It's been several years since our last visit, but it's still a good pizza! With a walk up window, the ambiance is what you bring lol. Service was quick and easy but I strongly suggest not ordering online or thru the "order" option in Yelp, as the pizza price showed $35 instead of over the phone ordering at $25 for the same exact pizza/size. What we appreciated from this pizza was its nice overall crust, good sized/not too thick dough presence, and quality of the sauce / toppings. We got the Buc Slammer XL for $25. What we found is that the sauce was awesome, though a tad on the light side. Wish they would have put more as it's so flavorful with a little bit of kick to really come through. The sausage topping was delicious, and they did keep to their word with the extra cheese on this pizza. I do think since it had extra cheese and was so thick, it could have baked a couple more minutes to completely melt down but it was still pretty good. While the pepperoni and ham didn't shine at all, overall the pizza was elevated and had a 'real' pizza presence. So many times we've gotten pizza at different places only for it to flop or lack. This one didn't, pretty good presence. It was oily, but that's always the case with any meat pizza that have oily meats... goes with the territory and gets the napkin dab like any other meaty pizza. We are giving this a 4.6 stars, and wish we could have given it a full 5 stars but 2 of the toppings were so plain it hardly came through. So to answer the magic question, yes we'll be coming back to try another pizza variation... and maybe a couple of their other Italian menu offerings. Wondering if they use that same delicious sauce ;) read more

See all

We used to love this place, but the last few times we ordered pizza from here things have just degraded. We ordered online at 4:45pm for a 5:30pm pickup. We received a confirmation email and headed there slightly early so we could take the pizza home hot. We showed up at the pickup window and the very nice employee behind the counter had no idea we even ordered. He tried to make our pizza quickly but the pizza's were not cooked all the way. One was so undercooked everything slid off of it while riding in the back seat of the car on the way home. We picked it up carefully supporting the bottom of the box, but it was so soggy my husband's finger went through the box! I actually had to put the pizzas into the oven to cook the rest of the way after we got home. Some of the all meat pizza we ordered had undercooked / pink meat on the top of it. Unfortunately that was probably our last order. If the business owner reads this: Please cook your pizzas all the way before giving them to your customers. read more

Pizza Haven - Undercooked, toppings slid off on the way home - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

7.99 for 2 slices and a can soda..good price. Slices were large and yes you can fold the slices if you like it that way. read more

Pizza Haven - Added Pepperoni to one. - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

This pizza isn't winning any awards, but it's also not getting voted off the island. The best thing about it? It's huge--so if quantity over quality is your vibe, you're in luck. Flavor-wise, it was just kinda... there. The sauce was lounging on top like it had nowhere else to be. The pizza was just so.....soggy and I kept hoping for that old-school NY magic from years ago--but alas, nostalgia wasn't on the menu. It's no longer owned by the same guy. The pizza had so much oil and grease I became sick from eating it. If you're on a quest for great pizza, you might want to keep exploring the map. read more

Pizza Haven - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Pizza was so soggy. The outside was fine the middle half wasn't even eatable. My neighbors recommended so we tried it but I don't think I would go back. read more

We ordered our Pizzas by phone. When we arrived, there is a pick up window outside where you pick up your food. There are a few tables outside of you wish to consume your Pizza there. They have a two slice special in case you are not that hungry or want a quick lunch to take out Pizza was very good. We ordered a large and a small cheese and they were both hot and had lots of cheese on th and we're cooked perfectly. Almost forgot pictures but I have one to show.... read more

Pizza Haven - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

Got the lunch special - 2 slices of cheese and a can of soda or bottle of water. Slices are big and it's a great value for the amount of food you get. Flavor is solid for a "ny slice". Cheese has that expected tang and good cheese grease and pull. Served piping hot although not fresh made it was still good. My main complaint is that it had burnt semolina all over it which really took away from the taste and it was super floppy. You walk up to the half door to order. No searing inside although they have a couple of picnic tables outside. Staff was nice, ordering is quick and only took 5 mins to get the slices. read more

Pizza Haven - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Worst pizza ever. I'm from NY and this is not NY pizza. I attempted the NY fold and the amount of grease that came off was enough to fill a shot glass, not joking. Poor quality ingredients! Oh and the service is horrible, took 22 minutes to get my lunch special of 2 slices and a coke. Save your money and go somewhere else. read more

very good food , Alex provided excellent customer service, definitely coming back soon

I ordered one of their larger combos that comes with two extra large pizzas, 10 wings, and eight cans of ginger ale... I ordered the pizza and the pizzas OK... The pizza itself is pretty good with all the toppings cheese and sauce... However, the crust is OK... I prefer crust that are a little bit more on the chewy side... The crust is a little bit on the dry side. I ordered garlic Parmesan wings... The flavor was great! However, it definitely needs to be crispy... I received soggy wings... It was great after I put it in the air fryer. It was a great deal for two extra large pizzas and wings and soda for 40 bucks. read more

Received pizza the other day. It was very good but not hot. But the large cuts remind me of the pizza back home like back home.. It's still worth a call back again for delivery. It's that good. I'll just have my pizza plate hot in the oven to put the pizza on when it comes. Put it in for 5 minutes and serve. read more

OKAY PIZZA! 6 out of 10! I stopped ordering food chain pizzas in support of local business, that and I'd like to think they are better than chain stores. However, this place isn't that big of a disappointment if you only order the pizza. I got a large pepperoni with wings and a soda and the damn wings and sauce kinda sucked @SS. The wings were for sure frozen wings hat you put in the over type deal and not fried; they were soggy, unevenly cooked and the sauce came in a little bag and they sucked. In conclusion, I'd stick with the pizza coz everything else kinda sucked! read more

Pizza Haven - Wings and sauce! - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

The food is great and the owner and his family are very nice people. I had a problem with my car front bumper and the owner came out to help me, that was really nice from them. I really recommend this place not only they nice people but the pizza and calzones are very good read more

Excellent pizza pies! True New York style pies! Good amount of cheese and fresh vegetables! I plan on returning often!

Probably some of the worst pizza and wings I've ever had in my life. The bbq chicken pizza had so much bbq sauce you had to wipe it off and is made with frozen, breaded chicken tenders that are as hard as a rock and freezer burned. The dominator pizza was better however that's not saying much. They made the pizza and threw raw tomatoes on top. The wings have so much fat they are inedible and have a horrible odor to them and hoping we don't get sick from them!! For all the rave reviews either we ordered ALL the wrong things or people don't know good food. HIGHLY DISAPPOINTED and will not be back. Much better pizza places in the Brandon area. Edited: been sick for 3 hours!! Do not eat here!!! read more

Pizza Haven - Chicken Wings, Damanator, BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Cool hole in the wall restaurant serving authentic New York style pizza! The people in the kitchen are always kind. I go here all the time :) read more

I always refer to Pizza Haven as Brandon's hidden gem. And I literally mean hidden gem besince it's tucked away behind the Walgreens on the corner of Parsons and Highway 60. It's at the far end of the strip center adjacent to the parking lot of Walgreens, where Subway is located. This pizzeria seems to head been built to handle social distancing. right now the inside counter and few tables are closed you pick up your pizza order from the outside window. They have very clear signage for social distancing and marked off X's on the sidewalk to assist in safe waiting. And now to the important stuff the quality of their pizza is bar none! I've been calling in my pizza order @ Pizza Haven for years. My order is always ready when they quote me a time. My family loves the Gator Special, consisting of two large pizzas with one topping - we get a cheese and pepperoni, garlic knots or chicken wings and a 2 liter of soda. We ALWAYS order the knots! Those garlic knots are literally the best garlic knots we've had since we moved to the area 15 years ago!! Do not order pizza from Pizza Haven without adding garlic knots you will knot regret it... See what I did there ;) read more

See all

This is my go to place during my lunch break. Best Pizza in the area, even if you have to do the drive it is worth it! At one point I lived in Tampa and made the drive out here to Brandon just to get Pizza haven. LUMCH SPECIAL: 2 NY style pizza slices and a drink for $5.55 Their chicken parmesean is good. If you try one of their dishes please order the garlic knots. They are worth being overstuffed for. read more

Pizza Haven - Can't go wrong with pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Great pizza Ny style .crispy and yummy ! Fast and friendly service ! Must try it . Very clean and also have gluten free cauliflower crust thin pizza read more

Pizza was one of the worse I had. I explicitly wanted it well done. Instead it's barely cooked and soggy. I gave it to my dog. If you like soggy Pizza, this place is for you. read more

Pizza Haven - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

Had this (delivery) the other night, and it was FABULOUS! I'm gonna say it: Best pizza in the area. The X-Large is *huge* and the dough has that crusty exterior and soft chewy inside that only the best pizzas have. We'll definitely be back. Again and again! read more

We tried this pizza through a mobile app We were very impressed w the fresh ingredients great crust. read more

Sadly, we just found out Pizza Haven has new owners. It definitely explains the overcooked garlic knots. The pizza wasn't cut and well, the sausage was not well spread out. Such a heart breaking disappointment. We've been going to pizza haven for 7 years. Now it's time to move on and find a new pizza place read more

We had high hopes for this restaurant based on the reviews. The garlic knots were good, and the staff was very hard working. However, the pizza was undercooked and the cheese was rubbery. read more

if I could go lower I would. I used to eat here with the old owners . it's no longer as good. super greasy and burnt , just plain gross . not to mention they increased their prices since the switch. Foods Mid. wouldn't eat here . Babes is right by it and they offer better pizza. read more

This place is by far the best pizza I've had since I've moved out of New Jersey. The sauce the cheese everything about it the crust is super thin but very soft not hard or crispy and they serve the pizza nice and hot it's very fresh love love love this place read more

Pizza Haven - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Most authentic. Great service good every time! It's small, but cozy. They have a great menu of not just pizza, but Jamaican beef patties. I feel like I'm back in the Bronx when I'm here! LOL read more

I think there must be new owners or something. Last 2 times I have been disappointed. First time order was wrong. Second time I think they missed my online order and when I come to pick up it was not ready then I got what looked like their slices pizza with ingredients thrown on top and put back in oven. I will no longer order from here anymore read more

Best pizza around. Hands down. Mo is AMAZING as is his pizza !!!! Order your pizza and ask to have the Garlic Knot garlic butter spread on your crust first... To Die For End of story! read more

My family has gotten pizza from this place every Friday for 15 years! Great food, and great service. Mo is super friendly and kind. read more

Stumbled upon this hole in the wall a while back. So glad I did! I love stopping in here for a weekday lunch treat while I'm out running errands. A slice + drink is just under $5. The crust is thin and crispy, just the way I like it! One slice is a very large portion so it's like eating 2 slices. Served hot, fresh and made to order. Garlic knots are the best item on the menu! To die for!! They will take longer than your pizza but well worth the wait. They prepare them to order, nothing waiting in the fridge or freezer. You can actually watch b them roll the dough and twist into knots before baking. You won't be disappointed! Table seating for 12 and 2 at the counter. Very small place but it's clean and the staff are friendly. read more

Pizza Haven - A slice for lunch..Pepperoni and mushrooms + drink for under $5! - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

I've called 3xs to order pizza and no answer. I would have been a new customer but they do not have the courtesy to answer the phone. I'm guessing the desire and effort by the staff to answer the phone is also used in their cooking. No thanks will never call again. Very sad. read more

Pizza Haven - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

This is one of two of our favorite Pizza spots in the area. It has the closest thing to NY pizza that we have found. The cheese pizzas are delicious. Their wings are amazing and cooked just right. And their garlic knots are delicious. And this is a small business and the owners are super nice and take great care of you read more

Pizza haven? More like pizza heaven! That was one good pepperoni pizza. So good, I didn't have a problem putting down half of a large by myself. Don't judge me. Pizza Haven is a family owned pizzeria run by Mr. Cruz, a pizza enthusiast, providing New York style pizza. All pizza is made by hand using fresh ingredients prepared daily. The building is old, and the dining area is small, but the pizza is good, and the service is friendly! They deliver if you're close enough. Overall, I would go back, but I would get my pizza to go instead of dining-in. read more

See all

Love this place. Fairly fast and pretty good pizza, which is VERY to find here in Florida.

I've passed this place for years and tonight the stars aligned (I'm usually too late passing by and they are closed). I was excited to try it and here's my thoughts PRO's - toppings are definitely fresh and in abundance, the dough has a sweetness to it which is delicious, but it seemed like it could have been a tad warmer (granted it took me 15 minutes to get home so I take it in stride). The garlic knots were surprising as they are these cute little knots that are bite sized CON's - the hours are short and while the pizza was good, it wasn't "great!" I would order again, but only as my 2nd choice place in Brandon.....I do prefer the place down the road by Wal-Mart, but overall pretty good! read more

Hairy pizza and they want me to bring it back. How about customer service and you come out and replace it. Never again. Absolutely disgusting! read more

Pizza Haven - Get hairy pizza and they want me to bring it back! How about you come get it and bring me a fresh pizza! Never again - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

We passed this place a couple of times but I always had it at the back of my mind to go try it and we did so last night. I have to tell you that all the years of my life searching for a New York style pizza like the one in the Ninja Turtles movie, this place is IT! We will not be getting our pizza anywhere else. We are set on this place for good. The pizza is so fresh and the cheese is literally melting as you pick up a slice. I have nothing but great things to say about this place. It's a small and great family environment. I love it! read more

Pizza Haven - Omgahhhhhhh - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

I moved to Brandon from Long Island in 1989 and of course had to find a good pizza place; which was not easy here in Florida. Little did I know the little place nearest to me would turn out to be a "taste of home" for this New Yorker! I have since tried other places when Pizza Haven is closed but none compares. Crust is thin but not hard, toppings & cheese are always generous. Stromboli is wonderful and calzone is also great not like some with thick crusts. I need to try their hand held meat pies. I am sure they are just as good as everything else they prepare. Come in and get to know Mo. You'll be glad you did. read more

We ordered a pizza, A Cheese Calzon, and Garlic Knots. I had to finish cooking the Calzone at home because It didn't have the melted cheeses (they took it out of the oven without being ready) and the cheese had a bad taste, I had to throw it away. The pizza tasted good but was EXTRA greasy. The only good thing was the Garlic Knots. *But first and LAST time buying food in this place. read more