Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sally’s Apizza

    3.2 (132 reviews)
    Closed 11:30 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated a few days ago

    Order Sally’s Apizza Takeout or Delivery

    Sally’s Apizza Photos

    SALLY’S APIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Trendy
    Classy
    Happy hour specials

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sally’s Apizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    The original, Yes this one is "ONE TO GO" after I had a pizza already inside
    Mark A.

    Every time I come to eat in the state of Connecticut, I have to make my way for a Sally's a pizza you have to stop here and try their famous tomato pie with the light cheese. It comes out cooked perfectly every time ,well done ,crispy ,moist juicy savory. it is a reason why this Pizza place has been around for nearly 100 years. The service was fast as always, super supportive and all my needs when I ask for some olive oil with pesto on the side they took care of me very quickly. The atmosphere is really clean and up-to-date modern, easy parking right in front. Take a look at the video ..100% five star Pizza. 9.5 Mr Portnoy!!

    Ken K.

    Ok , so I went back the next night ( they were previously closed for a private event) Really glad we came back. The food and service were outstanding. We had a garlic bread app ( fantastic), chopped salad ( outstanding), Chicken Parm ( very good), pizza ( phenomenal) *Only complaint , the young lady at the hostess stand wasn't very friendly... and when she was , it was fake. I had a reservation At 6:15 and when I checked in , she told me "you're going to have to wait until 6:15 , we're very busy" I looked at the time , it was 6:11.... Ok Then , another guy came in and didn't have a reservation, she seemed to enjoy telling him in a condescending manner that there was no way. She seemed to relish her position of authority (twit)

    Tomato Pie
    Lauren T.

    Great spot for classic Connecticut-style pizza. We tried the tomato pie with pepperoni: perfectly thin crust, chunky tomato sauce, and just the right crisp. The potato rosemary pizza was a pleasant surprise and ended up being a favorite. The garlicky white base was incredibly flavorful and paired so well with the rosemary and potatoes. Everything was delicious. Highly recommend checking this place out!

    Angelo B.

    First time here. Usually do Frank Pepe, but a CT friend suggested to give this place a try. Pizza was delicious. Maybe marginally better than Pepe. My favorite was the pepp, but everything we tried was good. Potato pizza was interesting. I believe that prices are higher than Pepe, but the pizzas are bigger too. We had 3 smalls between us two hungry guys, and it ended up being more than enough. Only complaint is that the pizza is a little slow to come out. We were there on a Thursday night and arrived before 6, so had assumed we would be in an out. I think they had a bunch of takeout orders ahead of us. Lots of parking, including a few 15min spots right outside the store for the takeout orders.

    Traditional pie
    Rida S.

    Amazing food as usual. The pizza came out quickly even though we went on a Saturday night. Our waitress who was the bartender also was so nice and attentive they ran out of the fox trot soda so she brought us other soda for no charge. And I love the ambiance very close to me and I love having sallys nearby.

    Exterior
    Michael W.

    I like the vibe in here. Our server was amazing even w a group of 7 people. Unfortunately the pizza was just "ok" for me. For the higher prices I expected much better. I also tried a bite of my wife's hot honey drizzled pizza which tasted great but I had some sort of reaction to it (I have no known allergies!). Figured it was a fluke but when I ate the leftovers the next day it happened again. Parking here is horrible because it's a shared lot w the apartments above. You're either parking a mile away or in tight spots just asking for door dings. Although it wasn't horrible I still wouldn't recommend and probably wouldn't go back even if a group of friends wanted to eat here. Way too many other great options in town or just over the river.

    Dan R.

    "Sneakin' Sally through the alley Trying to get away clean Sneakin' through the alley with Sally When up pops the queen" (Robert Palmer) New Haven style pizza has been in the news a lot lately, thanks to Connecticut's guerilla marketing campaign claiming to be the "Pizza Capital of the United States". Targeting New York City, Chicago, Detroit, and New Jersey, their billboard campaign playfully disses other cities' pizza styles, while promoting Connecticut's New Haven-style, coal-fired pizza. New Haven style pizza has long been found in Connecticut beyond New Haven, and today we visited one of the newer locations of the state's Holy Trinity (Sally's, Pepe's. Modern) when we had lunch at Sally's in Wethersfield. They've been open less than a year. I've eaten a lot of pizza over the years, but I don't think I've ever been to a pizza restaurant located on the ground floor of a four-story "Modern Luxury Apartment" complex, but that exactly describes where Sally's is located. The Borden apartments are in a massive brick building with four floors of apartment units; and there is Sally's -right on street level facing the Silas Deane Highway. So, if you're looking to visit Sally's, just keep an eye open for that tall brick building. When you walk in, you'll see a hostess stand, spacious dining room and Sally's open kitchen. The menu has pizza of course -three traditional New Haven varieties (Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Pie, Tomato Sauce Pie, and White Pie) plus ten or so rotating Specialty Pies with yummy ingredients like shrimp, potatoes, clams, and stinger peppers. If someone in your party isn't a pizza fan, no worries because Sally's also has appetizers, salads, entrees and sandwiches on the menu. Our server Laura started with an informational disclaimer about New Haven pizza, how its cooked in an 800-degree oven and may have a charred crust, but that's intentional. We shared a $14.75 Chopped Salad of iceberg lettuce, salami, peppers, mozzarella, red onion, olive salad, and chickpeas with an Italian vinaigrette. It was a very good-sized and delicious salad (maybe a teense spicy?) and very splitable for two people. We also split a small ($17.25) Mozzarella and Sauce Pie, and that was incredible. Yes, some of the outer crust had the black char on the crust's perimeter that Laura mentioned, but it did nothing to detract from the overall excellence of Sally's sauce, cheese, and micro-thin crust. Quite honestly, the pizza was sensational, and so was lunch at our first visit to the Wethersfield Sally's.

    Kazi S.

    We came here on a windy weekend day during lunchtime. Our experience was very positive. We were greeted and seated immediately and really enjoyed the inside decor. We were expecting it to be a little less fancier than it was. We were also able to take advantage of the happy hour between two and four on Sundays. We got the happy hour wings which were a little spicy but cooked to perfection. The pizza was very good as well. We got a large and added meatballs, and that was plenty to share with 2 to 3 people. We will definitely be making a trip here again!

    Pizza
    Tony Q.

    Finally had a chance to go to the famous New Haven pizza place while on a work trip. It's...ok. Broccolini was very under cooked crunchy, although the sauce was delicious. Pizza was also "fine" crispy bottom and edges but definitely not worth the price. It's way more expensive then a normal pizza place

    Todd R.

    Sally's Apizza has been on my bucket list for years and my first visit here did not disappoint! I am a huge fan of New Haven, CT style pizza, with its thin crust that is charred around edges. This was a great rendition, but I must say I was most impressed by the pizza sauce. Without question the best I have ever tasted! Add in their Sally's Pilsner beer and I was a very happy guy. Can't wait to come back!

    Meatball and ricotta
    Hannah C.

    The inside is super nice, very open and I love watching them make the pizza. Food was decent, the pizza wasn't as great as the true Sally's in New Haven. Seemed like our waitress forgot about us at some points. But the pizza is still good pizza, drinks were good as well.

    Small Sausage Mozzarella Apizza.
    Don P.

    The new Wetherfield location for Sally's Apizza is quite modern with plenty of tables and booths. Service was impeccable with an emphasis on hospitality, warm, inviting and friendly. No such thing as a bad pizza from Sally's but it didn't equal their original Sally's location. The same can be said for Pepe's and their other satellite locations. That being said, I think Pepe's comes the closest to replicating pizza's from their "Mothership". Sally's needs to fine tune a few parameters to come closer to their New Haven roots. One suggestion I'd offer is to keep the burnt debris from building up in the oven; make sure the oven is sweeped clean religiously. Watch the temps closely. I'm sure they will be successful in drawing closer to what we have come to expect and know as a Sally's New Haven Apizza.

    Lunch special 12" pizza with sausage, roasted peppers and onions
    Valerie R.

    I don't even like Sally's in New Haven. In fact, I hate it, and I always have. Their spizzas are terrible, the shop is dirty, and the workers are awful. I'm so glad we decided to try the Wethersfield location, because it's truly the opposite! We happened to go on a weekday for lunch, and were pleasantly surprised with the lunch specials. We both got 12" pizzas and a soda for $15.75 each. With the special, you can get up to 4 toppings, so I took full advantage. Now these same pizzas priced at standard menu price would have been $25 and $25.75 each, plus $3.95 each for the soda. If I had spend $60 on this meal instead of $33, I probably would have been irate. It was good, but it wasn't that good. Minus one star for their pretty high prices. The place is large and clean, nice staff, plenty of parking, and yummy pizza. They have a few flavors of foxon park fountain soda, including Birch beer. It's everything the New Haven location is not. Go check it out - especially at lunch! Lunch specials served M-F 11:30-4.

    Large mozz 1/2 sausage 1/2 bacon

    See all

    Photo of Deb B.
    0
    18
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    9.3/10 spot on perfect ratio of sauce to cheese...nice crips charred crust all around-no flop. One bite.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jon A.
    0
    22
    1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    I was there for their grand opening. It was awesome! The food, service and ambiance were great! What a great addition to the area!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 2
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Even if you order your pizza 10 hrs in advance don't expect it to be ready. Disappointed!!!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of K F.
    0
    1
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    friendly and attentive staff, food was good and came out quickly. overall a great experience!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Sally’s Apizza

    You might also consider

    Flock & Herd Gastropub - Double Smashburger (subbed cheddar cheese)

    Flock & Herd Gastropub

    4.2(56 reviews)
    3.3 mi

    I stopped by Flock & Herd with my parents on a Friday night and we were seated promptly with quick…read moreand kind service! The restaurant wasn't too crowded, but there were still a fair number of people, which was nice. There were a few specials--chicken noodle soup, meatloaf, etc that seemed tempting as well. My mom wound up getting the chicken noodle soup, and she loved it! We split the pork burnt ends appetizer. If I had known how good the pork was, I would've maybe gotten the pork belly bahn mi. I know I'll have to get that next time! Because this appetizer stole the show. I absolutely will have to get it again next time. I got the fish and chips, which were stellar! They were heavy on the fish and a little lighter on the breading than I normally expect, which was nice. The fries and coleslaw were delicious too--I really loved the fries. My dad got the wings, which he picked when he saw they make their own dry rub. Really great stuff!! Heavy on the seasoning but delicious. I'll definitely be back!

    I often come her for my solo dinner dates with myself. I recommend the appetizer that is golden…read morebeets with whipped ricotta and local honey. This particular occasion I had the double smash burger (I requested no bun) and a side salad to go with the keto diet I am currently attempting. So delicious and filling. Highly recommend this place for a date night and even a family place with a bit of elevation to your food.

    Photos
    Flock & Herd Gastropub - Bar

    Bar

    Flock & Herd Gastropub - Bomb Smash Burger (special)

    Bomb Smash Burger (special)

    Flock & Herd Gastropub - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    The Laurel - Vegan Hearts of Palm Ceviche with sweet potato chips

    The Laurel

    4.5(94 reviews)
    4.6 mi

    I'm glad I gave this place a second chance before writing my review. Our first visit was for dinner…read moreand while things were good, I did not love it. But it wasn't their fault, I didn't realize that there were olives (in some form or another) pretty much in every single dish I ordered and I don't love olives. As in, whatever I saw, say fish or duck with something I wanted, so I just ordered it without reading the fine details of what were in the dish. So that was my fault, I am sure they would have either suggested things without olives, or told me what things the olives could've been removed from. I knew the service was good and the food was beautifully plated, I just didn't love the things we ordered that time. I saw a post on Instagram that they had a French toast with Ube sauce and I knew I needed to go! I fell in love with Ube in Seattle a couple of years ago and now anytime I see it near me, I have to go get it. I saw the post on a Saturday morning and jumped online and made a brunch reservation for 11:45 the same day! Everything we had was fantastic, rather than wanting a basic sausage or bacon to go with the French toast sticks. I ordered the Bella Bella wings as my protein to go with my Ube French toast, and they were fantastic. I also had to start with the watermelon Crudo, which was interesting, the flavors were excellent, but the texture of the watermelon did not resemble watermelon so it could throw you off if you're not at least a mildly adventurous eater. My husband had the prawn and grits and said it was fabulous and that he would order it again. I did not try it because the portion is not that big and the French toast was filling me up so I let him enjoy his own meal, and did share a couple wings with him and he agreed they were really good. The service was great again, and as simple as it sounds, I loved how when we were seated the hostess asked what kind of water we wanted, we did not have to wait for any period of time for a server to come over and ask us. The attention is in the details and that is always important. The cocktails were great, though a little pricey, which is on par for things in Connecticut. We enjoyed them both at brunch and on our first dinner visit when we went we will be back, and I actually already prepaid for a dinner experience coming up with Filipino food and I'm excited for it! I have friends that went and said it was epic! So while we usually go to brunch, only if there are bottomless mimosas, this is one exception that will stay on our rotation! The restaurant is cute, intimate and clean.

    Went out to celebrate my birthday…read more The Laurel absolutely delivered. The kitchen started us off with a complimentary Watermelon Crudo...the exact dish I had almost ordered. Thinly sliced marinated watermelon over tahini green goddess with chili crunch and sesame seeds. Bright, refreshing, tangy, with just enough heat on the finish. A surprisingly delicious combination. The Brussels sprouts were loaded with flavor. Crispy sprouts, pretzel crumble, kielbasa, mustard vinaigrette, and whipped crème fraîche created the perfect mix of smoky, creamy, salty, and crunchy. The Picnic Chicken was comfort food with a creative twist. Pickle-brined drumsticks over smoky baked beans and fresh slaw. Every bite tasted like summer. All it needed was a wicker basket and a checkered blanket. The special Liempo was phenomenal. Tender Berkshire pork belly with a savory calamansi-soy marinade, crispy shallots, and herbs. Rich, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The Wagyu Beef Skewers were another winner. Tender souvlaki-style beef paired with whipped feta and an olive and date salad that balanced salty, sweet, and briny flavors beautifully. Dessert was their Unbirthday Cake. A light, airy angel food cake layered with marshmallow meringue frosting and a sweet soak that kept everything moist without becoming overly sweet. A fun, nostalgic ending to a fantastic meal. I love restaurants that aren't afraid to borrow inspiration from different cultures while still respecting the flavors that make those dishes special. The Laurel does exactly that, and the execution backs it up. Excellent food. Outstanding service. Another birthday dinner that won't soon be forgotten. Highly recommend.

    Photos
    The Laurel - Bar

    Bar

    The Laurel - Vegan Chocolate Mousse Valrhona chocolate, fried peanuts, shortbread cookie, peanut butter sauce (Photo by: Deanna Troy Travels)

    Vegan Chocolate Mousse Valrhona chocolate, fried peanuts, shortbread cookie, peanut butter sauce (Photo by: Deanna Troy Travels)

    The Laurel - Heart of Palm Ceviche

    See all

    Heart of Palm Ceviche

    Casadoro - Tagliatelle with mushroom ragu Chicken Parm

    Casadoro

    4.0(220 reviews)
    3.6 mi

    We came here to celebrate a graduation during a very busy weekend with graduations and Mother's…read moreDay, so we completely understand that the restaurant was packed. Our waitress was absolutely amazing. She was kind, attentive, and whenever something was forgotten, she immediately went to speak with the kitchen and tried to make it right. That being said, our table definitely seemed to fall into a bit of a communication dead zone. My chicken parm was forgotten, and while waiting for it the rest of my family's food got cold. They ended up sending their pasta back to be reheated, which also took a while. Our drinks were forgotten at one point as well, and our to go dessert sat waiting for a long time before anyone brought it over. The food itself was great and we still enjoyed celebrating together, but overall the experience would have been much smoother with better communication between the kitchen and staff. The perfume machine in the bathroom is a fun touch

    Went with a party of 10, I made reservations and we were able to sit down on time. Service was…read morewonderful. Drinks stayed filled, and the waiter came by to make sure we didn't want any refills on any alcoholic beverages as they were being consumed. He recommended a few appetizers for the table. We got to try the chef special, garlic bread with ricotta, and calamari. All very good. As was the bread and oil that I think comes with every meal. After I heard the specials, I went with the short rib gnocchi, but the salmon with spaghetti squash was a close second. I wasn't disappointed in my dish. It was a really good size and I ended up taking half of it back with me, something tells me it's gonna be even better the next day as most Italian food is. My one regret is that I didn't order the lemon cheesecake to go. All of the desserts sounded amazing, especially the hazelnut tart, however, the lemon cheesecake is super cute and I heard from other people that have been to this restaurant before that it is delicious. Maybe next time!

    Photos
    Casadoro - Front dining room

    Front dining room

    Casadoro - Broccoli Rabe

    Broccoli Rabe

    Casadoro - Instala Verdi

    See all

    Instala Verdi

    Sally’s Apizza - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...