I'm sure this is a local favorite but for someone new to the area, this was an absolute hidden gem! I think the Belle's Library feel of the place makes it very magical and would make a great date night or event venue. It is very small and does get kind of cramped but what Italian restaurant isn't? I had the tomatoes and burrata, and paired that with their garlic bread. So fresh and creamy. The ingredients are great quality. I got the mushroom pasta that had the most tender mushrooms and perfectly cooked pasta. I recommend getting it with the truffle oil, otherwise you'll need a little salt added. I would definitely come here again to try another one of their pasta dishes! read more

See all

Came here for dinner date. Highly recommend this spot. Its cozy and has a solid selection of italian dishes. Prior to covid this place was always packed and for good reason. The menu is full of great italian dishes, to name a few: the garlic bread, artichoke, spaghetti w/ meatballs and bolognese. The staff was friendly and attentive. They have put a nice outdoor dining area during covid which is a nice addition! read more

Cute little Italian restaurant tucked away on 123rd Street. Great ambiance. Lovely house G&T. I came with a friend who comes here often. We shared the seasonal fig salad and artichoke. I throughly enjoyed my bolognese over paparadelle. We finished off with berries and cream. Not too stuffed. read more

See all

Called ahead for a table outdoors, and it was no problem on a weeknight. Setup is great and very distanced. Loved the ingenious way they built the tables' platforms into the hill! My boyfriend and I shared: + stracciatella caprese - my favorite thing we ate, total fire + Orecchiette broccoli rabe with spicy Italian sausage + Spaghetti with prosciutto and spinach - both pastas were perfectly cooked + homemade coconut cake - also incredible, definitely get this + Tartufo, affogato style - my boyfriend is a tartufo expert and he loved this Our waiter (think his name was Jake) was amazing. I want to try the spaghetti and meatballs next time, and the brunch. 4.5 stars. read more

See all

The good reviews are spot on. We had a wonderful lunch at Pisticci. It's lovely inside and out. It was a beautiful day for the patio so we choose to sit street side under an umbrella. Service was perfect from start to finish. Our lunch was sensational! I had the Insalata Pisticci (minus the potatoes) and added grilled salmon instead. The spinach was fresh, the dressing divine and the salmon was flaky yet firm. My husband had the Seafood Pasta special. It was loaded with shrimp, mussels, clams and a white fish over linguine. There was more fish than pasta which thrilled my husband. If you're wondering if he enjoyed the sauce, I can tell you he alone ate the entire basket of the crusty Italian bread, dragging every piece through his leftover sauce and finally spooning the rest on his last piece of bread. We will definitely eat here again! read more

See all

Small, cool spot in a somewhat sketchy area. Service was spot on. Ambiance is comfortable. Food was insanely great. Soup was maybe the best I've ever eaten. Lamb ragu with pasta was amazing. Go there. read more

Great service, food is delicious, attentive and kind waitstaff, and plenty of beautiful aesthetics to view. This restaurant is bigger than what it seems on the outside, it has three different bars, and three rooms to dine in. Each room has a different decor and they use a local artist for most of their art. Nice and friendly spot in neighborhood that attracts a variety of guests. The atmosphere is chill and welcoming. The service is super fast and I highly recommend. More than likely this place will be a staple for me. One of the key benefit of this place is how affordable it is. Every budget can dine here. The food is fresh and made in house. They give generous portion of pasta, and the coconut cake was not too sweet, but was plated with a weird sauce. I can not recommend this place enough. read more

See all

My dinner was solid. I was there for a dinner event for about 30-40 people. I had salmon and a side salad. It was surprisingly good. The reason I said "surprisingly" is because it was a large party and all the food came all around the same time. The salmon was perfectly cooked, tender and juicy. The spinach was likewise perfectly cooked and seasoned. The salad was very fresh and perfectly dressed. I was really impressed, especially for a dinner party of that size. I had the passion fruit sorbet for dessert, which was just ok. Not very flavorful. Overall, really good meal. read more

the pasta with vodka sauce here is so good! also i was surprised by how good the meatballs were. after eating i felt great not heavy like you can feel sometimes when you eat a pasta dish. honestly one of the best pasta i have had. i only ordered take out, everything was packaged well and they even added extra parmesan cheese on the side. the person who took my order was very professional. i was greeted warmly when i came in to pick up my food. i can't wait to try more dishes! gonna get the spaghetti next chance i get read more

I came to Pisticci for dinner with a group of friends. Upon arriving, the restaurant was packed. Fortunately, my group was already seated. Despite the restaurant being full, the service was fairly decent. The server seemed very knowledgeable about the menu and gave good recommendations. Upon taking our orders, we waited a very reasonable amount of time - given the restaurant volume - for our food to arrive (less than 15 minutes). I had the Maltagliati with Ricotta, Spinach, and Lamb. Overall, it was pretty good. The lamb paired well with the ricotta and spinach, whereas the addition of pasta made the dish hearty. All the flavors of the dish were then tied together with the sauce. My only minor complaint is that the entire dish tasted a bit bland. But other than that, the food was great. read more

Pisticci - Maltagliati with Ricotta, Spinach, and Lamb - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Very good food and good ambiance. Authentic Sicilian/Italian food. It is in a convenient location where you can find parking and close by the park. read more

Nice brunch here. Definitely recommend the berry refresher, such a good drink. The bec was also good. Good service, no complaints o read more

Pisticci - Bacon Egg and Cheese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

11/10 date night experience at Pisticci tonight. Service was beyond wonderful and the food was incredible. -We started with the roasted garlic bread and requested a side of marinara sauce. The bread is soft and still crunchy on the edges it's so so good -got the house red wine and then ordered the rigatoni vodka with chicken and the Tuscan bean ravioli both of which were so flavorful and fresh - halfway through the meal I knocked my glass of wine directly into my plate of pasta and was immediately brought napkins and the table was cleaned for us and I was brought a new glass of wine. I was even offered a new entree which was so kind. -we finished with the coconut cake which is sort of like a cheesecake/coconut tres leches??? Phenomenal. Such an amazing meal here, can't wait to come back. Perfect spot to celebrate a birthday or graduation and romantic enough for a nice date. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch, not familiar with this quaint restaurant, and was pleasantly surprised!! My daughter had the beet salad with chicken... Amazing!.... I had the special salad, arugula, goat cheese stuffed figs, hearts of palm, mango, strawberry with chicken.... Amazing!.... And my husband had the pasta with mushrooms.... Again, Amazing! Will definitely be back, just hope they keep that fig salad!!! And Maddie our waitress was super sweet and so good at taking good care of us!! read more

Pisticci - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Went here for a nice meal with friends after taking grad photos - close enough to walk from Columbia! Nice atmosphere, has a homey Italian vibe. The outdoor set up is beautiful with the stringed lights! Insalata Pisticci - 4/5 - Yummy! I liked the balsamic on this, it was thick and a little sweet. Get this if you've ever wondered what having potatoes in your salad tasted like. Burrata Caprese - 5/5 - This is how burrata is supposed to taste like! Melted in my mouth and the pesto sauce was pretty good too. Black Angus Skirt Steak - 3/5 - This was okay, a little lacking in flavor. Texture was alright. Seafood Pasta of the Day - ?/5 - I couldn't eat this as I'm allergic to seafood, but it was the one my friends liked the least. They said they were expecting it to be more of a light pasta (they explained that it had a white wine sauce.) Fettuccini ai Funghi - 5/5 - Really good! Super light- was expecting it to be more creamy and flavorful because you can smell the truffle oil (if you add it) immediately when it comes to your table, but I liked it regardless. Cheese Ravioli (this was a special) - 5/5 - Perfectly cooked ravioli and a yummy ricotta? cheese inside. It wasn't too heavy either! Homemade Tiramisu - 6/5 - This was so good! I don't normally like tiramisu but this one was creamy and had such a balanced profile. Would get again! Fresh Coconut Cake - 4.5/5 - This is apparently grandma's recipe so we got it. Light and lightly sweet- I liked it! Probably wouldn't get again though. Overall, it was a nice meal! Pretty good quality but I think I thought it was going to be just a litttttle bit better. If I lived in the area or still went to Columbia, I think I'd frequent this place. But because of the abundance of Italian spots downtown, I don't think I'd come back anytime soon. read more

See all

We are always looking for authentic neighborhood restaurants so we trekked all the way up to the upper West end of Harlem, Fort Lee, from Brooklyn just to try this hidden gem. Get ready for some delightful pasta, generous wine pours and an inclusive atmosphere. Greatly enjoyed it! read more

See all

Nowadays it's hard to find a brunch place with good prices, good food, and outdoor seating that's both well-ventilated and warm. Pisticci fits the bill! Their winter outdoor seating is curb-side and some of the best I have seen, with heaters, dividers, and just enough siding to keep you warm but let the air flow. As a plus, it's also aesthetically pleasing! The food was delicious- my friend's lemon ricotta pancakes were perfect for a sweet-tooth, and the poached egg dish I ordered was savory and filling. They also offer a variety of cocktails, including warm ones which are exactly what you want on a cold, rainy day. Another upside- from 3-4 they close to switch from brunch to dinner, but they allowed the outdoor guests to stay. No need to abruptly end your conversation! This is a great spot to catch up with friends over brunch, and I will definitely be adding it to my rotation. read more

Pisticci - Uova Contadine and lemon ricotta pancakes - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Hands down the most amazing Italian restaurant, and we are lucky enough to have it right on our block! Our favorite appetizer is their roasted garlic bread, which is very crispy yet tender, with generous amount of garlic butter and goat cheese. We're also in love with the seafood special pasta, which has generous amount of seafood and fish, and comes with variations of tomato/wine sauce. The staff is always extremely warm and kind, and very attentive to our needs. Lastly, they're pet friendly and our Westie is always warmly welcomed by the staff. read more

See all

A very cozy NYC Italian restaurant. Need I say more? We started with a fresh burrata surrounded by split cherry tomatoes dancing in a wondrous olive oil. I was a little fearful that the pumpkin and corn soup special might be too sweet and creamy, but it was delightful, and I believe didn't have any cream at all. The ground corn provides nice texture to this delicious gazpacho-like (but piping hot) concoction. The fresh cavatelli with broccoli and portobello bathed in a delightful white wine and shallot reduction, was a really wonderful plate. The broccoli was perfectly cooked with the slightest, satisfying crunch, not over-cooked even by a second. The portobello slices were yum-umi, and the sauce provided a light touch that brought it all together. A glass of super Tuscan wine - actually two -paired nicely. Superb, friendly and prompt service. read more

This Italian restaurant is located near Columbia. It is very cute and the staffs are super nice. They have some innovative and unusual dishes and they are all yummy! I also like to try their daily specials. read more

There are a ton of good restaurants in NYC and Pisticci's is way up on the list. We came here for my daughter's graduation from Columbia (I know my review is late), and arrived early for our reservation. We were seated right away and the service was top notch. I had the meatballs with polenta and the dish was scrumptious! The polenta had a nice thin crispy crust and soft and pillowy inside - so yummy! Everybody finished their dish and we all are very picky with food. Great place! Great service! Great food! read more

I have been going to Pisticci for the past 26 years. They always have had good food and the people working there have been always very friendly and kind. Lately, they have hired a young woman who is always upset and mad. She obviously doesn't like to work there as a server and is unhappy. I understand work is not easy but she should move to something else and stop making miserable the patrons. Every time she is our server I regret eating there. read more

Anytime I'm in Morningside Heights and craving Italian, my go to is Pisticci. What makes this restaurant stand out is their use of their ingredients specifically the vegetables which they grow themselves. Most of their items are also vegetarian/vegan friendly and can be modified to be. I'm not vegetarian but I really like their plant-based meatballs. Their dishes are simplistic but delicious and it works so well. My favorite dishes are the Tuscan Bean Ravioli and Rigatoni Alla Vodka. I usually go for these two if I'm not feeling the Special Pasta of the day such as their Seafood Pasta. If you're feeling like having a cocktail, I highly recommend the "The" Grapefruit Martini which is huge and pretty strong. Overall, if you're ever in the area, this cozy Italian spot is the way to go! read more

See all

I've been eyeballing this place for a while, as I've ate or drank at about every place on that block over the year. Best things come to those who wait. I was able to do a walk-in of one and be seated at the bar. Place was packed but service kept up easily. Definitely a fully staffed restaurant which I know is hard to do nowadays, but it is easily noticeable. Service was great and their take on standard Italian fares was perfect. Very happy will be coming back more often. read more

Pisticci - Burrata Caprese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This has become our go to restaurant in this area. The Salmon was perfectly cooked. The Meatballs and Polenta is so tasty and the salads are so fresh. Inside or outside is very attractive and comfortable. The service is very chill but attentive. read more

Great place for a meal or brunch. Moderate prices. Very welcoming staff - excellent service. Had dinner and brunch there. No disappointments whatsoever. Calm ambiance. It's now a go to place to bring guests. read more

The restaurant itself is so cute and cozy. A great place to bring friends for a get together--one of those places you don't really have to think about because there will probably be something everyone likes! And the food is so, so comforting. It's become one of my favorite places to grab takeout just for myself! read more

Can't believe I have yet to review one of my favorite go-to spots! Im pretty sure it was to keep this hidden gem a secret. Haha, so onto a long one! Prior to COVID and when I lived a block away, I was always happy to stroll by on a Tuesday evening or Sunday morning for brunch. The ambiance was always warm, romantic and sometimes filled with live music. A favorite date spot, my boyfriend and I have even celebrated anniversaries here because the food is just too good. Some menu favorites: Mussels, Spaghetti al Pomodoro WITH meatballs, Fettucini al Funghi, Lamb Ragu (!) and finally the Lemon Ricotta Pancakes. These pancakes are probably the best I've ever had. So much so that I had to teach myself how to make them to get me during quarantine. Their dinner specials are always amazing! Sticking to fresh ingredients from local farms I don't think I've ever had one that's missed. I remember once they had the most delectable fresh-made rosemary pasta with duck bacon and mushrooms in a rich white sauce... I'm salivating just writing about it! During a COVID life, Pisticci is perhaps my favorite outdoor dining experience. Not only do they have tables in the little "alleyway," but also have gone far enough to build private-esque decks up along the hill. Thankfully it's a quiet street so even the tables closest to the street feel private... best of all, no street dining! In addition the staff are all in masks and you can pay on a tablet at your table. The food is still amazing, even if outside. We just had to order the mussels and the lamb ragu, as well as a stuffed shell type of dish. It was stuffed with fresh spinach and ricotta blanketed with a most delicious tomato sauce and served with the freshest and crispiest summer squash. Do you know what a treat it is to bite into a crispy and not overcooked yellow squash?! Huge kudos to Pisticci, wishing them the best and hope to continue visiting for many years to come! read more

See all

My friend and I had an excellent meal at Pisticci! We ordered their famous artichoke to start and their lemon butter sauce was ahhhmazing. The cavatelli with broccoli and mushrooms was also delicious, and the salmon was cooked exactly as we requested. Our server Julietta helped us make an excellent wine selection and was very attentive and helpful during our meal with anything we needed. A perfect atmosphere for a great italian meal! Thanks Pisticci! read more

Wonderful place with the best coffee cake. Great place for brunch, but pasta could be a bit on the saltier end.

This review is based on an experience at a party held at Pisticci. The restaurant itself is really cute, and all of the staff were so welcoming and attentive. Everything we ate was delicious, although the pastas seemed to be the star entrees. I wish the restaurant was not so far from me, because I would like to go back and order off of the menu, which had some interesting entrees. read more

Nice Italian neighborhood restaurant. I especially like the mushroom pasta. Service is friendly, on nice evenings the outdoors tables are pleasant. read more

Cute spot, amazing vibe and helpful servers. Food was spot on and they have amazing dessert options! read more

Pisticci - Burrata Caprese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

GREAT FOOD, hilariously bad service. (But it gives you something to talk about and once you get your food all is forgiven). Half of the times I've been there we have had issues with service. 1. The hostesses(?) outside the restaurant typically ignore you for 5 minutes or so while they talk to each other. 2. When you do finally get seated, your orders get messed up a LOT. As someone with severe allergies, this is not comforting, but luckily I can eat almost everything on the menu. 3. Sometimes, a nice person will take your order and then mysteriously disappear... after about a half hour you'll realize your appetizers haven't come out yet, try to flag down another waiter which is difficult, and finally be told that your waitress's shift ended and she never put in the ticket... this has happened to me on TWO DIFFERENT OCCASIONS!!! 4. Your bill will be wrong. One of the times #3 happened and the manager(?) said he would comp us our soup and our glass of wine... funny thing is that we never ordered or received wine at all! We spent the rest of the evening among ourselves trying to figure out whether it was fair that they were prepared to comp us a glass of wine, but when we said we never ordered wine, they didn't comp us anything else in its place. All in all, I'll still be coming back because it is really great food and the service is so bad it makes good conversation. read more

The food was wonderful, and our server Jesse was so helpful and friendly! We loved the pasta dishes we ordered and the Tartuffo dessert was delicious read more

I love me some Italian but THIS! is a gem! You must go here. The food is beyond amazing. And the drinks are just right. I've been back twice in one week I liked it so much. And the MOUSSE! most people don't know how to make mousse so you're in for a treat with this one. read more

See all

The ambience of the restaurant was great, service was also friendly. The food was underwhelming. My bolognese sauce was on the tarter side. Some of the tomatoes undercooked and pasta mostly over cooked. Had potential but didn't meet expectations. read more

Pisticci - Pappardelle alla Bolognese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Pisticci in Harlem packed a nice punch when it came to the most outstanding service, cozy style and food for our Friday night dinner. It's casual with a funky and laid back vibe. You can check all the boxes on this one: Romantic? Check. Bug out night? Check Check. Rendezvous of any kind? CheckCheckCheck! From Pisticci's different angles and seating areas, looks like they broke walls to expand their layout. It works. It just adds that intimate feel. Here's the deal: NO reservations the day of/ call the day before. However, if you come in w/out one, you might be in luck with the few available tables- just hang out with your sip at either one of their bars until your table's ready....which we did. That second bar was cute and manned by poker-face Ms. Bartendress who cracked the whip real good on my 'Ginger Snap' cocktail. Stuff was so powerful, I couldn't drink it all. Important to note: I like how you can transfer your bar tab to your table. Menu isn't overwhelming- but has enough variety for Vegans, Vegetarians, Pescatarians and meat-eaters. Pisticci is much more than checkered tablecloths. Just don't order Fettuccine Alfredo or Chicken Parm- this isn't the joint for that. Actually the owner has kept an environmentally-friendly restaurant using his own compost. Greens in our Kale and Walnut Salad starter were so fresh they were popping out of the plate. The accompanying balsamic vinaigrette was the richest I've ever tasted and when I asked for some to take home, our boy Rick said yes! Thank you man! Bread upon request was airy and good. As was hubs' lamb ragout with spinach and 'flat' lasagna-looking pasta. ø_ø. Maybe a Rigatoni? Curly pasta? Sautéed Mushroom mix and kale in my 'Vegetarian's Delight' was very tasty. All my 2 polenta chunks missed were brown, crispy edges to seal the deal. Tasted good though. Our Vegan Chocolate cake though- was moist but tasted a bit oily. The crowd? Columbia professors, millennials mostly and us as the only Latin folks dining here. Overall feel? Leisure eating and no rushed service at all. What a fabulous and lively buzz as soon as you go down the steps and head inside. read more

See all

Came here with a date and definitely wasn't disappointed. It is right near a bus that was near my home so I got there a little early. The date itself went well and I had good food. The ambiance was very nice and staff was definitely friendly + attentive. There was still social distancing with space so that was also nice at the time. No complaints from me. read more

Food is great, but I really wish it came faster. I highly recommend the spaghetti with meatballs. The vibes are overall very good, and there's usually chill music in the background read more