The customer service here was 10/10, great greeting and just a genuine conversation asking us where we're from, if we've been here before, etc... I've been going to this pizza stop for almost 20 years since I was just a wee lad and good gahlee miss molly is hasn't changed a bit - perfect vibe and a perfect slice. Thanks for bringing me back to when I was younger y'all! read more

Pizza Stop - Pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

See all

Man does this hit the spot after a long day on the mountain! To not have to go the busy market and then still come home to have to cook whatever was bought at the market is priceless. Review ratings aside - TBH I liked the pizza. Thin vs regular crust, pepperoni vs meat on meat on meat - it was all very tasty. The topping to crust ratio was perfect. The crust was just the right thickness to hold up to withstand the amount of meaty goodness but also not too thick to take over the flavor and texture of the pizza. Added plus, this was close walking distance to our AirBnB. Lol honestly in Angel Fire this is pretty close to probably everyone's AirBnB. read more

See all

Amazing customer service, everyone in there was lovely. The food however was undercooked crust and the garlic knots were burnt on top. The pizza body was a good pizza with ample toppings, we got pepperoni and black olives. read more

Extremely rude kitchen staff. Not sure if it was the owner or an employee. Upon entering to request a menu (since it is take out only and they don't have a website), this guy barks at us (2 adults, 3 kids) to go outside because we were holding cups of hot cocoa. We are on vacation and never been here and since it is not a sit down restaurant, who knew you'd have to dump your cocoa before ordering a pizza to go. We went to Angel Fired Pizza instead. It was absolutely delicious! Will not be giving this place our business, but it led to something great! read more

I would give this a zero if I could. Service was so slow and managing staff was horribly rude. Took over 2 hours for our order and on top of that they charged us $40 for a pizza that could've been $20 if they listened. Ordered 2- topping chicken and bacon with side of ranch and they changed us $38.64 for their house chicken ranch pizza. When we talked to the manager about the confusion, she was very dismissive and blamed everyone but herself. Horrible. Wouldn't even let us change our order because "it was already in the oven" even though they said it was a 20 minute wait still. The rest of the staff looked scared and said they couldn't talk to us, "only the manager can talk to you". The place was full of smoke and felt toxic to wait in. DONT GO HERE. NOT WORTH YOUR TIME OR MONEY. Do better Pizza Stop. read more

This place no longer offers dine in options. Placing an order was easy, we just stopped by. I loooove crust but their crust was really thick and oddly doughy even if the rest of the pizza was cooked well. I'd opt for the thin crust next time. They were not very generous with their pizza toppings for the price. The pizza itself was decent and hot. read more

Fast service. Super good pizza. I would recommend Pizza Stop for great food ready for pick up quickly.

If you like mid pizza and have a billion dollars in the bank this is definitely your spot! Don't get me wrong the pizza wasn't the worst pizza I've ever had. But it was unbelievably doughy and insanely overpriced. 34$ for one extra large pepperoni pizza is criminal and I won't be coming back. read more

Delicious Pizza & Friendly Service! We ordered The Works pizza, and it was absolutely fantastic--loaded with fresh toppings, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor! The service was excellent--friendly, fast, and welcoming. A great spot all around. Highly recommend! read more

Service was fantastic (take out order).... Pizza was very good, even though the regular has too big of a soft crust (more like a soft bread)... wing were good but tiny!!! read more

To go only and they are always busy. Ingredients were all Sysco house brand. Not a knock but nothing home made from what I could tell. Mozzarella cheese sticks were frozen and store bought. Ranch cost extra , wouldn't take $1 had to be $1.07. Folks were ok. Not overly nice or concerned with customers. Very expensive read more

Great pizza, great staff! Staff was courteous, no issues with phone order or pickup. Promised time was 20 min and it was ready when we arrived. We actually ordered from Angel Fired at the same time to compare. Our group was split - some of us preferred the thicker yeasty crust of Pizza Stop, and some liked the thin crust, garlicky sauce from Angel Fired. Pizza Stop seems like more sustenance for your buck ($). read more

Delicious, we ordered two pizzas and a small side salad with the house vinaigrette dressing! All was great, highly recommend their thin crust and homemade ranch! read more

We love this place. Both times we've taken the family skiing, this place has been a hit with kids and adults too! They're so good to us the pizza was so good! Loved the one with green chile! read more

Pilsbury doughboy pizza crust , do I need to say more ? Couldn't even order appetizer because they complained of being understaffed. Maybe shut the restaurant down instead of being miserable. read more

Mid Service was just ok need to work on the food taste it was bland. But it was aight read more

I'm giving four stars here because 1) it's open, and 2) the food was pretty darn good. Why would I give less than four stars? Cleanliness. This place needs a good cleaning - floor to ceiling - and maybe some new seating that's not cracked and lumpy. Back to the food. We went with other reviewers and we ordered the garlic knots. They came out (6) in a paper basket. We had to ask for some sort of dipping sauce - we got ranch. They were very tasty and the ranch was good on them. We also ordered a regular crust medium pizza with Italian sausage and green olives. The crust was exceptional. The rest of the pizza was just good. We wound up taking 1 garlic knot & 2 pieces of pizza home, so all that dough was filling. Service was good and we loved watching the hummingbirds dart to & from the feeders outside the screen door. read more

Pizza Stop - Garlic knots are pretty darn good - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

Delicious pizza and the kindest people work here! Got the Works and it was packed with toppings.

High prices for below average pizza. Feels like tourists are being taken advantage of. And they charge for boxes with a sign on the doors "take out only." read more

We just ordered tonight. It was so yummy! Only to go orders because of no staff but it was delicious!

Very good pizza! They stay busy so don't be surprised if you have a 30 min or more wait time for a carry out order. On the pricier side.

These are garlic "rolls".... Do not confuse them with garlic knots, per the delightful lady who makes them. They're quite good so don't overlook ordering them. Also be sure to get the ranch dressing. It's yummy! The pizza was pretty good. The sauce was good, and given the rolls, we probably should have just ordered the ultra thin crust. The regular crust is very doughy! Also, don't expect to eat there. This is primarily a take out, although you can get a beer while you wait. read more

Pizza Stop - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

See all

This is pizza! Everything you expect from a great pizza - good amount of toppings, good ratio of sauce to cheese, crispy crust, outstanding flavor! Pair this pizza with the garlic rolls, and you'll bring thanking the Lord as you go into cardiac arrest! Gray pizza! Charming lady, Trinnie! Would highly recommend. read more

Pizza Stop - Thin crust pepperoni! Love that they put cheese on top of the toppings as well. - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

Our visit was during Spring Break and it was To GO orders only, no dine in. I called and was told 30 mins and when I arrived it was already ready. Pizza was delicious, lots of cheese! We ordered the garlic knots even though not listed on menu due to many reviews on here and it's the truth they are amazing but would be better with marinara sauce to dip them in. After arriving it's obvious I'm not sure I would have wanted to dine in after the looks of the place but the food was great after a long day of skiing. read more

Great pizza and friendly staff. Restaurant is take out only. We red red both their thin and regular crust pizzas. The thin was thin but not so thin the crust was cracker like. The regular crust was not that thick with a thick edge that was very tasty. My mistake was not getting a side of ranch for dipping. Would definitely order from the, again. read more

Pizza was really good! Service was good as well.. overall, great experience... a little pricey but good.

This place was yummy!! The crust I am still thinking about a week later. The service was amazing!

Yummy pizza spot! We ordered an XL pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, and a lb of chicken wings to go. We ate leftovers the next day, and everything was still delicious. read more

Pizza Stop - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

Number one: we had not eaten all day. We were past hungry. Not a lot open in Angel Fire, and we didn't want to drive out of town. We just wanted to eat. I phoned Pizza Stop after seeing a menu online (without prices). Being only a quarter mile us, it was a no brainer. I phoned in our order for a large mountain meat pizza + black olives, regular crust. It was ready in 15 minutes for pick up (boo, Ciovid-19). The smell of that pizza was unreal when hubby got in the car. The plzza box in my lap was heavy. I mean...HEAVY! We got back to our condo, and had a peek. Wow! We dove in, and it was so hot the cheese would string from the box yo our mouths. It was fantastic! As hungry as I was. I could only eat one slice, as it was thick with meat and cheese, and olives! Yay! We had breakfast for Tuesday!!! For those who might faint at the thought of a $35 pizza, you gotta know: it was the best meal we have had in Angel Fire. There was no discussion about the cost because we were so happy and well fed! It's hard to argue with quality. read more

I could not get ahold of Mikuna Grill in the same center and they were kind enough to walk Down and let them know their phones were not working. We will be ordering pizza tomorrow!! Love being able to support this small ski resort town we love! read more

Family of 4 visiting Angel Fire for the first time. At first we tried to go to this place around d 1pm but the restaurant was closed even with the posted hours said it was open till 2 for lunch. Locals mentioned that the owner sometimes closes the establishment if by noon if he is not satisfied with traffic. They were open at 4pm for the dinner traffic.. We decided to try some of the local business and since this place was close to the Lodge, we ventured in :) The place is pretty run down, very small operation... We ate in, and ordered buffalo chips, two medium pizzas and an order of spaghetti. The Buffalo chips were ok, it is basically thick cuts of potatoes deep fried... They served the spaghetti burnt (see pic), guess they left the hot plate to long in the oven. The pizza was great... The regular crust is huge... But worth it. Next time we will order the pizza to go... But then again there are pizza places in the resort and town which we will try, because others (including locals) say is much better.... read more

See all

This place is fantastic. Way better than Zeb's. Zeb's is so, so bad. The worst. I would rather go to prison for 6 months than eat there again. But Pizza Stop is great. read more

Really good pizza. If you're thinking about going to Zebs, re-evaluate your life, get a grip, and come here. Only place around with semi normal prices and good food. read more

Called in an order from their website. When we arrived, the cost was considerably higher, we Paid over $80 for two pizzas. The people working there were extremely rude. They charged us three bucks for three small containers of ranch dip and when we asked for Parmesan cheese, they gave us two small packages for two large pizzas and five people. When we got back to the condo, we discovered they even charged us $2.50 for the takeout boxes and there was no dine in options. Will never return to this place. read more

Called 5 times never answered finally answered after 6th time finally answers I give my order, old lady at the front says it'll be done in 30 minutes. I show up 30 minutes later she says she forgot to put in the order and it'll be 20 more minutes. I wait the. crazy guys yells very obnoxiously loud that my order is ready. If you're thinking of coming here re-evaluate your life choices terrible place to go. Food was good. read more

I love the pizza, best in town honestly. All that being said the prices are outrageous. Paid $130 for 2xl and 1L pizza. The service is also lackluster at best and to be honest they are normally just downright rude. Either they know how good the pizza is or they are aware of how few other choices you have while in town so they just don't care. Know what you are getting into before you eat here and if you can deal with a rude staff, poor service and high prices then the pizza is awesome. read more

Delicious pizza, very friendly staff, super happy family eating after a long day of skiing! The pizza is so good I had to go back and get more for the family later that night. Sign in door said To Go Orders Only, which is what I needed! Best pizza in town! read more

Absolutely love this place ~ great owners Amazing pizza Consistently wonderful Pricey ~ but you are at a resort & it's expensive to own a business here read more

Prices are high. Pizza is decent. They don't open till 4pm, so no lunch there. Must carry out, no dine in

We had takeout from Pizza Stop and it was very good. Everything was ready in about 30 minutes. The pizza and garlic knots were both really. My only suggestion for improvement is to get the bottom of the pizza crust a little crispier. read more

Pizza Stop - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

See all