Master Pizza is my go to local pizza place. It is located on a busy road so the parking can sometimes be a bit difficult, but I usually never have any issues. In the nicer months they have some outside tables and plenty of tables inside. The service is always great! They have a pretty big food menu and also many different options for pizza types. They always have specials going on as well. I have not tried many of the different food options as I typically opt for some of the many different slice options they have out on the counter. They always have a wide array of different slices, and I have never had a bad slice. They definitely have some of my favorite specialty slices in the area. The prices are pretty good too for how filling the slices are. read more

Master Pizza - Eggplant Parm - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

It's a small tight space this place put out some good pizza. Very clean service is friendly and did I say good pizza?

Such a nice surprise today! Took 2 slices home, I have an air fryer and both were great. White slice not too much garlic. Plain slice pure and crispy. If I lived closer I'd be a regular. Look forward to visiting again, what a nice staff. I'll check out the meals yall patrons are bitching about later. Peace and Love. read more

They shouldn't even call themselves a pizza place. I ordered a pizza for the first and last time, and the dough was so soft and chewy, like it was undercooked. There was no crunch to the crust at all. Just save yourself the trip. read more

Really good cheesy garlic knots for a quick bite if you are in the area. Parling isn't great but if you find a spot go try them.

Gotta update my Master Pizza review! Master Pizza has become our local go to spot for pizza. Their pizza is always top notch and if my kids are being picky I know they will at least eat a slice of Master Pizza. The inside of the restaurant is still super cute and charming and every time I go the customer service is always so kind. Everyone is very friendly and accommodating. And they put up with my last minute request of, "can you make the plainest piece of grilled chicken for my daughter because that's what she apparently wants now, not pizza." Oh, and their pasta is great too! The prices are right and like someone stated below, they sponsor our local kids rec programs and I think that's so wonderful. My daughter played on the Master Pizza softball team last year and she thought she was the coolest person ever. Thanks Master Pizza for making it super easy to order last minute food in Carlstadt! read more

We are always pleased with what we order from Master. They are consistent with the quality of ingredients they use. The only issue I've found is that lately, my ability to get my "xtras" with my online orders is gone. Maybe I'm missing something? If you don't pay with cash, the fee increased a bit. Sorry, but I'm feeding 6 of us at a time, and the bill is at least $80! Credit is my friend.... All in all, we will stay with our Chicken/Pear salads, Buffalo Chicken Wraps, Pizzas, and Buttered Orecchiette. We love our delivery people, always so great! Thank you! read more

Solid, solid, solid all around. We made it to the Carlstadt location on a Sunday night. Parking is street parking on a fairly busy road but there also parking on the side streets. So not horrendous. We called our order in and all went smooth and our order was ready upon arrival. Of course, we got the Buffalo Chicken pie for the kid. I snuck a slice and they did it right. Kicking it up a step like few places do with even the slices of celery on top amongst the blue cheese dressing. Crust was slightly chewy but that's always subjective based on one's personal preference. We also got the Brooklyn Square. Perfectly cooked, the sauce was very good. Nice kick to it. The best part about it was that you got a little hit in the taste buds with the provolone mixed with the mozzarella. You gotta be a provolone fan, which I am, so it was very addicting. Only thing was it was slightly floppy but it's obvious because it was sitting in its own steam during a 15 -20 minutes drive back to my town. It would've been VERY crispy if we ate it there. You just know. I also got the Pompeii Wrap which was AWESOME. Grilled chicken, sundried tomatoes, arugula, mozz with a balsamic glaze. Extremely tasty and the mixture of the arugula with sundried tomatoes brought it in for the extra point. Don't snooze on this place. Worth going to all day long. read more

See all

Oh my lanta this place blew my mind and AJ is the sweetest guy! Caesar salad, garlic cheese rolls, and a drunken b'npmna w chicken. It was the most delicious pizza I've ever eaten! Way to go And the place is SUPER clean read more

I've been ordering from them for some time for pizza. last couple times {2} that it's been different. pizza I received today had a ri amount of cheese and watery sauce the actual dough was so soaked it was terrible it was also like it was undercooked. no crust so disappointed that they would deliver a pie like that. whoever cooked it had to know... The pizza was not worth it. will not order anymore from there. which is a shame but it's obvious they didn't care for a good customers order. read more

First time I ordered today from here. Pizza was spot on, I ordered a pastrami sandwich and it was delicious and tasty! Will definitely order again to try the asparagus soup! read more

One of my favorite local pizza joints. Their food is really solid from their pizzas to their pastas. I appreciate that my food is always ready at their recommended time frame when I go to pick it up. There's nothing worse than going to pick up food and having to wait a long time because they mistimed their preparation. Their packaging is solid too...no cheap/flimsy materials that could cause leeks or stains. They have a good variety of specialty pizzas and their pastas are well-cooked and have good flavor to them. My personal favorite is their bolognese pasta. The sauce is a bit different than traditional, but packed with flavor. The prices are extremely fair compared to other places as well. The one critique I would have is their execution on some of their pizzas. I don't know if it's an issue of them not cooking the pizza long enough, but I've gone home to find all the toppings/sauce scattered everywhere in the box, which makes for a less than ideal eating experience. Overall a great option for pizza and pasta! read more

Always happy with their pizza. I order it well to ensure it's nice and perfect. Staff is always friendly

The staff are very friendly and made my day! And it's sometimes small things like that that can mean a lot to people. The food is surprisingly fun and original, high quality, tastes great and reasonably priced. I've ordered a Nona pizza (square thin crust) as well as cauliflower and a personal bolognese, all great. Arugula salad was crunchy and fresh. For what it's worth 5/5 for staple pizza and fun food. read more

Master Pizza - Bolognese Pizza! 10" Bolognese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

Master Pizza is very hit or miss. Not sure why it seems to be that way. We have ordered pizzas, salads, wraps, and fried appetizers from here. Featured is one of the wraps that we enjoyed. This is the "Bella Vista Wrap". It contains grilled chicken, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sundried tomato, and arugula. I added broccoli too. read more

Master Pizza - Bella Vista Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

great local spot with indoor and outdoor seating. they even gave great pizza boxes to take home slices! very fair prices! sicilian slice was okay - my date and i each had one and felt it was sitting out for a little too long. i had the chicken teriyaki slice, which was loaded with chicken! this was very good! i will say, its a 1 and done for me. the sauce is thick and intense. the penne slice was a hit. creamy vodka sauce flavor, with perfectly cooked penne. it hit the spot. the cheesy knot was good too - not too crispy & the marinara sauce it came with was VERY garlic forward. would come back? yes. read more

Ordered pizza for lunch via Uber eats. I ordered the 16 in cheese pizza and 6 garlic knots. The pizza was good, it satisfied my cravings. The garlic knots were chewy but good. Nothing really stood out but no complaints either. read more

Master Pizza - 16" cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

Its good pizza service was good had it delivered Love the pizza box haven't try everything but seems like thy do a good job fresh food clean so I try again read more

I'm always a sucker for a place with a great name.  'Master Pizza' - you can't toot your horn too much more than that, right?  And they're only about five minutes away from 'Liquor Master' on Rt 17S.  (How these two businesses haven't synergically teamed up yet is beyond me.)  And what's not to love when you're looking at their menu on-line and see: "Garlic Bread is served with Garlic, Bread" and that they sell garlic knots starting quantity 3 going all the way up to 96?!  Sold and... sold! Went with the usuals: plain pie, garlic knots (only 6, 96 seemed a bit... excessive). First visit and everything was just... fine.  (The pie was a bit smaller than expected for a 'grande'.) A few months later we tried them again with some different items (including the kids' first time trying jalapeno poppers since they're currently obsessed with the show 'A Good Place' and poppers being Jason's favorite food when he was alive) and it was all... fine.  (My issues the last time being that the cheese on the pizza and inside the poppers seemed barely melted - like they could've used a few more minutes in the oven.  And the garlic knots are just too big and lacking in pop and flavor.) Inside of the store is clean, has a cool look.  Staff are friendly.  (Unfortunately none of the food has wowed us and we'd probably go elsewhere in the future for our weekly pizza-fix.) read more

AMAZING PIZZA GREat staff The sauce is one of a kind I come here atleast 2 t a week read more

my local spot! wide selection! these guys sponsor our local schools, can't beat that. my daughter is a pizza snob, and loves it here! we will be comin as long as they're here read more

This is a wonderful place yes corner I'm big suspended perfect romantic love it Friendly people, Love is pizza I love the pizza I love the pizza I love the pizza I love the pizza read more

Master Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

The pizza is on the chewier side but it still taste great. The garlic knots were soft and fun to eat. read more

Master Pizza - 16" cheese pizza with garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

This pizzeria has a nice setting with movable glass doors that allow you to enjoy a nice breeze. They do have some outdoor seating although it's tight so you could only fit 3 chairs. The staff was very friendly as-well but the pizza is just average. read more

Master Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

Master Pizza is to Carlstadt what Sal's on the Corner is to Ramsey -- the place to be if you care about good pizza. When I logged on to yelp.com and saw that Master Pizza (hitherto, MP) had a less than four-star rating I said, "Fuggeddaboutit!" MP is very delicious, and you can take that one to the bank! Here's how to order from Master's Pizza; it's a little bit different than your run o' the mill pizza joint, but honestly I think their system makes more sense and should be adopted nation-wide. First, you dial a number and wait until somebody picks up and says, "Master Pizza, please hold." Then they put you on hold for a little while, at which point you will listen to their hold message, where a boy or a man (I'm not sure) runs through a list of food items that you can order. He won't respond to anything that you say, but you can still pretend like you're talking to someone. Then someone else will come back on the phone, and you can place your order, by saying, "Imma need the Clams Oreganata, extra clam sauce. And make that medium well." And viola you just ordered from MP! The only complaint I have is that Master Pizza hasn't competed in a pizza making contest against Sal from Sal's on the Corner. Who would win that battle? Everybody. read more

See all

Mac N Chz w bacon personal pizza was excellent off their special lunch menu today. I was happy it wasn't dry. Love their daily lunch specials. Just looking forward to indoor/outdoor dining upon so I can eat there. Note: a little under cooked. Had to put in the convection oven when I got home. read more

Master Pizza - Mac and Cheese Pizza With bacon - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

I have ordered from the catering menu all time in the past. This time, I asked if the shrimp came with pasta. I also asked how many people a half tray would feed. They told me 8-10 ppl. I heard that it does come with pasta. After I got it, there was no side of pasta and the shrimp is definitely not enough for 6 people. Maybe 4 at most, probably more like 3 . This half tray at 50 dollars isn't worth it. It's probably better to just order two dishes of this because it does come with shrimp and pasta. Plus, I was charged a delivery fee and about 3 dollars for using a credit card. When I called back they told me that they said it didn't come with pasta. That there was nothing they could do. All in all, at $60+ for this small tray, I will not be ordering from this place again. read more

Great food , no complaints on the food ordered .. only concerns are the delivery staff... I had a delivery driver smelled horrible.( hygeine wise ). I was watching him from lobby. Struggiling swinging my bag of food pants falling .. if delivering food should be presentable!!! Swinging my bag of food into the lobby very just sloppy presentation.. overall food was well.... next time in area at hotel hope to have better delivery staff Kids were happy with pizza all that matters read more

Love This place. Regular cheese pizza is the best around. Been going here for years. Live in NJ and have eaten at all pizzerias

Update, and lowered rating: I just picked up a sausage and mushroom stromboli from them because it's late and they're close by, and instead of a hearty portion of mozzarella in there like every other place on the planet, they put... french fries?! I mean, there's a LITTLE bit of mozzarella in there, maybe? Not even sure, to be honest. But clumps of sausage, mini mushrooms, and I kid you not there's french fries. Seriously, why did I give them a second try? I should've just gone to Wendy's. Still great decor, but... french fries in stromboli instead of lots of mozzarella??? Did I miss a meeting or something? Not going to bother calling them to get it right. Not gonna waste the food, I'm eating it, but this does not taste good. Never going back. read more

Master Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

This place has forgotten the pizza and the last time they forgot garlic knots. I called to ask what's up and they said they'll send it out. I spoke to the supervisor and asked if it was an issue they commonly have, maybe they just don't like me because then he threatened to not send the garlic knots I'd already paid for. Most probably just bad management. Will likely have to find another pizza place. Beware if you order, might be waiting for cold food they left behind cause they forgot, and don't complain cause they'll give you attitude and act like your anger is unjustified and say you're "raising your voice" when they're talking over you and not answering your simple inquiry. Update: 27 minutes later I received the garlic knots with a sinister smiley drawn on the bag. No thanks. Update to marylee: I, a person who's been in the service industry close to a decade, never called anyone stupid, OR an idiot, you and the other person who answered on google need to get together and decide if I called them idiots or called them stupid. I never did either. But judging from the customer service and recent reviews you guys are losing customers by droves. Also no it wasn't handled that day, I was however threatened to never recieve something I paid for. Also I've orders about four times. Never has a smiley been drawn in any bag, that was clearly your supervisor showing attitude as he did on the phone. Good day. As an owner you should be careful, your bad customer service being given by supervisors and staff who don't care will make you lose your business. If you don't fix it, hope to see your windows boarded up soon. Not that I'll be ordering from you liars again. If you order from here. You will be eating dinner angry and cold at some point, save yourself the trouble, order elsewhere. read more

Master Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

Over fried zucchini sticks to the point that zucchini disappeared, oily and nasty, the Italian sandwich was dry and had no flavor whatsoever with yesterday's bread, chicken wings were ok. I would not recommend this place at all. Stay away read more

Master Pizza - Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

I usually order their eggplant rollatini , or calzone, but my favorite is their Buffalo calamari ! I love this pizza place even though I never order pizza lol read more

Its great I love it more than any other pizza it's crunchy delicious fine juicy it's probably the best place I've been

Not only is the food here great, so is Edson!! :) best pizza around and great lunch specials

10 stars !!! DELICIOSO !!! Love my local pizza over ANY chain restaurant!! Bring back the Mac n cheese pizza ! great staff, friendly and FAST !!! Love this place ! read more

Horrible! Where do I start? I picked up 2 slices on my way home from work & they were absolutely disgusting! Tasted as if the slices were sitting out for about a week & they just heated them up before placing them in the pizza box. They didn't taste fresh & they tasted hard. Nasty! & Even though the place is tiny, There were about 50 flies flying around inside. I will definitely not spend another Dime in that place. Ever. read more

Carlstadt.. They deserve zero Stars!!!!! The worst food ever and so over priced !!! I ordered a cheese steak sandwich with fries and a pizza pinwheel. $30!! The cheesesteak had a terrible smell and the steak looked old! Absolutely disgusting! The fries were just awful.. tasted like freezer burn. The pinwheel dough was raw through and through even after I threw it in the covectional oven!!! Never again!!! I should have gotten back in my car and brought this garbage back to them!!! $30 in the trash!!! You would think with their prices, their food would be phenomenal... well, on the contrary!! Just horrible!!!! read more

It is just not good. I ordered wings and they come breaded. Every other pizza place I have eaten at specifies breaded wings from regular wings but here they only have breaded which is not what I wanted. I also ordered a turkey club wrap and it comes with lettuce and tomato. They put the wrap in a panini press AFTER adding lettuce and tomato so the entire wrap was a large soggy mess that was falling apart right after I ordered it. Idk why they would even toast a turkey wrap without asking if that is what I wanted. Just weird & gross idk anyone who enjoys hot lettuce and tomato and hot mayo on a soggy wrap. Never coming back. read more

I have to agree with all the other reviews about how this place took a turn. I don't know if there is a new chef but the pizza I usually order is great and the slices I got recently were barely cooked and so oily. Honestly the staff is usually not that friendly when I go, but I'm giving three stars because a male employee made sure I was being helped this time. read more