Wasn't sure what to expect because the place used to be called Critter's but since we visit Torch Lake every summer, we thought we would give it a try. This is a hidden gem!! First of all, Friday night is fish night (a platter of shrimp, cod, walleye, and perch, fried and salad/coleslaw) and Saturday night is prime rib night. My hubs and I split the basket and ordered an extra salad. It was plenty. Their blue cheese and ranch are homemade and exceptionally delicious!! The variety on the menu is wide...no website to see the menu but you can check on Google or FB. All the fish was fresh (like bones in the walleye), all the fish was hand battered/dipped, and none of the fish was greasy. Shrimp were good size and the cocktail sauce was great. French fries were hot.
The service was very quick and server was knowledgeable. Food came out quickly even though it was fairly crowded (though we didn't have to wait. Waiter came back to check on us. Our bill with the seafood platter (4 shrimp, large walleye, 1large cod, 2 small perch, 1 coleslaw, upgrade salad (extra 3.00 and 1 beer) totaled 40.00 which included tip. Ambience is low key and extremely casual. Long bar in the back, pinball machines, pool table and outdoor area. going back to try several things. FYI biker night on Wednesdays. read more