Have tried this place three times and came away disappointed each time. Customer service and staff are unhelpful at best, prices are surprisingly unreasonable, and most importantly, the pizza is uniformly awful. Tasteless hard crust, gooey bland cheese, and spicy sloppy sauce. Don't understand how they're still in business - lack of competition in the neighborhood, I guess. Would avoid. Try takeout at Ella's or Pi in Chinatown for higher quality pizza (at a similar price) or just order Papa John's... read more

I ordered a pizza and it arrived about an hour late. Ok, things happen, I can forgive it. The quality of the pizza was very subpar. They got the toppings wrong and when I called them about it they put me on hold for about 7 minutes and made it clear that they didn't want to deal with me. The pizza looked shrunken and was not that great. They did offer to bring me a new pizza which was pretty cool. Overall a below average experience that received an extra star for offering a pizza replacement. There are better options in the Logan circle/Cheights area. Not sure how they managed to be the top pizza place on grubhub. read more

Great flavor in the crust, toppings, and sauces. Creative specialty pizzas. Friendly and quick staff in a convenient location.

Everything was terrible including the 2hr delivery, cold/hard/greasy pizza, horrible customer service and lack of response from store management. If you want good pizza in DC, go to We the Pizza or WiseGuys Pizza for much better food and quality of service. read more

First time in Washington DC and we found this pizza place close to our hotel room. The best pizza we have ever had!!!! It was all hand made and from scratch. Great place to get the BEST pizza!! read more

I was searching for pizza near me and I didn't have to look far! It was delicious and everything I could ask for! Not too greasy and just the right amount of cheese. If you ever need pizza near Washington DC come here! read more

It's a small independently owned pizza joint nestled into a neighborhood off Logan Circle. Service, prices and cleanliness get five stars, and the pasta is good for the price. I do carry out, which works for me since I live close by, so I haven't experienced the delivery side of things like some other folks here. But I've stopped ordering pizza for delivery since discovering this place. The pizza is hit and miss...either good or meh, which is the only thing that kept me from giving this place a 5. read more

First time Ordering from or eating Pizzoli's Pizza BAD: Waited an hour for the pizza (added a note to ask the driver to call so I could meet out front as I live in a multiple unit building; driver was not going to call-good thing I walked out to look for them; driver then told me they don't deliver to my area. . . then why did you let me order delivery??? I had no clue I was out of their delivery area. I tipped extra since apparently I am out of the delivery area) Realizing traffic in DC is a pain this would normally not have lowered the rating. Ordered a pizza with portabella mushrooms, caramelized onions, bacon, and alfredo sauce. It arrived with no alfredo sauce so that means it was a pizza without cheese or sauce since I was attempting to do both in one ingredient. Ordered a salad- some lettuce had brown spots, not a big deal if the pizza is right. Called to report my order was wrong. . . Guy that answered the phone was beyond rude. He told me that he made the pizza himself and that there was alfredo sauce on it. I asked what their alfredo sauce was (some places have different versions) and he responded alfredo sauce and then hung up. Really??? Where is the customer service?? Annoyed that I basically had bread with ingredients on it which does not make a pizza, so I decided to drive down (which took me a very long time in traffic) GOOD: Lady at the counter was really nice. Asked her if it looked like there was alfredo sauce on the pizza and she said no. She then proceeded to order me another one even making suggestions to make it better. Thank you for being helpful and fixing a mistake. Driver actually came to the front and thanked me for the few extra bucks. Thank you for realizing it wasn't my fault or yours that the order went through when it was outside the delivery area. Another male employee apologized that the order was wrong. Overall: Horrible phone experience. I shouldn't have had to drive down to fix the issue nor should he have hung up on me. Ended up being about 2.5 hours until I was sitting at home eating the pizza. However, excellent in store customer service which is why this review is a 3 instead of a 1. PIZZA The pizza was good -- not the best I've ever had but definitely not the worst. 6 or 7 on a scale of 1 to 10, but remember I waited 2.5 hours to eat and it was 930 on a weekday night by the time I got to eat. The caramelized onions were really good, as was the alfredo sauce and mushrooms. I prefer my bacon cooked more, but this may have been a side effect of an attempt to fill my order quickly. May go back if I am driving by and I'm able to find paring. I am a delivery person, so since I'm out of the delivery area the chances of return are less without using a delivery service. read more

Order this place late night after the bars. Decent delivery time and good service. Excellent pizza!

I used to order from them years ago.Delievery car could use a cleaning on the inside.Not even parked and I tip him 5 bucks as well.Opened the box up and it looked like as though he turned the Pizza Box upside down as he was driving.#pizzasoup Almost 30 U.S Dollars for this and the manager said "I will let him know for next time" These guys are way too comfortable taking hard earned cash in exchange for bad service. read more

WOW! I picked this place cause it's right across the street from a jobsite I'm working on. I had no idea what I was walking into. As I bit into my first "hot" wing, my eyes stole in excitement as these things pack the perfect heat to taste ratio I've ever experienced in my life. 4 stars for 5 AMAZING wings. read more

Gave this place a try since it's right around the corner--great gourmet style pizza with high quality toppings.

My husband and I just finished our first Pizzolis experience. We kept it simple and just ordered a hand-tossed pepperoni pizza. It was excellent! The sauce and pepperoni were delicious and the amount of cheese (fresh mozzarella) was perfect. The best part was the crust. It was soft and flavorful, containing italian seasonings, parmesan and garlic (our best guess of what we were tasting). My husband even went so far as to say it was the best delivery/take-out pizza he's had in DC. We will definitely order from Pizzolis again. read more

Ordered for 20 at work today. It was a hit with everyone. We are excited to add Pizzoli's to our rotation.

Not exactly NY style, but tasty sweetish sauce, great toppings & good crust. Far better than the usual run of DC pizza and it fills a gap in the Logan Circle area. read more

I had tried Pizzoli's once prior, the pizza was quite good. Ordered a medium pepperoni last Sunday and it was delivered burnt and cold. No one noticed that the pie was burnt! Removing the bookmark for Pizzoli's. And the pizza was $20! read more

... is a delightful owner operated non chain pizza, sandwich & salad neighborhood joint. They use local produce and organic produce (what other pizza delivery place does that??). Really tasty food! Buy local! Also, the meatballs are delightful! read more

These guys are good enough that they are on my iPhone faves list, right under my best friend. I like that their pizza sauce is not your average red sauce - it's got a little bite to it, some spice, and very hearty. The pepperoni pizza never disappoints and I think the mozzarella sticks are 10/10. The delivery guy is always super friendly, the order arrives fast, and they know my address and order even before I get the words out. read more

This is the BEST vegan pizza I've ever eaten! I recently went there with my friend and her children and we ordered a pizza with olive and artichoke and another with mushroom and eggplant. The best thing about the pizza was the flavor! The eggplant was actually seasoned which is definitely not usually the case. The crust was delicious and the ingredients were very fresh. The owner and staff were really nice too. Definitely found a return customer. read more

ordered delivery strombolis and wings tonight, couldn't be happier. well, the hot wings could have been hotter, but I'll just order extra hot next time. read more

This place was kinda on my "eh, if I have to" list UNTIL I realized it has vegan cheese! $22 for a large pizza, 8 nice slices with eggplant, peppers and caramelized onions. Would return w a group. Nice staff, typical carry out atmosphere. Picnic tables outside. Really quick actually, 10-15 minute wait at 11:30 on a Saturday. They have Ben and Jerrys ice cream and vegan kinds "in the back" (hoping it's true!) read more

Someone actually responded saying if I order again it will be just as bad. I didn't ask for anything "free" not sure if they even understand English now. Thanks for warning me not to order a second time. You're right - bad is bad and if you duped me once, you'll dupe me again! read more

Review of Pizzolis on 12th st, nw dc. I have only ordered from this place twice and never again. The first time I ordered a small cheese pizza and a coke zero, simple enough. I live only about five blocks from them on the same street. I waited an hour and 45 minutes for my pizza. I am a patient person but that was really pushing it. I swore to never order from here again. However, when the delivery person came, he was nice and gave me some excuse that something was wrong with one of the ovens. He assured me that he was their only driver and that next time he will make sure my pizza comes fast and he will throw in some free stuff. I said ok to giving them a second chance (i mean really, who says no to free food lol). I ordered again today, the same as last time, a small cheese pizza and a coke zero. They did a good job on coming on time. However, one, it was a different delivery guy (ay there goes my free food) and two, they brought me regular coke instead of coke zero. Lastly, the guy didn't even have enough change for my $20! Wtf, how are you a delivery guy with not enough change. Anyway, he got to walk a way with $2, which I wouldn't mind giving as tip if it wasn't by force and my order wasn't screwed up, but it was. I also told him I did not want the regular coke and told him to take it off the bill and he said he wasn't able to do that. After discussing with him for five minutes that it wasn't what I ordered, he reduced the charge and took the coke back. Their pizza is decent but def not worth the hassle of wrong food delivered to you. They need to stop smoking so much green and make a correct and timely order for once. The delivery guy came back an hour later to give me my coke zero free of charge and a dessert after I spoke with the gentlemen who took my order. Too late. They lost my business. Trust me, save yourself the trouble and don't get delivery from them. read more

I'm pretty much just rating this a zero for the girl that answered the phone when I called to ask how much longer for my order, and she hung up on me. read more

This place has won me over! I've ordered deliveries here twice in the past week and I've been delightfully surprised each time. The vegan cheese wasn't the gastronomic monstrosity I was imagining. It didn't detract from the pizza at all. They didn't go thin on the sauce nor skimp on the veggies. The pies were filling and definitely worth the value! Try this place! read more

Absolutely the Best Pizza in DC! Closest thing to Neopolitan pizza this side of Atlantic. Hand tossed dough with puffy edges and All Fresh toppings. Delivery is fast - always hot. My only pizza place read more

OMG I love love love their gigantic pizza! Their food is so delish I can't even beging to tell you! Everything I've had from here has been perfect! read more

Was going to order from them even though they seem overpriced but they called me back and told me that even though my address is within their delivery zone they would only deliver if I gave them an extra large tip because they didn't want to come to my address. They were incredibly rude when they made this call and felt the standard 15-20% tip would not be enough to deliver to my house. read more

Decent pizza but TERRIBLE staff. Complete and total incompetence. They can't take an order AND the manager is mean and charges for Parmesan!!! Awful. read more

Was hoping to like this place, unfortunately I found their customer service to be underwhelming and wasn't able to enjoy food.

Food is mediocre at best, but if you're in the neighborhood OK. The owner just doesn't make it worth it if you're looking for any customer service or humanity. Most unfriendly person I've ever met. read more

We ordered delivery from Pizzolis and while the delivery was prompt, our order was incomplete and the food that we did get is not even good. We ordered a salad, but it wasn't included in our order. The supposed "boneless" wings we ordered are actually chicken tenders that they cut in half. The chicken is also drier than dry, so dry that the sauce doesn't even help. In addition, we ordered waffle fries and spicy fries that aren't even crispy, or spicy in the case of the spicy fries. Our total order was a little over $50 bucks, you'd think we'd at least get decent food for that price. Overall, I'm not satisfied and will not order from here again. read more

This place had so many vegan options it almost made my head explode! I couldn't believe that this place replaced all cheese with a vegan alternative upon request. Unfortunately, the garlic-herb pizza sauce is not vegan, but the roasted eggplant most definitely is and is a great addition to every pizza!-Veg on read more

3 stars because the pizza was okay. Nothing new. Just okay I guess. Now, the gyro platter is absolutely horrible! I had it a few weeks ago and had a bad experience. I was late to pick it up and I thought maybe that's why my lamb meat was so hard and cold. Today, I decided to give it another try. Hence I'm a big gyro eater. Well, I got to Pizzoli's to pick it up but it wasn't done yet. Here I think to myself "fantastic! Nice and hot!". Im soo disappointed again. :( the lamb was dry, chewy and nasty. The tzaziki was soooo artificial. Tasted like plain yogurt. The pita, oh my goodness. -___- it's was the stalest thing ever! Overall I hated it. The only thing I enjoyed was the hummus. Sorry Pizzoli's , you've failed to please me. read more

Really good pizza. Very small place. There's just one tiny table inside, but we were lucky enough to go there by chance on an unseasonably warm December day and we were able to sit comfortably on the patio outside. My seven year old thought it was "the best pizza ever". I'm not sure I'd go that far, but it was definitely way above average. read more

I live in Brookland and my normal pizza place was closed. So I searched the interwebs for a replacement joint to fill my cravings. Pizzoli's had some good reviews, but Logan Circle seemed a little distant from my apartment. A little skeptical, I go on the website to order and to my surprise and shock the website says their delivery zone stretches all the way to Hyattsville, MD. Alright, cool. Less than thirty minutes later a delivery guy is at my door, but he tells me they won't deliver to me again because Pizzoli's is in NW and I'm too far away (about 3 miles). Too bad. Pizza was good, better than my usual place even. read more

Ordered late on a Sunday night and the pizzas came quickly and as ordered. The thin crust was very good and the sauce was flavorful. Just got two pizzas (both thin crust with the traditional red sauce, one with pepperoni and the other with pineapple). Haven't tried anything else there yet. However, the pizzas were tasty and I'm sure I'll order again. read more

I ordered the margarita pizza with pepperoni and it was excellent! The sauce tasted like it came fresh from the vine tomatoes and the buffalo mozzarella was very tasty. I rarely write Yelp reviews, but this was too good not to do so! Very very pleased and have been back twice since. read more

Tasted really good both was bummed that the large was pretty small. Idk if they messed up the order or if that is how it is, but plan for a small pizza according to my experience. read more

I don't know what pizza some of these reviewers ate, but I just waited about an hour and a half for Pizzoli's to deliver, only to end up incredibly disappointed. Pizza was awful. Definitely not ordering from here again. read more