Sammy Sue's BBQ is awesome. Great Beef Brisket and Pulled Pork., so far everything we have had there is good. On Thursday nights, Wing Night, you can not get in the door. She has amazing wings, plump and juicy, make sure you order those fresh cut fries with them. Good Cold BEER. When you are eating Hot Wings, you have to have cold beer, the two just go hand in hand. The Pulled Pork sandwich is amazingly tender and full of flavor, and the Brisket is very good. She serves several sides, cole slaw, red skin potato salad, baked beans, and others. read more

Insane (in a good way) ribs...some of the best ever. People are very nice; waiters/waitresses are on the ball. read more

Best bbq place I've ordered from. The prices are a tad high but the food was great as well the portions. Definitely will be back.

We visited Sammy Sue's BBQ yesterday afternoon for the first time and got what we were looking for - one of the best pulled pork BBQ sandwich ever. The facility is ok, and the gravel parking is ok, but the pork sandwich was GREAT! I thought my fair fries were really good, but the wife's BBQ chips were less then ok. So, how did we rate our first visit to Sammy Sue's? The BBQ pulled pork sandwich gets a 5++, the fries get a 4+, the BBQ chips get a 2, the facility gets a 3, the waitress gets a 5 and the meal value gets a 5. Will we go back to Sammy Sue's? We sure will for one of those pulled pork sandwiches and I have to try their ribs! read more

I'm at a wedding being catered by Sammy Sue's. The bbq is very tasty and the cheddar biscuits are good but they're small so people take two. Staff shouldn't get mad about that. Because people take two, they ran out. The mac and cheese wasn't hot and the salad seemed wilted. The croutons were soggy and far from fresh. Catering staff was friendly. read more

We were looking for a BBQ place and found this on yelp. We had the sampler which I would recommend if you want to try most of their specialties at one time. I was overcome by the smoked wings - they were awesome! The waiter told us to come back on a Tuesday or Thursday night for their wing specials. I can't wait to go back ! read more

Great food and service. I would recommend the brisket. Restaurant is the classic mom and pop ran joint with good local hospitality. It's a hidden gem. read more

This place is awesome! The smoked wings are perfect and it's way cheaper than it should be. Food always comes quick, even during rushes, and the wait staff is very attentive. read more

This is the best barbeque I've ever had! Everything is completely homemade and delicious! They recently opened, and from what I hear, the word is spreading and business is booming! We had brisket, ribs, and pulled pork. Everything was cooked perfectly. We will definitely be returning soon! read more

Good tasting bbq and wings! A local place that has a lot of character. Good food and good value. You can't go wrong with that!

Best pulled pork sandwich ever.... Love the sweet potato fries and dipping sauce. Wait staff is very attentive and friendly. Was at a wedding this fall and they catered and didn't disappoint us. If in town try them! read more

So I had no real plans of eating in the boonies tonight. But it's a long day, no food since 7 am since starting in Columbus. Change of plans and a new flight scheduled out of Cleveland tomorrow morn has me finishing up at 7:30 in Dover with an hour and a half drive ahead of me. Yelp to the rescue finds me this place...point 02 miles away. By the looks of Sammy's interior and exterior, this was once a very dive bar, slightly renovated and definitely standing on its culinary laurels! The 50 cent wing starter, half dozen please, with the bartender-suggested Spicy BBQ, smoked then grilled, are fantastic. I order the half of brisket with cole slaw and baked beans sides. My super friendly and attentive bartender/waitress (no room at the bar) approves of my order (I love it!). It comes out fairly quickly and it's mad good. Best baked beans ever. I'm later asked how everything is and I'm told the beans are smoked then brisket is added to it. Amazing. Notes: steady flow of take-out, constant dine-ins entering, great and friendly service and the portions are perfectly slightly big (enough). Finally, seems to be mostly locals and an excellent atmosphere. I'm bookmarking and I'll be back next month!!! read more

Oh my goodness! This place is a gem! The food is awesome! From burnt ends to jalapeño garlic smoked wings, there was nothing left on the plates! Took the suggestion of the bbq beans and Mac and Cheese from our excellent server Amy, she was spot on! A must visit! read more

Outstanding local fair. Very good ribs, awesome baked beans, good atmosphere. Kind of looks like a hole in the wall from the outside, but in my experience, those are the best kept secrets. We were staying in Amish Country and didn't want any of that "fake" Amish food (see my review of Der Dutchman). Opten for the drive out to Sammy Sue's BBQ- WOW was it good! Super nice waitress, food came out quickly, great local place! read more

I knew i was going into a good barbecue joint when I saw smoke billowing out the side. I had the beef brisket nice and tender with fair fries and baked beans. Great meal for the money. Great BBQ for eastern Ohio, i was pleasantly surprised. I would definitely come back. read more

Food was good, etiquette of the person taking the order was not, rude and very short. Not good when competing for business. Need to learn that attitude counts. read more

This place is incredibly great. I had the brisket. It was so tender I never picked up the knife. Baked beans were incredible as well. Do yourself a favor and come grab some grub here. read more

Solid q. Well smoked ribs nice and barky. Really good sides like beans and German potato salad. Ribs were St. Louis style, rubbed and glazed with a thick mollasis type sauce like Kc masterpiece or krafts. Good quick service real reasonable prices. read more

My family and I love going to Sammy Sue's. Great place to dine or get take out. Haven't had anything I do not like. Beer cheese and pretzels are to die for. and the wings, fantastic. Love the atmosphere and hometown feel this place has. Looking forward to eating there again. Staff is always pleasant. read more

Can I just say OMG! we were passing thru and read the yelp reviews about this restaurant and decided to give it a try. This place haa amazing food! We travel a lot and usually try to visit local restaurants. This one is definitely at the top of our list. We had the house BBQ brisket Sammie. The meat was so tender and the sauce out of this world. They have the perfect blend. Not tangy, not sweet nor heat. It compliments their meat perfectly. We actually ordered sauce to come home with us. Highly recommend. Food is delicious prices reasonable. The fair fries were a surprisingly good side. Would highly recommend. Our server, Amy was super friendly and service was fast. read more

We ordered carry out- the person taking our order was very helpful. We had the beef brisket, homemade chips, and steak salad. It is not cheap, but it was quite tasty. We will try again- maybe done in next time- children willing- lol. read more

Came from nyc for a business training and this place made us feel right at home. Great food good prices and lots of love.

Great local business with excellent barbecue style. You can truly order food however you want it. Everything has a home-cooked style that makes it worth the stop in. read more

Great service and awesome food. Brisket was excellent, and my wife said the cornbread was best she has had. Whole family happy, glad we stopped. read more

What can I say this is my go to place for wings. Servers are all always friendly and a different new sauce of the week to try. If you never stopped in try it definitely worth it on wing nights read more

Must have been an off night. I got the barbecue sampler. Wings, pork, brisket, ribs. I smoke approx 20+ times a year and what I found was that nothing was seasoned at all. Very bland. Also, no smoke ring on any of the items. They were charred by fire but no smoke ring at all. Pork was good, wings tastes like they were boiled then grilled. Ribs were good but I have never tasted brisket like this. It was not cut against the grain and tastes like pot roast that was then grilled. So many folks have given this such rave reviews I want to try it again it had to be just an off night. I will try again in a few weeks and update this post. This was not smoking but grilling. Also I did not see the smoke and no firewood outside no smell of smoke outside the place. I'm assuming they have internal smokers and just smoke in the mornings and not throughout the day. read more

Yep! I like their food! But, I'm afraid I have to rank it #2 to Hog Heaven's #1 place for bbq! And the "atmosphere" could take some sprucing up! read more

Generous portion, friendly staff and a cool dining room. Food was amazing, I got the pulled pork Sammie with mashed potatoes, I can't wait to come back here and try something else read more

If your family likes BBQ.. Please try Sammy Sues. Homemade in house flatbreads,ribs,sandwiches,wings and much more

Had the pulled pork and brisket..both very good. Coleslaw was excellent and so were the 'spicy homemade chips'. Beer cheese soft pretzels were awesome! Food arrived quickly, waitress was very friendly. Will definitely stop by again when headed down I-77. read more

Prices are fare, but portions are less than expected. BBQ Sauce was a copy of Sweet Baby Ray's. Service was efficient but cold. I have no real complaint other than feeling a lack of congeniality. read more

Just ate here loved the club sandwich very helpfully staff did not love the house chips right on the money fresh and crisp but a very sweet "dust on them" almost like a dessert might work on sweet potato fries but for me just not to my liking only other miss was just did not smell like a smoke house Bbq (Electric smoker not wood fired). But very good food and very nice people will deff eat here again read more

The 4 stars are for the overall experience, I would say that the food is a 3. This is a locals place but I felt right at home sitting at the bar. Everyone was very friendly and included me in the conversation. Would go back if I was in town. Based on the other reviews, I stayed away from the brisket and went with the pulled pork with mashed potatoes and baked beans. Everything was decent, no complaints. Less than $18 for dinner, a beer and a tip - how can you go wrong. read more

Stopped in during a road trip and my brother and I really liked this place. If you like wings you absolutely have to try the smoked wings with spicy blue cheese sauce! We also had the pulled pork and beef brisket sandwich. Both were really good but the beef brisket was great and was absolutely massive. The service was wonderful as well, everyone there went out of their way to speak to us and make us feel welcomed. read more

We ordered food while at Hoodletown. They totally messed up our order. One couple ordered two flat breads and only got one, we ordered a brisket sandwich, wings and salad. Never got the brisket and when she did bring it, it was COLD, had three slices of onion and one slice of pepper. The wings tasted like old chicken. For $30.00 it terrible. We tossed everything and will never from Sammie's again. I don't recommend it at all. read more

Great food, great service, would recommend for sure! Thursday is wing night. Tonight was $.60 wings. Will be visiting this gem again!

One word= RIBS!!! These ribs are so good! I, myself am a big rib girl and these are at the top of the yummy scale! The sauce is so good and the meat is so tender it falls off the bone. I highly recommend going here if you enjoy ribs. read more

Great surprise while passing through New Philadelphia. Greeted immediately when we arrived, everyone smiling and friendly. Ordered the brisket entree which was great. (1/2 portion was enough for me). Cooked perfectly and came with a great BBQ sauce on the side. Service was attentive, knowledgeable and friendly. I would recommend this to anyone looking for great BBQ. Missing one star due to front entrance being a little sparse and unwelcoming. read more

This is the best BBQ ever! Everything is fantastic. The ribs are tender, fall off the bone, delicious! the BBQ sauce is the best. The smoke brisket is some of the most tender brisket I have ever had and the flavor is out of this world. Looking for wings? The smoked wings are to die for! The staff is friendly, attentive, and very helpful! Also, you can't beat the prices! read more

Wonderful food, great service, I'd highly recommend the salmon or brisket. Simple & delicious, great home made chips.