I've been here a few times. I usually have coffee here every morning when I stay at the Atwater. I always notice the cook having so much attitude. And yesterday, my wife and I decided to stop by here for some late breakfast. Sure enough, the Pete's Omelette lacked quality and taste BUT MADE FULL OF ATTITUDE from the grill cook. So no, unless you're having just coffee...I will not recommend this place. Just go to Coyote Joes. read more

So Pete's is not luxurious but it is the most authentic Mexican food on the island. The cooks are super friendly and they enjoy listening to loud Hispanic rap music. Don't let that keep you from trying their huge breakfast burritos and fabulous tacos. Ask for their variety of salsas as they are superb. We enjoyed our coffee with the wife's favorite vanilla creamer. The venue is lower end but it's my style of relaxing and eating great food. Give it a try. read more

See all

Darn good food and the best Bloody Mary on the island. The admiral and I just finished playing 18 holes and we love to top it off by walking over to Pete's. read more

First time here. Gustavo was so great. Whoever runs this place needs to give his a raise asap he's best ever!!! I would come back just for his service and ofc the food was great because he makes it. Open late as well, perfect place to be come here! Awesome costumer drive and food. read more

Im so glad I discovered this local spot. There's a walk up counter and outside seating. It opens early, closes late, and serves quick Mexican food. Perfect for a quick meal in between your Catalina adventures or a late night snack after bar hopping. I loved their well seasoned Chips and chunky guacamole and oddly enough I really enjoyed the ice cream! They also serve beer and strong drinks if you're into that hair of a dog thing. Haha. In any case, you'll definitely love coming here for any occasion, day or night. read more

Come between 2-5 for happy hour. Half price beers, $1.50 chicken tacos, and live music. You won't be disappointed. read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - American Near Me - Avalon, California

Had lunch here yesterday. The walk up service was friendly. The club sandwich was good, as was the grilled ham and cheese. As others have mentioned, the prices are high, but hey, it's Avalon. We spent $33 for 2 sandwiches and 2 fountain drinks. read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Grilled Ham and Cheese Sandwich - American Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

We stop at this place every trip to Catalina. It's by far the best Mexican food on the island. It's located right next to the mini golf (highly recommend) and next to where alot of the tours to the interior of the island leave from. We usually get tacos and/or nachos and are literally never disappointed. If you want Mexican food in Catalina this is where you go! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Carne Asada Nachos - American Near Me - Avalon, California

AYCE breakfast for 20$ drinks not included or 16.50$ for a breakfast burrito. I decided on the breakfast burrito since I was going to be riding my bike to little harbor- I did not want to be weighed down with AYCE breakfast! Bike parking on the planters and tables outside. Server very organized and friendly. I got a separate check. 24.50$ she added tip since our group was 10 people. They wore masks and gloves. One time use wraps/ cups. I was pleased and food arrived fast! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Breakfast burrito full of goodness - American Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

LOVE Yelp steered me to a place that was closed, so I asked the Universe to find me someplace else for dinner. She did not disappoint. Pete's was open on a Wednesday night, despite Yelp saying it's closed. It's outdoor only, with spacious patio seating. Very friendly cashier. No waiting. Excellent fish taco and carne asada taco. Excellent buffalo milk. My first time trying the classic Catalina cocktail! It's basically a boozy chocolate banana milkshake. I watched her peel the banana, so you know it's fresh. LIKE Order at walk-up counter. Cheap! The employees were speaking Spanish and laughing -- they were having a good time, which is nice to see. Not very busy. You should change that, Yelpers! MEH Nada. ICK Nada! read more

Pete gets three stars for being open when everyone else we phoned at 8:30pm on a Tuesday was closed, and for providing decent Mexican food. I also liked Pete's enthusiasm when answering the call and taking the order. I called ahead and ordered a chicken burrito, chicken salad, two fish tacos, chips and salsa, and french fries. I walked over from our hotel and the food was ready in about five minutes. While Pete was ringing it up, he didn't mention the fries but somehow what we ordered minus the fries came to $49.89 and I didn't feel like handing him any more than fifty, so I left the issue of the missing fries alone, and dropped the eleven cents into the tip bucket. Pete's burrito is heavier on the beans than anything else, but I prefer my burritos with more vegetables than meat anyway. All the food was pretty good, but whether by mistake, deliberate or that Mexican food even at a dive stand is expensive in Avalon, fifty dollars for these items seems high - especially considering that the night before we had had a sit down dinner of oysters on the half shell, Caesar salad, pasta with shrimp and Australian lobster tail for $120. (plus tip). Go for Pete's if you are hungry and nothing else is open, but perhaps get a receipt to try to figure out what exactly the prices are so that at least you'll know that you are overpaying versus being overcharged. read more

Zero friendliness for hospitality. My wife was a bit cold so we asked for hot water and as we see the hot water faucet from the coffee machine she lies straight to our face saying they don't have hot water. The family talked about coming here next time we visit Catalina island but not anymore. So glad we already had had breakfast at the water front Antonio Cabernet restaurant which was excellent. read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - The cafe to avoid, noted. - American Near Me - Avalon, California

We were in Catalina for a port day and decided to stop in here for some bison (buffalo? I can never remember which) burgers. The burgers were great! They come with this MASSIVE pile of fries so bring your appetite! Our friends ordered a plate of nachos to share among the 3 of them, but after making a dent, they still couldn't finish. Super good, decent prices for Catalina, outside but under cover. Great meal! read more

Fire tacos ! $1 chicken tacos! I'm only a tourist so IDK Mitch about this town, but this spot has beer on tap AND food at an affordable price! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Oops, sorry halfway through and I remembered to take the photo - American Near Me - Avalon, California

Nice little place to grab a quick bite and enjoy a beer outside. Food is mediocre. Service is friendly and nice. A small bottle water is $2.50, so a family of 4 is $10 for water seems CRAZY! I might put up with it if the food was above average, but that was not the case. The fish taco fish was not local fish and the fish batter seemed super greasy and soggy. Fish tacos should have a light, crisp batter on the outside. Not here. Salsa was good and super spicy. Beer list was decent. Not sure if we will make it back. read more

See all

What a hidden gem Pete's is. I had several different items there and they were all delicious. I love the fact that they will pretty much make you anything you want. The shrimp nachos were huge and tasted perfect. The breakfast burritos are a slice of heaven. read more

Worst burrito in the whole world! This is the place to come. WARNING. WARNING Inside the burritos are only beans and 5 shrimps for the shrimp burrito and the chicken is shredded dried and no taste whatsoever. There are many places to eat I would Highly recommend that you avoided this place at all costs. Even if you desperate! I can not believe someone can mess up this bad! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Worst burrito in the whole world! - American Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

My tacos and sandwich were delicious! ; served promptly ;) staff was very friendly and accommodating Thank you! read more

Great cheeseburger and fries! You can't do much better for $15 on the island than the burger and fries here...juicy burger on a yummy bun with fresh veggies and piping hot seasoned fries! Very nice service too! Thanks guys!! read more

Birra was the best! We tried a couple other tacos but the birra was awesome!!!!!!!!!! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Carnitas nachos - American Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

TASTY TACOS! We absolutely love coming here to eat, especially later at night when all the other nicer restaurants close early. We love to eat their burgers, chicken nuggets, and tacos! The people are so nice also! Thank you so much! read more

Slow, bad food. People working there thinks it is humorous to make super slow food . Don't go

Omg the best breakfast burrito I have ever had! We got the sausage breakfast burrito and it was simply delicious! It was hot and crispy :)) We also had a beer of course! And a michelada... they were generous on the drink :D I will definitely be back! Sorry no picture posted because it was our first meal and we were hangry hahah ;) read more

We had a great lunch here -- excellent service, solid chicken and amazing carnitas in healthy sized tacos along with a very good artichoke quesadilla, an unexpected treat. Would definitely come back for another casual lunch in a convenient location in Avalon. read more

Food is aweful. Bought food, and our family brought food from another restaurant. The lady kicked us out! She said no food from other restaurants. She sent us across the street. I don't recommend this place. Respect your customers and they will come back. Food is not even worth it anyway! read more

The buffalo burger and fries are delicious! And the mango wheat ale....oh! It's the perfect place to eat while waiting for your ridge jeep tour read more

I'm shocked this place has only 3 stars because I'm from LA and Oakland, 2 places with great Mexican food in California. The tacos here tasted homemade and the meat quality was top class. Im obsessed with the guacamole and the salsa. The calamari taco stood out to me. Sooo good, I highly recommend. It's a bit expensive but it's worth! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - two plates of food on a table - American Near Me - Avalon, California

Awesome service ! Nice ppl that works here ! Carne asada tacos and a Cadillac Margarita is a must ! Btw they open 8am tru 2 am every day !!! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Carne asada tacos - American Near Me - Avalon, California

Pleasantly surprised by this little spurs happy hour. $1 chicken tacos were really good - moist chicken with a nice but very light spice. The salsa was wild - maybe a little too hot. All in for for tacos, a beer, and a water bottle for about $11 is hard to beat on an island. It is what it is - a taco stand. It's not vibrant, it's not beautiful, but it's inexpensive and tasty. read more

If you find yourself hungry in Avalon town any time after 8pm, you'll notice that most eateries have already closed for the day... but don't fret! Head over to Pete's, order one of their heaping orders of carnitas nachos and a beer and be happy! The carnitas nachos sincerely shocked me; I was preparing for stale-ish, chewy chips, mushy pulled pork sitting in some sort of stainless holding bin bathing in some overly-salty brine. Holy crap, was I wrong! An order of nachos is large enough as a huge meal, or sharing with two or three gracious guests. If we had more time, I'd have gone back to try their burgers and burritos, because those that I had seen ordered them were gushing over how tasty theirs was. And, you'll be hard pressed to find a harder working crew. On Saturday night there was a live band and they were poppin! I'm definitely going back my next trip out. read more

Omg don't GO HERE. Both expensive and DISGUSTING 0% MEXICAN. Meat was all fat and gristle. Only thing Mexican about this food was the person cooking it. This is dog food with Salsa on it and I would be ASHAMED to serve this to someone's dog even. Paid $20 for what competed with the worse nachos I've ever had.... The damn fish tacos had some sort of in n out spread on them... yikes. Why does this place exist? THIS PLACE MAKES ME NEVER WANT TO COME TO CATALINA AGAIN. CLOSE IT DOWN! THIS IS A SHAME. WHY DIDNT I READ THE REVIEWS FIRST read more

I've always gone late at night.. never encountered the jerks in the daytime staff.. wow that lil woman in the front is terrible. I came for lunch.. they wouldn't serve anything but breakfast! I returned an hour later.. still same attitude.. like I 2ant a burger.. if u can fry up bacon.. u can make me a burger.. lol If u can fry up has-been. Mu can toss in some fries? So I was ordering a breakfast burrito to go.. at noon.. cus they can't get their ish to for lunch.. and she says.. SORRY NO TO GO!!UHH.. Im looking at all those boxes.. for TO GO orders bahaha.. Lady im not a local.. I just want to feed my helpers working in my home .. geeziz what an unpleasant B... Anyway.. they are over priced anyway and mediocre in flavor.. I recommend taking your hungry tummy to Coney Island.. sweet staff & they don't give you drama.. AVOID PETES DRAMA.. read more

I would give it negative reviews if I could-- I've come here my whole life and brought my family here for their first time and was treated so incredibly rude by this female server before we even had the chance to order. Watching her be so polite to everyone else but treating my husband and our friends so inconsiderate for absolutely no reason. read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Bad server with a terrible attitude - American Near Me - Avalon, California

The carne asada and fish tacos are amazing here!!! Skip the chicken taco. But food, drinks and live bands?! This place is amazing! read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - American Near Me - Avalon, California

Gonna give a one item review.. But might be the most important item to us on this whole island. Our favorite restaurant on the island Picnic Fry (if you can call it a restaurant) looks like it closed this year, and we've been talking about their ceviche all year. We were on the way to the mini golf that we always play at least once, and figured that we'd try the ceviche at Pete's just to see if it could compare to our long lost fave. Drum roll please ...................... It DID! Ceviche was really fresh and vinegar-y. chips were nice and crispy and we were all digging into it until it was gone. Didn't take long, and the people there were pretty nice. Still not as good as Picnic Fry ... RIP.... but this place is now the best ceviche on the island, and we'll have to keep eating this until a new winner is crowned. read more

Pete's Plaza Cafe - Hard to find place next to the mini golf - American Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

The worst service (or lack of) I have ever received. One of the few places open for breakfast on the island, but the Vons grocery store is your better option. We tried to order our food at the window marked "order" and were told to take a seat. The waitress then went to 3 tables who clearly came AFTER us. I made eye contact with her many times and then she went back to the order window. I went back to the order window and was told she'll get to us. We just left. The RUDEST I have ever been treated. I worked in the food service industry for many years so I am typically incredibly understanding, but this place is just awful. Be sure to check out their health code violations as well- I'm glad we didn't eat here now. Vons Market had great service and selection + the Catalina Island Brew House has amazing coffee, enthusiastic workers, and a good selection of smaller breakfast items. read more

The tacos and drinks are Tried one of each taco, each one was perfect ans tasted authentic read more

Pete's was probably the best food and best value we had in Catalina. The Ortega burger and fries were great and not greasy. We also had the artichoke melt which was surprisingly good. read more

Great drinks & service . Very close and local to our hotel. Great outside seating to enjoy the island. Both men working were very kind and helped us enjoy the island :) read more

Overpriced and pretty crappy - the guy who cooks was super rude to someone that asked for condiments. Plus it's not Mexican - it's sole deep fried crap read more