Randomly drove past and decided I wanted pizza. Greeted upon entering and ordered my pepperoni slice to go for $4. They have seating if you want to eat there. The pizza itself was good. I didn't love the sauce but overall still a really yummy slice. Had enough pepperonis and cheese but my fave was the thickness and texture of the crust. read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

I was struck by a pizza craving on my ride to the supermarket and happened to see Mario's so I stopped in for a slice and boy was I glad I did because the pizza is ON POINT! It's probably some of the best pizza I've had since moving back to Jersey! The young lady at the counter taking orders was very friendly as well just making the overall experience even better. read more

See all

I was in the area and decided to stop at Mario's for a slice, pizza was pretty good couldn't complain staff was friendly and the place had that hardcore Italian vibe i definitely suggest read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - Plane pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

I came here with my family after physical therapy just down the street and ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich. They put onions on my sandwich, which I do not eat, so while I was removing the onions, I found a piece of rat poop in my lettuce! Upon notifying our host and the cook, they tried to assure me that it was a piece of "cooked parsley" or "burned bread" when it was clearly rodent feces ! As you can see from the photo there's no parsley anywhere on my sandwich nor is my bread toasted. I have been sick ever since leaving ! read more

See all

Mario's is our go-to pizza place. The sauce is delicious, the crust is perfect (not crispy and not too doughy) and has plenty of cheese. I recommend Mario's to all our neighbors and order for all our birthday parties - on-time delivery, hot and fresh. read more

Today I bought this new dessert that Mario's pizza added to their menu it was so delicious and I would recommend it. read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - I bought this new dessert and it was really delicious it's called trilece and it's really good - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

I've been in an Italian sub mood, so I'm on a quest to try all our local places for my new sandwich spot. I really liked my ham, salami, and provolone sub. So many onions!I would come back to get this sub again. My husband however was super underwhelmed with his chicken roll. The only thing you could really taste was the marinara sauce to dip it in; the chicken roll itself didn't have much seasoning. I would come back for that sub, but my husband would probably pick something else to eat. read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - Large Chicken Roll - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

This place is slow, especially the gray-haired older dude with glasses. His customer service was horrible and so was his attitude. I called ahead but my food still wasn't ready after a 12-minute wait. In fact, a guy came in after me and ordered two slices from what was on display and the gray-haired dude served him, warmed his food up and he was out of there before me. As a result, my garlic knots were burnt on the bottom! I even had to ask him for the receipt twice for which he gave me more attitude. I may be wrong but I got a vibe that he had some type of issue with serving me. I wouldn't recommend and now I see why several co-workers stopped patronizing this place. read more

See all

If you enjoy smashed pizza where the cheese instantly falls off each slice and there is enough grease for an entire roll off paper towels well then Mario's is the place for you. Don't take my word for it, Look at this photo. Do yourself a favor and run as far away from this place as you can. Best advice I'll give all week read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - pepperoni and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Pizza is onnnn point.. i live 15 min away so i be hurt wen i get home because its not hot anymore but..that first slice out the box when you get to the car awww man.. def a sleeper..im usually a vinnies pizza guy and im always torn between these 2.. If you like the big slice ny style slices with a unique taste of sauce? This is the spot! #MarKnowz read more

Pizza tastes like they don't have a pizza oven. Wasn't cooked enough. Inside of place is very outdated and not in a good nostalgic way -very cringe. They don't have a website. Sauce tastes cheap. Place is weird. It's lowering the level of that mini strip of stores. I hope they would replace it with something better or get a business owner who cares so that it would help the real estate around it since it's not a bad area. read more

What happen! I grew in Brookdale Blmf NJ. This was my hometown pizza place. We would go after school and grab a slice or two. My famiy would order from here every Friday night. It was alwas so good !!! I ordered a pepperoni and onion pie thin crusted and well done, a sicilian slice and a sausage roll that I put in last minute. Thank God, because that was the only thing that was good. The sicilian was bad, but it was a slice. It could of been sitting there for awhile. Sausage roll was good. But the pizza. Wow. I was shocked on how bad it was. Not thin and not well done.The pepperoni was not crispy or cooked at all. It might as well been thrown on the pizza after it was cooked or was it. It was no different then grabbing a peice off a cheese platter. Not well done even a little bit. Not a black char mark on the pizza at all. So much sauce, that is all you could taste. The cheese was weird. Was it Mozzerella? I have no clue. It was like old cheese. It didn't stretch, it broke apart. I had heard their prices went up, but I always said. You get what you pay for. BUT not in this case. $18.75 for a pepperoni pizza plus onions $+3.00 = $21.75 Pizza. Way to much for that average pizza . I am actually so disappointed with Mario's Pizza. They used to be so much better. This time around it was a 4\5 pizza stars out of 10. Rating C - read more

Was looking for good pizza in jersey and the grandma pizza was recommended. Ordered pizza and wings, can't go wrong with that, right?! Well the wings came with no Buffalo sauce and the pizza was ok, pretty average place especially since they can't even get the wings right. Wish i had a better experience but honestly I was so turned off by having no wings that i am sure i won't order here anymore, I am not a fan of wasting my money and all they had to say was that they were sorry, no offer to make it better! Keep you money and try something other than this hole in the wall! read more

Lunch Apr 30 Neighborhood pizza joint with lots of history. I am NOT a fan of big NY Style greasy, triangle cut pizza (waiting for the gasps and cries of sacrilege). But I did like this for 1 reason - the bottom of the crust was very crispy and not flimsy. Pepperoni's were big and good quality. And I tried the Chicken, Bacon, Ranch gimmick pizza and again - it want bad. 3 of us had drinks and 2 slices each and it was under $30. So yeah - I liked the pie here. read more

Pizza is doughy but good, not the best for the price you'll pay, $23.00 for a pie with 2 toppings ,is a little too much for standard pizza.

Former New Yorker trying to find that pizza the makes me feel like home Mario's since the day the I went for the pizza I was stuck almost weekly I order and never lost consistency always got great meals from this place !! Hidden gem !! read more

Parm alert...Bloomfield N.J.!!! I was participating in a disussion on Yelp regarding the best places to order a "Parm" from in New Jersey (parmigiana in Italian-ease as Parms seem to be an American construct) since then, I've revisited some local joints in my town of Bloomfield lately which really has proven to be hit or miss where pizza fare is concerned, but Mario's Famous stands out as the only solid choice, well above the lackie cardboard slingers in this town. Mario's chicken parm is so good that I ordered it twice in one week. The full loaf large size comes in four six inch segments that are enough for four people who maybe are on a diet but want parm, or two people who dont give a damn, or one person who has just plain give up on life. The chicken parmigiana was stacked thick with well prepared tasty chicken breast, delicio sauce and plenty of melted cheese (note to self and others, if you prefer toasted bread, ask for it, as Mario's doesn't finish off the sandwich in the oven like I prefer). This way too conservatively yelp starred Bloomfield mainstay deserves four stars for the 36" of parm I was served, and the pizza is notably good as well, even the slices ordered at the counter reheated. Perhaps there is a flame war amongst the local lackie inconsistent pizza places in Bloomfield trying to keep Mario's under the radar? Some of the low ratings seem to come from inexperienced reviewers comparing pizzerias to steakhouses,and the prices are certainly not $$$, but as a Bloomfield resident of seven years, my opinion is, if you want to order from a local pizzeria and not feel cheated with bad food and skimpy sandwich contents, order now, stop looking, bookmark it and speed dial add Mario's to your favorites. read more

Um...Famously terrible pizza. Seriously this place was gross. We got a large pie with mushrooms and it was canned mushrooms, low quality mozz, and flavorless dough. With all the pizzeria's in the area, how is this place still open? I will not return. read more

Really good pizza although sometimes I'll get the wrong chef and it's greasy. Same hit or miss with wait staff but the early shift waiters are best. read more

I have no idea how I've managed to never review this place...its literally next door to the office. OK well not quite that close, but almost. We go here often, and oddly enough...I don't seem to have any pictures of the food or the place. Probably because every time we've gone there, we devour the food and there isn't any time for silly pictures LOL yes, i love this place. It's cheap, it's good, and it's close! I'll update with pics soon *fingers crossed* read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - delicious pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

Wow..having moved from NYC to Jersey I thought I'd lose out on the classic slice, but this pizza is way better than any NYC slice. Try it and tell me I'm wrong. read more

The pizza was good enough that I don't even mind being overcharged. A chicken cutlet pie is $16 and a broccoli pie is $14.75 so if I get half chicken cutlet and half broccoli, it shouldn't be more than $16. It should be LESS than $16 actually, I'm replacing a more expensive topping with a less expensive topping. I was charged as if both toppings had covered the entire pie. Not exactly quantum physics. But they charged me $21 and wouldn't adjust the price even after I explained. I paid the $21 because I had a hungry wife at home but I won't be making that mistake again. read more

I have always supported this pizza shop, however, their recent price gouging to customers is not right. This company may want to re-evaluate there ethics and short term benefits over the long hawl of valued customers leaving them. Pricing is now double to other pizza shops in the area. Don't be taken advantage of, take your business to someone who does not gouge you on prices. read more

My husband has lived in Bloomfield all his life and loves this place . I have recently moved to Nj from Manhattan and have to say not a fan of Jerseys way of pizza but I like it here . We order chicken parmigiana and chicken Francese both orders are big enough to share satisfying and delicious ! The Buffalo wings and meatballs are also great and well proportioned. I'm 4 months pregnant and haven't been able to eat due to Nausea but his pizza has definitely been one of the many few I crave and can have both cheese and pepperoni. I usually Order for deliver so have no complaints about costumer service but my deliver people have always been great and friendly . As per my husband the staff has always been hospitable and friendly when he pics up he says Mario is definitely very passionate about his restaurant and food which can some times be misinterpreted but he means well. read more

WOULD GIVE ZERO. RUDE, NASTY SERVICE. Got a pizza with "fresh garlic" and mushrooms. It was fine. Pretty good, actually in spite of it not actually having FRESH garlic as requested, but... Got chicken fingers, everyone loved them. they were great. I ordered a caesar salad for myself. No indication that there was roasted, oily red peppers on it. I now have hives all over me and my tongue itches. Never heard of a Caesar salad with roast red peppers. It's Romaine, croutons, cheese. Called to suggest that they let people know when ordering and the asshole woman on the phone told me to go to the emergency room if I was so bad, that's how they make it, I was being unreasonable etc before she hung up on me. Before I had even finished my first sentence she said "I understand". NO. YOU DON'T. I HAVE NOT YET TOLD YOU THE PROBLEM. NEVER EVER AGAIN. I can understand "alternate" recipes but a salad is pretty simple and to tell me to go to the ER? Holy shit. What a way to run a business. Never again. read more

So it seems they have the food handling situation under control. This is good, because I've come to accept this place as my go-to local pizza joint. The pizza crust is always consistently good. It's not super thin. It's not too thick. No bubbles, never burnt. Good balance of cheese and sauce. My favorite topping is the meatball topping - evenly sliced meatball. Their fried calamari is actually my favorite of all time. I've had all sorts of calamari - thin sliced, super thick sliced, etc. This calamari has the best breading (could be tempura), a hint of salt and is never rubbery. I also like I can get a spicy version of the tomato sauce that comes with it. I'm actually really partial to their cheesesteaks. I dunno what it is, but it seems like their cheesesteaks are really well balanced. I add mozzarella in addition to American cheese. I usually don't like American cheese with anything, but it just works. The bad part is the individual slices they have out are almost never good. They're either too dry and/or I don't like the topping combinations they have. read more

Ordered the penna with vodka, buffalo chicken wrap and the meatball sub. First, this place is a little pricey for a local spot. That being said the penna vodka was DELICIOUS. the buffalo chicken wrap was very good as well. The meatball sub was good and not so good. The actual meatball and sauce was VERY GOOD. THE SUB (bread portion) was to soft. They should have toasted the bread. That being said. I definitely would return for the penna vodka. read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

I'm really surprised by the low ratings. Mario's has ample sauce and cheese and great flavor. It's been consistent quality for over 25 years even with different management and, I'm sure, chefs. I've heard the recipe has changed, but they managed to still keep the pizza great. It was my family's favorite when I was growing up, I came back not too long ago, still the same great pizza at a reasonable price. I highly, highly recommend it to anyone in the Upper Montclair/Glen Ridge/Bloomfield area. read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria 1279 Broad Street We ordered food at 9:07 on eatnow.com I received a conformation to my email that my order has been confirmed. It's now 10:19 and we called about our food, they are insisting that we are TOO far and they never sent out our order. WE HAVE ORDERED FROM THEM BEFORE and THEY ARE LISTED ON THAT SITE AS IN OUR AREA. They were rude and if we didn't call- we wouldn't even have KNOWN that our food isn't coming. They are refusing to give us our food and we are now left starving. Thanks for NOTHING, Mario's. I guess they don't want money or future business. Eatnow.com might want to contact this vendor and get straight where they deliver to. I have never been treated so poorly. I'm also calling the health inspector because I'm sure that people with staff this poor working for them can't be clean. read more

Mario's has been my go-to pizzaria about once a month for the past five years. It's not the best pizza I've ever had, but it's definitely the best in the area. Before settling in with Mario's, I ordered/ate-in from a half dozen other places around Bloomfield, Clifton, and Nutley. I even had a place in Bloomfield that was my local winner already. But a friend got me to try Mario's and I switched favorite local pizza places. I've ordered pizza, calzones/stromboli, and hot sandwiches from Mario's. I've never once been left unsatisfied. I grew up on north Jersey and NYC pizza, and this is what I've come to expect from a delivery place. read more

This is THE pizza place for us ever since we moved here. Our favorite is Mario's special. If you like thin crust with very rich toppings, this is the place to go. read more

I ordered a Sicilian pie with extra cheese and I must admit I was disappointed. Right off the bat I did not think it was extra cheese... so much so that I asked to make sure they indeed added extra cheese! In addition, it was not a saucy as I like it and the edges were burned almost to a crisp in several places. I'll give them another chance since I'm not a one and done type person and I'm hoping next time will be a lot better. Will keep you posted. read more

Love the consistent quality of food at Marios Pizza. This is one of those awesome comfort food spots that will make your day. I love the homemade chicken noodle soup, the baked ziti and pizza read more

I had to rush order a few trays of food from here and I have to say they were amazing! The salad was very fresh, the chicken franchise was so tender and the pens vodka was so delicious. The staff is always very friendly and accommodating to our needs. Always great food! read more

We just had food delivered. Veal saltomboca, chicken parm and pasta fagoli. Pasta a but overdone for my liking but everything else was good, hot and NO leaking containers! This is no small feat for take out so they deserve round of applause. The pizza us fairly good. Thanks Mario's for delivery of a tasty meal while I get to hang out in my yoga pants and be lazy. read more

Mario's Famous Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Was visiting a friend of mine in Bloomfield and didn't feel like going out for food so delivery was our only option. My friend recommended Mario's. We ordered 1 large pie half pepperoni and the other half plain, an order of mozzarella sticks, and a soda. The Pros: pizza was very tasty. Not greasy like you receive from most delivery places. Loved the fact the slices were actually sliced and didn't require us recutting the pizza. Mozzarella sticks were on par. Just happy they were not cold and/or super soggy like you would expect from delivery. And the delivery time was unexpectedly quick for a Saturday night. Cons: not much I can think of. I will definitely order from here again next time I'm in the area. read more

I'm a definite loyal customer. Their food is always good. their calamari is delicious. pizza is awesome as well. My kids love their pizza and chicken parm sandwiches. my fave is the eggplant supreme with the fresh mutz. and their vodka sauce even makes you want to have more! So far i just get the sandwiches now since my kids need all the protein boys need at their age. Growing boys can't have pizza all the time. I tried other places around and i don't like them as much as Mario's. Keep up the good work you guys! read more

The food here I had tasted great. I only ordered cheesy bread lol so I don't see how they could get that wrong. I can agree with some of the not so good reviews pertaining to the prices OMG! They are for sure a little too expensive, a can of soda cost me a $1.40. read more

I don't post often as you can see from my account but I have to write this one. We have ordered from here tons of times and I am beginning to wonder why. Just picked up an order that was wrong, AGAIN! How hard is it to put lettuce on a sandwich???? A chicken cutlet sandwich was ordered with lettuce and tomato. No lettuce. Not a big deal this one time but this place has messed up soooooo many orders lately. One time they gave us an entirely wrong order, someone else's food. Had to get back in my car and drive back to the place to return the food. The only reason why I give them 3 stars is because the chicken parm sandwiches are always good. read more

Slightly above average pizza...because of that, i would say they're overpriced...i know its not fair to compare it with the 7.99 pizza of chains like dominos,etc(which would be half the price)...but the famous rays of new york is even priced lower at the other side of town...the comments about the rude staff is almost accurate...maybe they try to adapt the new york pizzeria rudeness... I've come about twice now(in maybe 10) that they're nice enough...probably because i know my orders before coming... seats for dine in if needed..parking is mostly available on street or at the back...review is based on pizza alone...havent tried anything else on the menu read more