This place is a must stop! This pizza place is a hidden gem. The service is amazing it was super…read morequick pizza and soo tasty! Everyone loved this stop!

Absolutely fantastic! Service was great and the food was amazing. The pizza and garlic bread were…read moregreat. They also have probably 50 types of "dirty" sodas and energy drinks. I love Superman ice cream which is hard to find and they had it! Ice cream portions were huge and chea

Those who know, know. And now I know where the best Pizza in Arizona is served. Gotta give props to…read morea friend of the family who told us that Old Country Inn, located in Pine, AZ, made the best pizza she had ever tasted. Couldn't agree more. My wife and I spent a week in the Payson area and we wanted to enjoy some really good food, so the Old Country Inn was on our radar. Pine is a unique town with a lot of natural beauty, so we sat on the patio. The highway was busy, but that didn't matter because it was a gorgeous day. Our server Joyce was great. She made recommendations and helped us select the Burrata Pie based on her description. It did not disappoint. I wish I had taken a photo of the whole pizza before we ate the entire thing. Several things stood out. The crust is soooooo good. The char from the wood-fired oven was perfect. The pepperoni was also the best I've ever tried. Now add the dollops of Burrata Cheese, hot honey, fresh basil, and cracked pepper. Best. Pizza. Ever! I've enjoyed the numerous varieties of pizza that are available. And I've eaten at that famous one in Phoenix. Sorry, but I would choose the pie that requires a four-hour round trip over the local fav. Make the drive and you won't be disappointed! This review was generated entirely by my brain and not AI.

Here's the thing, they really don't answer the phone. And they are busy. So just set your…read moreexpectations and deal with it if you want really, really good pizza. Even their gluten free crust pizza was good. They do that thing where the pepperonis curl up and are crunchy. Yummy!! Yes we had to go down there on a Saturday night to order to go and yes they told us an hour wait. So we sat at the bar, ordered drinks and watched the kitchen staff kill it calmly and professionally. Lots of outdoor seating, games to occupy the kids and yesterday they were celebrating St Patrick's Day with style. Fun vibe. By the way, we got our pizza in less than an hour!

Online order 30 minutes before I went there and got told to wait 40 minutes they are barely putting…read moreit in. Why allow online orders if that's the case. Ordered 1 calzone. asked For a refund have yet to receive.

Pizza was great! Employees were so friendly and took great care of us!! Definitely give it a try!read more

Pretty solid pizzeria, they run a lunch buffet here, simple salad bar, pizzas with a rotation, bbq…read morechicken, supreme etc., ; So on a scale of 1-10 the pizzas based on Dave Portnoys grading scale would probably sit somewhere in the 6.7 area, but if you rate it against Pilot, Flying J, Godfathers Pizza or Mavericks Truck Stop Pizzas, this place would be a solid 8.5/10. Good underside, good layer of cheese, good marinara, a pretty solid pizza on Route 66 Arizona i40. glad I popped in here for a quick lunch. Young Italian lady in there probably Tony's daughter...was very courteous, explained how things worked, and even asked what type of pizza I'd like to see at the bar. Excellent service. As for the other young lady, curly black short haired. mid 20s-30s, Navajo or Hopi even....she was probably experiencing a bad day, and was lashing out at me for checking the hot bar before making a decision whether or not I was going to order from the menu or do the Buffett. Having been in the restaurant industry, all is forgiven. Snapped a ton of photos, great place to explore this Captain Tony's of Winslows Arizona! So park your rig next door and give this place a go.

The food was great here, got a pizza and huge calzone!! Had an awesome salad bar, super fresh…read more They also have a good wine and beer selection!

On our long drive home, we stopped to eat. We ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza and honey BBQ wings,…read moreand everything was delicious! The pizza was tasty, and the wings were flavorful with just the right amount of sauce. Great food and definitely worth a return visit if we ever drive this way again.

Surprisingly good tasting pizza . Pleasantly surprised and glad we stopped. Thought it was weird a…read morepizza place was showing 5 stars, but now I taste why;)

Service is really friendly pizza took a little to get out and is a little pricey but food was…read moreexcellent!!

Would I recommend. Absolutely. I get the 14 inch veggie pizza. Delicious. The customer service…read moreis great. Brett is always there. And he is super friendly. They are there for the community. Thank you for the great food.

This place is great! We came in with a group of 35 guys, and they accommodated all of us without…read moreany issues. The pizza was very good, the service was fast, and the staff was super friendly. If you need a quick pit stop for pizza, this is definitely the place to go. Highly recommend!

I've been here three times, and unfortunately the consistency has been consistently poor. The staff…read morelacks personality and often comes across as borderline rude. Combined with the location, the overall atmosphere has an uncomfortable, almost Deliverance-like vibe. The place itself is not very clean. Each time I've ordered wings, they've been sitting in a puddle of oil. The pizza is mediocre at best not terrible, but far from good. Having worked in several pizza places myself, it's clear they're using old dough that's been sitting out, which results in a below-average product. Considering the high prices, there's just no value here. We won't be returning.

Blew my expectations out of the water. Went here a year ago and I still think about this…read moreexperience. We had the Hawaiian pizza and some white sauce pizza. Only regret was not getting wings because the sauces were good. We were hungry after hiking in the Grand Canyon and were headed to Page AZ. On the maps, there were very few restaurant options, so we weren't expecting much. We were wrong. Pizza Edge hit the spot. Is it the best pizza I've ever had? No. But if I ever pass through again I will stop in.

The pizza was phenomenal we ordered a box of pizza for our work party at the hotel Pizza Edge is a…read more10 min walk 2 min drive. If we ever have another group pizza party we will be going to pizza edge for sure! The pizza is a thin slice pizza crust which ma it so you can actually have a bunch of pieces and enjoy the many varieties they have. I have to say I really really enjoy their pizza. The service was amazing. And the ambiance was easy and was able to get in and get out.

Everything, and I mean everything, was good. This restaurant has a young, hip, sort of upscale…read morevibe, without being white cloth fancy. Excellent service staff. I had minestrone soup and their pitalian salad. Both were delicious! I was surprised that the beans and vegetables in the soup were cooked beautifully without being mushy in the broth. *Lovely broth without being excessively salty. I really enjoyed the soup. My partner had soup with sausage and meatballs in a cheese sauce. Out of this world! What a treat! Worth a visit is you are looking for a fun menu filled with light dishes and pizza options. If we lived here it would be a go to restaurant for sure.

Look, from all the high ratings and positive reviews came I, who unfortunately followed the…read morepopularity of this restaurant and turned up to be a bad dinner. I ordered the Spicy Meatball pizza, and while the dough was fresh, it was extremely salty and hard. The sauce and cheese were no better, being just as salty and very artificial. The "spicy meatballs" were just weird-tasting meatballs with a ton of chili flakes, not spicy meatballs. It was very cheap in quality but expensive in price. I do not recommend anyone who loves pizza to get this one. People always say the service is fast, but I had lazy service. What I mean is that you have to go up and do everything yourself except for the cooking. I almost was charged for an extra cheese pizza that I didn't order. It took about 30 minutes for this ~8 inch pizza, which wasn't that bad. But everything was just slow and there were some times where things were really busy. The restaurant itself was okay. Although it doesn't make up for the 3/10 meal, it was cushy but there were places that were pretty dirty. It's more interesting than actually good, but the booths were a little nice. Overall, I do not recommend this place. Take your business somewhere else, because I will most likely never come back to Pitalian. Sorry.