Pretty good pizza! We drove by the Pizza Shack several times over the years and when we had friends to the beach, we decided to give it a try. It was pretty good! The crust was crispy and our friends said that they were making the dough in the back. We got a Hawaiian pizza, a veggie and a cheese pizza. All of us were happy with each pizza. If you like cheese, they put plenty on the pizzas. The staff was friendly and promptly waited on us. There are two booths in the store, so you can eat there or at picnic tables outside. We just waited at one of the tables and our pizza was ready very quickly. We took the pizza home and it was nice and hot. Recommended! read more

You know the old axiom "There's no such thing as bad pizza"? Well, it's not true and Pizza Shack delivers. I've never met a worse crust. I was watching them put pizzas together while I ordered and assumed that the "crust" they were putting down was some sort of cardboard liner to box up your pizza. Nope, they actually pretend that this is some sort of food. The crust was inedible. New York attitude without the good pizza? Check. The woman at the front taking orders was super rude. Didn't want to be bothered with us on a busy night. I wish I'd taken the hint. An hour, two pizzas, a few nasty, soggy mozz sticks and $55 later, we were finally able to get our order. I opened the pepperoni box and saw a cheese pizza with a single piece of pepperoni in the middle. I'm sure I'm not the the first one to have to go back in and ask is this was an actual pepperoni pizza, but they think it's a good idea to put the pep under the cheese. Who likes crispy pep anyway? Not the 15 incredibly sad looking employees in there. The white pizza was maybe the absolute worst thing I've ever had. No further notes, 0/10, would not wish on my worst enemy. Folks, this is absolutely MISERABLE pizza. Brave the wait and go a mile down the road to Pepperoni Grill where they make good food and appreciate their customers. Pizza Shack is a blight on your soul. read more

The place is reasonably priced and fair on wait time but we were not impressed with the quality especially on the crust.

Very good and was just the right size .It was delivered.......came in reasonable time. I have used this place for over for 40 years.

Pizza and salad were delicious. Prices are very reasonable and the staff was friendly and efficient. This restaurant is a great find on Oak Island providing local excellent dining. read more

The amount of toppings and distribution was on point. The crust is thin and doesn't sit heavy. We ordered 16" Half Supreme with Jalapeños and extra cheese and half Pepperoni and mushrooms. We also ordered a pepperoni/ jalapeño and Pineapple pizza. It was so good that the family wanted to eat there two more times that week. read more

See all

Quick snd friendly service, great price, decent food. Affordable way to feed a crowd. read more

This place has good pizza but tonight I called to place an order for a taco pizza and they said they couldn't make one... they had already cleaned up that area, whatever that means! Also they were cash only! The owners might want to look into what's going on there! read more

Great Pizza Great staff Always timely Great local family business... Thank you Pizza Shack read more

Great pizza! Crispy crust and wasn't too expensive. We got a family size Pepperoni, ham, onions, and mushrooms, $20.

Placed a pickup order for 5 pizzas. We won't even go into the service... it was as bad as the pizza. All but the supreme was awful. I equate the crust to what I imagine a cardboard box tastes like. The sauce had zero flavor. The only redeeming quality on the supreme pizza was that the additional toppings that masked the failure of the rest of the pizza. Not good. read more

The staff was incredibly friendly and the pizza was absolutely delicious. 5 stars all around!

This place has great pizza, family atmosphere and cheap books to peruse while you wait! We get it at least once every time we come to visit. Cash only. No seating. read more

It's like if Little Caesars opened a mom and pop concept. Not great. The staff was kind when I picked up.

Always love to get pizza shack when we're down for vacation. Better than most other chain pizzas and they definitely don't skimp on toppings read more

Pizza Shack - Mexican pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

See all

Meh not great. Friendly staff and delivery man. Ordered two larges are on a Friday evening and they were delivered within an hour. Ranch is not made in house. read more

Pizza shack is still a reliable and consistent pizza establishment on oak island. We have been enjoying them for years and continue to. We just got done eating their awesome bbq pizza, italian white, and hawaiin. All were piping hot. Dont call, go there and order in person. You will save a lot of time. read more

Pizza Shack - Oak island bbq, Hawaiian, Cheese, and Italian White Gourmet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

Pretty darn good nice and crispy and thin great sauce. One bite everybody knows the rules read more

The best pizza! Sauce and Cheese on point! I live here and it's the best on the island. Their kitchen is immaculate and staff is super friendly. read more

Finally tried their pizza after my daughter raved about it. I can say it did not disappoint. We had it delivered and it was piping hot and delicious. Will definitely be ordering again and love the fact they deliver! read more

Pizza Shack is a great takeout pizza! For $20 we got a large hot "All American Bacon Cheeseburger " pizza that is delicious and left a $4 tip to the friendly and courteous staff. read more

Pizza Shack - All - american Bacon Cheeseburger - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

Just a little local cash only establishment. I'm all about a local pizza place as opposed to a national chain.. been here a number of times they've always been real consistent read more

I was highly anticipating our visit here, as my husband had good things to say. He was correct and incorrect. He ordered a double pepperoni and onion, I ordered the Hawaiian. His came out with regular pepperoni. Mine came out looking alright, but eating it was a different story. He was disappointed due to his order being incorrect, but he still enjoyed most of his pizza. I, on the other hand, struggled to get through mine. The sauce was super tasty and super flavorful, but it took away from the rest of the pizza. I couldn't even tell there was ham or pineapple on mine. I would highly recommend this place, but only if you're getting light sauce on your pizza, or getting a pizza that tastes good with flavorful marinara....the Hawaiian is not that pizza. read more

Pizza was okay, more of a kids pizza. My kids said it was okay. Not super flavorful. Price was fair

So good! So many pizzas to choose from. Pizzas were fresh and the location is great. Limited seating, I'd say about 10 tables on the deck if you're looking to eat in. We tried the lasagna pizza and the Philly. Both were delicious. read more

For the price, it was good. We will probably still try it again. It wasn't the best but I disagree with the "just go to dominoes" review. They are better than Dominoes. They told us they would call when it was ready and, after over an hour of waiting, we decided to go in and check. It was ready and waiting. It was warm when we picked it up but not hot. I am not sure how long it had been sitting out of the oven. read more

Called order in, she was very nice. They were busy but our order was correct. Pizza was hot and delicious. We haven't been to Oak Island in over 19 years and the pizza was exactly like we remembered. We will definitely be back soon. read more

Good pizza at a fair price. Locally owned place that knows how to make a good pizza. Will definitely recommend!

This place is a hidden gem. The pizza is great, but the staff are the real treat. Don't complain because this place is busy! And don't complain because you have to wait. Consider it the price of a great pizza. I only hope this place stay around a long while. Small town pizza places like this are hard to find in this area. read more

A family favorite locally. Local folks making pizza for locals. Always friendly and hard working. I love that the crust is always cooked but not burnt. Most pizzas are dripping with grease. Greasy pizzas aren't a problem here. read more

Friendly. Smells amazing when you walk in. There are a lot of orders coming in as it's changeover night on the island and the staff are all cool and collected. read more

While visiting some friends on the beach, we decided on pizza for an easy dinner one night. Went with a nice variety of 4 different pizzas: cheese, pepperoni, veggie, and supreme. The supreme was the best, but the pepperoni was also pretty good. The crust was somewhat flaky, which wasn't my favorite, but it still had a good taste. Hopefully you'll read this somewhere else or will be told.....CASH only. No big deal, if you know ahead of arriving. read more

We ordered a 16 inch "The Works"...from the call to delivery it took 23 mins. The delivery person was very nice. The pizza was hot and delicious. Highly recommend if you're looking for pizza that's much better than the chain restaurants. read more

Pizza Shack - "The Works" - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

See all

Great Pizza! Cooked to perfection. Loved the simplicity of of there set up. A great way to start a vacation. Will definitely be back.

Ordered and went outside to wait. Came back 30 minutes later and she hadn't put the order in. then took 40 minutes to prepare the food. food is ok but awful service. read more

See all

Called 20 times - no answer. Finally I drove there because my husband was so dead set on eating their pizza because he does rave about it. Got there to find it open but then they told me it's an hour wait (for take out) and cash only. I understand a wait but at least answer the phone to allow soon to be customers to know in advance. Slightly disappointed on my experience and I haven't even tried the pizza. Better luck next year. read more

I ordered a pizza to go last night for the first time from the Shack. When I drove up to the I wasn't sure what to expect. Ended up being one of the best pizzas I've ever had. read more

We just moved here in August and trying all the local spots. We were very disappointed in the pizza. The crust tasted pre made and I would say it was equivalent to the pizza at Chuck-E-Cheese, which is not a compliment. They were very stingy with toppings. I've never seen a slice of pizza with only one pepperoni. I get it if the pizzas were $5 each. But dang.. Very disappointing. We will not be going back to this place. For the benefit of their reputation, I hope they make some changes. read more

It was hot and fresh! Good price. We got the family sized cheese and pepperoni. There was a lot of pepperoni under the cheese which was a cool touch. The people there are so kind and friendly. read more

Pizza Shack - Family size cheese and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

I had the medium pizza with pepperoni, sausage, black olives, green peppers & onions today & it was fantastic. The best pizza I've had since I moved to North Carolina. What set this apart is that the cheese was put on top so it sealed everything in. Sensational. It was cooked just right. The cheese was slightly browned & bubbly. All the flavors were exceptionally blended. Marvelous. A+++++++ read more