What a great location! Clean, great parking and slice deals! Friendly and informative staff! Slices…read moreare hot And huge! Not a lot of toppings but the price is right!

Great Pie part of our weekend habit never fails me and the wife love this place never stiff us on…read morethe toppings

The sauce has changed. It is so spicy and hot our throats we're on fire . None of us could finish…read moreour food. We use to really love your food. The meatballs were hard as a rock and burnt. Could not even cut them. Garlic bread was the only edible thing. 40 bucks wasted as we had to dump our meals.

Awesome thin crust pizza. I will be back. Fast friendly folks in a warm home feeling restaurant.read more

My wife and I drove up from Chicago to have lunch with our Grandson and his family…read more We both agree that this restaurant is deserving of a 5 Star Review for the following reasons: 1. Friendly proprietor 2. Cozy environment 3. Good appetizers 4. Great Pizza We will definitely be back when in Sussex.

Excellent service! Excellent pizza and garlic bread!…read moreBeer was cold! We arrived around 6 PM. We will be back! Great place for the family too.

The flavor is fresh and delicious. Great customer service and I had delivery, but it was warm…read moredelish and fresh tasting

MOD Pizza - Pewaukee, WI…read more Let me just say--this pizza hit every note. My fiancé and I stopped at this location recently, and as someone who's plant-based and dairy-free, I was honestly blown away. The dairy-free cheese was melty and flavorful, the crust was perfect, and the amount of veggie toppings they offer? A dream. I felt like I could build a pizza that actually fit my body and my tastebuds--and that's rare. No stress. No settling. Just pure deliciousness and a welcoming vibe. Thank you, MOD Pizza Pewaukee, for making people like me feel seen and satisfied. We'll definitely be back.

The sandwiches we ordered were good. Service was generally ok as well. The area in which we were…read moreseated was nearly empty on this Sunday early evening. The prices seem reasonable as compared to other places. When the check arrived we noticed a "Customer Service Charge" that left us wondering about it. When questioned, the server indicated it was because we paid via credit card, not cash. This was an irritant because there was no prior mention of this additional charge either from the server or the menu. If it's stated on the menu it apparently wasn't in a prominent place. What I don't get is the fact that I can order something a bit more pricey with the card. When I'm made aware of this I order accordingly; that means a lower priced item. That in turn translates into less profit for the establishment. Card users have a tendency to order more items or more expensive items. That gets lost when it becomes card vs cash.

Great food and fast service. The setting is unique and appreciate the history. The pizza was…read moregenerous even for a small and the toppings were fresh. I'll be back.

Hands down the best pizza I've ever hand in Wisconsin having lived here for nearly 15 years…read more Not a lot of seating, we got there at 4 PM right when they opened. Try to reserve if you can or get there early, we went on a Saturday and was a packed house by 4:30 PM. It's clear they know what they're doing and our waiter was great with our kids. No question we would go back and highly recommend to anyone wanting to try a new pizza place!

I was verbally attacked by the drunk owner with zero reason last evening (5/24/26). My daughter…read moreworks (now worked) there and my son and I came in to visit her, get some food and hang out. The owner out of nowhere told my daughter that "the woman in the black shirt is obnoxious...don't wait on her" to which she responded "My mom??". Note that I have NEVER had any kind of interaction with him in the past, although I had heard many stories about his verbal abuse of employees and managers. And apparently also customers. You'd think after finding out that he had said something disparaging about her mother, he'd shut up. Not drunk him. He proceeded to tell me and my daughter that I was a "piece of shit" and "an abusive mother" (meanwhile my daughter is crying and telling him stop and that it's not true) and kept on with his abusive words. It's interesting that every single time he does this, it's with a woman. Apparently being a 5'5" very small man, he is too afraid to do this to a man likely because he would get his ass kicked. Perhaps he should go buy himself a sports car or a fancy boat to satisfy his "little man syndrome" instead of being an abuser. Prediction that he'll come and reply to this review with some made up excuses instead of taking accountability for his actions. Typical narcissist.

What sets Sal's pizza apart is the cheese. It's amazing, and they don't skimp on it. We are so…read morehappy that Sal's has come to Sussex. As for the service, our pizza was ready exactly when they told us it would be, and they have two card readers which cuts the wait time to pay in half. Great experience for our first of what will become many trips to Sal's.

My parents love this place. The pizza is good overall. I'm a big fan of sausage on my pizza but the…read moretaste of theirs is a bit off. Lots of cheese. Sauce isn't too bad. For some reason my son and I always get stomach aches after eating their pizza. Not sure if it's the cheese, sauce or what. Pizza is always ready on time and staff are polite. I can't speak to seating service as we always get carryout. Not much of a restaurant ambiance inside. I think if we get carryout again I'll try something else off the menu as pizza is one of those foods that vary from person to person as far as what they deem good.

Best pizza ever. We…read moreare from out of town and we're craving pizza. Not many options around but we decided to try Sal's. Delicious with every bite!

Always a good time at Sal's. Pizza is a bit pricey but the slices are big. If you're in need of a…read morequick bite with a buddy this is the place to go. Not the ambiance of a stay a while place but oh well, ample seating. Service is always good with rotating college students eager to do service work. I would recommend, I go there at least once every few months. Highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza!

It WAS outstanding pizza with very fresh ingredients! However, they are no longer there. The…read morestation was sold...it is now a BP, but they do not sell the pizza. :(

After reading some reviews we decided to give it a try. We had one made in the morning and baked it…read morefor supper. It is thin crust but the picture I took makes it look like pan pizza because of bare edge was larger than I think it should be. After we baked it, the toppings looked a bit skimpy. However, the pizza did taste good, aided by the provolone cheese they use wth mozzarella. So, I think the question is if a Grumpy's pizza is better than Papa Murphy down the street. I'm anxious to hear what others think.

UNBELIEVABLE SERVICE. Really understated operation but helllooo thin crusty cheesy goodness. wow…read more get the sausage!!

Can't even get ahold of this restaurant. Who knows if they are even opened, I tried calling and…read morecalling