont twist. Prices are higher than other nearby restaurants, but you'll get substantial portions. In fact, that's what J.Morgan's is known for. Extra large slices of cake from an extensive dessert menu, and massive mounds of mashed potatoes and sides, for example, all served on industry-standard large white plates. Everything, except the desserts, will be sprinkled with a generous shake of parsley. To be fair, this will please most diners, especially blue-collar locals splurging on an anniversary meal or lobbyists accustomed to hotel meals and stick-to-your-ribs fare. What is gained in portion size and breadth of menu, is at the expense of refinement and complexity. These aren't dishes that will knock your socks off and have you pausing between bites to savor the experience, but rather, they are dishes that serve to please a wide-variety of people and palates, but fall short of providing an epic experience for more discerning diners. And I say this all with a caveat that there are restaurants in the area, at a similar price point, that provide something more intimate, more nuanced, more refined, and more divine. Needless to say, J.Morgan's decor and ambiance will make for a good impression if looking to impress a romantic partner or business connection. It's a safe bet. It's a sure thing. It's consistent and efficient, perfectly suited for any number of diners and occasions. A steakhouse is Vermont could do far, far worse. read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - House salad with chicken. - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

See all

First visit since they opened again after the flood. I have travelled the country as a connoisseur of steak, and the 55 day dry aged ribeye was absolutely amazing! In the top 3 steaks I have had in my life, and better than the $250 wagyu ribeye at Emeril's steakhouse in Vegas. Thick, perfectly cooked medium rare, a simple yet robust flavor profile of butter, salt, and aged beef. The tuna tartare appetizer was phenomenal. The Chicken and waffles with spicy bacon was out of this world. It's good to know that J Morgan's is worth every substantial penny read more

See all

Megan did an excellent job serving my family and i had a good conversation with us, food was good!!!!

Extremely Disappointed - A Far Cry from the J Morgan's I Remember We visited J Morgan's this past Saturday for a 12:30 PM lunch reservation with a party of 10 to celebrate a birthday. Unfortunately, what should have been a special and joyful occasion turned into a frustrating and disappointing experience. We arrived on time to an empty restaurant -- not a single other table was seated -- yet it took 40 minutes just to get drinks, and not even everyone had water in the meantime. After waiting patiently, I finally had to walk over to the bar to ask about our beverages, only to find no one there. I stood awkwardly for another 10 minutes before someone finally noticed me and I was able to explain the situation. When our food eventually came out, half the orders were incorrect or incomplete. Items were missing, others were poorly executed. One guest's burger came without cheese -- which feels like the bare minimum of a cheeseburger. The mac and cheese with chicken was $30 and practically inedible: dry, flavorless, and visually unappetizing. The chicken was overcooked and tough, and there was no cheesy creaminess to the dish at all. Other meals ordered medium rare arrived well done. Across the board, presentation was lacking, and the food felt like a rushed afterthought. To make matters worse, the check included items we never received. While the staff did fix the bill after we pointed it out, the final total was still over $300 for a meal that felt like a chore. It's honestly heartbreaking -- this used to be one of Montpelier's more upscale, classy spots, and I remember coming here years ago and having a great experience. What happened? The location inside the Capitol Plaza Hotel once added to its appeal, but now it feels like the quality, service, and attention to detail have all plummeted. To be blunt, the bowling alley we went to afterward had better food. We're sharing this review not to be cruel, but in hopes that the restaurant takes the feedback to heart. J Morgan's has the potential to be great again -- but it needs serious attention to service, kitchen execution, and overall guest experience. read more

We stopped here tonight for a dinner while exploring Montpelier. While the staff was overwhelmingly kind and polite, the restaurant was clearly understaffed and overwhelmed. The ambiance was pleasant, but the food was just okay. One member of my party was quite disappointed. While I'm sure this could have been a great experience on a less busy weeknight, it was somewhat disappointing and our simple meal (just entrees) took just over two hours! read more

This is nowhere near the quality of the original J. Morgan steakhouse. The name should be changed. Lunch was low class and way over priced.

Food was very good. Service was excellent. Steaks are sourced from outside VT and they are great, tender and tasty. Chicken Piccata was correctly prepared, unlike every other place I've ordered it in VT. Vegetables were good. The chef clearly knows what he is doing. Prices are not at all more than expected and drink prices are quite good. Free spacious parking lot. Ambiance is OK but do suggest half the space be walled off and opened for vents. Would definitely return. read more

The food was fine, but the male host (David) working on New Year's Eve was incredibly disrespectful. I came in with one other person to place a takeout order. We're both adults who happen to look young and are often mistaken for kids. Despite being first in line, the host completely overlooked us and proceeded to check in the two older couples behind us without even acknowledging our presence. As someone who has worked in the service industry, I found this behavior extremely rude. At the end of the day, we're all paying customers and deserve equal respect. Management should reconsider who they place at the door, as these individuals set the tone for the overall experience. Fortunately, Todd (the bartender, I believe) noticed the situation. Even though he was very busy, he stepped in to take our order, which we truly appreciated. read more

We had dinner here while staying at the hotel with friends. We made reservations when che king in so we were seated right away. The waitress was very friendly and came right over to take our drink orders and give the specials information. It took almost and hour for our food to arrive, so that was frustrating. Everyone really enjoyed the meals. I had the special with was the COD over mashed potatoes. The COD was very good, but could a used a little more flavor, because the chowder was a little over welming. Myvwife had the maple based salmon and really enjoyed it. It was worth a visit minus the long wait. read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Maple basted salmon - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

See all

My family has always chosen J Morgans to celebrate big moments. We have been frequent flyers since my high school years dating back to the early 2000s. Through COVID we continued to do takeout every other week to support the restaurant as best as we could. For my biggest birthday bash my husband got the infamous strawberry cake. Show stopper for sure. Through the selling and flooding we had not yet visited the restaurant, as they were in renovation and rebuild for quite some time. Once J Morgan's reopened, have been told not to bother by many locals, but in our heart or hearts we wanted to try to support a place that has been long part of our family celebrations - Patriarch's birthday was a great opportunity. Ambiance - Completely different look and feel. Felt more like a beach vibe. The kids wanted to or course see the trains in which now only go in a few circles and we were told were stuck and they had to hit it with a broom to make it go. It was clean and relaxing environment m, but we had a large table that was quite close to another table and felt a little crammed in. The game, tv area with couches was fun to visit with kids during the long 2 1/2 hour dinner. Service - Service was the most similar to our prior experiences. The server was pleasant, professional and kind. I felt sorry for him as I am wildly aware he must receive consistent complaints in the food quality and massive changes from the previous J Morgans. Food- The food was less than mediocre. As my dad put it, we are a family willing to pay for good quality food. Our bill for 6 adults, and 11 year old and 5 year old was $647. It was very disappointing. The steaks were the highest quality since meal, but with two order costs $150 combined. I had halibut. It was cooked well, but grossly under-seasoned and the sauce it was served on had an unpleasant taste and bright artificial color. The salads were also extremely disappointing. We had strawberry cake to go. Another massive disappointment. It was burned and dense cake and strawberry sauce tasted artificial. The only similarity was the frosting. As a family, we had a nice time, but have agreed this will no longer remain our destination of choice for these special events. Feels sad to admit an end of an era. I hope the restaurant survives and they are able to take the feedback and make changes. read more

After waiting many months to see how everything has changed since being under new ownership, I'm happy to say my dinner was wonderful and so was the service and the drinks are perfect! I think expectations have changed with new ownership and them not understanding what the locals expect from J Morgan's and what we've been used to for many years. New owners seem frivolous with decor but cheap with just about everything else such as portion sizes and wine selection. read more

I loved the old J Morgan's. We went for brunch on a Sunday. Both of us got the eggs Benedict. The home fries were soggy and barely warm. The hollandaise was OK, but only flavor was the butter. The bloody mary and all the fixings, was OK but only came with olives (I don't call that ALL the fixings). It was very understaffed. Took quite a while before we were greeted, restaurant only had a few groups seated, took a long time to be waited on, and even longer for our food. We were never asked how things were, never offered more coffee and when it came time for our check had to get our check even longer. It isn't what it was. Brighter interior doesn't make it better. I can forgive food inadequacies if service was good. We won't be going again. read more

Keeping the old restaurant's name was a major mistake. The prices haven't changed, but the portions are now a fraction of what they used to be, and the quality has dropped significantly. Paying the same for less food and worse taste is not a recipe for success. read more

Met a friend for dinner with the family. Fantastic food! They were also very accommodating to my friends Gluten free diet. Yummy steak tips, lobster Mac n cheese, bacon wrapped pork chop, pesto scallop fettuccine, and salads. We sat for 2 hours. Our wait staff took good care of us. There was a main waitress and support staff. Most of the tip was included in the bill. This was a surprise to me but not enough to cover the great service we had. Recommend for seafood and steaks! read more

See all

Food was great, service was fantastic. Loved the trains running throughout the ceilings. Definitely recommend. read more

See all

Thanks Yelp this was a great find , food was outstanding great service, good amount of well prepared dishes and the presentation was spot on ! Hotel , bar restaurant, we walked in no reservation and was greeted friendly and seated promptly. I could see where this place could have a wait. We were lucky!! Just a short walk to Capital of Vermont shops and sweet treat ice cream shops. Want a date night out this is it. read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Simply Grilled Salmon, Steak , Asian spice Shrimp,Fries Bread. - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

See all

As a family - we have celebrAted multiple occasions here and have ALWAYS been very happy with the food, service has been excellent And the atmosphere is great. We've celebrated our 25th anniversary them, my birthday and tonight a multiple of occasions- Mother's Day, a birthday and an anniversary! We are NEVER disappointed and will definitely be back and will Recommend them to others. Loretta and family ( about 9-11 people each time) Can't wait to go back! A special thank you to Gretchen for taking my calls - to make the reservation, confirm it and then change it. Thank you to our servers, Rose snd a gentleman- he had the other half of the party and I didn't get his name - sorry! Thank you to all of you for making our special occasions that much more special! read more

We had a great family lunch here! We are moving to the area from up north and decided to spend the day in Montpelier. After many recommendations from coworkers, we had to come in and see for ourselves. Our food was delicious, there were many safety measures in place and the staff was friendly and attentive. Our table got a mixture of steak, burgers, the crazy BLT and the horseradish sirloin baguette. Everything was delicious, and very decently priced. The table next to us had ordered salads which were HUGE, definitely on our list to try next. Do yourself a favor and get their famous garlic bread! You won't be sorry (in fact, you might want to order two!). read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Crazy BLT - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

See all

This was the restaurant adjacent to our hotel. We enjoyed a nice dinner here. I had a steak Caesar salad which was fine. The winner was the mussels appetizer = SO GOOD and it was HUGE! We also ordered the garlic bread but it was soooo garlicky! It would be better to have more bread of the kind they serve with it, for dipping! The server said a smaller portion of these is available on the HH menu. read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

Visiting the area and decided to try J Morgan's It was around 3 pm on a Friday Late lunch early dinner. Not crowded, no wait for a table. Wedge salad, great! One ordered ny strip steak. And I had the sirloin baguette sandwich with sweet potato fries Steak and mashed potato's good. sirloin baguette sandwich with sweet potato fries Both fantastic Would go back if in the area !! read more

See all

I'm a local and come here now and then for lunch. Hours have changed since COVID. They are no longer open on Sunday and Monday, so no brunch. The portions are huge so I typically order a starter only. Even the entree salads are too large. If you want to take food home, great. If, like me, you don't really like leftovers then there will be a lot of waste. Prices reflect the extra food you won't eat. That said - Ambience is nice. Pubby/clubby but not dark. Downside is it isn't very accessible. There is a very ramp around the corner of the building by the bank (large building) and the distance will pose a challenge to a manual wheelchair and isn't suitable at all for a walker. And the seating area is on two levels, with stairs. They do have ample area for largish parties (up to 10 without a hassle). Food is quite good. Although I typically have just a starter, I have had their burger, and their mixed salad - really good. I have often ordered the fried calamari (traditional version) which I loved because there were tentacles, and they were tender and light. However I just had them today and there were no tentacles and they were a lot drier. So they have obviously downgraded. Won't order those again. My other go to starter is the pub chicken. Basically fried chicken tenders. These are light and wonderful. Must get. The small amount of slaw that accompanies them is nice but can sometimes be over sauced with blue cheese. If you like blue cheese, it's for you. The exception is the French onion soup. It has enough salt to cover your dietary needs for a week. Why three stars instead of four? 1) the downgrade of the calamari and 2) I don't like paying for food I'm just going to waste. They need to cut back on the portions. I know they have a price point they need to keep but really it's such a shame. They need a few healthy small plates (not so much fried and carb loaded stuff) if they insist on serving giant main dishes. They make good martinis.... Just a note - they add a 20% gratuity. I take no issue with that. I sit at the bar and service is great. read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Remnants of the fried calamari - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

Service was inattentive, and I understand that people are strapped for employees right now in the service industry. The host did her best, and I don't blame her for anything. They didn't seem to have a bartender working at the time (I went for a late lunch) and when I finally got a drink it wasn't very good. I got a burger, and it was cooked perfectly, but still lacked in flavor. The fries were average. Nobody asked me how my food was or anything of the sort. They include a 20% gratuity on all checks, as did my place of employment, as a Covid thing, but I feel they need more help to properly run this place. I would not return. read more

Don't bother. Go to Applebees. Decent food but small portions, small selection and not immodest prices- $20 hamburger, $38 salmon. No garlic bread, no crackers, no soups, no vegetable sides, odd appetizers ( carpaccio in Vermont?). Served in a generic, sterile Choice Hotel-looking dining room. Hilton managed to suck all of the charm, quaintness, ambiance and comfort from the Capitol Plaza's long time favorite restaurant, J. Morgan's. If desperate, this will fend off starvation but it is nothing special and seems proud of that fact. read more

Absolutely the best cake I have ever had, I can see why it was featured in Bon Appetit read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Fresh Strawberry Cake (Featured in Bon Appetit Magazine) - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

See all

If you want to pay EXORBITANT prices for mediocre food, this is the spot for you. I found the wait staff to be polite--and exceedingly apologetic about the various surcharges and gratuities on my bill. That's legitimately the only nice thing I can say about my experience. For the cost of my crappy, measly, overpriced meal at J. Morgan's, I could have had three FEASTS at another restaurant. You could have a better dining experience at Applebee's. Covid was extremely hard on the restaurant business, and consumers are excited to get back out and support their local eateries. But you simply cannot jack up your prices and reduce portion sizes to make up for lost time and revenue. There are other (vastly superior) restaurants in the Montpelier area that deserve your patronage, and they won't force you to donate plasma just to afford an appetizer; seek those out before you lower yourself to eating at J. Morgan's. read more

As good as Peter Lugar's Better than Sparks in NYC Cowboy on the bone was absolutely delicious. Service was excellent And place is casual. A must stop for a Great Steak read more

Such an amazing find and wow this service was top notch!!! Amber was simply on top of her game, and she was super busy but never left us wanting anything!! She truly was a service with a smile....and the food and deserts were phenomenal and were seasoned perfectly!! Thank you...,also thank you to our hostess who was able to accommodate our reservation.., read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Front - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

This is probably one of my favorite steak houses. Service was great salad was great food was really good. I had New York strip. My wife had the mac & cheese with lobster. We loved it. Definitely the best steakhouse in Vermont right now. read more

J Morgan's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Montpelier, Vermont

I believe this place has been closed since the floods in July 2023. The food prior to that was tasty and a little pricey. I put 4 stars because that is what I would have given them last June prior to the flood. read more

Chris, great waiter- helpful with the menu and always nearby to refill water or wine. Wine prices very reasonable. Spinach artichoke dip - great cheesy flavor with chunks of artichoke- loved it! House salad with balsamic- incredible flavors. Apple salad - husband's favorite, all local produce. Wedge salad - crisp, fresh lettuce, excellent blue cheese with crispy bacon. Filet - cooked perfectly. Vegetables of the day - roasted beets - to die for. I ate all mine plus my son's portion. They were sooooo good! Lamb - husband said some of the best he's ever had. Mango sorbet- son wanted seconds, but the kitchen had already closed down. So, if you want more food, speak up before 9. Maple creme brûlée- smooth, melt in your mouth, maple not overpowering, perfect sugar crunch on top. With real, fresh whipped cream! read more

See all

Recently had a fantastic meal at J Morgan's. I'm in tech sales, have traveled all over the country hosting clients at steakhouses, and am confident that the food served at J Morgan's could hold its own against all of the steakhouses I've been to as every menu classic that I tried was executed flawlessly! French onion soup and wedge salad were fantastic! Clean flavors and seasoned to perfection. Had a perfectly cooked filet for a main, paired with a delicious Demi-glacé. I've had more lackluster Demi's lately than I care to mention, so I was really happy when I tried J Morgan's. You can taste the time that went into making it the right way without the shortcuts that many others take. Last but not least, the service was incredible. Literally everyone greeted me with a smile, and provided top notch hospitality. From the hostess, to our server, bartenders and kitchen staff...you could tell that everyone was heart-set on providing a 5 star experience! read more

This is my favorite restaurant in town. Glad to be back after a hard year. Last night's dinner was the best ever. Montreal seasoned ribeye! Divine! Arturo is a wonderful waiter. Thanks for another memorable night. read more