When staying at Boyd's Campground, Roostica is a walkable location. Had the Italian gravy special on Sunday. It was excellent and we had plenty of leftovers for the next day. Service was excellent. read more

Delicious pizza and friendly service. Ambience is warm and welcoming- outdoor dining was well shaded and enjoyable on a hot day.

Food was very good. Server was quite personable. Masks were required but they did not enforce social distancing! The table next to us was marked as not available but 2 ladies sat down there. I asked our server about it and was told "they are waiting for an open table". The staff didnt care enough about our safety to tell those folks to move along. In non virus times it would not be an issue, with this pandemic however I feel that this lack of enforcement is unacceptable so they lose a star for that. read more

Looking for something besides Seafood. This place excellent reviews. This was exactly what we were looking for. The bartender Sara was super friendly and attentive. We had Johns pizza and mmmm perfect. We loved this place so much we ended going there again the next night. Husband had lasagna and it was delicious. The barratta cheese appetizer and pesto was out of this world. Oh yeah. The flan was best I've ever had. read more

See all

First time there, we order Togo. The pizza was amazing!! Quick service and staff was friendly!

Absolutely recommend this place. Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Their gluten free crust is delicious.

Been wanted to go here for some time. Great food and service. Will definitely be going back

Amazing food and service! Some of the best food in the Keys. Recommend pizza and chicken Parmesan.

Food was great! Tommy was cool. Server was meh! By the time she checked on the food & I asked for extra sauce, everyone else was done. So when sauce finally came out, she asked if we wanted a to go box & check. I wasn't finished but we got it to go. Bummer. The sauce was excellent btw! We were gonna do dessert. Guess we'll get it elsewhere for that. May try again, may not. read more

Roostica - Italian Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Delicious artisan pizza with pecorino and some very tasty salami and pepperoni. Thin and crispy. Very satisfying. Cool building inside and out. read more

See all

What a find, unless I searched on Yelp for the best pizza in Key West, we would've never found this place because it's hidden behind the main road. The place is cute, rustic, and surprisingly big. Indoor and out door seating. Happy Hour is not listed but it's from 4p-6p, Saturday thru Monday. The food is phenomenal, service is friendly and efficient, portions are quite large. Everything that went by us from the kitchen looked wonderful. We are pizza snobs and this place won our vote. We are going back again for the happy hour tomorrow! read more

See all

Service was good. Pizza is very undercoat and nothing was done about it. No replacement no refund bad this poor management.

Pizza was good, kid spaghetti she loved!!! Cheese sticks were a joke 4/$5 lol . Nice atmosphere we sat outside

Average Italian food. Less than average service. Important - if you visit with friends, they will not give separate checks! May be important, maybe not. read more

Excellent food. We arrived near shift change and were a little disappointed when we had waited 10 min without service. We were ready to leave when a server finally came to our table. I'm so glad we didn't leave. We ordered the burrata mozzarella (toasted garlic bread with prosciutto, pistachio pesto with the soft fresh cheese) & it was fantastic, tasted so fresh & delicious. Even though it was one of the higher priced appetizers on the menu, and not included in happy hour menu pricing, my husband agreed that it was totally worth it. Then for our main course we ordered the Sicilian deep dish, a little on the spicy side but was so good done in the wood fired oven. The crust was crispy on the bottom & the flavor was really good. They have runners bringing the food to the tables so it came out fast & was screaming hot. We were there for happy hour so our tab which included 2 beers each + tip was just under $57, a bargain with restaurant prices today. We will be back. read more

Very delicious pizza. We'll definitely visit again on our next trip. Highly recommended!

Great happy hour. Drinks and food. Very interesting take on Italian foods. The staff where pleasant. Wish there was more parking.

The food here is amazing. The atmosphere is wonderful and the service was excellent. We were in Key West a week and ate at Roostica at least 3 times. I would highly recommend this place. It's definitely a gem! read more

Food was great. We tried the Jamaican chicken wings and a pizza which was very good. The woman who served us made great recommendations and we received our food promptly and hot! Love the t-shirts for sale. read more

As always.. the food and service was amazing. There was a bus guy that had really bad BO.. made it a bit harder to really enjoy

I think it is best put if you are from an area that is known for Pizza (NY, Chicago, SF etc) you will be disappointed. The service is great. The staff is willing and helpful. They are prompt. The Brussel sprouts are very good. The pizza is wood fired. We had 4 types. All lacked flavor and texture we are used to from wood fired pizza. Note. They do not deliver so you do have to eat in or take out. I would order other dishes than the pizza if you are a pizza person. If you are a Dominos is definitely a 5 then order a pizza read more

We were sat quickly & our waitress was very attentive. the food is perfect. I will definitely be back read more

Roostica - Homemade Meatball Sliders (3) - Italian Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

I had the chicken parmigiana it had very little sauce and was burnt on the edges. Service was good. My wife had pink shrimp Alfredo it was pretty good only six shrimp. read more

Family all ate here and WE LOVED IT!!! Check this place out when in the keys! Great food. Great prices. Awesome portions and incredibly friendly staff! We will be back! Highly recommended!!! read more

We have been here twice and plan at least two trips more before we go. It's within walking distance of the Perry Hotel so we got to get off the boat, have a little exercise and a great meal- what could be better? Everything here is 'fired' and so delicious! read more

Sweet baby Jesus this food was absolutely amazing. Portions are substantial and flavor is absolutely amazing. We ate ourselves into a miserable bliss!!! 10/10 recommend. read more

See all

This place is open and serving people. Unable to hang around long enough for an order because I have to get back to the mainland. I don't feel like doing takeout. read more

I wanted to try every pizza on the menu! I got a margarita and a pig and fig pizza, both were delicious. The flavors on the pig and fig went so well together and the dough was perfect. The garlic bread was heaven, I added cheese. Everything is fair priced too and the staff was super friendly. Definitely will be coming back. read more

Sincerely the best pizza on Stock Island. Tops for all of Key West. Especially the staff. So welcoming and friendly. We loved our bartender, Ms Summer! ***couldnt resist to add more. Hannah A. treated us like regulars. She read our vibe and picked out our meal for us. Rotolos to start (omg), the Sicilian deep-dish and a side of Brussels sprouts (needed green roughage). And she picked my red wine. All amazing. Happy! read more

Roostica - Italian Near Me - Key West, Florida

Food is absolutely delicious! Every dish we ordered was great! Oysters Rockefeller are the best I ever had, cooked to perfection, fresh well balanced flavor, just yummm! Antipasti plate is huge with great meat cuts. read more

See all

100% one of the best restaurants on stock Island, I would put it up against any restaurant on Key West as being a top five in all of Key West. Great staff great food and good wine. read more

See all

Great for a pizza or pasta, not many other options though. The indoor and outdoor seating options are both great. Unfortunately sandwiches are only available at lunch read more

8 min walk from our camp site!!! Great Italian Restaurant, made it for happy hour too!

Drove past this lovely place several times during our stay in Key West. I'm very upset. We only decided to stop in on our last night, when we could have eaten here a few more times!!!! Our server, Amanda, was positively wonderful, offering helpful suggestions and totally understanding how important it was that our group of six needed to have enough food, which was brought out quickly. We had the fried calamari, which was perfect, a couple of salads, which were fresh and tasty and accompanied by the most delicately flavored salad dressing. The pasta, of which we had lasagna, chicken Alfredo, and spaghetti and meatballs, were all delicious and al dente perfect. The Brooklyn Boys pizza was out of this world!!! Crust was crispy and chewy, sauce seasoned perfectly, and the meats fresh and bursting with decadent flavor. For those who enjoy ambiance - truthfully it matters not to me - the atmosphere is casual but not chain restaurant cheesy. This could be a first or fifteenth date spot, a nice and easy dinner on the weekend place, or a family dinner place. Apologies for the lack of pictures, but everything got eaten too quickly. Also, please note how many times I used the word "perfect" in this review. :) read more

Lobster ravioli for the Monday night special!! Holy crap, so delicious! Best meal I had in the keys. If you don't have a car to drive here...Uber, taxi, ride a bike...whatever it takes. Worth the trip! (P.s. the pizza is amazeballs too) read more

Roostica - Lobster ravioli - Italian Near Me - Key West, Florida

We were excited when we entered because the t was decorated in a very inviting way. However, when we arrived at 8:30 with a 10:00 pm close, they were not eager to serve us. The server was not very attentive and the food was very bland. The pizza was undercooked and my shrimp was rubbery. read more

Pizza is great! Unbelievably delicious! My favorite dish is the chicken piccata! Great atmosphere and off the beaten path of downtown Key West! Definitely a locals go to restaurant. read more

Well made pizza! Nice snappy crust with great toppings. My kids picked up a few pizzas and brought them back to us at a nearby RV park. Very convenient location with good pizza and quality ingredients used. I was a little upset That the hot peppers we asked for were red peppers, but still tasty. read more

We had dinner at this restaurant and the food is solid. Excellent pizza, nearly as good as ones from New York. The entrees were large and well made, with authentic and classic flavors. A very nice place. read more

This place was awesome. Only issue I had was eating to much. :) The staff was very friendly and there wasn't a long wait to get in. Try the hog fish and pasta, you won't be disappointed. We will definitely be coming back when we visit the keys again. read more