We ordered this for dinner for the first time after receiving the coupons in the mail. We used the 2, 2-topping medium pizza coupon and got a side of their 151 breadsticks. We were a bit concerned after seeing reviews saying it was just Marks under a different name, but we all thought it tasted and looked very different than marks, which was good! That being said, they really gotta work on improving their pizza-making. The crust was good, a bit doughy as some mentioned but we tend to like that. However, we got a white and red pizza. The red pizza was light on sauce and the white pizza was even worse, some slices seemed like there was no sauce at all. The breadsticks were probably the best part as they were essentially just a pizza with garlic and red sauce. They really need to use the amount of sauce on their breadsticks on everything else. The chicken on the white pizza was pretty bland as well, making for a doughy, dry, tasteless. The meal wasn't terrible, the pieces are there to be good, but execution for a pizza place is lacking considering there is some good competition around. Add some more seasoning and be a bit more heavy-handed with sauce and toppings and it would be a great experience! read more

We have ordered from Pizza 151 more than a handful of times now. It is awesome!!!! Their service and quality have always been consistent for us. Their deals are pretty good too. We always get the sweet sauce pizza and wings. To me, the sweet sauce is great and the best I've ever had. The food always arrives piping hot and have never had any issues. Will continue to order from them and have great dinners! read more

I placed my order online and when I showed up, they said they didn't have it. I then showed them on my phone that I indeed placed the order. I asked for a discount for having to wait and he said no. No one seemed to be in charge either. I ordered it at that time for a specific reason and needed it at that time. He said it wasn't their fault. I said if it wasn't my fault and it wasn't your fault, who's fault is it? He really didn't care. Then while I'm waiting, they're in the back dropping f bombs. Super unprofessional. I get home and the pizza is as thin as paper. I will never go back. Wrote an email to them and no reply. They don't care, don't go there. read more

Wow what an amazing pizza i had there. The crust was excellent and i took a risk and ordered a little xtra sauce on and it was tremendous!! The is a small place maybe a table or 2. There is a big sign outside and its tucked in the corner of the plaza. Will i be back???? YES!!!! read more

Pizza is absolutely incredible.. they now offer both a sweet and regular sauce which I'm told is awesome (not a sweet sauce guy ). They also have a $5 combo for a slice and drink and it includes tax so all u need is a $5 bill and they do it all day... prices are good and coupons are even better. Matt is the Gm and will do absolutely anything to make you happy even going as far as making a whole buff chicken pizza when I only wanted 2 slices ... food is awesome with even better customer service, couldn't ask for anything else from a pizza place read more

Have been going to a pizzeria a little closer to me until I discovered 151 had cup and char pepperoni- pizza is awesome!! Won't go any place else now! read more

The pizza can be really really good, or not so much. so, Inconsistent. The delivery service is garbage. If you order before 5 pm, it's good. I ordered my pizza this evening at 5:57 , it's 7:45 and it's still not here, I am 10 minutes down the road from them. So, I am dissatisfied and disappointed. If it does finally arrive I'm guessing it won't be so good...... read more

I am so disappointed. As a Grubhub driver, I've delivered pizzas from here several times and they always look amazing. I saw on their menu that for their calzones, pizza 151 supposedly offers a wide variety of toppings including "crispy chicken fingers" and pickles. I finally just took an evening to order my dream calzone, and the best part of it was the crust. Pizza 151 wouldn't put pickles as a topping, so i switched to spinach which was uncooked. The chicken was just chunked cooked chicken, not "crispy fingers". And they also didn't put the ricotta in, which is always a default topping for calzones. Sad, and expensive experience. But at least now i know I won't be ordering for myself again. read more

As a manager of a convenience store at the main intersection into Batavia from the NY Thruway I am constantly asked by travelers "what's good to eat here?" I am not from around here, so I've always been at a loss for an answer. I live about 30 miles away and commute. So I have recently started to sample Batavia restaurants and deli's. I love a good pizza and I'm really picky lol!! I have had pizza at about 4 different locations, and I've heard from my staff of locals their opinions, because the only thing worse than sub par food is paying for it. Well last night I was sitting in the parking lot of the tops grocery store wondering what to get for dinner and looked over to see Pizza 151 in the strip mall. I went inside and asked if I could taste the traditional and the sweet sauces, I ordered a personal size which was 10" with a combo of both sauces, flat pepperoni (bc they've got 2 kinds!) and olives and extra cheese, it was done in 15 mins and it was hot!!! I took a bite and it was amazing!!! Absolutely BOMB the crust was so delicious (I love crust!!) and the sauce was exactly what I wanted, ample toppings and an amazing symphony of everything together, it was soooooooo goooood!!! 5 Stars ++ And I don't usually do reviews unless it's what I think the public should absolutely know. I will always send my customers to Pizza 151. Their menu was very large with plenty of variety for appetizers, salads, subs hot and cold, calzones, pizzas, pasta dishes and even desserts, restaurant seating and draft beer choices on tap self-serve, wide screen tv and darts Restrooms were CLEAN and modern. Thank you to the young man with red hair and beard I apologize I am terrible with names he knew everything about the ingredients and chuckled when I asked to sample sauce, but he made me the best pizza I have EVER eaten. I dont have a pic to submit bc I started eating it the moment I got back into my car, but next time I'll make sure to snap one first. I was full after 2 slices, and I've got lunch today with the rest. Absolutely the best $13 I ever spent!! read more

Great pizza and breaded wings they have only disappointed me one time not sure what happened it was just a not that great of a pie that night there sweet sauce is very good and the wing have always been done just right but they have out done themselves this time the pizza looks awesome!!! Thank you Pizza 151 great job!! read more

Pizza 151 - Deep dish sweet sauce and breaded wings - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

Ordered nine subs to take with us to a fundraising event, and it really wasn't that cheap. When we got to the place and started eating the subs, my pregnant daughter-in-law, Who ordered a turkey BLT sub, got her sub with no turkey on it. When we contacted the business two days later, they told us that they could do for us was put a sub on our account as a credit or give us a medium pizza with one topping coupon. I thought that was pretty crappy since my daughter-in-law did not have her dinner that night and after all the phone calling and running around we had to do the only thing they would compensate us for is that lousy pizza. Don't waste your time, there's way too many other good pizzerias in Batavia. read more

This is our favorite new pizza and wings take out after work. Ordering online is easy and they are always done with an accurate order. The pizza and wings are some of the best around. The service is great. The place is always so busy finding a parking spot for quick take out can be tricky in spite of he nice large parking lot, but it worth it for the food, read more

Customer service is spectacular, truly makes a differences to have such nice people working there!

Mark's was our go-to pizza place, and I was bummed when it closed. Pizza 151, however, is better. Friendly owners, tastier sauce, great crust, a variety of types of pizzas. We've ordered several times and have always been very happy. We have a new go-to! read more

First time we ordered pizza and wings were really good. The pizza and the wings were fresh and cooked perfectly. This time pizza was dry, hardly any cheese and over baked. The wings seemed like leftovers reheated. Dry with very little meat. Will think twice before ordering next time. read more

The first time we ordered from here, we had a chicken bacon ranch pizza and a red veggie one. Both had a good amount of toppings, the crust was flavorful but while the chicken bacon ranch had a good amount of sauce, everyone who tried the veggie one commented on how there was hardly any sauce on it. A few weeks later, we ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza again, and while the toppings were the same, everyone who tried it commented on the lack of sauce, with one person postulating that there wasn't even any sauce on it. Seems like they are very inconsistent, can't really recommend them. read more

I ordered a pizza over the phone, got a price, waited 25 minutes and drove to the store. I wanted to get in and get out. They did not make my pizza. I was so upset. I left, came home, called the store and the manager called me a "child" for leaving before they could make another pizza for me! Last time I checked we were under quarantine and standing in a small space with people coming in and out was unacceptable. When did it become ok to treat a customer like that? read more

Got the extra large pizza with 2 sides it was very good and just the right size. Wings very good

Good pizza and boneless wings. Buffalo Hot is hot. Always have had good service. Ordered online for pickup ready as projected.

Ordered pizza and wings as a family splurge ($85) based on the recommendations of others. It was literally the worst we have EVER had! The pizza was incredibly dry and overcooked, the cheese actually looked petrified and the wings were also waaaaay overcooked and skimpy. Brick-like crust was dry, tasteless... i.e. Prepare for dental work. It looked like it had spent a week in the Sahara sun. There were a few dead carrots enclosed with the wings for good measure-I can only guess they are trying to be too cool to put celery in . Maybe they were trying to make a statement, but it wasn't a good one! Maybe if they wanted to make a good statement- enclose some quality bleu cheese dressing to hide the beloved carrots. It speaks volumes that not even our dog would eat it. Grandma's complaint letter with the attached receipt went completely unanswered. I mean who would want to own up to this hot mess of an expensive meal?! When I discussed it later with the manager, Matthew Scott via PM, I was basically told I was lying and looking for a freebie. Doesn't everyone want a second round of stale nasty pizza for free?? Crazy dude! Hey, I've been a manager... was just trying to give you a chance to redeem your sucky food! And everyone makes mistakes...even epic ones. One measely well-made thoughtful pepperoni would have done it. Just prove you can actually cook and are worth another chance! Poor food, worse customer service. Wait, is that even possible?Lots of other places to choose from in the area- not wasting my money on this trash 1 star earned because, well, even North Chili roadkill served in a Pizza 151 box is edible to someone, I suppose.... read more

I was hoping since separating from Marks pizza that they would improve the sub size , with tax over $11 for a turkey club , good sandwich but in my opinion $ 2 high priced and smaller than the competition. The sub does come with chips that nobody orders ? I might note on tonight's sub it is suppose to have mayo but my sub was dry , not a big deal but when I already feel like I am paying more than average it would be nice to have your order correct. read more

Ordered twice from them now and the food has been delicious! Fast delivery and their on line ordering is super easy; let's you select exactly how you want your pizza cooked. Will be my new go to for pizza. Their fried dough with cinnamon is awesome! read more