Great sandwiches, easy ordering and pick up. Was happy they kept the drive up and text for pick up post pandemic. Roast turkey hot sandwiches is a favorite go to. Wraps also delicious. Overall solid , consistent selection that you can't go wrong with whatever you choose. Scotcheroo (?) dessert is pretty yummy too! read more

Their sandwiches are absolutely phenomenal. Each one is packed generously and the flavor combinations are perfect. I've visited this restaurant close to 10 times over the past year, and each time the food tastes as good as the last. From my experience, they never serve a dud sandwich. read more

The Picnic Basket has been a local staple in Nashota for as long as I can remember ... 20 years??? It's always been fantastic, and started life as a road little roadside country store where local tradesmen and kids would frequent on the regular. They have remodeled time and again over the years always raising the bar. Most recently they have really done a nice job finishing their outdoor seating area. Their food is always homemade, fresh and full of flavor. When you order the roast turkey sub, they actually roasted the turkey... For real, slow roasted, tender, juicy and way better than anything you've had at thanksgiving! They are known for great subs on great bread! The meatball being my go to, but they make a mean pizza and do a nice job on Americanized Mexican dishes... Don't expect Abuela's old standby dishes, but for what the Picnic Basket is, it's darn good! 1:30 PM on Saturday... Packed house of about 40 inside, and by the time we left... There was a wait! There kitchen and staff could run a how-to. Top notch service with a fast kitchen that puts out piping hot food that's right all the time! Great to see a thriving local business! read more

See all

I have never tried this place but a co-worker was picking up and asked if I wanted some lunch. I got the Bacon Chicken Wrap with Cole Slaw. The Cole Slaw is the best I have ever had in my life and the Wrap was fresh and tasty. Looking forward to trying other items on the menu soon! read more

Great little sandwich shop. Everything is fresh and made very well, even the pizza. Not the cheapest place but you get what you pay for

Wow. A locals favorite and it is no wonder why. Great sandwiches and extremely flavorful for anyone who wants that ... like me! The Khalessi Fire (yes, GOT) was my first try and it was great. Can't wait to try the Pesto one. read more

One of the best lunch spots in all of lake country. The subs and pizza are second to none.

Great food! Lovely atmosphere. The sandwiches and pizza are equally fantastic! Definitely recommend a visit!

This is absolutely one of the best places to go and eat. Locally owned and operated by a staff of the best people I have ever encountered while dining out. Quick, accurate orders. Fair prices and best of all there is not a bad sandwich on their menu! Curbside service during this rough going has been just as good and tasty as inside dining! My order came out to my car within 1 minute of pulling up and texting in. Delivered in a bag by a person wearing both mask and gloves - PERFECT for me. Their cucumber deli salad is the absolute best! Supports the local groups around the area. I try to get here at least once a week, more if I can. Drive up for a great meal! Keep up the great job! read more

Great sandwiches, salads, and pizza. Love the porkopalyps. Very convenient online ordering

I give alot of 5's on Yelp, but honestly Picnic Basket deserves it. Here me out... I've only sat and ate here twice, but both times the service was great. The seating area inside is comfortable and accommodating. Most times I've ordered my sandwiches to-go. Everytime the wait is reasonable, regardless of how many people are ahead of you. Never have I waited longer than a few minutes. The menu is awesome, especially for a sandwich shop. There is a sandwich called the BLT marathon with 26 slices of bacon on it. Come on!?! I've had a ham cold sub most times, but have also tried the bandit (ham, turkey, bacon, cheddar, provolone, banana peppers, and bbq ranch sauce) and chicken bacon cheddar subs as my trusty backups. The subs come on a great 6 or 8 inch tasty sub roll with plenty of meat and veggies. I get the 8 inch and I'm definately not ever hungry afterwards. You can get chips as a side and soup, as well. Never tried the soup but I've heard good things. They also have an interesting side in jalapeno cilantro coleslaw. Alot of flavor, not to spicy...I like it! Picnic Basket is another hidden sandwich gem in Waukesha County. read more

Terrific lunch spot! Small but clean dining area. Service was excellent. Sandwiches were large, delicious and fairly priced. Kettle chips and cucumber salad were delicious. Our only complaint is that there is no parking lot! Restaurant is located on a central, busy street. Extra difficult when snow has been plowed. read more

Hidden gem out in Nashotah! They are a full service restaurant but great for take out and pick up as well. They have sandwiches, wraps, pizza and salads. Their sandwiches are awesome. I love the hot turkey. My husband had a chicken sandwich with Alfredo and loved it. The pasta salad as a side is really great. Haven't had a sandwich I didn't like! Their rice crispy treats are so heavenly! Crunchy and gooey! read more

Great subs. They are huge and filling. Ordered the Super Bomber...holy cowwozers was it huge!

Probably one of the best sub shops I've had in a long time whenever we're in the area I'll make sure to stop bye

Dear Picnic Basket Team: Thank you for your curb side service during this trying time for everyone in U.S. and around the World. You guys are the best! Dan and Annie VanKorn read more

Best sandwiches in the area hands down!! I recommend the Super Bomber it's amazing and big

Have gotten take out a few times and the food is so good! Their sandwiches are yummy, and a lot of food for the price. And their pick up process is slick. My favorite thing to do is pick up food with the kids and take it to a nearby park. read more

GLUTEN FREE OPTIONS!!!! I love this place and I especially love their rotisserie turkey sandwich. It's a great non-processed meat option and delectable to boot. I also highly recommend the rice krispy treat and cole slaw. I would recommend ordering ahead. They take phone orders. But it does take a little while for the food to be prepared. Totally worth it. read more

So many good regular options on the menu, and so many interesting specials. Every soup I've had here has been good. Every dessert, for that matter, too. The Bada Bing is a favorite. The mass of meat and toppings slides out of the bread every time. Not really a problem when every part of the sandwich is good and can stand on its own. read more

What is not to like? Delicious subs, great service, they've adapted to Covid properly and again, subs are delicious!

I grew up in the Lake Country area and Picnic Basket was always a favorite. However, I did eat meat then so my perspective of their subs and the gap of time since eating them may have changed my mind. Stopped in a few weekends ago to grab some lunch while in the area. I told my bf that they had really good subs (from what I knew) but he went with a bacon chicken wrap instead. In his opinion, there wasn't much ranch in the wrap itself and the wrap was just okay. It was a huge wrap so he couldn't even finish it. I went with the veggie sub and added guacamole at the employee's suggestion. My main issue with the last two veggie subs I have had from here is that they are MESSY. They fall apart and are difficult to eat, maybe they are just too big. They lack flavor too. The guacamole tasted a bit off and I would have preferred it not to be there even though I love avocados. Their coleslaw was fantastic, that we both really liked. The staff was friendly and there was a bit of a wait for our food. Overall, I haven't been very impressed with my last couple of visits. I have yet to try the pizza or Mexican options. I do recall their meat subs being tasty back in the day so I'm sure they still are. read more

My favorite place in all of Delafield.l (I'm so obsessed I have a T shirt). Grew up going here and the sandwiches are still as excellent to this day. Nothing beats the Picnic Basket. Everyone is friendly, the food is prompt, and the sides are great. read more

Fantastic. Sandwiches were better than most you can get anywhere else. Prime rib sandwich was out of this world. read more

Picnic Basket - This is The place to stop when in the area. - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin

The food was reheated, bland and sloppy. Presentation and flavor are lacking. Service was as expected, fast and unorganized. I've only been to this restaurant once, and I won't be back. Too many other choices with better service, etiquette, and taste to waste another visit here. read more

My first trip to Picnic Basket. The wait staff certainly wasn't accommodating to parents with infants. Server was fairly rude when my wife simply wanted to sit while waiting for a table. She was upset that we were taking a table. Problem with that is that nobody was behind us waiting. ...we left. But I get it, finding good staff is challenging in these times. Guy behind the counter seemed embarrassed and he seemed to understand and tried to accommodate. I'd like to try again when maybe someone else is there or the server is in a better mood. read more

What a great deli! The menu is extensive for such a small restaurant in a small town. Picnic Basket knows how to change with the times to keep business hopping. They offer easy online ordering and quick pick up just like big chain competitors, but with better food. They also feature regular specials to keep the menu interesting. Some of my favorite menu items include: seasonal fresh lemonade, any of their sub sandwiches (really great bread) - especially the ones with guacamole, and of course the classic sides like kettle chips and jalapeno cole slaw. No matter what, you shouldn't leave without grabbing a Scotcheraoo Bar. Trust me. read more

Another fantastic meal from picnic basket. The Nashotah club was outstanding, Variety of salads all with great lettuce , fresh veggies and meat with good dressings. Roast beef sub was excellent as was the corn beef. Love there curbside pickup and delivery. Always at time promised. read more

First time here. We've been talking about going for awhile and had high hopes. My wife and I got salads. $10.99 and $7.99, and description said "mixed greens" which is clearly not the case. (See pic.) Kids mac and cheese is Kraft, which I guess is ok. Trying to give this place the benefit of the doubt, and maybe they're known more for the sandwiches or pizza? So we'll maybe give it one more try. Disappointing first experience though. read more

Picnic Basket - Large Garden Salad - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin

Fantastic fish frys and corned beef sandwhiches

I went to this establishment today and ordered my food to go then I decided to eat in and was told I could not in the most rudest way of the waitress who was very aggressive with telling me no I could not eat inside because I didn't order from her and I wanted to eat inside that I had to order from her I told her I did not know that and thought it was ridiculous that I paid my money to eat and if I change my mind to eat in I can't WOW as the waitress talked loud in front of other customers I felt degraded and embarrassed as she seem to block me from sitting as if she was pointing me to the door as if I would be pushed out if I sat down I told her I did not know this there was no signs posted anywhere stating this was it just her or was this really the rule I've never been to a restaurant where I can't change my mind to eat inside instead of carry out the cashier was nice by trying to accommodate by saying she didn't know it was my first time there she gave me some samples but it just didn't take away the disrespect i felt I went because I heard the food was good but the service was bad i took it upon myself to try anyway and it was true I would never go there again and will not recommend this to anyone read more

One of our go-to spots for delicious sandwiches. The offer take and bake pizzas as well as homemade desserts you can grab from their cooler. We usually carry out but the restaurant is very causal and cute If you choose to dine in. Outdoor seating too. read more

Always great no issues ever! The chicken pesto sandwhich is the best! High quality food and helpful staff!

Bada Bing Baby! We drive from Waukesha for this sandwich. That and the kettle fried chips. Easy order. Curbside pick up. read more

Picnic Basket - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin

The Picnic Basket never disappoints. With a cute and simple indoor/outdoor setup, the food always comes out fast. Whether it's a dine-in or to-go order, the food is always fresh and the meat is good quality, not to mention affordable. The staff is dedicated, have great attitudes and are quick to greet customers. We've also found that The Picnic Basket is a great choice for casual catering for a small party or event. Check out the menu, there's something for everyone -breakfast, lunch and dinner! read more

I needed a quick lunch. Stopped in, had to try the Rhode Island Doritowich. A small sub: Pit ham, lettuce, pickles, tomato, cheddar and a bunch of crushed Doritos. Plus a side of jalapeno slaw. All for under $10. Very good. And day service. I'm going back. Plus the place looks neat. Nice locale too. read more

Best little secret in Lake Country. Don't expect to be intimidated by the food. The menu is all in the name: Picnic Basket. Good quality, fun food. Go there often and enjoy. read more

Food is great. Never a bad sandwich, but the online ordering is irritating. I shouldn't have to login with a password to place an order. I have more important things in my life than to remember a password for Picnic Basket. Adding to the irritation is that the password reset does not work. Modern problems, I guess. read more

Best sandwiches around. Period! Can't get enough of the Chicken Bacon Cheddar! Worth the trip to little Nashotah. read more

They didn't use the rotisserie turkey on our sub or salad. It really set them apart. Hope they bring it back. read more

Picnic Basket - Farmer's salad. American cheese, deli turkey and ham nothing special. - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin