the ice cream is average not bad but what irked me the most was the way i was treated. the staff was rude and gave attitude when nothing prompted it. I personally wouldn't go again read more

My wife and I were in Avalon on a port day from our cruise ship, and decided to get some ice cream before heading back to our tender to take us back. My wife had noticed the Sailor's Delight shop earlier in the morning, so we decided to stop in. It was really, really good. My family lived in Wisconsin for more than 20 years, most of them in the Madison area. During that time we got to really love a local favorite ice cream brand: Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream. It's definitely a premium brand and thought it was local to the Midwest only. Well...once we entered Sailor's Delight, signs proudly proclaimed that they served Chocolate Shoppe, shipped directly from the plant in Madison. This made my wife immediately look for her favorite flavor: Zanzibar. It's a chocolate ice cream, blending 3 types of cocoa, to produce a very rich but bingeable ice cream. One scoop was priced at $7.50 in a cup, with each additional scoop being $2.25. So I added one of my favorite flavors, mint chocolate chip, to pay for a two scooper. And in Wisconsin tradition, one scoop really means two...our attendant took a regular size ice cream scoop and plunged it in each container to grab two scoops of each. We ate it outside. The ice cream was as good as I remember, and alternating between mint chocolate chip and the Zanzibar was marvelous. We sat down on the edge of the fountain right outside, doing a little people watching while enjoying the weather. It makes me smile thinking about it. I was curious if there were other places around where we live that serves Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream, and OMG Burgers and More seems to do so. Guess where I am going, the next chance I get... read more

See all

I really enjoyed this cute ice cream shop. We would come every evening after dinner during our 3 day stay on the island. The ice cream is delicious and they have a variety of flavors to choose from. I also think the price point isn't too bad for Catalina. It is imported by boat after all! It's located on the Casino side of the island, along the boardwalk and near the water. Nothing beats a stroll along the water with ice cream in hand. So few places are open later on the island. It was so great that Sailor's Delight is open until 9pm!!! read more

See all

Not amazing but very good. Some interesting flavors and great service. For a tourist place, excellent. read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

Background On Sailors: Sailor's Delight Ice Cream Shop is a family-owned business founded in 2021 by longtime island locals who have been residents of Catalina Island since the 80s. Having owned Pete's Cafe and Stacy's Cards and Gifts in the 80's, 90's and early 2000's, they knew they wanted to continue to contribute to our community. They're happy to be able to bring ice cream back to 220 Crescent Ave, and to continue bringing memories to new and old generations of Catalina Island. Ice Cream Made in-house or sourced elsewhere. They get their ice cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Co in Wisconsin. Background On Visit: Temps at Avalon was hot enough to make you uncomfortable on the day that we visited. With that said, we went to Sailor's Delight to try their ice cream. Restrooms: No restroom. Credit Cards: They're available. Price Point: It's a bit pricey due to where the shop is located. Location: Located on Crescent Ave. (The locals call that street, Front Street) Ambiance/Decor: It's a little ice cream shop. Just enough to go in, try a sample or two, order what you want, pay, and get out of the shop to find a place to enjoy your ice cream while taking in the views of Avalon Bay. Service: Service was alright. Didn't feel rushed when we patronized that shop. Line wasn't long. Samples: You're only able to sample 2 flavors so I had to make a emotional decision based on my how I was feeling. Ice Cream Flavors Of Choice: I got a 2 scooper in a cup. Decided that the base should be the savory pb hearts chocolate (Peanut butter ice cream swirled with a smooth chocolate ripple and kissed with peanut butter cups) and the top scoop should be kitty kitty bang bang (Cheesecake ice cream mixed with a sweet raspberry ripple, Oreo cookies and soft chocolate chunks.). It was the greatest decision I made. Absolutely yum! It was a bit messy to eat, because it was literally melting on my hands. Make sure get plenty of napkins and some water to clean off your hands. Sailor Delight For Thought: Would love to come back and try their hearts of love and pistachio nut. read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - two scoop: Kitty kitty bang bang and pb hearts chocolate on the bottom - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

LOVE THIS SHOP! I wish I lived nearby, so I could visit every weekend! I am always on the hunt for dairy-free ice cream, and usually have to settle for sorbet at ice cream shops. Sailor's Delight went above and beyond and offered 3 different kinds of dairy-free ice cream! Black Cherry, Vanilla, and Chocolate Chip - all made with oat milk. I ordered the Black Cherry Oat and it was perfection. I would buy this if it was sold in pints at the grocery store. Not icey or grainy like other DF alternatives, but creamy and full of flavor! read more

See all

Big fan of Sailor's. They serve quality ice cream aka "super-premium" from Wisconsin's Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream on Crescent Street across from Coney Island. Same location as Big Olaf's from days of yore (where apothecary tables come from). The store is pretty small, but it's more organized than Scoops. It's hard to look at all the flavors before you order, but it's doable. Kinda wish they'd put a "sandwich board" outside everyday listing the current flavors. I've ordered the Superhuman Ice Cream a couple times, and I can't quite describe the flavoring. The website says it combines cherry, Blue Moon and Vanilla ice creams. It was very flavorful!, super creamy, kinda thick and kept at the right temp. It's cool that they have special American flag cups on the 4th of July! read more

See all

Recommended to us by our scuba instructor. She was telling us about the different eateries as we were walking to the diving area. I looked them up before stopping by. This shop is family owned and looks like they've been on the island since the 80s. They were not open at noon as scheduled. They were a few minutes late, but I noticed on their website that they said "hours and closures may vary." I wanted s'more to Love but they did not have enough to fill a scoop so I opted for chocolate and added chocolate sprinkles instead. Gavin ordered the superman (cherry, blue moon, and vanilla). The ice cream were creamy and not too sweet Not sure when we will be back, but we both finished our single scoop. read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Chocolate with chocolate sprinkles. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

Great ice cream, the servers were very nice, no seating area inside but in catalina theres so many more better spots with views outside. Recommend to try if you come to catalina read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - 3 scoop coconut, heaps of love, and banana cream pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

This was the BEST place on the whole island. The ice cream shop is very tiny. The ice cream was soooo good. I walked in and received service right away. The ladies working here were nice and helpful. Ate my ice cream while overlooking the water. Definitely a memorable experience and ice cream treat. 5/5 stars! read more

See all

We had a wonderful experience at Sailors today! I really enjoyed the two flavors I tried with the waffle cone, and everything was delicious. Maryanne and her team did an amazing job accommodating our large group, and everyone was so friendly and welcoming. Thank you for making our visit such a great one. We will definitely be back! read more

Out of the three options, I would say this is my favorite ice cream shop on Catalina Island. They really stand out with their huge selections of interesting flavors and the staff was polite during our visit. They didn't have any flavors that I order on repeat but they had a ton of great options and some very interesting and unique flavors. Inside is very small and they don't have indoor seating options so this will be just to go. However it's located right on the water on Avalon Bay and right in the heart of downtown Avalon so it's a great place to grab some ice cream before you walk around and people watch. I will definitely be back next time I am on the island and plan to get it again tonight after dinner. read more

See all

Omg wow. Best ice cream spot in Catalina island according to the locals here! As we were driving around catalina island on our golf cart, we can't help but smell the fresh waffle cones coming out from Sailors Delight and knew we had to get some after returning our golf cart. There was a small line around noon when we got our sweet treat to cool down, but the line moved quick! I got 2 scoops (blackberry lemon bar and apple cider donut) because I couldn't decide on just 1 flavor. There was a great selection of flavors. I'm a sucker for lemon flavored foods and the blackberry lemon bar was so refreshing with pieces of lemon cake bar! The apple cider donut flavor was also very good. I loved the cinnamon flavor in the ice cream. Both paired perfectly together. Bf got a smores shake and enjoyed it so much he wanted another one!! It was rich and creamy. We will definitely be back again when we visit! read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Top: Blackberry Lemon Bar, Bottom: Apple Cider Donut on a sugar cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

SAILOR'S DELIGHT ICE CREAM - A WISCONSIN HYPE THAT IS FACTZ Located on the other end of the Catalina pier. There's three ice cream shops, this is the one you want to experience. Forget the generic, mass-produced frozen desserts; this is real ice cream, made with a smooth texture and experiential ingredients that dance well together. Walking in, you're met with a fun, airy vibe that makes you feel like a kid again. The playful menu is filled with creative, laugh-out-loud flavor names that make choosing a scoop half the fun. And the best part? Tasters are encouraged, so you get to explore before committing.  My personal favorite? "Exhausted Parent"--a bourbon-infused masterpiece. I don't like bourbon, but in ice cream.. Absolute perfection. The balance of flavors is spot on and indulgent. Like a good rum cake. This parent went from exhausted to elated. When you're on the island, Sailor's Delight, is a must. Not maybe. Not next time. It's the kind of treat that reminds you why real, handcrafted ice cream and calories is worth the stop. My recommend rewrite of the Google description, what do you think? "Sailor's Delight Ice Cream serves rich, smooth, and naturally flavorful ice cream made in Wisconsin--because if you think our cheese is the best, just wait until you try this.  Stop in for a taste, grab a scoop, and discover why real, handcrafted ice cream is worth it." read more

See all

Two words: Fat Elvis. Sailor's Delight Ice Cream was Catalina Island's saving grace for food and beverage. We came here twice during our 3-day stay...and I miss it! Peanut butter and chocolate ripples in a sweet banana cream? Perfection. Helped us fight off the heat and perfect to grab while walking around. read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Fat Elvis - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

A sherbet you never thought you needed - carrot mango. A soft sherbet, melt in your mouth. Not overly sweet with mostly mango flavors, but the subtle sweetness of the carrot. Dairy free. Gluten free love. They also have old fashion vanilla, mint chip, and rocky road. What's great is they have oat based creamy selections and even some with a touch of coffee, espresso, or bourbon. Everyone one of us has only great things to say. Lastly, no seating inside, but ample seating all around. read more

See all

We visited Avalon for a short and relaxing honeymoon. We were there to treat ourselves in every way possible. And ice cream tops pretty high on that priority list. We tried a couple other places around but once we found Sailor's Delight, we just kept going back. No need to waste time in line for generic or over-rated ice cream... just head straight to this spot and find the absolute best gourmet ice cream on the island, if not anywhere! Now, listen, I say "gourmet" but I'm a Thrifty's girl, not a snob... I do like a Cold Stone or Italian gelato too. So hear me out, gourmet doesn't mean weird or snooty, at Sailor's Delight it means FANTASTIC and tantalizing flavors that you'll never forget! At the risk of sounding like a complete pig, I will tell you that more than once (possibly many times) I couldn't decide on a flavor so I had triple scoop in a cup! Yes, 3 heaping scoops at a time and loved every single bite. Although we tried nearly a dozen flavors between the two of us, here are some of the flavors that will remain in my fondest memories forever: - Blackberry Lemon Bar (lemon ice cream with blackberry sauce swirls and perfect chunks of poundcake) - Munchie Madness (I can't even tell you all the bits of candies that were turned inside this sweet vanilla ice cream with caramel ripple) - Party Animal (tastes like those pink and white animal cookies times 10) They've got Vegan and Non-Dairy flavors as well, tons to choose from. We tried the Raspberry Lemon Italian Ice and it was just the right amount of pucker and sweet. There are even some No Sugar Added options! Several cone options, but we like ours in a cup. We enjoyed each lick and each bite while watching the beautiful Pacific Ocean under the sun. Located across Crescent from the Metropole Market Place, right next to the water. Dare I say it is better than Lloyds, better than Scoops and better than Catalina Cones (which used to be our favorite). But all are just fine in their own rights, but Sailor's Delight is definitely a cut above in taste and service. Enjoy!! read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Sailor's Delight: a MUST try while in Catalina!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

Decided to check this place out after seeing all the positive Yelp Reviews! This is a quaint little shop located next to a clothing store. They have a myriad of flavors and I decided to get their most award-winning flavor: THIS $&@! JUST GOT SERIOUS Even though I'm not a fan of caramel ice cream, this was shockingly creamy and delicious. I can see why they won an award with this ice cream flavor! The cashews along with the sea salt elevate this flavor to make it taste scrumptious. This was a nice treat after eating lunch. read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - THIS $&@! JUST GOT SERIOUS - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

The best ice cream and alternative ice cream options in town! The service is always friendly and provide samples. The ambiance is clean and sometime there's a long line, but it's worth it! They are always changing flavors and it's so refreshing! read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Black cherry ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

Great ice cream and friendly staff! Visited on 5/19. Will return again to try their other flavors.

Good ice cream, not anything outstanding but still a really nice option in catalina!!!

This is a small ice cream shop located in the busy city center -- perfect for a quick grab-and-go treat, as there's no indoor seating. They offer some unique and interesting flavors. I tried the cherry, and it was quite good. Conveniently located within walking distance from the Catalina ferry drop-off point. read more

See all

2 samples per person, and high prices! I get it because it's such a touristy spot but still. Ice cream was good. My husband and I shared a double scoop and that was enough for us. Workers were nice. Very small place but plenty of seating outside the shop and by the water read more

Honestly been so long since I went, but I recall there being a HUGE LINE. The store is absolutely tiny but so worth the wait! Getting the cone in the cup was such a good idea because it didn't end up melting all over my arm. They let you try samples which is so nice, but it was so hard picking which one I wanted. They're all SO YUMMYYYY! I think I opted for raspberry cheesecake? I forgot but I remember finishing it quick. Especially after snorkeling, this is the perfect treat! Pretty quick service but the line felt gruelingly long haha! read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

Loved the ice cream from here so much that I came two nights in a row and got the same exact thing! The single scoop cups were very large and really closer to 2-3 scoops, so I went with a single scoop, but half and half of the Ultimate Oreo and This $&@! just Got Serious. Though not displayed with their cup sizes, they also have a kids scoop, which my mom got of the Blackberry Lemon bar and loved. read more

See all

The peach lavender ice cream is 10/10 I don't normally like super sweet and that was a perfect amount of sweetness. The staff is so so kind and they get you in and out easily and kindly. I went both days I stayed in Catalina and crave the peach lavender ice cream. read more

We heard about Sailors while we were waiting in line for our Catalina Express Ferry. It was from a local suggestion who stated that Sailors has a better selection and taste than the other famous location on the Island Scoops. I am glad we listened because this place was very delicious. The waffle cones were 10/10, it was made fresh. So fresh it was literally hot in my hands! The staff were super friendly and the ice cream tasted delicious. read more

Your classic icecream shop with the classic flavors. This has a more local mom and pop feel than Scoops. If not looking for anything fancy this is the place to get it. read more

Hits the spot after eating dinner! The fat Elvis was everything!! I don't take a picture because of how good it was sorry yelp

good ice cream very much enjoy. small shop tiny words need to get close to see menu but big line. 2 samples per person so choose wisely. has vegan options read more

Great ice cream! The quick and friendly service can't be beat! It's not overly sweet or artificial tasting. Very rich, cold creamy goodness. The s'mores is off the charts, literally spot on. The bubble gum is great for the kids, my son said the gum is just chewy candy and not actually gum. My black cherry scoop had giant chewy pieces of cherry, every bite was satisfying. If you are looking for a solid ice cream shop, this place won't disappoint. The price was under $20 for three single scoops. My only complaint is the paper is really stuck on the sugar cones lol, eating some paper is safe I guess once in awhile. Stop in and support this small shop, it's really cute and very Catalina! read more

See all

There are many ice cream shops in Avalon but I decided to give this one a go. They give two free samples per person so I got two try out 4 different ones with two people. I ended up getting the waffle cone with 2 scoops of ice cream for $13. Ice cream was very tasty and you really can't go wrong with any flavors here. I got the strawberry cheesecake flavor and it hit hard. It's a bit pricey but for great flavors and overall great taste this spot is a solid. They only open on the weekends, (at least that's what it was when I came in December) so if you're around definitely worth a try! read more

See all

The most delicious ice cream I have ever had ! The country cherry was a favorite ! Exhausted parent was delicious too, quick service and friendly gals over the counter . read more

Good ice cream option for a hot day. They'll let you try 2 samples. I got a kids size in a cup. The Keylime was decently tart and the graham crust was nice and chunky. read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Keylime cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

This was my first time visiting Avalon on Catalina Island. The first thing to hit you as you walk by is the heavenly smell of waffle cones being made fresh in shop, as if I needed an excuse to check it out. I got a double scoop of the Zanzibar chocolate ice cream in a waffle cone. This was probably the BEST thing I ate on the island. The staff were very friendly. The shop was clean, and although small, had a great in and out flow so it didn't feel cramped or crowded. If you visit Avalon, this is a definite must try!! read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Sailor's Delight Ice Cream Shop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

The ice cream itself is really good and they have a couple of fun and unique flavors! Minus 2 stars because the sprinkles tasted very strongly of soap almost like they were soaked in fabuloso making the ice cream inedible. read more

We paid over ten dollars for a basic two scoop cup of ice cream that was not made in house. The flavors are sourced from Wisconsin, most likely from Chocolate Shoppe, which costs about two dollars and twenty cents wholesale for that portion. Most boutique scoop shops that actually make their own ice cream charge around five fifty to six fifty for two scoops. This shop charged significantly more for a product they did not create, with no toppings, no cone, no table service, and not even a place to sit. That is a markup of around three hundred to four hundred percent for a very basic experience. To top it off, they did the awkward line where the staff says the register is going to ask you a question, and then it prompts for a tip. You are already paying a premium for resold product, and they still ask for more. The flavor tasted extremely plain. No cute cups, spoons, branding or ambience. Nothing about this justifies the price. I would not return. read more

The ice cream was delicious! It tastes authentic. The service was quick! I didn't see the cookies and cream flavor in the buckets out front but the employee heard me say "they don't have cookies and cream?!" And she said we have it right here (it was on the back counter) so I ordered that in a waffle cone. I was surprised that the waffle cone was WARM! It was warm and yummy! The shop itself is small, so plan to enjoy your ice cream outside! read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Cookies n cream waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

Really nice staff! I'm lactose-free and was so happy to see more than one option for me. I got the vegan cookies and cream and it was so good. Wish I could try the non-vegan flavors too -- they looked amazing! read more

Sailor’s Delight Ice Cream Shop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Avalon, California

We stopped by for an evening delight. We miss Olaf's terribly. I ordered two scoops of vanilla and hot fudge in a cup. I didn't even walk out the door and the ice cream was melting all over my hand ... The fudge was more like jello it smelled burnt as well. We asked for just vanilla with no fudge instead. We received a refund for the difference. It wasn't exact and we had to review and concur with the staff member once more to correct. Catalina is not the same, seems staff was unhappy. read more