They were mean to me. And they lied about a lot of stuff too. It used to be better before these new workers came in too.

Rocky's has a great cheese pie! Picked one up in a hurry for dinner one night and was pleasantly surprised. The sauce was delicious, thin crust and just the right amount of cheese. The interior of this place could use a little facelift but the staff is friendly and efficient. I'll definitely stop by to grab a pie in the future. read more

Regular neighborhood pizzeria. Pizza fair. Ordered shrimp parm hero: fresh bread, good sauce, scant shrimp. Place is good for me because it's in walking distance of home. read more

I had only been to this pizza place once in my life. And that was 11 years ago when my son-in-law's father reserved the whole building. We went there after my daughter and son-in-law's had their rehearsal at the church. And that was the best pizza I had ever had since I moved to Florida. But could not remember how to get there or the name of it. until last week when I carried my childhood friend to Flagler Beach. She came down from Tennessee for a week and I just looked up as we were walking. And I looked at the outside and I knew that had to be the pizza place. So I ordered a pizza and OMG that was it. So now that's my go to place for the best pizza. read more

I would say their food is average. Pizza is okay, not the best I've ever had but always does the job. We've ordered delivery a bunch of times and have never had any issue. read more

Rocky's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

After passing this place numerous times, we finally made our way over to here. From the outside, it's like a time capsule. Very simple and probably hasn't changed since it's opening day. Which was 1979 after speaking to the guy inside. I absolutely loved the simplicity of the decor. Now I'm usually not a fan of thick crust pizza but for whatever reason, after looking at the menu, I went with the Deep Dish Chicken Vodka Pie, Buffalo Chicken pie as usual, wings for the kids and a small meatball parm hero. The chicken Vodka Pie was excellent. Sauce was extremely tasty, as was the crust. I loved it. My wife felt that the chicken pieces was too big but I disagree. I thought it was great. The large pieces of breaded chicken was great. Buffalo Chicken pie was also on point. I asked him to hit it with some ranch as our son lives ranch on his Buffalo Chicken. Wings were also very good. The sauce was not overpowering and the chicken was very tasty. Meatball parm was better than I was expecting. It's very hard to get a good sandwich from a Pizzeria. The roll was just a little too big for the sandwich. The meatball itself was good and the sauce was excellent. The lighting on my pictures unfortunately don't do it justice but this place is definitely worth a try. Yo Adrian, you did it! read more

See all

My family and I have been a resident in Nutley for 3 decades, and we absolutely loved (past tense) Rocky's Pizza. We ordered a gluten free pie for pickup as my father has celiac disease. When my brother went inside to pick it up, the staff behind the counter was very rude. The worker behind the counter was insistent that there "was no such order and we're mistaken". My brother was very kind, and said he did place an order and showed the charge on his credit card and the call log. He even expressed that he was more than willing to wait, as it was busy that day. After waiting 20 minutes, the order was "found" on the counter with other orders. Seems that it was misplaced and there was no communication. I understand that customers are not always right, but a simple "I'm sorry" would've been nice. Instead my brother was given attitude and had the order thrown at him. Fix your attitude or blow off some steam in the back freezer, not to customers who were more than understanding of the situation. read more

I visite this quaint little place yesterday I ordered lentil soup Buffalo wings and a large cheese pizza! My family enjoyed everything I most liked the soup and I am always looking for a place that has soup and this place has like four kinds of soup! I will be coming back the staff was awesome Mike was so nice !!! read more

Better to eat in. Delivery for me has been very long & arrives cold. I Had a chicken parm sub that was pitiful. High school lunch spot. Place is clean and their eat in slices are the way to go. read more

Came here for a quick dinner with Boo Boo. I order the large chicken cutlet sandwich and she got a plain slice. The slice was just okay. The cheese and sauce was very bland but the crust was really good a crusty. My sandwich was huge but the bread was like the wonderbread of sub rolls. It was soft and tasteless. The chicken was season good but I loaded it with a lot of red pepper flakes and garlic powder. Everything was about $15. Very reasonable price. Decent food but I wouldn't go jonesin to dine here. SQ machine so cc accepted. read more

Rocky's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Chicken cutlet sub - Pizza Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Simply,,,,great old fashioned Pizza.The sandwiches fall onto the same ballpark. I enjoyed it emencely.

What happened to Rocky's pizza? Paid $14 for a plain pie with a flat dough crust and a taste one step up from Ellio's frozen. After going to Rocky's for decades, being from Belleville, something is majorly amiss here.Won't be returning to this risk this again. Called to express our disappointment without criticism, but rather to ask "What's wrong ?" and got the equivalent of a shrug. Try Wawa or, even 7-11 and at least save a few bucks. read more

Delicious pizza both plain and pepperoni pies are yummy!! The one little thing was only it was a little bit oily but it wasn't a big deal. Thin pizza and crust and very tasteful!! Yum! read more

Absolutely loved it! Everything came out Hot and Fresh. Staff was super friendly, and the Food came out quick!! Id come here again, food was amazing. read more

Rocky's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Buffalo wings and Fries - Pizza Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

My family & I love to try different things in Rocky's menu so far everything we have ordered was excellent!!

Very disappointed. Just ordered the Eggplant Rollatini Baked Dish (not the appetizer) to pick up. I knew there might be a problem when I called and the kid I placed the order with (though pleasant) asked me how to spell "Rollatini". Let's go in and see how pick-up goes... Nice man preparing pizzas called someone over to check me out. The guy checking me out never told me which order was mine and there were orders strewn all over the cash register area in a very haphazard manner. Also, when the guy rudely says to me, "This one is yours; I thought I told ya." I certainly didn't think it was mine due to the puny size, nor am I familiar with Rocky's disorganized pick-up procedure as I've never been there before and will never return for that matter; sorry, cashier guy. Let's get this "treasure" home and see how that goes... Again, unsatisfactory portion size and must have been the appetizer size (or maybe even TWO appetizer portions slapped together, God help us!) and not even a damned hunk of bread, pasta, or salad to go with it. Talk about an Italian sacrilege! I can understand perhaps charging a small additional fee for the salad, but undoubtedly bread and pasta needs to be provided for what I ordered and expected; a DINNER-size portion. We are lucky enough to live in a part of the country where Italian restaurants are a-dime-a-dozen. Don't put up with this place unless you like being almost as hungry after you eat a meal at Rocky's as you were before. read more

I used to go there on my way home every day. It's bad enough that the pizza got worse, now basically some salty dough. No love or care goes into this pizza. That's bad enough, like I said. What's worse is having to deal with the surly attitude, the right wing Q anon talk radio constantly in the background and did I already say the bad attitude? The bad attitude. I have other choices in town. read more

I'm so happy to get good pizza again! I grew up with a great pizza place, Turiellos, in Nyack NY. That became my gold standard for pizza. Then I lived in Astoria/Woodside Queens for a decade. And I never found even a decent standard pizza place there. So when I moved to Nutley, a largely Italian neighborhood, I was hopeful that I'd find great pizza again. After a few misfires (Ralphs being one of them) we found Rockys. And I'm so glad I did! It's the best slice of straight up pizza I've had in town. The reheated slices I've had from Rockys have been better than the pies I've had delivered. It seems like perhaps they rush the deliveries. So the pie hasn't quite gelled yet, and it arrives a bit soggy, with the cheese sloshed about. It's still good, but not great. But by the slice, truly, it's one of the best I've had. read more

Great pizza and environment. Really nice place. The cheese pizza I got was great. George is super helpful. Its in a great area too.

Fantastic small business. Pizza that reminds me of my old neighborhood on the lower east side. But most of all, excellent customer service. When ever there's been a misunderstanding on an order, they've done everything to make it right. A customer for life! Check'em out. read more

Amazing food ! Amazing staff we recommend Rockys- we've over the years tried everything on the menu !! Today we went with the pizza and was delicious read more

Found myself craving pizza... but in Nutley... New Jersey? I will hush my mouth now. What a fantastic slice! They have a lot of specially/gourmet pizzas by the slice. I had the penne a la vodka (a double carb whammie) and the cheese steak slice cuz I never have pizza concoctions like that. They heat up well and taste fresh. Friend had the buffalo chicken slice it said it was great. I'll def be back and try out some other Italian dishes and see how they measure up. Go Rocky's read more

Rocky's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

I was about to go in and get pizza until I saw the employee smoking outside and then walk in and go behind the counter without even washing his hands. I watched as he used those same dirty hands to pick up pizza for a customer. This place looks skeevy so I won't be trying their food ever. read more

I have had a place in this area for quite some time now I really like the pizza Normally I like to go inside and sit down Great calamari Salads Thier no alcoholic drink selection is great! The young guys who work here are very friendly. The servings are very big But there are a lot of Italian and pizza places in this area, I like this one most, the decor is what a jersey 80's pizza parlour should look like Parking is fine, this is the first time I'm ordering delivery read more

I called in an order to eat there a large well done pizza I was only a few minutes away when I got there it was already ready and it looked and tasted horrible, he must of had a pie lying around then reheated it I couldn't even eat tasted like card board with dried out sauce and cheese took the remainder basically threw it out . The soup I ordered escarole and bean was also garbage beans were mush escarole was hardly there and also mush !!! Never go there again !!! read more

Really not sure what all the hype is about. Decided to get an order for delivery based on the positive Yelp reviews. Kept it simple w/ a large cheese pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was very Meh... the bottom was not crispy and the cheese was already cool and congealed by the time it got here. Maybe I should have toasted it in the oven after receiving it, but it seemed to be a bit much for an order that JUST arrived. The wings (16 wings for $10) were also a disappointment. They were drowned in a generic hot sauce and were overall lacking in taste and depth. No celery either, although the blue cheese was decent. Overall, the prices are pretty steep for a mediocre experience. I will say that their delivery times and estimates are spot on! read more

My first, and still my favorite penne vodka slice! I've been eating at Rocky's since high school. Their cheese pizza is still my favorite classic slice in Nutley. My only tip would be to avoid eating there for lunch, as it is flooded with high school kids. Just order delivery read more

This place is the worst! It was probably once a good place to eat, being that the good reviews are from 2012/13/14. That being said, today 7-20-17 I placed an order for deliver. Wasn't anything major, small plain pie 8 wings, meat ball sub, chicken fettuccini Alfredo and a 2L soda. The guy on the phone told me 30-40 min, I had no problem with that, but when we waited hour and a half for the order I called and the guy told me my food wasn't even done yet and I had to wait. Ok today was a very hot and humid day, probably a lot of calls. I canceled the order because we are starving. Went to pick up Burger King, I drove by the place and the parking lot was empty and 1 person was dining inside, if you see on google reviews, I'm not the only one with this complaint. There are so many other Italian restaurants in Nutley I don't even know why I wasted my time With Rocky's. DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME HERE! read more

Meh. Salad was gross. Pizza was sub-par. There are plenty of other places for Pizza in this town. I suggest forgoing this place.

BEST pizza in Nutley!! I absolutely love this place, the food is awesome and the service is great too! Delivery is always fast and friendly! I highly recommend this place. read more

From a good start to worse ending I started ordering their pizzas from 2012 but started in 2015 the pizza started to taste like garbage. As if someone microwaves the pie to heat them up. They taste awful now, so I stopped ordering from them which is a shame because I was a regular customer and they've completely backfire themselves with an awful chef who should get fired and have the place checked every week. read more

The best pizza in Nutley by far, tremendous ownership too. I think they strength is pizza , the place a pioneer pizzeria in Nutley been there forever!! read more

Their chicken/penne vodka deep dish slices are out of this world!

Thanks to the guys at Rocky's ,lunch was what it should of been,perfect. After cleaning the grounds at the u.s.post office. We were hungry and Rocky's cheesesteak and pizza's were on the money, everything was great. Thanks again guys . Just sorry i did'nt take some home for later. But we'll be back soon. read more

Rocky's has GREAT food!!!! When it comes to their specialty pizzas they are absolutely phenomenal. The Taco pizza is something different if you want to try something new and has great flavor. Their chicken parmesan has a great portion and you can get it with marinara or vodka sauce. I personally recommend the vodka sauce because they have one of the best vodka sauces! Overall anything you get there is worth the money!!!! read more

Since the new ownership the food and pizza is awesome we especially love the Grandma Pizza. Food is always fresh and delicious

OMG! The best place on earth! You can feed your family and still enjoy a vegan pizza!!!

Good pizza/Stromboli. Wouldn't go too far beyond that. Had chicken parm- very mediocre.

Came here because it's right around the corner. The pizzas were decent, nice and crispy.

Never had the pizza, but always order their penne vodka for parties. Never disappoints.