After a day with my friends I needed a minute to myself lol I left them at a nearby bar and found Rome to Brooklyn. The smells pulled me in and I ordered a couple of slices. I sat at a table and watched as it became increasingly crowded. The service was fast, the pizza was delicious and the location gave me the opportunity for people watching. read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

One of the better unhyped slice joints in the Williamsburg-Greenpoint area. I tried both the margherita and the vodka-burrata Sicilian. The Sicilian dough was light and airy, and I loved the creamy vodka sauce. The margherita had a nice freshness from the tomato sauce as well. read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza here was tasty! Buy some! I ordered a margarita slice and it was delicious. The store front and inside was very clean. The service was immediate. The music didn't match Rome but who cares...I love Spanish music. I give this experience a 10/10 ..by the way they clean the soda can tops...winner behavior. Thanks for lunch guys! read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Outside seating ...appealing storefront - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I always go to the location on Grand St but I was near this location so I figured I'd give it a try. Ordered two slices of plain cheese and was confused when it came to $8 and change. I looked at the receipt and the cashier accidentally charged me for a can of soda. It wasn't a big deal but he was so apologetic but I told him a few times it wasn't a big deal. They refunded me and charged me correctly. Problem solved. Nothing to be sorry about. =) The pizza was delicious. I think they may have used more than one kind of cheese but idk. I just know it was good. I like this location better to be honest. It's MUCH bigger than the one on Grand St, has a bathroom, more seating......would definitely go back if I'm in the area. read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Two cheese slices - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza was the perfect snack after a show at the Warsaw. Crunchy and delicious, I could've had another slice. The service was super quick. Ambiance very casual. read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious pizza. Crust is nice and crispy. A great stop on our pizza crawl. Grandmas slice was really good because the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Cheese slice was a classic. Def recommend read more

See all

Stopped in for a quick bite on a really hot day. The establishment was air conditioned but the heat was intense so it felt like a slight relief from the scorching heat. We got some slices and drinks from the fridge- cans of soda. The soda was not cold. Asked for a cup of ice and they said they didnt have ice. There wasnt a bathroom from what I could see. I ordered the mushroom square slice and a vodka slice. The vodka slice was really great. My family ordered regular slices and thought they were good but we all agreed the vodka slice was phenomenal. I also ordered a cypress salad. The tomatoes were hard and had no flavor to them. The cheese was fine but it fell flat. I didnt finish it. Its a lovely new spot. Hope it does well. read more

Omg the garlic knots are SO addicting! I recently ordered from here for the first time and got a cheese pizza and single knot. Unfortunately, the pizza was not warm by the time it arrived but that's not the restaurants fault. However, i liked how thin and crispy the pizza was and that its a good size. read more

Rome to Brooklyn was surprisingly really good! My friends and I stopped by before heading to the bar down the street and was satisfied by our pizza. The place was a no-frills pizza spot and wasn't too busy. We each got a garlic knot and I got a vodka pesto grandma slice which I thoroughly enjoyed. The slice was thick, the bottom was crispy, and I liked the pesto! The rolls were also pretty good but I wish it was more cheesy and garlicky. Overall, Rome to Brooklyn is a great pizza spot! read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Burrata, Pesto and Vodka Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Solid place to get a slice! I find it kind of hard to rate pizza, because I feel like at a certain point, it's all the same to me lol. That being said, I thought the crust had a good texture, and the toppings were yummy. I love a white sauce mushroom pizza, so of course I had to get a mushroom slice. I do wish that more of their slices came in a triangle shape though, because I'm not a huge fan of square slices. read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - cheese, grandma, truffle mushroom, vodka burrata pesto - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Rome to Brooklyn 587 Manhattan Ave $3 a slice and $2 for a Coke. Just sharp, consistent pizza baked with care. That alone makes Rome to Brooklyn stand out in a neighborhood where slice prices often creep toward $5. What you get here isn't a reheated corner slice; it's pizza that reflects craft and intention. The crust is the first giveaway. Each pie comes out with a golden, crisp base that crunches cleanly without losing its airiness. It's thin but not brittle, light but structured. You can tell someone's watching the bake closely. A thin sheen of pizza oil glistens on top -- just enough to catch the light and remind you this is still Brooklyn, not Bologna. The plain slice is solid, but not where Rome to Brooklyn shines. The real gems sit on the bottom row of the glass case-- the vodka burrata, Grandma, and a rotating lineup of creative pies that show off the shop's skill and range. Those slices have more character: richer sauces, clever toppings, and a bake that brings everything into focus. Inside, the space feels considered and modern without crossing into pretentious. There's plenty of seating, clean design, and an easy calm that makes it equally suited to a solo lunch or casual dinner. Beyond pizza, the menu branches out with sandwiches, pasta, and panzerottis, giving it the feel of a neighborhood Italian kitchen rather than a strict slice shop. Rome to Brooklyn doesn't chase trends; it perfects fundamentals. It's a place where the price stays fair, the crust stays crisp, and every pie feels intentional. Bottom line: In any other town, this would be the best pizza around -- but even in Greenpoint, it's near the top of the heap. 8.5 / 10 read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'd rate Rome to Brooklyn three and a half stars. I think it's a Taglia style pizzeria. The crust style was sort of a Sicilian style but I don't think that was the intention given the pizzeria is called Rome to Brooklyn. The toppings were the showcase of the slice. We had one with vodka sauce and pesto sauce. Lots of seating inside. Service was very quick. read more

First to review! Well deserved 5/5 stars. I previously reviewed the other location in East Williamsburg, but after coming to the new location, I wholeheartedly give this place a perfect 5/5 star. I've been to a good 40+ pizza joints in my lifetime and I've literally gone from Rome to Brooklyn and Brooklyn to Rome during the summers for Agosto with my Italian partner back to his hometown in lazio. Namely, Lucalis's, l'industrie, Fini, Di Fara, Luigi's, John on Bleeker, MyPie, Upside, Paulie Gees, Scarrs, Mamas Too, etc. This place deserves a rightful place in hall of fame for top 3 pizzas in all of NYC. The pizza here is thin, albeit some other thicker pizzas are Sicilian style, but delicious in a different style. Very light and not heavy or greasy, you could easily scarf a few slices! My personal poison are the garlic knots. Best garlic knots in all of NYC. The owner Aurel is a super nice down to earth guy, and he is the stereotypical friendly neighborhood pizza owner. A definite favorite pizza joint I visit frequently, and now I don't have to go all the way to East Williamsburg anymore! Convenient for my desires, dangerous for my waistline ‍ read more

Pizza is good but not as good as the original locations! Regular cheese was greasy and not super crispy but specialty slices were good! read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Vodka pizza and grandma slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very Brooklyn vibe pizzeria. After much deliberation, ordered a mushroom grandma pie to go. Mushrooms were a plenty, fresh & meaty. Crispy & not bready crust. Garlic infused tomato sauce, could have used just a tad more salt. Service couldn't have been any friendlier. I will definitely go back & try a regular pie. read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Mushroom grandma pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Absolutely phenomenal! We were visiting from St. Louis and staying in Manhattan but as pizza lovers naturally wanted to try pizza in Brooklyn, and this place was such a peak experience! The service was just above and beyond, and the pizza was SO incredible!! We tried so many different kinds and they were all SO good. Will not disappoint, and look forward to visiting again next time I'm here! read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I am a gluten free girlie. I have very low expectations. BUT the cauliflower pizza crust was amazing!! We got the pesto, mozz, cherry tomato za, and the flavors were light and delicious. Not soggy, crispy crust, amazing aroma wafting from the box--honestly can't wait to go again read more

I've been walking by this place for months since it was under construction and I finally got the chance to grab some slices today for dinner. I grabbed six slice and five of them were thin slices with the crispiest crust ever. You could tell ingredients are prioritized here because the pepperonis were those cute and fancy little cup ones! Each slice tasted so fresh and crispy. I did grab one thicker slice which was the burata and vodka slice. This one was hands down my favorite I couldn't get enough of it and I refused to share that slice (corner left in the pic!). I am so excited to get a fresh pie of the vodka burata and see how much better it taste fresh out the oven my mouth is actually watering as I think about it! Rome to Brooklyn is going to be my new go to spot for dinner (and probably lunch). If i could give 10 stars i would that's how amazing this place was. read more

Rome To Brooklyn Pizza - from top to bottom: margherita, buffalo chicken, romano, burata with pesto and vodka, mushroom and truffle oil, and grandma pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Amazing pizza & amazing service. The staff was very kind to me and my service animal. Fresh ingredients were used in the food which made every bite enjoyable. They are true pizza masters! read more

Wowww so good definitely recommend, I'm coming back for sure! The grandmas pizza is so good I want to try everything!

My wife and I loved the pizza, but what really stood out was Jordan's exceptional service. He went the extra mile to ensure we had a wonderful experience. We'll definitely be back! read more

We got a Mushroom slice and a Grandma slice. Crispy, cheesy, perfect! Both were to-die-for DELICIOUS. Service is pretty amazing too! I'm getting a pie next time! A+++ read more

Great atmosphere and wonderful staff. Stopped in unplanned and had a great experience. Pizza just as good! Will definetly come again!

Really really good pizza. Great addition to the neighborhood. It's my favorite pizza by far. Great sauce, great crust and great taste.

I had an amazing experience thanks to Jordan! From the moment I walked in, his warm and friendly attitude made me feel welcome. He's knowledgeable, passionate, and recommended one of the best pizzas I've ever had. read more

Food is delicious but the service was terrible. This is the second time I've had a problem there. It seems like when the owner isn't there the service stinks. Ordered an upside down pie today and he burnt the whole pie. Threw it away and wanted to start over with a pre made dough. I figured its a pizza pie. Shouldn't they use fresh dough every time. Today is Thursday January 23rd 2025 1:06pm. read more

Shoutout Jordan for an amazing pizza! Crust was delicious, ingredients fresh, and the store was beautiful and clean. Staff lovely, would absolutely come back to try more flavors read more

Amazing service the staff is so friendly unreal pizza and garlic nots. Definitely come here

I came in wanting to try a NY slice other than the typical cheese slice, and I was not disappointed at all. I tried their mushroom slice, vodka burrata, and prosciutto slices and all of them were bursting with flavor in every bite. The staff were super welcoming and attentive, and this location had a really nice ambiance to eat at. Can't wait to come back again!! read more