Pizzamore

This pizza was one of a kind, so amazing and the ambience was grown and sexy. The service was…read moretop-notch. my family and I can't wait to return back to New Jersey to visit this establishment again. Don't walk, run to this pizza joint. You won't regret it.

Horrible. I've been here before, and the food and drinks were great! Today, however, the drinks…read morewere HORRIBLE. The margaritas tasted like water mixed with cheap liquor, and the "lemon drop" tasted like watered-down lemonade. There was no sugar on the rim, and they literally just dropped a lemon peel into the drink. The pizza also didn't look or taste the same as it did during my previous visit. Our server was nice and pleasant, though, so that made the experience somewhat bearable. Unfortunately, based on the quality of the food and drinks this time around, I will not be returning.

Interiors

See all

Restaurant

Gusto WoodFired Pizza

4.4(68 reviews)

0.5 mi

Came in with a party of five on a Sunday at around noon, and it was empty at the time. To start,…read morethey bring out some ciabatta (?) bread, which was crusty on the outside but soft on the inside. For food, we decided to order a bunch of things to share: -Zucchini fritte (with lemon aioli dipping sauce) - this was thin and perfectly crispy but somehow not oily. It was addicting -Arancini - these were okay. Could have used more meat -Margherita pizza - can't go wrong with a margherita. I do wish the actual crust was thinner -Meatball & Co pizza (meatballs, sweet sausage, cherry peppers, tomato sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese) - same with the crust situation. The description also said cherry peppers but they also added jalapenos, which is not a big deal - just a call out. The sausage was alright -Seafood fra Diavolo (sauteed clams, calarami, mussels, spicy tomato sauce) - sauce could have used a bit more spice. They don't skimp on the seafood though. I was pleasantly surprised by the calamari, which can taste rubberband-y but that wasn't the case here -Tiramisu - tasted fridgey/supermarket-bought -Affogato - a nice way to end the meal. Made me wonder why I don't make more affogatos at home Overall, it the meal was fine. Is it something I'd crave for? I don't think so. Well, maybe except that zucchini fritte. I wouldn't mind ordering that again. Tip - BYOB (there's a liquor store across the street)

Don't sleep on this place. The food was absolutely delicious. Portions are generous. Our waitress…read morewas fun and engaging. The owner was super helpful and friendly. But the star of the show was my veal Milanese, so tender I was able to cut it with a fork.

Indoor atrium seating

Bread rolls

See all

Casano’s Pizza Parlor

4.1(74 reviews)

1.3 mi

Hands-down, the best pizza I have ever tasted in my entire life. And just so you know before you…read morego....they only sell FULL PIES, and trust me, you're going to want the whole thing anyway! The pizza was absolutely incredible. The crust had that perfect crisp while still being light and flavorful, the sauce was delicious, and everything came together perfectly. You can tell they put so much care into every single pie they make. There's something about finding a pizza spot that keeps things simple and absolutely NAILS what they do, and Casano's is exactly that. No slices... just fresh, delicious whole pies made to order! The quality really speaks for itself, and this is easily a spot we'd come back to again and again. If you're in Rutherford or anywhere nearby and consider yourself a pizza lover, Casano's needs to be on your list. The chicken Parm is absolutely amazing too !! Here's a list of my favorite pies that I LOVE : Stracciatella vodka New Haven White Garlic French Onion Pie I also love the fact that it looks like stepping into your grandmas living room inside. The old decor, furniture, and everything else makes it feel so cozy!! Service is excellent and everyone is so friendly !!

Gotta say I was a little disappointed. It may have been because the owner wasn't there and a bunch…read moreof very young kids were running th shop when I went in. I tired the cheesteak because he made it look so good on Instagram. What I got was not that. First we had to wait almost 30 minutes which is fine if the food is worth it. The cheesteak I got had maybe 2 ounces of meat and cheese. Very skimpy. Would not get again if that's how they always come out. If not these kids need to learn to make it the way the owner does. The place is awesome! He did a great job recreating the old feel and I love it. I still have to try the chicken parm. I'll be back if he is working. If not I'll probably walk out.

Vodka, chicken, Parm, and tomato sauce chicken Parm

See all

Front of store

Natoli's

4.5(408 reviews)

3.1 mi

Are these the nicest guys in NJ? Is the bread here going to take your sandwich to the next few…read morelevels? Is the pepperoni a perfect chalice of grease and flavor? Yes, yes, yes! This is a classic deli, walls full of tomatoes, pasta, family photos, and citizen of the year awards. (It only takes one interaction to understand why.) you can sit outside in nice weather, but the chit chat inside makes you feel especially welcome. My only regret is we forgot to get cannolis on the way out. (Probably because the portions are huge.) Not far off the highway so you can keep dad feeling like we're still making good time. We'll be back on our next Northeast haul.

I ordered delivery from here on a Sunday, took about 45 min, not bad…read more But the food was below mid. I ordered the buffalo wings, garlic knots, a small cheese pizza with vodka sauce instead of marinara & mushrooms, and a cannoli. The wings were not Buffalo, they were a mix between Buffalo and bbq. If I had known, would not have ordered. Did not like the bbq sauce flavor. I also asked for ranch as I despise bleu cheese but alas, I did not get ranch and had to eat my wings plain. Garlic knots were perfect. The pizza tho. Ugh, it was so bad. They made a cheese mushroom pizza with way too much cheese and then put the vodka sauce on top after!!! Like a drunken grandma pie. That's not what I wanted. I asked for, "a cheese pizza with vodka sauce." It was so soggy that it soaked through the bottom of the box. Stayed soggy even after reheating in the oven. I ate half a slice and tossed the rest sadly. I won't be ordering from here again. The cannoli was fine but wouldn't order again either. The only thing I would eat again is the garlic knots. Very disappointing for Jersey pizza.

See all

&pizza

4.1(28 reviews)

0.3 mi

Lesson learn you can't go into this place get an order since they take online orders first go…read morefigure customer infront trying to order food 20 minutes . One team member working guess that's why you closed in Paramus!!! plus I lost all my credits !! customer behavior

So glad there's an &pizza close to me. It's located in a busy shopping mall with other fast food…read morechains. I made my own pizza with mushrooms and jalapeños and chose the pesto drizzle. Good place to get customized and quick take out pizza.

Build your own pizza with vegan cheese, grilled onions, Beyond (plant based) sausage and classic sauce.

See all

New G

Master Pizza

3.4(125 reviews)

0.2 mi

Master Pizza is my go to local pizza place. It is located on a busy road so the parking can…read moresometimes be a bit difficult, but I usually never have any issues. In the nicer months they have some outside tables and plenty of tables inside. The service is always great! They have a pretty big food menu and also many different options for pizza types. They always have specials going on as well. I have not tried many of the different food options as I typically opt for some of the many different slice options they have out on the counter. They always have a wide array of different slices, and I have never had a bad slice. They definitely have some of my favorite specialty slices in the area. The prices are pretty good too for how filling the slices are.

It's a small tight space this place put out some good pizza. Very clean service is friendly and did…read moreI say good pizza?

Bella Vista Wrap

See all

Pizza box

Ralph's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.8(94 reviews)

0.5 mi

They never disappoint. If you have cash it's $3 for a slice vs $3.31 w card. The pizza is fresh and…read morecame out hot. The staff are always fast and efficient and nice. Plenty of seats also. Also a ramp for wheelchairs.

I love this place, my boyfriend & I have been coming here lately - the staff is great, the food is…read moregreat- we've had pizza, soups, and chicken parm. All of it was very good. I can't wait to go back and have the broccoli cheese soup again

Pasta Fagioli Soup

See all

Bella Pizza

3.8(133 reviews)

1.8 mi

In town for business. Happened upon this place. Absolutely fantastic. Pizza was typical NJ pizza…read moreand delicious. Cheese garlic bread was on another level, best I've ever had. Wait staff was informative and very friendly. Couldn't recommend more.

I like the pizza here but everything else is either hit or completely miss. I order fried calamari,…read moreif they aren't into making and serving calamari I wish they would take it off the menu. Absolutely abhorrently gross. Why the plastic container, why is that texture, why is the oil so old, why is there a bed of lettuce in there......there's too many questions, it's just not worth the risk really. I received it and immediately put $15 in the trash. I'd say it was about $.75 per calamari ring so they owe me $14.25, the rest legit is in my trash can. The delivery was friendly, on time and good

Cute pictures inside

Prime Steak Sandwich

See all

Bella Pizza

Corleone's Pizzeria

4.4(345 reviews)

2.5 mi

Always a win! Did not go with my usual and it did not disappoint. Staff are always a pleasure (in…read moreperson and delivery). Always on time and on point. Got the personal philly (new for me) today and mozzarella sticks with vodka sauce, and it was delicious. Highly recommend

We had the white pizza and a calzone! Delicious food and very friendly people! Definitely…read morerecommend!

Inside

Half bbq chicken/half vodkq

See all

Birch Beer

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Manny C.

4 years ago

John Touches money goes to the bathroom serves pizza and food and doesn't wash his hands. How do I know this I used to work there. On 3 occasions the exterminator came there because of his rodent problem. Georgie is worker who touches raw eggs and then cuts cold cuts why Because John yells at him to work fast when customer orders come in fast that they can't keep up with on Delivery apps. His girlfriend Daniel informed me that hes uses cocaine Which I could tell he was on something and she said he Beats her from time to time. That's a coward who beats on women. A delivery driver that used to work for him confirmed he was on cocaine When he owned the other pizza shop. He owes people money Including me And he pays Georgie bounce checks. John himself told me he doesn't like black people and his races. John also doesn't like to pay people money he owes them. A bad person to do business with. He also lies on his catering menu prices to customers And also talks about people when they leave the store. Maybe if he didn't cheat on his wife he would be a better dad. A low life who likes to drink a lot as well. read more

Marina H.

8 years ago

Love this spot. It's fairly new but it's really good. They have fresh options and everything tastes very authentic. They're pizzas are so good, perfect sauce to cheese ratio with a soft yet crispy dough and if you're into mediterranean food you should definitely hit up this spot! Their hummus is so delicious, their falafel sandwich is heavenly and so are their zaatar pies! It's a small family owned business and when you walk in everyone wants to help you and welcomes you with excitement! read more

Valeria H.

1 month ago

I've been coming to this pizzeria, great environment and the food is delicious, especially their award winning meatballs!! I for sure recommend this place amazing people and food. read more

Kyle L.

8 years ago

Pizzamore has great sandwiches and even better pizza. The staff is super friendly and accommodating. The Texas Thicc Burger is amazing. Highly recommend!! read more

Joseph O.

8 years ago

A great new take on pizza featuring the flavors of Lebanese cooking. Excellent "regular" pizzas as well. Good prices and fine service.

John S.

6 months ago

Stop back at PizzAmore as always, hands-down best pizza and meatball sandwich award-winning

Pizzamore - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Pizzamore also viewed

Rose's Pizzeria

4.1

(196 reviews)

I came here after the gym in Wallington, my home gym in Fort Lee is temporarily closed... did a…read morequick search for pizza and noticed Rose's was close by, had good reviews and the pics looked pretty good. Got just a plain slice ($3.04 tax inc). The slice was alright, very cheesy. Maybe my expectations were high because of the reviews on Yelp and Google. I saw reviews raving about their Sicilian slice so I may get that the next time if my home gym is still closed. * Parking on premise * Parmesan cheese available upon request

The NY pizza shop across the corner from Penn Station did NOT disappoint. You walk in to a gorgeous…read moredisplay of pizzas ready to be ordered by slice. The service team is friendly and quick to take your order and get your choices in the oven. Very clean and ample seating. Perfect chance to grab your last slices before headed home to mediocre options lol :)

Piazza Di Pizza

3.9

(58 reviews)

I will never come to this pizza place again!!!…read more They have signs all in front of them and on the main road saying $1.00. So we figured let's give it a try. We go in he makes the pizza. Everything is fine up until I asked to pay. Something told me to pay before I sat down to eat and then when I go to pay with card he goes the price is regular if it's w card the $1.00 slices is if you pay cash. I responded nicely with " I'm sorry but where does it say anywhere that it's a cash only offer?" He then got rude and said "you can't read it says 1.00" Now I see why they don't make the business!

I work by this spot so im always in 1-2 times a week grabbing lunch from here, especially since…read moreit's a new owner! Jasmin is always hooking it up for me and making me personal pies just the way i like it! He has made a new menu and so far everything Ive had id rating 9-10/10! Customer Service: 10/10 He is always accommodating and open to small talk/ideas! Owner is proud and passionate of his work. Food: 10/10 Love that he does personal pies and you can customize it just the way you like with good topping choices! Menu alone is great! Alongside the personal pie option, def recommend the Mac and Cheese balls, Southwest salad, garlic knots, and buffalo chicken pizza!

Da Mario Pizzeria

4.1

(81 reviews)

[A decade later, my original review needs a sprucing up...]…read more Rutherford is an interesting town, right? Where else can you find multiple shoe repair shops ("cobbler" - there's a Scrabble bingo word for y'all!) rubbing elbows with state-of-the-art apartment complexes, and a smattering of 'hip' and 'hot' new restaurants that keep getting rave write-ups and making all sorts of "Best of..." lists. If you're a working stiff that doesn't want to break the bank to feed your family - you can't help but appreciate that there's a place like Da Mario's that's not chasing 'likes' but remaining humble and knocking out damn good food that's affordable and tasty. The pizza is solid. Good taste, a satisfying crust, it's not going to lure any 'influencers' their way and that's fine. (Da Mario's doesn't look like a place that has any social media presence and I'd bet they still have a dedicated fax line!) The garlic knots looked 'basic' but they had a serious smack of flavor that took me by surprise, I can't lie. (And their mozzarella sticks were a hit with my kids.) And - per the usual - I must order cavatelli and broccoli when I see it - and they absolutely nail it. Not the most comfortable chairs to sit in? A table you're expecting to be a bit wobbly? Generic maps and drawings of Italy on the walls? The place is bare bones... nothing fancy, exactly what you're expecting from an old-school pizza joint. Crew behind the counter - awesome. Metered street parking (but this block is incredibly busy, so you'd be keen to drop a quick prayer to St. Frances of Rome - the patron saint of car drivers - to help you find a spot). A family of four stuffing their mugs for about $8 a person? In today's economy? Cosa non è da amare.

Ambiance : your typical family pizzeria , great food. Love their salads specifically Caesar with…read morebreaded chicken and mozarella and 2 side dressings Yumm on my cheat day i get the Philly cheesesteak big portion tasty and affordable prices, when it comes to service Tina is amazing she does it all from cleaning prepping, serving dealing with customers and answering the phone all 3 lines A " JACK OF ALL TRADES" all by herself , no help ,so professional always courteous polite big Smile and positive attitude, 5 stars plus ,,,, on weekends be patient if you call they have a very highvolume of calls so it can be busy just hang in there THE FOOD AND SERVICE WORTH IT ,!!!

Ralph's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.8

(94 reviews)

Emilia Romagna Pizza & Restaurante

3.5

(88 reviews)

great service, great atmosphere, amazing food, nothing wrong about this place. The workers here are…read morevery respectful and are always hardworking to put together the best pizza in town.

I am from Brooklyn, pizza capital of the Tri-State and I have never been treated poorly like I have…read morebeen at Emilia. I do not know what happened to the customer service in this place buts it terrible. I have to wait 5 minutes for someone to step up to the counter. Can I help you. We only have old pizza. Want me to warm up 4 hour old pizza? They always have no fresh pizza. I don't care if I get there at noon for lunch all the way to 5pm. They said they don't make fresh pizza past 3 or 4 pm unless you buy a pie. Which takes a long time. I went to purchase a slice and she slices the pizza and then the phone rings. She walks away and takes the phone order like I was not there. WTF. Who does that, I know.... A place that does not want my business.

Mama Rosa Pizza & Pasta

3.4

(107 reviews)

I had a craving for a spinach roll.I stumbled on this place. They had spinach rolls and meatball…read morerolls. I ordered both. On delivery still piping hot. Freshly made cooked perfect. Just amount filling in both. Sauce for dipping was tasty as well. Definitely recommend.

Not worth the price. I got a square pizza, chicken marsala, an order of garlic knots and two drink…read moredrinks. Total came back to $67. Add an order this off of GrubHub or anything, I called and I picked this order up. And the pizza was frankly, not good. And the marsala was flavorless. If I had paid like $35-$40 (Which by the way if you go off of the menu they have on their website, that's what it would've costed. But I guess their menu is outdated and has the old prices on it) for that I wouldn't be so upset. But the fact that it came out to $67 is disgusting.

Mr Pizza

3.9

(35 reviews)

The O N L Y place for pizza. Thinner than your regular boring too much bread pizza and too thick…read morepizza. Just enough cheese and "gravy". I'm Italian, I know!

The staff is really nice Pizza is always consistent and good…read moreDefinitely not my favorite but one of the better ones I've had

Stefano's Pizza

3.2

(39 reviews)

If your on a budget and want some good food, this is the place to go. I've been a fan since 2002…read more The pizza and calzones are great. They usually have a good deal on their pizza like 2 slices and a drink for like 6 bucks, and the calzones are huge and definitely worth the price. The slices aren't puny like most place either. It's not much of dine-in environment, but if your looking to just get a couple of slices, a drink, or something like that the prices are great, the place is clean, and the service is quick.

I went back here recently after a long time away. I got the impression that it's under different…read moreownership. They did some cosmetic changes to the inside that to me... I see the effort but I don't think it was worth it, I really doesn't make the place wow, doesn't have much of a sense of style, and it was fine before as your standard pizzeria. The service was pretty good. Initially I was really disappointed because before I could get quite the generous Stromboli here at an extremely affordable price that didn't seem to go up. Now, you walk away from here paying a lot more, but now it's one size Stromboli and honestly it's two meals worth, and I'm a pig so it's seriously two meals worth at least for most people. So you do get your money's worth. Did I prefer it before? Honestly, yes. It was five stars from me before. But what I warn people against it and tell people that it changed and they shouldn't go there? No. Just realized that it's not the same as it was, but the food tastes pretty much the same, and you're still getting your money's worth, you just paying more upfront for more food, I would say. so don't be thrown by the changes if like myself, you came back after a stretch and found yourself surprised. I recommend at least giving it a shot.

Taormina Pizzeria

4.5

(40 reviews)

Been coming here since I was a little girl. Pizza taste has never changed and pricing remains…read morereasonable ! Service was quick considering I got one slice during lunch time . Good ambiance there's seating space to eat in or take to go. Haven't been here in a while but today reminded me why this place is worth stopping by!

I'm have been getting pizza here since my childhood. Hadn't been in a while so decided to stop in…read morefor a slice. Still decently priced considering the economy. Got one plain slice and took it to go. Good service has always been my experience even when they are busy. There is space to sit inside. Has a small parking lot and there is street parking.

Angelo's Pizza & Pasta

3.4

(96 reviews)