Pie, Pie My Darling

4.7 (73 reviews)

ModerateDesserts, Bakeries, Cupcakes

Closed • Closed

Updated 2 weeks ago

Add Review

Directions

Website

Pie, Pie My Darling Photos

Pie, Pie My Darling - The oatmeal crème pie compared to my face! - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pie, Pie My Darling - a slice of snickerdoodle biscotti from handlebar who sells pie pie slices. - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pie, Pie My Darling - rainbow sprinkle cake - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

+100

Pie, Pie My Darling - chocolate hazelnut - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pie, Pie My Darling Popular Desserts

3 Photos8 Reviews

3 Photos4 Reviews

6 Photos3 Reviews

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pie, Pie My Darling

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

We had the most incredible experience with Pie, Pie My Darling for our wedding! As a vegan couple having a small wedding, it was really important to us to have a beautiful, delicious cake for a traditional cake-cutting moment in front of our families -- and Heather absolutely delivered. The chocolate pistachio cake was a showstopper; it looked stunning and tasted even better. Even our non-vegan family members couldn't stop raving about it! Heather was an absolute joy to work with. She was so flexible and accommodating, even allowing us to pick up the cake a bit earlier, which took a lot of logistical stress off our big day. We are so grateful to her for helping make our celebration even sweeter. If you're looking for a vegan cake that everyone (vegan or not) will love, we highly recommend Pie, Pie My Darling!

Todd G.

We have been long time fans of Pie Pie my Darling and they are truly one of the best vegan bakeries in Chicago. Their high quality creations are vegan and most important outstanding. Highly respected and all about not loosing that touch. I think we have tried most of their creation most recent we picked up a trifecta of creations from one of the restaurant partners that they have built out. Raspberry Lemonade 2.0- A new creation which has a good zesty lemon pop with smooth and silky raspberry tones. Moist and amazing ... love this for spring and summer! Hard to find as it's new but if you get the opportunity it's a must! Confetti- I personally really like this cake. It's classic and balanced well. It's a classic cake, vegan and freakin amazing Cookie Dough- my family favorite... it's a 10 out 10 cookie dough explosion topped with chocolate chip cookies. It's seriously amazing. A little goes a long way. It's very sweet and literally like eating cookie dough which is a good thing despite what your mom told you! Okay so to sum it up- if you haven't tried Pie Pie my darling it's a must. True entrepreneurs. Do the community a favor be respectful and share with your friends. Things got a little crazy when they became known and some people became not so nice when they couldn't get a cake.

Puneet S.

During these times, this small gem and baker found a way to create such a unique way of bringing together cake and a classic cookie in Nutter Butter. The cake is light and fluffy and the cream filling is the perfect amount of sweet. This cake melted in my mouth and the consistency of the cake was also on point with no cake falling apart. The peanut butter taste was not too strong and very happy with my slice of sweet from here, can't wait to try more creations!

The oatmeal crème pie compared to my face!

Jordyn M.

Everything Pie, Pie My Darling has to offer is delicious. I have ordered from PPMD on multiple occasions. The staff and owner are a dream team and radiate passion for what they do.

Maiesha T.

I accidentally ordered my birthday cake from Pie Pie My Darling. It's quite funny. I follow them on IG, and I definitely thought I had tasted their cake at Vegandale in September. I didn't realize that I was wrong after I paid for the cake. Best mistake ever!!!! . Customer service: I was due to pick up my birthday cake on February 2, the day mother nature dumped a boatload of snow on Chicago. The bakery reached out to me to let me know that if I wanted to pick up my cake I could but I could also reschedule my pick up. Love that customer service!! Thank you for not forcing me to drive 15 miles in snowy/slushy awfulness!! The cake was so delicious. It was moist and super cute. You definitely can't "taste that it is vegan." I will be a repeat customer.

Banana split, cosmic brownie, lemon, and biscoff cake cups and a slice of lemon cake... All vegan.

Oly G.

Hands down the best vegan cake!!! I first discovered PPMD via Instagram. Heather (the owner) is very engaged with her customers and you can tell how much love she puts into her baking. So far I've tried the banana split, lemon, peanut butter pretzel, biscoff, strawberry funfetti cake slices or cake cups (not cupcakes but a small container with a mini cakes inside). I can't honestly tell you which one I prefer over the other because they are all delicious and moist (I have found most vegan cake to be dry before PPMD). Now you can't walk in to get a slice, you can only order on their website once a week from a certain time. Currently, the only day you can pick up your preorder is on Saturday. They do accept cake orders with at minimum of 7 days notice. The menu switches flavors monthly for the cake slices and weekly for the cake cups. Slices are about $9 and the cake cups are $6.50. Also, PPMD donates a portion of their profits each month for organizations that provide help and support for communities such as LGBTQ+, Indigenous, African American, mental health, Ukrainian humanitarian aid, etc. So you get a tasty treat and also help organizations that are making a difference.

Grace W.

This place is FANTASTIC! Everything that they make is stellar. I love how accessible their cake slices are throughout Chicago, and their flavors are so inventive and always delicious. I've tried their pumpkin snickerdoodle cake, chocolate and mint cake, and their carrot cake. My favorite was the carrot cake but you really can't go wrong. Non vegans I've shared these cakes with could not believe the cakes were vegan. I've also tried their cookies and pies through their Saturday treat pick ups at their storefront which have allowed me to see how versatile their baking is! Key lime pie is something I loved before going vegan and so it's such a delight to have a go to vegan option. Please support this incredible women-owned business!

Julie Y.

This is a review of their pre-ordering process, more so than their cakes. Their cakes are phenomenal - which is why I am so sad to leave this kind of review. To Pie Pie: Please, at the very least, consider adding additional detail to your preorder emails. Or perhaps an automated texting system to remind your customers about their orders. I understand that you have more than enough demand, but that doesn't absolve you of trying to notify your customers about orders placed with their hard earned money. To Customers: If you think you double checked your order pick up details (like I did), triple and quadruple check. -----more detail----- Pie pie's cakes are lovely. They have extremely high demand and have a competitive ordering process. We really wanted to support local Chicago restaurants for Thanksgiving, and decided to splurge on a cake from Pie Pie, and a meal kit from Frontier. To order from Pie Pie, I bookmarked the preorder date (Saturday, 11/14/2020) so we could be sure to refresh the page at the right time. On Saturday, I checked the webpage, and the preorder had been pushed to Monday, 11/16/2020 - during work hours. This was a little frustrating, because it was more difficult to get an order in in between meetings. But between my husband and I, we managed to place an order! Sweet! They sold out very quickly. After placing an order, I received one confirmation email (attached). Note that the is email purely confirms the order, and does not include any details about the order process, when/where to pick up/rules, etc. At the same time, I also placed an order from Frontier (attached). Note that Frontier's email includes specific instructions on when/where to pick up. I marked my calendar for Thanksgiving day, thinking I would pick up both in one fell swoop (my mistake). Additionally, Frontier sent a reminder two days prior with details about pick up. The night before thanksgiving, at around 8 PM, I pulled up my orders to confirm pick up times. It was at that point, that I realized Pie Pie's pick up was that day between 12-6 PM..... all the way at the very bottom of the website, I see that they had a disclaimer about orders being donated if not picked up within the window. I was surprised that they wouldn't give no-shows a call/text to see if they were going to pick up their order. I sent them a question on Instagram immediately and also sent an email, asking if there was any way that I could pick up my cake, or get some sort of partial credit (any amount at all) toward a future purpose. I even said that a guaranteed spot in the next preorder would be great! $44 on a cake is not a trivial amount to spend on a cake - especially during the holidays - ESPECIALLY during the kind of year we've had. My query was met with a cold answer that effectively said 'No, we can't give you anything. Next time, cancel your order if you aren't going to pick it up' I understand that time and effort go into your cakes. I had 0 expectation of a full refund. Even a slot in a future preorder would have been a show of good faith in a loyal customer.

Clark S.

On my visit to Chicago to see one of my best friends and his girlfriend and to attend Chicago Comic and Entertainment Expo 2019, we ordered and (almost) demolished an entire pie! To celebrate my friend's birthday, his girlfriend ordered a Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Pie. It tasted incredible! The presentation, the texture, the flavor, just everything about this pie was amazing! Between the three of us, we almost ate the entire thing in one go. On top of that, the pie is completely Vegan! If they wouldn't have told me, I would never have guessed it. In addition to pies, PPMD makes cakes and what's cool about this is that they take all of the extra cake scraps and shavings and create these mini cake trifles in pack them in mason jars. We ended up trying a Thin Mint Cake trifle and Classic Chocolate Cake trifle. Both were outstanding! It's probably a good thing I don't live in Chicago because I'd be eating these cakes and pies way too much! I can't wait to come back though and, hopefully, try a cake or just have my own cake trifle.

Abe C.

This is something else right here! The cake I got here might be the best cake I've ever had! We got a Cookie Monster Cake slice made from Pie, Pie My Darling after my brother recommended it to me as his favorite cake. Lets just say his recommendation did not disappoint as it lived up to all the hype! This vegan cake is so much better than any regular cake I've had which surprised me. People usually like to give anything vegan a bad name, but this cake right here proves all the critics wrong by a longshot! The cake itself is so moist and smooth and so unflaky unlike a lot of cakes I've had. It literally just melts in your mouth and puts your taste buds in an uncontrollable frenzy! The crazy part was my brother said this wasn't even the best flavor cake he's gotten here! Honestly this is the type of cake you have dreams about years later. I can not thank my brother enough for treating me to this delight! Honestly you truly haven't experienced cake until you've tried Pie, Pie My Darling.

Maitri S.

I finally got to try the chocolate chip pie and it was VEGAN HEAVEN! The slice was hugeee (with it for the price) and the cake was moist and creamy. I can't wait to try the other flavors.

See all

Skye J.

Elite 23

260

6 years ago

I preordered a Cookie Monster cake and it is SO GOOD. It tastes just like cookie dough and it's vegan?? read more

Pie, Pie My Darling - Cookie Monster - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marisa U.

6 years ago

How in gods name does this place have anything less than five stars. The cakes are gorgeous and celebratory, and taste even better than they look. If you can score a whole cake rather than a slice, do that so it doesn't dry out. read more

Pie, Pie My Darling - Lol I got excited when my husband texted about funfetti - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Margo M.

Elite 23

335

5 years ago

This vegan bakery is woman owned, and in addition is probably the best vegan bakery I have ever tried. It all feels very exclusive to me as their goods usually sell out extremely fast due to the fact that they are a small business, and their products are mind numbingly delicious. She has seasonal flavors, and all the goods are decorated so whimsically and cute. I have been dying for a birthday cake from them, if I get on their site early enough and follow all directions to ensure I can secure one, I can probably get lucky, but I haven't gotten lucky enough so far. My cousin just scored me one of their "Cake Cups" I almost cried when she presented it to me, it was so amazingly delicious, I wanted more and more!!!! I believe it was cookie dough flavor. It came in a good size cup with a cute bakery sticker with it. My non vegan boyfriend woke me up from a nap to tell me how good it was- I was so worried he was going to eat it all, I peeled myself up out of bed to make sure he didn't! lol Pie, Pie is a serious treat, and any one, vegan, or not should give them a try, you won't believe how good it is. I am so appreciative they exist! The only gripe I have, is that it feels really hard and frustrating to get a cake from them- there are a lot of specific instructions and directions to follow. I hope one day they open more locations, and expand their business so their products are more readily available and accessible. read more

Pie, Pie My Darling - Cookie Dough Cake Cup - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarah C.

103

4 years ago

One of my favorite businesses to support! The owner puts so much love into her cakes. They keep the business small on purpose to maintain the quality of their product and it shows. You can pre-order treats on Friday to pick up Saturday or get cake slices at a few different vegetarian/vegan restaurants in the area. I've been a loyal customer for a few years and never been disappointed! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Vanessa S.

5 years ago

The best vegan treats! I always order birthday cakes for myself and my plant based friends! Always a big hit with vegans and non-vegans a like. The cakes are never too sweet and you can't tell they're non-dairy! So delicious and easy to order and pick up! You're supporting a small business who has done their fair share of donating to important local causes like BLM and LGBTQ+ charities. This is dessert you can feel good about! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dan J.

5 years ago

Best cake I've ever had, my favorite is the banana split, banana cake with strawberry, chocolate and vanilla frosting with chocolate shell and peanuts read more

Pie, Pie My Darling - Choc chip cake - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pie, Pie My Darling - Banana split cake - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pie, Pie My Darling - Carrot cake - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sydney D.

6 years ago

I never write reviews, but I feel like I have to for Pie, Pie My Darling! The staff, Heather especially, is so sweet and friendly! Even though there's usually a line out the door in the morning, the line moves very quickly! I've only tried their cake jars so far, but they're amazing!!! They don't "taste vegan" at all-- so so so good!! Definitely worth the early Saturday wake up and 1 hour public transport commute read more

Pie, Pie My Darling - Desserts Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Faith F.

7 years ago

I'm not actually vegan, but had a dairy free stint while breastfeeding my dairy sensitive baby. I consider myself a bit of a cupcake snob, and will randomly do cupcake crawls with friends. I ordered some PPMD Cookie Monster cupcakes for a party and umm ... totally ate two while driving THESE ARE THE MOST *amazing* CUPCAKES I'VE EVER HAD!!! Follow her on Insta or FB to know when she opens up her order list for the next month. She'll usually announce it via a story. She has a limited number of orders and they sell out fast. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Nat P.

7 years ago

The most delicious vegan cakes, pies, cookies and cupcakes, etc. And had my wedding cake made by her as well. Amazing quality, so amazing that my non-vegan guests couldn't believe it was a vegan cake. Love everything I've tried. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Matt W.

5 years ago

A neighbor introduced us to this bakery, first dropping off a mini pie and then a slice of their nutter butter cake (which I just finished). I'm not vegan, but this cake is ridiculous. Probably one of the best things I've eaten in a long time. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Trina S.

8 years ago

Heather runs the one-woman business of Pie, Pie My Darling. We have had it multiple times at her pop-ups throughout the city, Vegan Fest, restaurants (including Handlebar!), and even had her do our wedding cake! Her products are the highest quality and you can tell she puts 1,000% effort into everything she makes. She does it all, from cookies and brownies to cakes and pies. I can not recommend her products highly enough! read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rachel W.

5 years ago

This is truly the best cake I've ever had, hands down. I'm so sad that I just discovered it in 2021!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lee E.

5 years ago

Here's my review- When you're in the mood for a cake, you're in the mood for a cake! Vegans alike have their cravings. I've been a vegan for 6+ years at this point and sometimes miss my rich and fluffy stuff, namely cakes. I'll give her that -- it tastes like a cake. I will say that the hype tastes better than the actual cake though. I thought it was good but 'meh' at best, or above average. Also, I didn't like the chocolate chips or "just throw shit on it" approach she has. Cake is a specialty item that comes with finesse, love, sculpture and patience. For me, just throwing shit on a cake -- the shotgun approach -- isn't my thing. I like sweet but I don't need more sweet. I need enough. That said, pricing is a little high, but not outlandish. I wish around $25-30. I need to be honest here and I will -- for a vegan alternative, if you don't care about your health at all (she doesn't and she freely admits this on her website when she says "this is meant to taste delicious, not healthy") it works. Otherwise, it's terrible for you. (Tons of oil, salt, sugar) For me, I'm not willing to pay that price. But it's not her fault. She's a nice person so I recommend it -- if that's what you want, but honestly, wtf? Personally, I value my health more than I value a cake. For that reason I may not come back but that's a personal vendetta I have with myself. I also got pretty sick from the mocha slice. I almost never get sick so I don't know... Taste is decent. Texture is well done. Look is pretty good. Overall I give it a 6 since I got plenty on stomach pain from it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Emily D.

5 years ago

The most delicious cake / cookies / pies / goodies in general (not just the most delicious for vegan goodies). The kindest owner and staff too. Growing at their own speed, but it's worth the wait! Be patient and kind read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mallory M.

6 years ago

This place is great! The Cookie Monster jar is my favorite and one of the best desserts I've had in a long time. I'm not vegan but I'm a huge baker myself and these treats are by far some of the best! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Marissa G.

484

5 years ago

Amazing!! Was able to get a piece of the Cookie Monster cake from Handlebar with my dinner tonight. So rich, delicious & adorable. Can't wait for them to open the storefront again so I can visit, but until then I'll just hunt down some treats around the city read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Leonel O.

6 years ago

Best vegan cake I've ever had. Her recent Snickers cake was amazing and is my favorite of all time now. It's inconsistent in a good way, as each bite is better than the last hahaha. But seriously vegan or not you need to get your hands on this cake. She also doesn't stay silent on serious issues and I love that about her. I'll be supporting this business forever read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nah F.

5 years ago

Writing this for post-COVID days, because the preorders during the pandemic sell out within minutes.. for good reason! I tried this place because I loved the name but am not strictly vegan. That said, the Cookie Monster cake is the best slice I've ever had - bar none. I know how in-demand they are so I've been trying to "take a week off" from placing orders here and there so more people get to experience my new faves, and it's *so* hard to do. Looking forward to better days when we can all just stop in because the people there are top notch too. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brittney M.

5 years ago

Ah. May. Zing. I used their cakes for my twins first birthday and everyone loved them. I wanted to eat a piece everyday until the cakes were gone...so I did. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laura S.

7 years ago

Seriously, seriously delicious. Literally one of the best bites of cake I have ever had- if not the best. I'm not even vegan, and this was mind blowing for me. My friend and I are going to order a cake from her with no special occasion because we can't wait until one of our birthdays. Five stars isn't enough! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bree L.

170

8 years ago

I have never seen a fricken baker do as much Pie, Pie My Darling does with their cakes. The most beautiful delicious perfect creations, and I'm only truly at peace when I go somewhere to eat (Handlebar, Kitchen 17) and obtain a cake slice. When I die, cremate me into a PPMD cake. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

L K.

411

6 years ago

I am a professional event planner and I recommend Pie, Pie to all of my clients vegan or not. My husband and I have been dairy free and vegan for 7 years. When we first learned about Pie Pie My Darling it was from our local favorite restaurant Handlebar. BOY oh BOY were we delighted when they opened up a shop in our neighborhood. Their desserts are absolutely DIVINE. So well made, so delicious and a dream for us vegans who avoid dairy! Please do yourself a favor whether you are vegan or not and visit them. Support your local, small, woman owned businesses! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Hallie R.

678

6 years ago

THE BEST cake in Chicago, hands down! I'm not even vegan, you'd never know! Service was fast. Everyone's super nice. All desserts were fresh. Everything tastes amazing. Packed great. Stays fresh over a few days. High recommend! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Margaret H.

5 years ago

The cakes here are phenomenal! I have actually never directly ordered through Pie Pie (although I'd love to try some of their other treats), but I order slices when I get take out at Handlebar and they are truly incredible. It is a perk that they're vegan, but I would choose this for a treat regardless because they are that good. Highly recommend! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kelsey M.

5 years ago

Vegan or not, my favorite bakery in all of Chicago!! She is transparent about their small capacity and tries to make her treats as accessible as possible. Boy oy boy do I wish they had a store front on every corner but each slice of cake is made with love by the owner and you can tell. A wonderful place to support in Chicago! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Haley H.

6 years ago

Let me start by saying I love their products, it is exceptionally well made. The hours are terrible, even before the Covid 19 situation. The owner continuously makes excuses for why they can't be open more or have enough stock. Extremely off-putting. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael A.

5 years ago

Five stars, tasty delicious vegan cakes. People disappointed because of the high demand for their cake or their illiteracy of pickup instructions should be ignored. Heather is amazing at making vegan treats and her compassion for others is unmatched! Thanks for all you do for cake lovers and our community! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Margaret D.

256

5 years ago

The best cakes and baked goods I have ever eaten. They happen to be vegan, which means you can feel good about your purchase and what you're eating while you enjoy the heck out of their products. I've had their cosmic brownie, cake, cup cakes, and sugar cookie. All spectacular. The owner, Heather, is lovely as well. Her Instagram is fun to follow, both for the eye candy of all the baked goods and behind-the-scenes posts, but also because she is genuinely a kind and thoughtful human who cares about the world and the people around her. I will forever be a PPMD fan. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kimberly M.

105

6 years ago

This is without a doubt the best cake I've ever had. They do a Nutter Butter that is life changing! Trust me when I say you need this cake!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Adam M.

7 years ago

Would love to try this place because i hear its got great food. I have a friend who wants one of these cakes for her birthday and I've been planning on ordering one to surprise her.Tried to order it at the beginning of may for a June birthday and the website told me to come back on Monday the 20th because that is when they will start taking June orders. Woke up this morning and went to the website fully ready to order a cake and it now says they are fully booked through June and i should come back in a few weeks. My friends birthday is in two weeks so i guess that's not going to work. Really disappointing. I understand if the business is booming and you have to cap your orders. Just don't lie about it on your website. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

SJ M.

6 years ago

holy moly! best cake i have ever had. most vegan pastries are too dense and sweet for me... these are perfection though. thank you for giving vegan a good name! xo read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Trevor N.

6 years ago

Heather is super sweet and her treats are even sweeter! I'm a sucker for the Cookie Monster cake jars and the oatmeal cream pies!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joseph A.

7 years ago

My cousin lives near this bakery and she and her husband bought the chocolate peanut butter pretzel pie for Thanksgiving. They bought it with me in mind, I've been vegan for over 20 years. It was the first time I've been able to eat desert on Thanksgiving. The chocolate peanut butter pretzel pie was amazing. I really enjoyed it. I hope to try their other baked goods in the future. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Back

Page 2 of 2

More info about Pie, Pie My Darling

2636 W Chicago Ave
Chicago, IL 60007
Ukrainian Village, West Town
Directions
Visit Website
https://piepiemydarling.net

Hours

What time does Pie, Pie My Darling open?

Pie, Pie My Darling opens at 12:00 PM on Friday.Pie, Pie My Darling opens at 11:00 AM on Saturday.

What time does Pie, Pie My Darling close?

Pie, Pie My Darling is closed on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Pie, Pie My Darling closes at 3:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu, Sun ClosedFri 12:00 PM - 3:00 PMSat 11:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Pie, Pie My Darling take credit cards?

Yes, Pie, Pie My Darling takes credit cards.

Indoor Amenities

Does Pie, Pie My Darling allow dogs?

No, Pie, Pie My Darling does not allow dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Pie, Pie My Darling have parking?

Yes, Pie, Pie My Darling has parking options. Street Parking

More Info

Special Hours

Ask the Community - Pie, Pie My Darling

View All 4 Questions

You might also consider

Molly's Cupcakes

I live Uptown & this location opened at 9, so I came in this morning to grab TONS of treats for the…read moreteachers and staff at my son's High School. Today is Parent/Teacher conference day, and although his grades are amazing & technically they don't need to see me, I wanted to do something special for them. He's a Senior and graduates this May. The staff were SO kind & super helpful!! The young lady at the counter (Crystal) helped me choose a variety of treats and even congratulated me on his graduation. If I ever need anything else, I'm definitely coming here!!

Crème brûlée was a 7.5/10. The sugar coating was a little too sweet, but I loved the crunch it gave…read moreand the cream in the middle was so good. Blueberry cheesecake gets an 8/10 overall. I didn't love the graham cracker because it had a strong buttery taste, but I get that it's needed to hold it together. Without that, it would've been a 9/10. The cheesecake topping tasted almost like custard and paired well with the blueberry cupcake base. Chocolate sea salt caramel... 10/10. This might actually be one of the best cupcakes I've ever had. Rich chocolate cake, caramel sauce in the middle, buttercream that wasn't too sweet, and the salt on top tied everything together perfectly. Peach cobbler was insane. 1000/10. It tasted like pumpkin pie and apple pie combined, probably from all the cinnamon. Not overly sweet, super light cream, and just perfection. Definitely worth the hype. The chocolate sea salt caramel and peach cobbler might actually be the best cupcakes I've ever had.

See all

Sweet Mandy B's

We came back home to Chicago to celebrate my birthday with our close friends. We called sweet Mandy…read moreB's to order a cake for our celebration. Michael took our order and set up delivery to the restaurant we were celebrating at. We called the day of the event to double check and everything was a go and even got a Happy Birthday wish! The cake was absolutely delicious and our guests raved about it! Thank you Sweet Mandy B's for making my birthday celebration so sweet. You never disappoint.

Absolutely delicious! The cupcakes are so good. I love the Cookie one but they all are worth trying.read more

Photos

Cake tops

Ordering at counter- wonderfully, lovely staff, very helpful.

See all

Jennivee’s Bakery

This is my absolute most favorite bakery. So this is my ode to the bakery and Dom, who is a gem of…read morean employee there. I've been a customer of almost 10 years and have been obsessed since they first opened their doors at a different location. I literally live an hour away without traffic and even longer with traffic, but I make sure to stop by or send someone else to get it for me at least once a month or more. I love the amazing cakes that are so delicious and unique but on top of that, it is Asian owned, LGBTQ supporting, etc. A lot has changed since their little storefront with no seating. The bakery is now a full on cafe and I'm so happy to see how much they've grown and how successful they are. And while it is glorious, I will say I miss the sweet neighborhood charm and great customer service it used to have. Getting in touch with the bakery through phone or text can be tough and to be honest, sometimes one of the people working there is kind of...very mean. It had me questioning if I should keep coming back. I just love this bakery so much though and being raised by parents that had a small food business, I can't help but want to support. I had a particularly difficult last minute request for the bakery a few weeks ago and I was reminded why this place is so great. It had been YEARS since I made this specific request, which was an order for a slice of cake for every flavor and a cupcake for every flavor. This is a BIG and time consuming request, especially if it's last minute. Unfortunately I come to the city whenever the traffic isn't atrocious, so it's always last minute. Dom absolutely pulled through though. Even though there were other employees there (I saw two others but one disappeared and then another male was kind of walking around the cafe and such), Dom took this giant request and fulfilled it himself. The other gentleman (not the mean person previously mentioned) was actually who I made the request to, but he told Dom to do it. I was kind of confused why they didn't do it together but idk, maybe the other guy isn't allowed to handle food? Who knows. Regardless, this request obviously took a long time and the line was getting longer; people were getting a little restless but Dom stayed calm but was swift. I swear he was moving faster than most people in the industry could with a cake knife like that. He was not impatient or rude to me at all. He was just there to do his job as fast and well as possible. It's so rare to see that type of work ethic. He is also so obviously proud of the bakery and the food they serve which makes you feel good about being a patron there. So although I continue to have an unpleasant experience with one particular employee there, Dom keeps my love for this bakery alive. He reminds me of what this bakery was like when they first opened their doors. I hope Dom is cherished there and I bet he is considering his work ethic. I will continue to support this bakery and I recommend everyone else to support as well. It may not be that small little shop anymore but Dom is a reminder of the heart of the place.

I've been to Jennivee's twice now and I also got my college graduation cake from here last year for…read morepick-up! They did a beautiful job. For my graduation cake, I chose the tres leches and it was so creamy, moist, and delicious. I basically ate half of the cake by myself lol. This most recent time, I needed a snack and wanted something sweet. Everything here looks amazing and I'm sure tastes amazing too, so it's hard to choose. I chose to get the berry chantilly cake slice since it was a hot day, and it was the perfect refreshing treat! It was soooo good.

Photos

Inside

See all

Main Squeeze Cupcake and Hazelnut Bomb Cupcake

Sweet Mandy B's

I ordered a carrot cake with cream cheese frosting for my mom's birthday and it was fantastic!…read moreThere wasn't a single piece left. I will definitely use Sweet Mandy B's again in the future!

My husband and I booked an adventure in the city that takes us around little restaurants in Lincoln…read morePark to "collect" food and end with a picnic in Oz Park and just... so much fun! The most adorable little dessert shop. The vibe was a whole VIBE. I love it. And the chicas behind the register were so sweet. We got cupcakes here and they were yummy. So happy to know this place is here so we know where to go for our sweet tooth if we're ever in the area.

Photos

Custom birthday cake

Peanut Butter Rice Krispie

See all

Molly's Cupcakes

I had the best red velvet cupcake of my life here. Moist, buttery, not too sweet. It was…read morefantastic!

I like that Molly's always has some tasty filling in the core of the cupcake. It's their signature…read moreand it works really well. The cupcakes themselves are a good balance of fluffy and sweetness. I don't love their frosting though. I've had a number of flavors and the frostings are always way too sweet or way too buttery. I often end up wiping off half the frosting and eating more of the cupcake and filling in the middle instead of the frosting.

Photos

What we received instead

See all

Interior swings

A Sweets Girl

3.8

(11 reviews)

5.9 mi

Ripped off. Rude and dismissive owner…read more Ordered through Too Good To Go app and paid $4.99 plus tax for $15.00 worth of drinks. Recieved 2 drinks which totaled $7.95 according to the menu prices. I was supposed to receive $15.00 in drinks. When I questioned the owner she wouldn't give me a straight answer. She said that they lowered the Too Good To Go price. And that's what I get now. Then she offered to refund my money, but not the taxes. I told her I would leave her a bad review, and she said she didn't care. Shame on this business owner.

bad service bad attitude…read more small quantity for what i payed for. i payed for $15 worth of drinks on the "to good to go" app. only got 2 drinks. last time got 4. then she said if i don't like it don't come back...

Photos

German Chocolate Cupcake reminds me of old times in Europe

As you can see, menu is expanding with a choice of beverages and sandwiches

See all

Desperately needed bakery in Canaryville opened its doors in October of 2024.

Magnolia Bakery - Chicago

I'm so excited to finally try Magnolia! There were so many different options and everyone can find…read moresomething they like here. I got the confetti cake slice and a chocolate cupcake. I didn't expect the confetti cake slice to have cream cheese frosting (which I thought was an unusual choice), but I think it worked! The chocolate cupcake was okay - not the best I've had, but was still pretty good. Prices are a little steep - could be due to the name brand of the company. Bakery was cute and clean. Service was nice!

Window shopping at Magnolia bakery. Banana pudding bar, yes please!…read more Please come and create your own adventure.

Photos

See all

Bake

What a cute bakery! It's a very cozy and welcoming place to…read morechat or read and the variety of baked goods is impressive. I only came for tea but plan to come back if I'm in the area. They also have a lovely gift selection

I used to go here every weekend for the quiche and pistachio croissant to the point where they…read morerecognized me and my order lol. I moved from the area but I would still go back if I could!

Photos

Reminds me of the movie Up!

See all

Almond croissant

Chicago Sugar Daddy Patisserie

If I could do ten stars I would…read more I first used Chicago Sugar Daddy for some desserts for my office Pride lunch in 2025. After that, for every months birthday celebration, I go straight to them. The flavors are AMAZING and endless. And every single time a new employee tries a cupcake they always ask 'where did these come from?!' What was supposed to be just desserts for lunch turned into the only bakery I will use for all of my events. And they are so friendly when they drop off the goods(and ALWAYS on time). If any of you haven't yet, please give them a try. It's definitely worth it and one of the best bakeries and patisseries in Chicago.

OMG! Try the Ube cake, it is amazing! The huge slice, the frosting Im glad I don't live too close…read moreor I would be here 4 times a week. Quaint place and the staff were so welcoming and helpful. Check them out!

Photos

Strawberry Shortcake

See all

Obligatory plant wall with clever neon signage.

Molly’s Cupcakes

4.2

(110 reviews)

1.9 mi

Molly's Cupcakes has a lot of unique cupcakes in their display case. The one that really caught my…read moreeye was the creme brulee cupcake! There was a cream filling inside, the cake batter was moist, and the top had the hardened sugar. There was a lot of cute decor inside, and the worker was super friendly and helpful.

Always a go to for a sweet tooth. I'm a red velvet girl, and theirs is pretty good. They have a…read morewide variety of options and their service is fast and efficient. This location had some cool decor and art inside.

Photos

Perfect ratio: frosting to cupcake

See all

Kasama

Almost everyone I know who has been to Chicago told me to visit Kasama, and now I totally get why…read more They're a two michelin star modern filipino spot that's a bakery by day and a tasting menu restaurant by night. The line is almost always crazy long. Pro tip: place an online order right when they open in the morning so you can skip the line for pickup. I went close to 2pm, so I only waited about 15 minutes for brunch, but most of the pastries and breakfast sandwiches were already sold out. ＊Matcha Pandan Eclair $9.5 ** The biggest éclair I've ever seen! You get a mini version on their tasting menu, but the bakery sells this full-size beauty. My favorite pastry from the haul! I loved the crunch from the toasted genmai and the light pandan whipped cream. I just wish the matcha flavor was stronger. ＊Black Truffle Croissant $16 * Every bite was packed with black truffle flavor, and with fresh shaved black truffle, truffle oil, and a premium truffle filling, I could see why it costs $16. You also get a mini version on the tasting menu. But I wasn't a fan of the crunchy pearl sugar on top. I ended up shaving it all off. ＊Ube & Huckleberry Basque Cake $9 Loved the little powdered sun stencil inspired by the Philippine flag. It was filled with ube pastry cream and huckleberry. Personally, I found the filling too sweet for my liking. ＊Filipino Breakfast $20 ** I originally wanted their signature longanisa breakfast sandwich, but it was sold out, so the staff recommended this instead. Best recommendation ever, I even thanked them before I left! Every component was so thoughtfully done, especially the meats. Now I need to come back for the tasting menu. ＊Oh, Hot Yam $6.85 ** Hands down the best ube latte I've had. Super ube-forward with a hint of coconut sap that made it even more comforting on a chilly rainy day in Chicago.

I arrived on Saturday at 9:15 AM and ended up waiting in line for two hours. While waiting, I…read morenoticed many people bypassing the line entirely by ordering ahead. When I checked the website in line, they still had same-day afternoon pickup slots available (~2PM) with a great selection (including the black truffle croissants, eclairs, and muffin tops). The interior is nicely air-conditioned, and they offer outdoor seating. The inside can get quite cramped with crowds waiting for tables and orders. After my two-hour wait, I was told at the register that the black truffle croissant was sold out. However, I kept seeing fresh trays of them being brought out--presumably to fulfill online orders. It was incredibly disappointing to wait that long outside only to miss out on a signature item that was in front of my eyes. Breakfast Sandwich-- Loaded with longanisa, hash brown, eggs, and cheese. The eggs were incredibly fluffy, the longanisa was juicy and flavorful, and the hash brown was super crispy and golden brown (no white interior to be seen) I tried the ube and huckleberry basque cake, matcha pandan eclair, and foie gras danish. The basque cake was the standout pastry-- moist with crisp edges and a beautiful blend of flavors. The Kaffe Calamansi and Manila Fog featured incredibly unique profiles and disappeared in minutes. Note: If you choose to dine in, you can luckily order additional items from your table if you want to try more!

Photos

@endoedibles on Instagram 03/21/25

Breakfast sandwich: soufflé egg, longanisa, cheese, hash brown

See all

Breakfast Sandwich: longanisa, egg, and cheese | $12

Sweet Bean

stopped in for a quick caffeine boost on the way to the Field Museum. it was an adorable shop, the…read morelighting wasn't too bright or too dim, the decor was well thought out and tasteful, and I enjoyed looking through their pastry options! the barista (I wish I could remember their name!) was friendly and knowledgeable and made the best oat milk cortado I've ever had. I'll definitely be returning next time I'm in Chicago and look forward to trying their pastries!!

A Taiwanese bakery. How could a place that loves Michael Jackson be bad?…read more Salted Egg Yolk Bolo Bun流心菠蘿麵包: Calling it "流心"(runny) isn't quite accurate; it's a bolo bun菠蘿包 (pineapple -shape bun) with a salted egg yolk filling, but it had an authentic, old-fashioned flavor that made me feel like back to childhood. The crust was thin and crispy, with a large air cavity, making it very soft and fluffy. The salted egg yolk has just the right balance of sweetness and saltiness, and wasn't too cloying. Garlic Cheese Brioche Bun蒜香奶酪麵包: Perhaps its more Taiwanese name is "八蒜包" (Eight Garlic Bun). Its appearance and taste were very similar to those I've had at Taiwanese bakeries in mainland China. The cheese and garlic flavors were very strong, but the bread itself was slightly coarse. Hojicha Latte: The whole milk was very milky, but the hojicha flavor felt a little weak. However, it's already great to find a tea latte that's not very sweet.

Photos

Inside of Scallion & Ham Bun 蔥花火腿麵包 ($3.95) - very strong scallion flavor. Bread is soft, moist, and pretty oily.

See all

Inside of Lychee Cranberry Scone 荔枝蔓越莓司康 ($5.75) - not the best, is dry and powdery. Definitely not worth the price.

Hero Coffee and Bagel Bar

I'm from Los Angeles, and I have to say this place was such a sweet surprise. Everyone was…read moreincredibly welcoming and made me feel right at home, which always stands out when you're visiting a new city. The outside is super cute too it actually caught my eye when I first found them on Yelp, and it's just as charming in person. I tried the Teddy Graham latte on the barista's recommendation, and I'm so glad I did. It had great flavor without being overly sweet, and I got it with whole milk which made it perfectly smooth and comforting. If you're in downtown Chicago, I'd definitely recommend checking out this spot. It's a cozy little gem with great vibes and even better drinks.

Clearly a popular spot, run like a well oiled machine. The space is tiny so they only allowed four…read morepeople in a time and then you wait outside in the alley for your order. The bagel was good, I had a hippie sandwich and my boyfriend got a bacon egg and cheese which he said was good too.

Photos

Inside hero cafe

Bulls Eye on Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel with sausage instead of bacon

See all

Storefront

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Heyward T.

Elite 23

195

203

5 years ago

Pie, Pie My Darling. I completely forgot about it; I was here for the and then completely forgot to write them a review until now! They've already gotten a lot of attention, and it's well-deserved. Pie, Pie My Darling, aside from having a good name, this was a fantastic place. I got a Halloween pre-order here, and booking was simple--no other/extra options. I'd heard that cakes in this place sell out quickly, so I was fortunate to get one of the few remaining ones. I picked up my order at 3 p.m., and they were prompt, accommodating, and didn't make me wait. I was anticipating a plain cake, but it's not only lovely to look at, but it also tastes great. I'm not a huge fan of sweets and only bought some for my grandchildren, but the cake was delicious and vegan. These people are doing an excellent job. I also purchased Snickers biscuits, which my daughter adores, and Caramel Apple Lolly, which taste good for me (around four stars). The baker certainly put his or her spin on things, using tastes you'd never think of. This would be one of my favorite places for cakes. On one of my healthier days, I'll return to try the other vegan. Because they aren't baking the same cake every day, I appreciate the "limited spots." Customer service is excellent. Until the next time, friends! read more

Joshua L.

7 years ago

Very tasty, beautifully created vegan desserts. The owner clearly loves what she does, and it shows in the quality of her offerings! I am not a vegan so I consider myself a good judge of taste comparison versus traditional dairy based desserts. I can honestly say that I cannot taste a difference between the vegan desserts and traditional desserts. read more

Pie, Pie My Darling - desserts - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Pie, Pie My Darling also viewed

Bake

381 reviews

Wicker Park, West Town

Alliance Bakery & Cafe

1057 reviews

West Town, Wicker Park

Defloured

250 reviews

Andersonville, Edgewater

Cake Sweet Food Chicago

234 reviews

Near West Side

$$$

Amande Dessert

20 reviews

Albany Park

Intoxicakes

7 reviews

Lakeview

Keto Eats Chicago

3 reviews

Avondale

Mr. Cake

184 reviews

Cragin

Simply Simon's Cheesecakes

1 review

Uptown

Dorothy's Bakery

10 reviews

Lincoln Park

Pie, Pie My Darling

Pie, Pie My Darling Photos

Pie, Pie My Darling Popular Desserts

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pie, Pie My Darling

Reviews With Photos

More info about Pie, Pie My Darling

Payment methods

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Pie, Pie My Darling

You might also consider

Molly's Cupcakes

Sweet Mandy B's

Jennivee’s Bakery

Sweet Mandy B's

Molly's Cupcakes

A Sweets Girl

Magnolia Bakery - Chicago

Bake

Chicago Sugar Daddy Patisserie

Molly’s Cupcakes

Kasama

Sweet Bean

Hero Coffee and Bagel Bar

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

Pie, Pie My Darling - desserts - Updated July 2026

Best of Chicago

People found Pie, Pie My Darling by searching for…

Trending Searches in Chicago, IL

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Chicago, IL

Browse Articles

People who viewed Pie, Pie My Darling also viewed

Pie, Pie My Darling

Pie, Pie My Darling Photos

Pie, Pie My Darling Popular Desserts

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pie, Pie My Darling

Reviews With Photos

More info about Pie, Pie My Darling

Payment methods

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Pie, Pie My Darling

You might also consider

More businesses like Pie, Pie My Darling

Molly's Cupcakes

Sweet Mandy B's

Jennivee’s Bakery

Sweet Mandy B's

Molly's Cupcakes

A Sweets Girl

Magnolia Bakery - Chicago

Bake

Chicago Sugar Daddy Patisserie

Molly’s Cupcakes

Trending businesses in Pie, Pie My Darling's area

Kasama

Sweet Bean

Hero Coffee and Bagel Bar

2 Pie, Pie My Darling reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

Pie, Pie My Darling - desserts - Updated July 2026

Best of Chicago

People found Pie, Pie My Darling by searching for…

Trending Searches in Chicago, IL

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Chicago, IL

Browse Articles

People who viewed Pie, Pie My Darling also viewed