New York pizza with a winter coat! I was blown away finding this gem on top of a mountain in Colorado. Large full-sized slices you can fold like a newspaper, real tomato sauce (fresh?), decent cheese, a new crust(!), and most of all amazing seasonings. Pizza Pedalr has been around for a while but this is my first year trying it. Swapping out the typical NY pizza crust for sourdough is the best move they could have made. The one thing from NY I've never seen reproduced well is the crust. They didn't try and instead gave this amazing fluffy and chewy experience in its place, and I love it. Not only finished the crust but wished I had more. If they made just the crusts like breadsticks with the tomato sauce inside I'd be down. Plenty of NY-style pizza out there, but this is next level. I have not been actually excited about food in I don't know how long. This is the most unexpected of surprises to find this winter! Overall, the place is really welcoming, and the decor is nice enough for looking at while waiting for your pizza. And you might wait a bit... but this is worth it. I also feel like I just had a meal instead of a snack after one slice which does make me feel better about the price, which is kinda high, but it's a resort village so it's going to be. If you're coming up to WPR or anywhere else around here this is first thing on the way into town. It's worth the experience! read more

Pizza Pedal'r - I had to bring a slice home! I don't think I could have finished both - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Been patronizing Pizza Pedalr in Winter Park CO for years. Prior to last year, this was the BEST pizza-by-the-slice to be had anywhere. Totally deserved the "best pizza in Colorado" year-over-year rating. Orders cooked/baked to order, came out piping hot and fresh. Oof. So good. And then, last year, they changed. Now pizzas are pre-cooked and sitting whole under a heat lamp at the counter. If you want a slice with extra ingredients (say, jalapenos added to a pepperoni slice), they'll add them to an existing cooked pizza , and "reheat" the slice. Unfortunately, the "slice" is already cooked, and the toppings - in this case pepperoni - are already toasted, if not, burned. Just an awful result. Such an effing same to see this change. There are so many other pizza options in the town of WP. I would (and will) skip visiting Pizza Pedal'r from here on out. read more

Like another reviewer, this used to be our favorite place to eat in Winter Park. This was our first trip here this season. The crust used to be a 5 out of 5. Now I would struggle to give it a 1. We ordered the yardbird and the burrata bianca. The yardbird had 10x the amount of sauce it should have. It was basically inedible. If I wanted to drink BBQ sauce, I would have gone to the store and bought a bottle. Barely any chicken and bacon. As for the burrata bianca, the flavor was OK, but again very little Brussels sprouts and bacon. Literally struggled to find any. Bottom line is new management has cut costs by using inferior ingredients and poorly trained staff and at the same time increased prices. They know they will continue to do a great deal of business purely on the location. Response to owner's comment: It's not about my preferred "flavor". I went to the #1 culinary school in the United States, the CIA in New York. I have extensive knowledge in Italian cuisine, especially authentic pizza. Also, flavor has nothing to do with an over-sauced sloppy pie with barely any other toppings. read more

Great pizza! And for mountain food, 10/10! They even apparently have sourdough dough, which was delicious, only thing I wish they would have put more toppings on the pizza. Sauce tasted great and service was good and size of pizza was awesome! read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

After a great day on the mountain pizza sounded perfect...we popped in and had a great pie!!!! We also picked the perfect time at about 3 o'clock... Because it wasn't terribly busy so we got our pizza pretty quick... Service was incredible. The place smells awesome and it was overall a fantastic day. A great selection of cocktails to go with your pizza is available. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Super cute place. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

We have been here twice now and planning on going back next month for our next trip to Winter Park. The first time we got a whole pizza and shared it. This time they had a special that you get a giant slice of any pizza with a Montucky can of beer for $12. That slice was so big, I had to take half of it home. Can't wait to go back next month. read more

Stupid good pizza. It's absurd you can get pizza like this at a ski resort. I've been all over the world; easily one of the best things I've ever had a ski resort town. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

This has been our go to food place for years at WP. Yesterday was our first trip in this season - even told some out of town folks on the lift on our way that they had the best pizza in Colorado- but when we walked in it was clear everything had changed. All the cool decor was gone and a kiosk has replaced the local kids serving pizza. Slices are $9 now!!! And sitting in a hot box instead of cooked up fresh. So we ordered a full pizza and were told it would be 20 minutes. There was only one other table in the place and they were already eating?? Ok whatever but then it came out and it was greasy greasy w burnt pepperoni. And so clearly not the delicious pizza we love :( Quick internet search shows new management from Florida. Booo! I would give negative stars if I could. We held a moment of silence for the death of our fav place when we got home. Looks like we are now Pepperoni's customers at MJ base. So sad to see an institution like the Pedal'r get ruined! Bring back the delicious CO pizza we love! read more

Fabulous pizza in the top 5% of pizza. Crispy and soft crust. Pepperoni was perfection! read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

Stopped in for pizza and beer on a Friday afternoon, and it was hopping! We were staying in the area for Nordic skiing at the YMCA of the Rockies, and we used Yelp to suggest a pizza place. We didn't realize it was inside of the Winter Park Village, but the gate attendant said free 1 hour parking is allowed on the top deck of the garage. We wandered down into the village to find this cool spot tucked in among the shops. There is not a lot of room to sit inside, but we snagged a few seats at the end of one of the long tables. We ordered a large pepperoni, Epic Barrel Rolls, and the $2 beers. Despite being very busy, the food came out fresh and fairly fast. The employees seem to really enjoy the job, and they treat every single person with kindness. The art work on the walls was a nice touch, and the background music was fun. We found out that the music was from a band called the Kitchen Dwellers, and I downloaded their most recent album right away. Great pizza; great employees; incredible atmosphere. Our next visit will be to stay in Winter Park, and we will definitely be returning. read more

See all

New management and new seating arrangements that make it feel more comfy BUT the biggest and best is a new GM and the food has stepped totally up. It has always been our go to for pizza but now, over the top favorite. The quality of the food has just gone up and it needs to become a stop when you are in the village!!! read more

See all

The food was excellent and served quickly. The service was really friendly, and there was a good atmosphere inside. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Mega Cheese Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

My favorite pizza in the WP/Fraser area. The crust, sauce and overall way the pizza comes together is absolutely amazing. Everyone that works at Pedal'r has been super nice and whether I've gotten a slice or whole pie the pizza has been consistent. Big fan read more

Great pizza! I got the vegan veggie. Crust is super good! Their online ordering system was down and couldn't get through on the phone, but the wait time wasn't too long when we walked in to order. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Veggie pizza with vegan cheese - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Great refresh under new leadership. New options with some old favorites (ie Hard Tail). Fantastic option in WP.

This place is great. Small and very chill. My husband and I crushed a whole pizza and a couple beers after snowboarding. It was perfect! We got the Berm, which made us feel better as a "healthy" choice haha. Also probably why we ate it all. The staff was friendly, as were many of the guests! read more

This pizza is amazing. Crust is perfect, plenty of sauce, good amount of toppings, and it keeps you wanting more. This location is in the village of Winter Park. It is a popular hangout of hungry skiers and snowboarders. They have more than pizza on that menu, but I only tried the pizza. Inside, go to the counter, order what you'd like and find a seat. If the weather is nice enough for you, there is outside seating. They also have a good selection and beer - I had a local stout. The inside is quaint and fun. The tables are tall so if it is crowded and you end up standing, you won't feel out of place. Great stop! The kids I was with claim this is the "best pizza ever!" They may be right..., read more

See all

Great pizza with vegan cheese and vegan pepperoni options!!! Ended up being really pricy for 2 medium pizzas but service and location can't be beat. The people working there were very nice, great service all around! I will come back every time I'm in WP. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Vegan pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

This used to be my fave place, the food was great and they made everything to order, even the slices (which I really appreciated). Unfortunately, it came under new management and it went down hill. The pizza isn't as good, the slices are premade in a warming case so you can only get what's available (last time they only veggie available...), the ordering is at a tablet now which is totally impersonal and doesn't seem to improve efficiency, service is bad, they don't acknowledge you, it's just not the same. Very sad, Pizza Pedal'r used to be the best :( read more

Our pizza was burnt. The crust was so stiff. The dough bubbled up while in the oven. Our pepperoni rolls were burnt as well. The worst experience. we will not be back. read more

Love this place! Great pizza in the village and honestly really well priced. Seth and Christian were great and made some great pizza. We were staying at the vintage hotel and super easy to take the cabriolet over and the free shuttle back. Best priced dinner in the village and you can never go wrong with pizza and beer. read more

Been here a handful of times during both the winter & summer months. The place is small but, still fits a good amount of people. You place your order at the counter and they give you a number and delivery your food. The pizza is fresh with a fluffy braided crust and has a good amount of toppings. Would recommend and will be back. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Inside (ordering counter) - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

YUM!! What better way to spend a break from the slopes than with eating a delicious pizza. You can make your own pizza with as many toppings as you want, and it comes out with the delicious fluffy crust! It was a nice day so I got to sit outside, and enjoy! I'm sure it can get busy, but I had absolutely no wait on this day towards the end of the season. Staff is friendly and chill as you would expect at a ski resort and prices are even decent for a ski resort. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Create your own pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

Amazing pizza in a small space, but totally worth an hour wait on a busy Winter Park night. The crust was crunchy chewy and yummy. My family was able to wait at a table and watch crusts flying in the air and the chefs preparing our pies. Can't imagine how this small crew could make so many pizza's! Busy, but worth the wait. We stayed at Zephyr lodge and could have taken it to our condo, but enjoyed the atmosphere and some of the best pizza ever. We asked for honey packets to eat on our crust and it was like dessert. Excellent customer service too! read more

Best pizza in WP! Located in the village, this is a perfect place to grab pizza. Not a lot of seating inside but most people order take out. The medium size was plenty for two people! They have plenty of vegetarian and vegan options as well! read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Great slice and salad, staff was good, easy in and out! Will return next time we are in winter park read more

My friend and I received a receipt to visit the pizza place and we were very pleased with the food and service. The staff were very friendly. read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

Staying in winter park for a long weekend and hit Pizza Pedal'r for dinner. YUM! The salad had great ingredients and the pizza was amazing! Zappa recommended a bottle of wine for us and did not steer us wrong! The place itself is nothing special but it's definitely a repeater! read more

Pizza Pedal'r - a pizza on a serving tray - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

I go here every time I go skiing and it is amazing food. Best pizza in all of Colorado! It is not only in a super convenient spot but the pizza also tastes amazing and the service is quick. My only critique is that is isn't very big and can get crowded quickly. Recommendation: I recommend getting the pepperoni pizza it's to die for! read more

Stop looking at reviews. Pizza is top notch, good beer selection, and excellent vibes.

Tristan and Zappa were fantastic, super friendly people, great service, very well versed in what they have to offer and very transparent with their suggestions. The pizza was fresh and delicious, great music, an awesome place to hang out after a long day of biking! read more

Gluten free crust is amazing! Fresh ingredients lots of choices Always a great experience read more

Solid pizza and cheap beer. Stop here every time. Usually get the pig pizza and a outlaw beer after a bike ride

Amazing pizza. Seth took great care of us. The music was good. Truly amazing vibes read more

Pizza Pedal'r - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

The pizza was mediocre at best. They got our order wrong. It was loud. would not come here again.

Great pizza and super friendly staff! Close to the lifts and convienent we always stop here for lunch and the food is always killer! Great vibes in the dining area and outdoor seating as well! read more

This is the best pizza I have ever ate the service was really good everyone there was super nice 10/10 so delicious

A must try if you are in Winter Park. Great pizza!! The manager is a hoot as well. He is a transplant from Florida and we are from Florida as well so we had some good conversation while waiting on our food. Highly recommend!! read more

best pizza I have ever had I wish I could have it every time I order pizza but I can't drive 2 1/2 hours every few weeks their Service is amazing the workers are so nice and helpful. It has great vibes at the place and it is a cute cozy little place for when you Are looking for good food to eat, it could be a little bit cleaner but I don't blame them at all because it's right next to a ski mountain (it's probably cleaner then most places) read more

Great pizza! Would definitely go back! Loved the jalapeño, pepperoni & cream cheese pizza, we took off the pineapple. The cookies that were sold at the counter were delicious too! read more