Pickup&#x27;s Pizza Company

Worst pizza!!! So expensive for terrible pizza and a frozen dessert. Nobody would help us when we…read morecalled to complain

Not great anything. We had pizza, ranch, and salad. Easy right? Nope! Basic cafeteria grade stuff.read more

Olive and mushroom

See all

XL Pepperoni pizza

Flour Power Craft Pizza

5.0(3 reviews)

0.3 mi

Amazing pizza! I love all the creative ingredients! You have to try the Fruit 'Za! They do…read moresomething with the dough, I think it's a homemade custom style. If you have the means you can also get the pizza made fresh for your party or event! You have to try

Best pizza in the whole vail valley!!! Great service and wow that dough is amazing. Got at color…read morecoffee on Friday and now having them cater a dinner for my family that's coming to town.

Pizza ready out of the oven in just 3 minutes, our dough is specialized for high-heat ovens

We use Ooni ovens, so your pizza expirience can be outdoors with this portable ovens!

See all

Pizza napoletana, cold ferment process on dough

Pazzo's Pizzeria

2.8(70 reviews)

0.4 mi

We enjoyed a great dinner on the patio. The server and service was awesome! I forget the server's…read morename, but he was from Russia. The portions were huge. We all enjoyed our meals. The homemade marinara was delicious! We also got the garlic cheese bread.

Straight forward. Really good Philly Cheesesteak here. It is, hands down, my go too. Bartenders…read morehave been here forever. Today, for St. Patrick's Day, I had the beer cheese soup. So. Good. This place is a quick, as to be expected, local place that turns out really good, consistent food. If in the area, check it out.

The pasta dish my daughter got. She had already taken a few bites but it was a big portion! I tried it and it was delicious.

The calzone was huge! I could only eat 1/3 of it. The homemade marinara was really good!

See all

Cheese pizza

Capitol Public House

3.9(33 reviews)

0.8 mi

Long drive into Eagle for the night. Looked for an affordable balanced menu and found capital…read morepublic house. Great menu. Great tasting food. Nice sized portions. Mike our server was very attentive and provided great service. The manager was very accommodating and got us two pup patties. Perfect setting and place.

This place wasn't bad. The service was excellent, but the cut of beef was mediocre. Too much fat…read moreand gristle for the price. Everything else was delicious, and the atmosphere was nice.

See all

Eagle River Brewing Company

4.7(10 reviews)

4.3 mi

The beer here is wonderful, the jalapeño poppers from the connected pizza place were the bomb and…read morewe even met the brewer Tom, great place, great people and we love that it's dog friendly inside and out!

My wife and I met up with some friends here for some beers and pizza. We've been wanting to come…read morefor quite a while and we finally made it. It's definitely a place that we'll come back to. They have a bunch of excellent beers and there is a food truck in the back that serves delicious wood fired thin crust pizza and other "gourmet street food" according to the writing on their truck. We had two of their large pies and an order of Wisconsin cheese curds. Between the four of us, I think we are all but one slice. As for the beer, I think we had at least 6 different beers. They have a great selection of pilsners and lagers that are around 5-6% abv, which is good since we had to drive. They also have a couple coolers with soft drinks for kiddos, DDs and those that don't drink beer. They also had a couple of hard seltzers available. All of the beers we tasted were great. I'd recommend getting a flight of 4 if you want to try a few different kinds. My favorite is probably theirr Free Stone lager. The space is pretty unique. All parking is in the back in a crushed stone parking lot. There is a deck off the front and the back. I think most of the action is either inside or on the back seating area. There was a gigantic TV inside where there was a football game showing, but we stayed mostly on the deck outside except for coming into get more beer and use the restrooms. There were three restrooms, M, W and either. Lots of high top tables inside and a handful of rocking chairs on the back deck. Be sure to bring a jacket or other layers because as soon as the sun goes down, we'll, it's Colorado so you should know. The temps dropped pretty quickly. It's a great place to bring well behaved dogs and meet up with friends for good food and drinks. We're adding it to our down valley rotation.

Mountain Barley Pop Vienna Lager

Eagle River Pilsner

See all

Amazing beer and great environment

Domino's Pizza

2.6(23 reviews)

3.1 mi

Just wanted to thank the Domino's crew for being open late and having great pizza Lynn was our…read moredelivery driver this evening we have had an issue with our address but she was on point she found it right away way to go Lynn!

I ordered a pizza with toppings on half and received them on the whole pizza and it was pretty near…read morecold when it arrived. Driver was nice but doesnt speak to the prep behind the counter. Maybe in store purchases are better than online.

See all

The Back Bowl

2.8(65 reviews)

0.4 mi

We were in Vail for the week and decided to go bowling. This was the only place open within a…read morereasonable distance. The disinterested teenager at the front desk went through the motions, and certainly didn't put any effort into his job. The rental shoes were velcro, which didn't stay, so the shoes kept opening up. The lane kept keeping our balls which meant further interaction with the disinterested teen. Time ticked on why we waited multiple times for our bowling balls to return. They rent the lanes based on time so while the teen meanders back, the clock is ticking. The lanes were fine, but the approach was sticky with either soda or beer. Finally, one a positive note, the bar wait staff were friendly.

They don't honor their own advertisements on happy hour deals from 4-7pm. Also half of the lanes…read moredon't even work. We had to be moved to other side of bowling alley to get a lane with bumpers for our kid. Staff mentioned multiple lanes out of order. Then when you finally get to bowl your bowling ball gets stuck every other time. Pretty high prices for bowling early. We got there before 5:00 and no wait staff came by so went to the bar to order and bartender told us go see the wait staff lady over there. As soon as our time expired the waitress came and took our food without asking if we were done also. Then the prices were double what the sign says and they said you have to order and eat your food at the bar and it doesn't say that on the signs. We spoke to the owner and they did nothing about it. At least I know why I never go here now.

State of the art bowling center.

Fine casual cuisine.

See all

Twisted Root

4.6(10 reviews)

0.7 mi

Quick stop for good food and fast and friendly service…read more Asian salad fresh and delicious. Chicken wrap big and good. French fries crispy. Did I say service is friendly? It's over the top but not overwhelming. Background music good and lovely decor. 5stars and AAA

What a pleasure interacting with Turner who does a bit of everything here from beautiful and…read moredelicious lattes to food recommendations! Enjoyed dinner fri of French dip, Asian chicken salad, chicken parm sub, and chicken sandwich. Returned sat am for bfast...another latte and maple chicken biscuit. Perfection! Do yourself a favor and enjoy the experience and food!

Chicken wrap

Pizza options

See all

Lunch and dinner options

Taco Bell

2.4(25 reviews)

0.9 mi

Fast service at the drive thru…read more Prices seemed fine despite mountains location. Looks like a place the local Kids work. Plenty of parking for big rigs.

If I could rate lower I would. Talk about disappointment. Our food came out 5-10 business days…read moreafter ordering as we stood and waited. Once we took our food to the car, the most disappointing event of all happened. THEY FOROGT OUT CHIP AND CHEESE. What a waste of time, money, and effort. DO BETTER.

See all

Subway

2.3(8 reviews)

0.5 mi

Almost didn't come here because of the reviews but it was very clean, the staff was professional…read moreand quick! Highly recommend coming here.

I went there today after a 13 hour shift. Exhausted tired beyond belief. I didn't have the energy…read moreor desire to make dinner so I stopped here. Mistake, huge. The sandwich was cut with a knife that was sitting in water/sanitizer wiped off. I prefer my sandwich cut with a clean dry knife. I was getting a refill on my drink and was informed there is a limit to one refill. Never heard of that before. Not returning. Clean knives is not too much to expect.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

17 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

J H.

11 years ago

The reviews on here must be friends and family of the owners. It's by far not 5 stars. I'm from Chicago and this is not Chicago style pizza. The pepperoni tastes like gritty sausage and leaves a really bad taste in your mouth. They also slice it in small squares so you need like 5 to equal a slice. I felt like I was a a little kids bday party. I was not impressed with this pizza at all. I hope they make it, but they need to step up their game. read more

Scott Y.

3 years ago

Forcing customers to use credit cards and charging credit card fees is a horrible idea. It discriminates against people who prefer to use cash and don't want to pay the rates associated with credit cards. Also needs to be on your website, and over the phone that the Eagle location doesn't accept cash. All because the owners prefer to be at the Edwards location drinking. read more

Michael S.

11 years ago

Got the sausage with peppers. Very tasty. You can tell that the ingredients are fresh and better because of it. Love the local non-corporate feel too. As you get more customers you might want to add an additional phone line or two. read more

Ashley D.

4 years ago

Hands down the best pizza in the valley! Always get pan crust- it's sooooo good and honestly any kind of pizza on their menu or any topping is bomb- I've tried a lot of them and it is always so delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Adam P.

9 years ago

Best pizza, ever! I work in Eagle and often get the lunch special at Bonfire - $5 for two slices of pizza and a beer at the brewery - can't beat that! read more

Mohd M.

8 years ago

This is the first time in the town and i went to many different contries and cities and this one is now , one of my favorit

Courtney M.

7 years ago

Always delicious! You can't go wrong with either style - thin crust or pan pizza - whenever possible, order one of each!

Kat C.

8 years ago

Our favorite pizza in Eagle! The Goat pizza is the best. Wish the had a bigger dining room and served beer!

Laura B.

2 years ago

one of the only places to get deep dish pizza in the valley. great pizza and people. crust is delicious.

Thomas E.

9 years ago

Awesome pizza, this is becoming our go-to pizza connection whenever we visit the family in Colorado.

Kristi Jo L.

4 years ago

The Goat pizza yum and roasted peppers and Farm Salad................it's all good!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lori M.

4 years ago

We love this place and it's friendly staff and options. Never a bad pizza and always delicious!

Glen W.

Elite 23

177

4 years ago

Awesome and extra flavorful. Nothing else needs to be said. I'll be back again and again.

Devin D.

7 years ago

Good pizza. Really good pizza. Like the good pizza you always want. This pIzza is good.

Sara S.

11 years ago

Delicious pizza!! Fresh ingredients, great quality. Finally some amazing food in Eagle!

Lady P.

8 years ago

Best pizza I've had anywhere, I'm so glad that it's in Eagle.

Tim H.

7 years ago

Good pizza and they deliver to the local brewery, awesome!!!

Pickup's Pizza Company - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Pickup's Pizza Company also viewed

Pizza One Avon

4.4

(89 reviews)

Missed the mark... I was starving after a long ski day and since it was the only thing open in the…read morearea, I decided to give it a shot. I got the Margherita pizza. It didn't have any sauce... there was a heavy layer of cheese which wasn't great. There were a handful of tomatoes. Margherita I expect a balanced pie with good sauce base. The staff were friendly enough when picking up and the space is small good for pickup or delivery. The pizza is not my favorite giving it two stars because the people were kind and they were the only thing open at night.

I tried to call and ask a question about how they prepare their gluten free pizza. Despite their…read moremessage directing you to press 1 to ask a quick question, they did not pick up during any of the 3 calls I made. If you are celiac like me--or have any food allergies--I'd stay away from here, unless they're able to reliably answer questions before arriving

Chicago Pizza

3.2

(95 reviews)

Spicybeans87 B. Loves the energy of the woman who is sometimes behind the counter. She is always so…read morelovely. Huge fan of the Italian Sausage sandwich which came smothered in sauce. Wish there were spicy beans somewhere on the menu but ce la vie. Yours always, Spicybeans87 B. P.s. If you sold a combo of the cactus cooler and say maybe some spicy beans.. I think it'd be a huge hit. Think on it, don't stink on it. Yours always again, Spicybeans87 B.

Eating in and enjoying a game of cards while pizza is being made. Look at this salad! Cannot wait…read moreto dive into this salad before our pizza arrives. Pizza was delicious and quick service out of the kitchen.

Marko's Pizzeria

3.3

(92 reviews)

We stopped by Marko's Pizza while visiting family and looking for a cozy post-ski dinner, and it…read moredefinitely hit the spot! We ordered the Sweet Boarder pizza and it was absolutely amazing great flavor, perfectly cooked, and exactly what we needed after a long day on the slopes. The only downside was that it was pretty busy when we went, so it was a bit loud and hard to hear each other over the hustle and bustle. That said, it's clearly a popular spot for a reason!

We waited over an hour for two slices of pizza and a pasta. The quality of customer service was…read moreabysmal. Don't go here unless you're prepared to spend the rest of your afternoon at the store waiting for a single slice.

Peppino's Pizza

4.5

(68 reviews)

yuppies ruined Carbondale, but somehow Pepino's persists in making wonderful pizza at a good price…read morewith no New world order propaganda being shoved down your throat. Thank you

Solid pizza in Carbondale, CO. Place was super busy. Lots of pizza by the slice options. And…read moresandwiches. Friendly service. We got 1/2 supreme and 1/2 meat. Very good. Chewy crust. Worth a stop.

Local Joe's Pizza & Delivery

3.4

(242 reviews)

Lost my phone mode they were so kind to help me recover it. Crispy pizza and the best service,…read more Would recommend! Ask for Kayla

The two times that I've eaten here. The pizza has been very good. I usually get the chicken bacon…read moreone and it taste delicious. The garlic bread is fire!

Pickup's Pizza Edwards

4.5

(36 reviews)

I can't believe I never reviewed this pizza place. This has to be the best pizza I ever had. Once…read moremy coworker friend introduced me to it. I kept going back with her or myself often. The owner told me it's Detroit-style pizza. I love that it's square shaped and doesn't have crust. I never liked pizza crust. The toppings and cheese go to the ends of the pizza. I don't live in the area anymore and miss having their pizza. I found a similar one where I live, but it's not as good as Pickup's.

If Lou Malnati's from Chicago had a Detroit style pizza, this would be it. It's also a deli. I had…read morethe Reuben, which was great, then went on to finish my wife's last square of Pizza. I'll be stopping in for lunch again.

New York Pizza

3.7

(16 reviews)

The only thing saving this place is the food. Instead of taking accountability and saying…read morethey missed my FIRST doordash ticket. I overhear the worker blaming me for placing two orders. Sorry, but I work in customer service, and if I didn't see the ticket to an order, that would be my fault. Not anyone else's. Not to mention the order came in fifteen to twenty minutes before the one that came out. Lastly, the workers have the audacity to sit on their phones (looking at the cook who's sitting on his phone leaning on top of the prep line with his phone, absolutely disgusting and a total violation of health code) and not even call out that the food he had made almost an hour late was ready. Don't waste your money at this location.

This wasn't the absolute worst pizza I've ever had, but it's very close. Crust was lackluster and I…read moreended up getting a pizza that was almost all raw onions. Other toppings were sparse and the whole thing lacked flavor. I've learned my lesson to NEVER order there again.

Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry

4.6

(86 reviews)

We just visited this place for the first time and loved it!…read moreI ordered the Mountain Cristo sandwich with pickled cucumbers on the side. My husband had the cheesteak sandwich with the slaw. Both were delicious and served with love. You order in the counter first and then they bring your food to you. Service is pretty efficient too. We also loved the ambiance with lots of European and Asian products on display. It is priced well for the area. For both sandwiches and two bottled drinks we spent around $45. In this area this is very reasonable. We'll be back!

First Time Here We…read moreare out of towners here for a travel baseball tournament at the Eagle Sports Complex which is about 8 minutes away. If you are looking for a good sandwich place to appease everyone in your family, that's not your traditional place, come here. The menu is carefully crafted to elevate your sandwich cravings. The sides were also delicious. Asian inspired nods throughout the menu and some interesting Asian grocery items to fill you pantry with. And some unique cookbook reads.

Mezzaluna Willits

4.1

(69 reviews)

•$$$

We recently hosted a dinner here for 22 of our community partners! The restaurant is beautiful and…read moresuch a fun space to gather! The service was incredible and every server greeted our guests with a smile! I had to make a last minute change to the menu on the dessert choice - the flourless chocolate torte is incredible! Would highly recommend for hosting a large group here.

All good things to say about this restaurant. I had pizza and it was great. My husband had the…read moregnocchi and said it was very flavorful. Nice outdoor patio and a great waitress. Two thumbs up.

Los Cazadores

3.9

(29 reviews)