The best pizza of the three i had that night. Romeo's reminds me of that classic NY pepperoni slice that's packed with cheese, flavor, oil, and an amazing crust that holds everything together. I got a full pie well done, so it was made good and fresh. Restaurant has that classic old school pizza restaurant look with all the Italian hero portraits plastered on the wall. They're usually open during the wildwood season so if you're down there, be sure to check them out. You'll enjoy! read more

See all

That shit is nasty . The pizza had no sauce . Philly is better . The chicken steak was ass . The fountain drinks taste ass

The guy at the counter was rude, the fries weren't cooked all the way and these were the "chicken fingers". Never again. read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - Chicken finger - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

Best pizza I ever had amazing service, fast nice people. Amazing design nice seating area. They gave us the wrong food we said it's fine they wouldn't let that slide they gave us the right food fast amazing staff read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - Design - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

0/10, food was alright, ive had better. was more disgusted about the amount of trump signs, stickers, and flags. gross. plus the guy was kinda rude, average trumpie. read more

Great food ! Open until late so you can get some food in you after the bars !! Pizza is really good

Unfortunately this place was quite disappointing. I got this recommendation from my Uber driver who said he lived in the neighborhood. Despite the reviews here being variable I decided to trust the recommendation... We got the bbq chicken pizza that was quite questionable and very plane - it was just cheese, chicken and bbq sauce. The chicken on the pizza was ground chicken, which I've never seen before and there were no onions or bell peppers. The crust also lacked flavor. One positive is that they do stay late open but I likely will not be coming back. read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - Bbq chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Our pizza was so awesome, I really don't understand this place having only 3 stars. Got white and regular pizzas, everyone with us gave it a solid rating. Easily in our top 3 in the wildwoods. read more

I came to Romeo's earlier Sunday morning being there open till 5am. I'm a 19 year old kid, I grew up in an amazing pizza restaurant by far the best on the town. I came with my friends and sign says cash only which I don't carry . My friend has cash all day so I asked for him to pay and he said yes. I order and get 2 slices of a fresh pizza from the counter I tell my friends to order and take my pizza to eat. I take a bite and my friend says he forgot his wallet and the women immediately gets slightly aggressive say "I told you it was cash only" about 3 or 4 times. I explained to her the situation and apologizes and say I can do a Zelle payment and asked why she is being nasty towards me. She looked like a cartoon with steam coming from her ears. She continued to raise her voice and then tells her co worker (great man btw) to get my Zelle. As I'm getting his Zelle information some old guy I assume to be the owner tells me to " get the money or die" !! I'm shocked i asked if i heard what I thought I did and he confirmed. I paid co worker passes some Parmesan and I left. Pizza is terrible. Service is terrible. That comment from the owner was terrible. If you can't deal with working night shift find a new job and go to sleep. Jersey needs to stay out the pizza business. read more

Good pizza, especially late night - open until 5am. Wings are decent too. We order at least once each time we are in town. Convenient delivery to the Crest. read more

The goodfella so good. Can't wait to order it again. Love it here the music is great late at night. read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - Goodfella pizza was so good - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

We ordered last night. Quite possibly the worse Italian food I have ever had. We ordered a large Italian Stromboli. It was under cooked and we did not eat it. It went into the garbage. We asked for extra sauce and did not get it. The chicken parm sandwich and cheeseburgers were fine. We ordered bayseasoned fries extra crispy. They were limp and under cooked with zero seasoning. We threw the menu out that was at our rental so nobody else orders from here. read more

Tasteless food . Only Philly can make cheesesteaks that taste right clearly . The cheese fries had unmelted cheese , the fries looked like those thin potato stix & the cheesesteak had no flavor . The dough was hard too . read more

The food isn't the best on the island, but it's certainly nowhere near the worst. Pizza is okay, crust is good, usually not too greasy. White broccoli pizza is good. Pepperoni rolls are great, get them with marinara. Prices are on par with the island, a little cheaper than some boardwalk places. It does get packed after midnight, especially 2-4am when bars are closing. Not too busy during dinner time. I've never ordered delivery, so I can't speak on that. read more

See all

Look my friend Moe Green told me about this place and he was right it's the best pizza on the island. Stevie Paglione is the best pizziola on the island. Only God makes a better pie. The sauce crust and cheese were cooked to perfection and it tastes like the award winning pie that it has always been. Romeo's is da BEST read more

Great family owned business with amazing pizza, pepperoni rolls and the freshest cutlets on the island. Friendly workers always welcoming everyone coming in. I see an influx of 1 star reviews which seem to be spam for some unknown reason. Highly recommend stopping here if you're on the island for a quick bite that the whole family will enjoy. read more

We have been coming here for 20+ years and we love everything about this family owned business from the owners to the people that work there you are always greeted with a smile! And the food is always on point!! We are locals and wish they were open in the winter read more

The pizza was amazingly delicious and the freshest I've ever had. The service was top notch besides it feeling like home.

I am absolutely appalled by the disgraceful food they sent us we waited two hours for this terrible terrible food. they gave us a burnt chicken Parm sandwich and a barbecue chicken pizza where the chicken was raw. I would not feed my dog this disgraceful food . I thought Mr. Romeo was a standup guy I learned I will never order from this place again. Very disappointed. read more

See all

Yes, they're open late, but the pizza is garbage and the delivery driver was an inconsiderate slob. I wish I hadn't been so generous with my tip. This place will never get another dime from me. read more

Best pizza in wildwood. Any other reviews are all over shadowing the god stuff about this place. The service was good and the cashier was nice. The pizza took a while to cook but totally worth. Cool ambiance and it's very calm inside. read more

We ordered pizza and a hoagie delivery, awesome pizza! exceeded expectations. Service was great too!

Solid 4 for what it is. Great pizza, handling the summer crowd with ease. Delivery is on point. The pizzas were "good". As good or better than others. The buffalo chicken was a bit dry, but the pizza with traditional toppings was GREAT. Thanks all Four stars based on ratings in the area, comparatively. read more

Great Place! Very good pizza. Well-done crust and great thin dough. Had a Margherita and some other basic slices. Open late and extremely friendly peeps. Shore businesses get slammed and have very long times to wait during busy nights thats just the way it goes. Too bad for the yelp! Community they don't apparently understand how tough it is for seasonal businesses, many rely on seasonal labor to keep it running smoothly. As far as their pizzas, solid! Worth the wait. Dont let the one star impatient people ruin youre opinion. Check out my photo! Its good stuff! read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

the best staff and food. love the atmosphere and i tried the whole menu pizza is the best and they have great sandwiches. the homemade cutlets are just like home. read more

Excellent pizza , fast service is pretty much the only place open super late in wildwood. The slices were all coming out fresh the place was packed but the older gentleman behind the counter was hustling !! read more

Stumble into Romeo's Pizzeria and you'll be in for a real treat. After bar hopping, i popped in for a slice around 2 am. A line that moved fast, but it was okay because i enjoyed looking at all of the celebrities on the wall. I had the magarita slice, and i loved it. at first i was iffy because the gravy tasted sweet, but the fresh basil and the cheese were a perfect pair. the slice wasnt too thin or thick, i truly liked the slice and would be back in a heart beat to try more. the slices in the window looked very edible, unlike the majority of the pizza places in wildwood. FYI, CASH ONLY! read more

Wow I really hate giving places bad reviews but this place really deserves it. First you can't pay with a card witch is okay because most places down the shore you can't. Talking to a worker on the phone was almost exhausting since he has no emotion and kept telling me they were out of everything I was pretty much asking for. Should of cancelled my order then and there but it's the only late night joint open. I ordered here twice and was deeply disappointed, the first time the order was, stuffed shells, cheese fries and old bay fries. Now come on how can you mess up fries. The fires look like potato stick chips, small and skinny there was a glob of cold cheese on the top and a sprinkle of old bay on the other. The stuffed shells were cold and undercooked. The sauce was watery and not good. The second time my friends and I ordered we ordered a pizza and mozzarella sticks. The pizza was oily and once again COLD, the mozzarella sticks were cold and brownish grey, not golden. I took once bite of each and stopped eating. As dramatic as this review sounds everything was disgusting. Save your money there are 10 other amazing pizza places you can give your money too down here. read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - stuffed shells - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

Mega fries? More like MINI fries! And HORRIBLE customer service. Sent about a dollar's worth of fries with barely any cheese and hardly cooked bacon and have the nerve to charge $9. Asked for well done fries... they were undercooked, tasted still raw and were limp and gross. Called as soon as they were delivered and the girl asked me what do I want her to do about it? (with attitude) Since she didn't have any idea what their policy is, I suggested send your driver back here to pick these up and give me my money back. Her: I dont know where the driver is. Me: Call him? Her: Ok, I will send him out for them and to give your money back. 45 minutes later, after we have eaten dinner, I call to see where this driver is and she puts me on hold for a long time then comes back on and tells me that wait, no, they can't refund my money but will bring me new fries. Well, who wants new fries now when everyone has already eaten??? Where was that when I called immediately after delivery when it would have made sense to have new fries with dinner??? Now they are keeping me on hold forever. I guess hoping I will go away. Oh well, I have time... Just got "disconnected" again, hmmm. Called back and they tell me new fries are on the way and they are not refunding the money. Also, delivery driver didn't bother to wear a mask when bringing our food to the door either time (even though I mentioned that he didn't have one after the first time) so apparently they aren't too concerned about the NJ mandated covid rules they are supposed to follow. read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - Limp, barely cooked fries - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

yea this place is disgusting and the service is even worse. they were rude and disrespectful and did our order very late and did people who came after us order first. The food was also not good at all. very disrespectful and i do not recommend. also it was as very dirty and the worker used a bathroom that had no tissue or soap and went back into kitchen with unclean hands. read more

Owner was very rude when he said they were cash only. That is not stated on their menu, on their website nor their front door. I do not usually give my business to cash only places, as they are likely trying to avoid paying their taxes. I would take my business elsewhere. read more

I was hoping for more flavor, the pizza was good but not something to remember. It is similar to Mack's on the boardwalk, just too greasy for my taste and the sauce needed more taste. Priced fairly and made fresh, just needs something. However the pepperoni rolls shine! While $2.50 each, these are delicious. Cash only, and eat in tables available Romeos sits on Pacific Ave in the heart of downtown Wildwood. read more

Very good pizza, will definitely get it again. Prices are pretty good and their open extremely late (another plus). Haven't had anything besides a pepperoni pizza, so can't justify giving a 5. At 3 or 4am (with a very limited selection available) this place is a 5 star, during daytime hours I'd say it's a solid 4. read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - Slice of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

When first walking in, there must have been 5 workers, NONE had a mask on, not a single one, and they were very close to one another in the kitchen. Also, I witnessed a cook wipe his nose and then proceed to stick his hand in a container of mozzarella and then top the pizza with it. Disgusting. Another thing to note, the lady who took our order got finished counting money and then used her BARE HANDS to grab our pizza. The amount of cross contamination here is absurd. Also, the pizza bottom tasted like an oven that hasn't been cleaned in years. read more

the only place we knew was open at 1am. solid steaks! when you're half drunk and hungry it's a life saver!!!! the steaks aren't chopped they're the flat cooked steak. it's not a bad place to grab food!!! read more

This honestly is the pizza in wildwood and I've tried them all Mack's sams whatever this place wins by miles and please if u don't know now u know try the pepperoni rolls!!! The pic is a Sicilian pizza btw read more

Romeo's Pizzeria - This is the caecilian - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Ordered a half cheese half bbq chicken pizza. Delicious ingredients. The service was good, prices were decent my medium pizza costed $15. Took less than 15 minutes to come out. Service was fast and good, very busy, definitely a hot spot in the area! read more

Horrible the pizza was disgusting n what I ordered isn't what I received... Also I asked for a 2 Ltr of coke n they sent me RC COLA something u can buy from the dollar store all for 25$$ if I had a choice it would be not even 1* I'm good read more

Never again! It took 90 minutes to get our delivery. We had ordered four dinners of which three were wrong. We called and they did redeliver in about 45 minutes however it was still wrong. Never again! read more

Burnt pizza every time i go. Service was even worse. Also very very dirty. If its dirty where they allow you to see imagine whats going on behind closed doors. read more