Sally&#x27;s Sweet Shoppe

Love this place. I'd been here over 5 years ago and remembered they had really delicious coffee…read moredrinks, so I stopped back in here when I happened to be in town on a snowy December day. Staff was super kind and welcoming when I walked in, and had no issues changing/updating my order when I discovered they had an incredible list of holiday drinks instead of my boring old latte. My Gingerbread Latte was soooo decadent and a welcome treat on such a cold and icky morning. I arrived when they first opened in the morning, in a snowstorm, during finals week... so I was the only one there that I could see, but they do have tons of space to sit down at a table or curl up in a comfy seat... and multiple rooms. It's a very homey spot that I certainly recommend checking out.

When we first arrived on a weekend day it was crowded and they were out of a lot of things in…read morebakery case. Staff was friendly, our order was correct and food and drink was decent. Extensive drink menu and some food items for breakfast or light lunch. Food took a while and the table was sticky. But I think they were busy and short staffed.

Coffee Tea and Sweets

Bagel sandwich

See all

Cornerstone Restaurant

4.5(79 reviews)

0.1 mi

This is one of our favorite restaurants and it never disappoints. We had the Meatloaf and Monte…read moreCristo sandwiches along with the chicken dumpling and mushroom soups. Everything was delicious, as always! Our server, Khean, was excellent. She has a great personality and a wonderful personality. The restaurant is wonderfully decorated with art from different artists. Do yourself a favor and check out their dessert assortment. Some of their desserts come from Sally's Sweet Shoppe, a local bakery that makes awesome desserts and breads.

Our favorite restaurant in the Milwaukee area. It is set in Genesee Depot which is basically out in…read morethe country. Food is wondeful and the cost is reasonable. It is family-owned so we love to give them business.

Monte Cristo

See all

Meatloaf sandwich

Simply D'Lish Cupcakes

5.0(8 reviews)

8.1 mi

Good food and terrific owner I can't imagine anyone not enjoying the food and loving Anna…read more The dining room has always been nice and cozy but I'll admit I have not been a dine in since before the pandemic. But I would think it would be the same. I usually do Take out only.

Wow ! Make a trip off the beaten path and come to this place …read more I don't like sweets that much and I find myself craving these cupcakes ! The flavor combinations at this place are out of this world ! The cupcakes themselves have amazing texture ! Each cupcake is topped with its perfect frosting companion for the ultimate finishing touch ! If these cupcakes were ever entered into a contest they would win every time. They sell both big cupcakes and smaller bite sized ones . Prices for these are spot on ! They are only open Friday , Saturday and Sunday . They cater for events ! My sister used this place for her wedding and it was a huge hit .

Order one to eat in :)

"Red, Burlap & Bling" Wedding

See all

Clausing Barn, Old World Wisconsin

Brick House Mercantile & Artisan Kitchen

4.8(8 reviews)

6.2 mi

Five stars is not enough! Locally sourced organic culinary artwork! The chef, Jeremy is amazing…read more Joe bakes the most fabulous treats. Not an ordinary restaurant so check their website for hours and offerings. Dine in or take out, healthiest, yummiest food you could want!

This is the second time that I had lunch here. It was just as good as the first time. First thing…read moreyou should know is that it's not a restaurant, they refer to themselves as an artisan kitchen. Check out their website for more background on this difference. What I love about this place is that the menu is constantly changing. Each day may bring something new, so come prepared for an adventure. Came a little before noon with a friend. It's a small place, with a few small tables and a couple larger ones for groups or seating strangers together. Lots of nice light coming through the large windows. Got seated right away with a couple waters (with lemon). And Joe (one of the owners), helped us settle and took our orders. The two entrees today were Blacked Mahi-mahi Tostada and Wagyu Beef and Summer Vegetable Bolognese. These both did not take long to come out. Both the perfect temperatures and excellent flavors. So good that you want to take your time and savior the complexity of all the flavors and textures. It's a gourmet experience in a casual environment. They sometimes run out of items, so get their early if you want to be sure to your first choice.

Teas

Bolognese

See all

Citrus ice tea

Bon Ton Bakery

4.8(30 reviews)

22.2 mi

They did a great job on the cupcake ring for an engagement party I was hosting for my son and new…read moredaughter-in-law

Amazing baked goods, my absolute favorite donuts that remind me of my grandmas baking! And the…read moreservice is always so sweet. Whenever we go, we get oodles of goodies!

Look at that bun cohesion! Whatchu kno bout that bun cohesiveness!?

See all

Da bomb

Lauber's Old Fashion Ice Cream Parlor

4.7(40 reviews)

12.5 mi

Amazing spot! We can after dinner on the 4th of July and it was incredible. The place is like a…read moremuseum with classic fountain ice cream, amazing malts and shakes!

Walking into this place is like walking right back in time! It's an old school ice cream parlor…read morewith matching decorations! They have a great candy selection. You can sit down and enjoy your ice cream or get it to go! The turtle sundae with butterscotch and fudge, YUM. It is a little pricey but fun and delicious for the experience. Worth a visit!

Key lime pie ice cream cone. Yummers

Candies and old drug containers

See all

The storefront

Babes Bubble Waffle Cafe

4.7(25 reviews)

13.0 mi

First time here. Came here after seeing a movie. It's in a strip mall with some other shops…read more There are inside tables for groups of 4. The walls and decor are bright and cheery. There's a spot towards the back for an instagram shot. They offer shakes, cones, and their signature Bubble Waffle Cones. It was around 8:30 pm, and there were a few other people there, and they were waiting in line to order. Unfortunately, there was only one person working and he was doing his best to keep up. After a bit of a wait, we were able to order. The employee did a great job of not showing his frustration and getting to everyone as fast as he could. We ordered a double waffle cone and a Biscoff Bubble Waffle Cone. They were out of the cardboard holder for the Bubble Waffle Cone, so that ended up being made in a plastic to-go box. The Bubble Waffle Cone all get made fresh, and the ice cream sits on top, and is able to get soft from the warm waffle. He did a nice presentation in the to-go container. It was delicious. Ended up taking more time than it should, but it was very tasty (thanks Omar).

Babes is a huge spacious waffle cafe with ample sitting and awesome hangout vibes! I got their…read morestrawberry chocolate bubble waffle with Ferrero bites added and it was so good! Will definitely come again!

See all

Belfre Kitchen

4.2(246 reviews)

6.7 mi

Today we dined for the first time since the Llazar Konda Group reopened the Belfré in its group of…read morerestaurants, which includes KAVOS, The Beach House Bistro and La Tavola, all in the area. We were thrilled with the familiarity but also with the newness of the menu. As it was far too hot to eat al fresco, we were given a table on the first floor near the window. We had 5:00 reservations and were seated immediately. Our server, Mason, was fun and efficient, but he also had to cover the bar so he was running. A few more staff would have been helpful as the tables filled up, and by 6:15, people were waiting outside to get a table. The age group of diners is varied, and everyone seemed to be very satisfied. We ordered the Bruschetta and the Salmon with Lemon Risotto, both of them prepared very well. The food tasted very fresh, and the presentation was lovely. I also ordered the Bolognese because I love a good dish of it. This one did not disappoint. However, the meat pieces were small pea-sized bits of beef, which tasted good, but looked a bit odd. I would like to know why, but I was too busy enjoying the dish. It is my birthday and so I was offered either a free cocktail or a dessert. I love a good treat so the flourless cake was my choice. It was a very nice birthday present. I really look forward to our next visit. The menu has lots of options I want to try.

I'm so glad I was able to drop by for their last weekend of service…read more Why review then? They're closed! Well, I do think it's worth mentioning they were top notch until the end and I hear there's a new chapter (possibly different, but with some of the same people involved) on the horizon. So, if when the new chapter arrives for the building where Belfre Kitchen thrived for so long, you wonder what came before and do these folks know what they're doing? They do. Belfre served up delicious food in a chic, warm, and welcoming atmosphere by servers who were kind and caring. Until we meet again, Belfre!

Perch

See all

Drop Donuts with a Frizz and Cream

Boulangerie Du Monde

4.7(86 reviews)

29.9 mi

The bakery gets a solid five stars--one of the best old school bakeries I've ever patronized. My…read morefav is the rare Gibassier, with its subtle anise and orange flavoring. Their bread is the best you'll find. The staff is always pleasant. The only suggestions I have: Bake more items so that you are not always out, and adjust hours to be open longer.

Well, here we are again, and sure enough we're on our way to Door County. This time, I thought I…read morewould call ahead on a Saturday morning to reserve a couple of almond croissants as they always disappear readily. No one answered, and I subsequently learned that their policy is not to answer the phone on Saturdays as they are too busy! So, now you know. We arrived at 10:30am, and sure enough no more almond croissants. Oh well, we still bought a croissant au beurre, a danish, and a couple loaves of bread. We had the pastries for a mid-morning snack and they were tip-top fresh and delicious as expected. You can't go wrong buying anything from here, and til the next time!

Saturday mid-morning selections.

I thought you had to be a red-head to attend the counter, but with the new brunette, maybe not!

See all

A delectable almond bear claw, $4.50.

Here's the Scoop

4.3(12 reviews)

6.8 mi

Amazing ice cream, flavors selection, and loved that our group could try many samples! Ordered half…read morescoop of banana cream pie and half this got real. They even had free waffle cone samples. Lots of indoor seating and was pretty quiet for a winter weekday evening. Nice location in downtown Delafield.

What a quaint little shop in the middle of Delafield! The aesthetics are very pleasing as the shop…read moreis quite spacious and relaxing. Staff is super friendly and there is an abundance of selections for your frozen sweet tooth a little on the pricey side for ice cream versus gelato comparable. But very, very good.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Michelle N.

2

14

2

11 years ago

I couldn't believe how delicious their baked goods are. I've had the truffle cupcake and the chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and both were the best cakes I've ever had. I'm a huge fan of Gigi's cupcake chain, and they have nothing on Sally's. The chocolate cake was rich in flavor (not too rich to enjoy a nice hardy slice) and very moist without it being too much. The balance between frosting and cake is perfect. The cake was special order, and it did not disappoint. I've had a lot of cake in my day, and Sally's cake/cupcakes stands out by far. The staff is super friendly, and I love the small town feel. My mom tried the cookies and said they were wonderful. I can't wait to get back out and try even more goodies. read more

Nancy H.

1

0

14 years ago

Sally's is the best. The carrot cupcake and cream cheese frosting in the good old fashion taste I remember from my childhood. Scones, dark chocolate cupcake, huge cookies, lemon bars that you actually taste the lemon. All spectacular! English muffin bread is a must in the morning. Granola fresh and healthy. She even carries gluten free items. So don't walk run to Sally's before it is all gone and don't forget to check out their buns. read more

Julieann L.

0

1

0

14 years ago

Anything chocolate here is THE BOMB.COM! Cakes, cupcakes whatever your little heart desires! I've had cakes & cupcakes for a rehearsal dinner, bridal shower & a baby shower from Sally's and there isn't anywhere better! All the guests commented on how delicious they were and asked where I got them!!! If you are in the Genesee Depot area make sure to stop at Sally's for a yummy treat!!! read more

Amy H.

0

1

0

14 years ago

Love this bakery! We have ordered tier cakes for a wedding anniversary and birthday cakes. Love the cupcakes and the lemon bars are my favorite! They have great buns for all occasions too. The bakery has such a warm feeling....like you are in a friends kitchen! We don't really drive through this area much but we are happy to go out of our way to visit and get some treats! read more

James N.

2

23

8

11 years ago

Everything I have eaten from Sallie's has been amazing. That is no short list! Cupcakes, rolls, sticky buns, crumb cake and let's not forget the cake, ooh the cake. read more

Wyatt G.

0

4

2

3 years ago

Best place ever it should be in because the bakery there is so good it needs to be worldwide

Tammy D.

0

2

1

11 years ago

Great bakery. We had their cinnamon rolls & coffee - what a treat!

Sally's Sweet Shoppe - bakeries - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Restaurants near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Things to Do near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Coffee near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Desserts near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Breakfast near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Cupcakes near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Ice Cream near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Thrift Stores near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

BEST of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin Shopping near Sally's Sweet Shoppe

People found Sally's Sweet Shoppe by searching for…

Best of Genesee Depot

Things to do in Genesee Depot

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Sally's Sweet Shoppe also viewed

C Adam's Bakery

4.2

(205 reviews)

I LOVE C Adam's bakery. They've been in the MPM as long as I've been alive. Their cookie dough cake…read morejar is to die for. Their brownies are always delicious, too. They are reasonably priced, especially in this era of expensive pastries. Service is always very friendly!!

Tried C. Adams Bakery, it was alright overall. They've got a good range of sweets so you can pretty…read moremuch find whatever you're looking for.

Molly's Gluten-Free Bakery

4.4

(37 reviews)

Great selection of gluten-free items, both fresh and frozen. They have a nice case with beautiful…read moredesserts displayed, too. We really enjoyed the take and bake pizza, bagels, English muffins and bread we tried on our most recent visit. Everyone was super friendly and helpful. Can't wait to come back to try new items!

Got a box of 25.00 cookies. They added 4 peppermints and the rest of the box was tainted with the…read moretaste .the cookies seem sloppy and I have had better cookies else where ,I should have bought one to try and than judge...lesson learned. I won't be getting anymore of these .Ive been GF for 14 years and understand the diet well and quality well.

Mama Ducky’s Desserts

4.3

(7 reviews)

At first, I was not feeling very positive when I walked in the door, and there were two employees…read morewho turned their backs on me as I was the only one there. Didn't even greet the customer which kinda left a bad taste in my mouth. But then, everything switched when I received my order of delectable desserts! Everything is made fresh and with care they just need to work on their customer approach. It is a very important selling point when you greet customers when they enter your establishment. Make them feel welcome and acknowledged as a human being. Thank you!

Seriously- THE BEST carrot cake cupcakes. So good, I ordered some for hub's birthday. A big, big…read morehit.

National Bakery & Deli

3.5

(39 reviews)

I have purchased doughnuts from National Bakery for years- particularly for their vanilla frosted…read morelong johns- (at least when I was there early enough to get them before they were gone. ) unfortunately the last few times I have purchased them they were not the same. The frosting seemed to be the same frosting but thinner and skimpy. my main disappointment was the dough. It was not the same recipe, it didnt even look like the same "homemade " ones they used to make. All in all -not good enough for me to make that early morning effort to get them any more. Disappointing. Chris.

First time at this location. I stopped in to pick up a cake for a special occasion…read more Food: They have a great selection of cakes, donuts, pastries, and other bakery items. What really caught my eye was their amazing assortment of filled coffee cakes. You could choose from custard, cream cheese, or buttercream fillings. All three sounded delicious, but I finally settled on the buttercream. Some people in our group thought it had a little too much buttercream. I, on the other hand, thought it was just about perfect! Service: A couple of very friendly employees helped me out. I couldn't decide what to get, and they never made me feel rushed. They even offered a few suggestions, which made the decision a little easier. Atmosphere: The bakery has a large, open layout with plenty of room to browse the display cases, tables, and refrigerated deli items. The large front windows let in lots of natural light, making the space feel bright and welcoming. There's also a large parking lot, so parking wasn't an issue. Definitely a place I'll be stopping at again, especially for that amazing buttercream-filled coffee cake.

Treats by Bernadette

3.5

(21 reviews)

I was sticker SHOCKED by a dinner totaling $27. Believe me it was a normal size to go container…read more Like one dinner is $27, in a typical to go container. The food was mid. Was mad the whole weekend. Be prepared for $5+ cupcakes. The cupcakes were amazing but again small for over $5. It is very hard to find a decent soul food place in Milwaukee.

I almost missed trying this place because of some 10+ year old reviews, so be aware of that when…read moreassessing this business. I was incredibly impressed with a caramel cake I purchased. It was truly wa sone of, if not the best, caramel cakes I've ever had. I am very critical of baked good because I am a baker myself. She does a masterful job of developing and balancing flavors without her desserts being overly sweet. The texture of her caramel is silky and the flavor was decadent. The cake was the perfect balance of the appropriate moisture and density, especially for caramel cake. I had no issue with my customer service. The prices were more than I was expecting but when I tasted her cake I understood how they are justified. I am eager to try more of her treats. Kudos!

Sugar & Flour Bakery Cafe

4.5

(29 reviews)

We are back in town for a summer vacation visit and had to come back to reminisce with friends that…read morepatronize this local and we wanted to try other items. Our son went to the local high school with the chef here and he has gain much training and does a great job in supervising the other cooks. He also does wonderful menu creation. We had a BET sandwich with hash browns and the sandwich had two eggs, bacon and tomato on home made sour dough toast. I have also had two eggs, hash browns and sausage patties with s side of toast while my wife had a toast with a hole filled with egg. And a side of fruit. It's all great.

Love Sugar and Flour! They have prepackaged tiny sugar cookies that are amazing…read more As far as food goes, I love their avocado toast. It's delicious. My mom's go to is the apple butter French toast. Prices are reasonable. The cafe has an artsy vibe to it with pottery mugs on display. There are tables, bar seating that looks into the bakery, couches as well as a few tables outside. Staff were helpful in answering menu questions. Check this place out.

Scordato Bakery Inc

4.8

(45 reviews)

First time here. I was originally planning to drive to Brady Street and visit Sciortino's, but then…read moreI came across Scordato's. I'm glad I did. Food: I found all the classic Italian bakery treats I was hoping for, including cannolis, cream horns, and an assortment of cookies. Rather than trying to decide, I asked the person behind the counter to put together a selection for me. I mean, how can you go wrong? It's all good! Service: There were a few people ahead of me, but it didn't take long to reach the counter. The person helping me was pleasant, although not much for small talk. The entire visit took no more than five minutes. Easy breezy! Atmosphere: The storefront features large windows that let you see inside before you even walk in. They also bring in plenty of natural light, making it easy to browse all of the bakery items. The display cases were well organized and easy to navigate, so it was simple to get a good look at everything. After getting home and sampling my assortment, I realized I don't always have to drive downtown to Milwaukee to satisfy my Italian bakery cravings.

Best Italian bakery around!…read more Everyone is always so friendly when I visit and their food is always delicious! 1) The wall of cookies is like no where else. They are excellent and I can never leave without getting at least a small container (you know as a snack for the ride home haha). They are always sooo fresh. I've tried most of them and they are all excellent. 2) The hot ham and rolls on Sunday are hard to beat. Their super thin sliced ham is so flavorful and their rolls are so fresh. 3) If you have not had sfincione yet just get some (if it's there- it sells out quick). Sicilian-style pizza and you'll thank me later

Greige Patisserie

4.3

(61 reviews)

•$$$

We were in the mood for some bakery treats and wanted to try out Greige. Early on a Saturday…read moremorning, they were not busy and we were able to order and get our items quick. We got a lemon meringue pie tart, chocolate croissant, cinnamon roll, and some macarons, and a tea. They were great to warm up the chocolate croissant and cinnamon roll! We got a variety of macarons, some of the more fun flavors included blue moon, cookies and cream, and Irish cream. We finished most of them after our visit and they were fantastic. There were many great bakery items, a variety of drinks, and some beautiful displays on the artful wedding cakes they do. Will have to be back to try some more!

I have enjoyed their goods off site before, but finally got to stop into Greige and it was the…read morecutest sun filled cafe! I was impressed with the variety of their menu, from breakfast, to cocktails. I love their lattes and seasonal syrups, and my favorite pastry might be the almond croissant! I'd love to stop by for a drink and dessert with friends someday.

Lakeside Cookie

4.7

(3 reviews)

Very extensive selection to pick from They do offer coffee…read moreand tea Service is awesome Located inside the Mequon Public Market

Tried a variety of cookies, but was most excited for the strawberry penthouse sugar cookie. The…read morefrosting used real fruit; the cookie was soft and melted in my month. They also offered cupcakes, slices of cake, and dog treats. A great way to end your meal at the public market.

Mr Dye's Pies

4.6

(56 reviews)