Worst pizza!!! So expensive for terrible pizza and a frozen dessert. Nobody would help us when we called to complain

Not great anything. We had pizza, ranch, and salad. Easy right? Nope! Basic cafeteria grade stuff.

Amazing pizza which was fresh and cheap. It tasted very good and all the flavors mixed perfectly on the dough, if you want good pizza definitely order from this establishment! read more

Ordered for pick up on our way through town. Great customer service and yummy pizza!! Will definitely stop by again!

I really liked the pizza. They give you plenty of pepper spinkled and red pepper flakes. The sausage has good flavor with fennel to give it that real italian flavor. Good crust too read more

Great local joint for pizza with super side options. In fact, we like it so much we haven't tried anywhere else. Their salads are terrific healthy options. We especially love the crust and make it dessert by adding honey. Maybe this could be added to the menu? Rachel, our delivery driver was exceptional. read more

This pizza was great and had perfect flavor. I was in town for training and was craving something close to New York style and this was pretty darn satisfying for my cravings. read more

Pizzaone - XL Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

Always fast, yummy, usually open, great punch card deal, the nicest staff, and good prices!

A great find in Eagle. We began with adult beverages...great selection. My husband and I each ordered a small Greek salad and split a Veggie Zone. The salads were sizable for a "small". They were freshly made and delicious. The calzone was crispy on the outside, filled with gooey cheese and lots of veggies. Megan, our waitress, was a delight, attentive and friendly. Would I come back or recommend this restaurant? You bet! read more

I really really wanted to love the pizza at pizzaone but it was just okay. The regular pizza crust was incredibly thin and in my opinion it tasted similar to dominoes. However, I added a star for service and for the cinnamon bread. The service was impeccable. We ordered delivery, the man who took my order was incredibly kind, and the pizza was at my house within 30 minutes--I live 10 minutes away from the shop. While the pizza was just OK, the cinnamon bread was AMAZING! It was so much fluffier than the pizza crust--thick, buttery, lots of cinnamon and sugar and the frosting dip was fab. I would seriousy just come here for the cinimon bread read more

Pizzaone - Olive and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

Perfect and consistently good pizza. They deserve to have One in their name, as they only place nearby, who always make pizza, which is always the way I like it. Recommend. read more

This is without a doubt the best pizza I've ever had in my life, it's so good, I'll probably come back to eagle just to have this pizza

Absolutely incredible. We ordered the XL BBQ Chicken pizza for pickup. After only 25 minutes, they produced the BEST PIZZA I've ever had in my life (30 years). My fiance agrees. Don't miss this place! Thanks guys! read more

They have the best pizza in the Valley. Delivery is fast and they come to my door (despite all the security hoops). Delivery is speedy and paying with a CC at my own door is a plus. Very convenient! The wings are great too. read more

This was the very BEST Pizza I ever ate, and I use to own a Bakery, Deli, Pizza business. I have never eaten 4 slices before in my life, but this was soooo good I couldn't help it. It was the supreme and arrived Hot and and ingredients were spaced perfectly around the pizza. I just can't say enough about how good this Pizza was. Can't wait to try it again! Thank you PizzaOne in Eagle, CO read more

I was pleasantly surprised at the quality of the pizza and the affordable price. It was very good. They also offer delivery which I will take advantage of in the future. The gentleman working was also quite pleasant and polite. read more

Great pizza, super fast delivery. Got the large sausage and garlic cheesy bread sticks. Next time I'm in town ill be sure to order from them again! read more

I can't rave enough about this place. Unfortunately I was involved in a hit and run accident during the latest snow storm and got stranded in Eagle late at night. While I waited for my ride that was about two hours away I walked into Pizzaone in hopes that I could enjoy a slice. Not only was the pizza extremely delicious, the staff was amazing. I told one of the employees of what had happened, and he went above and beyond to try and make a shitty night a little better. Thank you so much for the amazing hospitality, if I'm ever in Eagle again I will definitely be back! read more

Ordered the Hawaiian pizza which had jalapeños on it. It was amazing ! Perfect combination of toppings and sooo delicious.

First I want to answer the haters - Sara W or Sara V, obviously it's the same person. Sara what kind of drugs are you using, they really do the job I want some :). If you have noticed there is a Burger King across the street working 24/7, I'm sure they gonna satisfy your sophisticated taste, if you hate pizza don't go to the pizza restaurant, it's that simple. Chelsea you actually can keep calling for 555 minutes and nobody will answer, the key is to call during working hours! Second I'm sick and tired of yelp trying to extort money from small businesses, please make an effort and read the filtered reviews, they gonna give you really picture of the place and product. I apologize for the the intro, now back to the PIZZAONE. I'm a regular customer buying pizza weekly, on numerous occasions I witness the guys cutting the fresh veggies in front of me and putting them on my pizza, they really make their dough in-house and the sauce too. The menu is not very big but for the quality and selection it hits the bullseye. If you like pizza like me this is a must try place, words are not enough. I hope this review will not be filtered Ike the other ones. read more

We order from Pizza One about once a week. Their drivers are always really quick and really nice. We love their pizza and cinnamon bread too. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for an easy meal that is tasty. read more

I don't know what this guy is talking about, the food is great... These pies are consistently good. The chicken wings rock- actually my favorite wings from a pizza joint ever!! I highly recommend these pizza and wings. Dont listen to this hater...I'm calling them now to get some more weekend grub. I posted this review weeks ago and don't see it when i look at the yelp site. Whats up with that?? Yoh keep a bad review up. But won't post a good one... I think yelp needs help! read more

Delicious! We just moved to Eagle and we're looking for delivery. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and a salad. The price was very reasonable, the delivery guy was super nice. Pizza was hot and yummy, not greasy at all. And the salad was SO fresh! Yum!! We'll definitely be back!! read more

Ok pizza ok service ok location...... Normal stuff average prices regular ole pizza

The only reason I gave my second review 3 stars is because the delivery guy was so kind. This is my second review, I wanted to give them another chance. Didn't end up working out so well. Didn't receive my soda, and the food wasn't so accurate. Hopefully they get others orders right. Yelp reviews are usually pretty much accurate. John, I believe you are a friend or an associate, it's obvious. You may have other places that are doing well, but maybe you should look into this location on accuracy and making your guests happy instead of putting them down. I will say though, great start on wonderful delivery man. Wish I knew his name. read more

Local but small pizza chain around the eagle county very cheep and lots. Of tasty sause on the pizza great every nite of the week

We have been ordering regularly from Pizzaone for a year and a half. Their service is fantastic; we order over the phone and have the food delivered. They are ALWAYS friendly, courteous and on time. We order pepperoni pizzas and cinnamon sticks and have never been disappointed. We highly recommend Pizzaone. read more

Nice soft and chewy crust, if you like that art of thing. Toppings were pretty sparse. An overall okay pizza if you're in the mood.

Great home town pizza palor. Make sure you get the Cabo Pazo. it was awesome. also the waiter open a new bottle of Cab to make sure it was fresh. Service great for a young wait staff. I'm stuffed! Ask for Eric. He's a great waiter! read more

It's okay on a good night. Pizza is very simple but it seems Pizza One lacks common knowledge on how to make great Pizza and have quality wings. Someone needs to show the only Real pizza place in Eagle. I would choose Luigi's Italian Restaurant. A bit more expensive but they have amazing pizza!! Not to mention an entire Menu to choose from. read more

We have ordered from here a few times now. I am not impressed, everything taste frozen. Your hot wings are Tyson's store bought in a bag hot wings. It is not hard to make fresh wings, the prices you change for these is disgraceful. Pizza is easy,wings are easy sauce is easy, no reason not be made fresh. You say you hate yelp, maybe listen to your customers and you might have a shot! read more

Great place. Delicious pizza made with fresh veggies and home made dough. Greek pizza is one of my favorite. Service is on very high level, they have different specials every day, staff is friendly and deliver to you front door. I love this place! read more

I'd compare the pizza to a fast food restaurant. I had there pizza and it wasn't anything special but definitely edible. I'd order from them again read more

I love this place! The delivery service is fast, and the pizza comes HOT. The price is reasonable, and the Supreme pizza is oh, so yum! The staff is totally great. It surely is everything I want in a pizza spot. read more

This place is okay but the new pizza place in the valley Pickups blows this pizza out of the water!

Best pizza in Eagle. Love their sauce. Cinnamon bread was very good.

We were hoping for something different, as far as local pizza goes and this was a first and last experience for us. Everything from the wings to the crust and even the vegetables were not fresh, cooked frozen and tasted "stale". Garlic bread was covered in garlic powder and chewy and cardboard like. Sorry, if your looking for Domino's or the like, maybe this is ok, but Pazzo's is right around the corner and totally worth it to pick up. read more

Why are all of the good reviews hidden?! Pizza One is great. Come on people (or person who gave the bad review), it's a small town, not New York City. It's typical pizza, but very good. What makes them great is that it's always consistent, they have extremely fair prices (with awesome specials) and they are very friendly. Delivery is really fast, too. If it takes more than 30 minutes, it's because you've ordered during the peak time of a Saturday night. You can't order 4 different kinds of crust, but who cares. Chicken wings are ok. If you really need a fix, they'll do, but they're not deep fried and lets face it...that's what makes a wing taste good. The wing sauce is great, though. They may not win America's best pizza, but overall, they are AWESOME for a small mountain town! Oh and did I mention that they have a punch card?? Actually, it's signed each time, but whatever. The point is...take care of your local business and I promise you that your local business will take care of you, too. That's why we order from them once a week (at least!). read more