Bought a dozen bagels. The owner asked me to wait 15 minutes while he cooked up a fresh batch...worth the wait to take hot bagels back to the house. They were very good, larger than most. But the best I've had recently are from Bagels Forever in Madison WI. read more

They are back open! During the hurricane Schmagels took some significant damage causing them to close, gut the place and start over. I'll tell you, it was worth the wait! What a wonderful place and great food. Best part is... they deliver around town! I had the tomato basil Breakfast wrap and it was delicious! Thanks guys! read more

First of all, when you check in at Schmagel's Bagels on Yelp, there is a deal (currently). So do it! Went here because it was close to our hotel. There was an array of choices in both bagel and cream cheese and there were many other sandwich choices. The food was fresh and tasty and I loved the veggie cream cheese. I also noticed that they have a monthly cream cheese offering that changes. It was Apple Cinnamon this January 2012. My only complaint is the wait for a bagel with cream cheese. It was longish. The seats outside are cool and I liked it all. Great breakfast joint! read more

Always loved coming here when I went to Flagler College. Friendly service and great food. Conveniently located right in the downtown area so it's close to everything. Everything about this place just ozzes local shop and I love it. Highly recommend it. read more

Small cozy locale that is an absolute gem for those seeking bagels and breakfast sandwiches and wraps! Friendly crowd situated on the end of Hypolita street with public parking conveniently located across the street easily walking distance. Love the atmosphere and staff, must try! read more

Great Bagels. The Sesame has so many seeds! Lots of cream cheese options. The check-in deal isn't what it seems. You have to buy two drinks and another bagel in order to get the free one. I would go again. read more

I had the tuscan bagel with sundried tomato and basil cream cheese--delicious!! The patio is quiet and cozy with fans to keep you cool in the summer. Things to know: Flagler students get a discount, no American Express :). read more

Cheddar garlic cream cheese. Toasted everything bagel. Yum.

I get that this is NOT NYC, and I get that if you buy your bagels at 11am they are not fresh from the oven.....BUT....we purchased 4 bagels with cream cheese and only 1 was edible (oh, and they got that one wrong. I ordered cinnamon raisin but hey gave me a blueberry...but at least you could eat that one. That's the reason for the 2 stars.). There is absolutely no chance the other 3 were made today, maybe not even yesterday. They were bricks with the worst tasting cream cheese. How does one get veggie cream cheese wrong you ask? By spilling a bucket of salt into it, that's how. If you choose to spend your hard earned money here, come early, ask if the bagels are made this century (maybe the bagels are so old because this is the oldest city?), and don't get any flavored cream cheeses. read more

The egg & bacon wrap was really good and fresh. The place is cute. We went at 8am on a weekday so it was empty but the Good was Good. My breakfast wrap gets 4 stars. read more

6/29/14. Stopped here after church for takeout. Everything was good. Only problem was that I asked for the bagels to be sliced. They stapled the bag so I didn't check. We were staying in hotel and didn't have any cuttlery. When we got back the bagels weren't sliced. It wasn't a big order so this should have been easy. But everything tasted good. read more

This place is kind of hard to find, but so so worth it! If you are a big bagel fan and especially if you are a lot and bagel fan - you need to go here! read more

Their specialty cream cheese flavors each month are to die for. The chocolate chip is AMAZING! The everything bagels are delicious. A must try every time you are in St. Augustine. read more

Great breakfast spot. Good food, nice outdoor seating, friendly staff. Quiet spot, too.

Yum. Such a great place I love the outdoor seating. The bagels are soooooo good. Try you will not be disappointed. Great walking area. Been there both times I visited at st Augustine. Go read more

Awesome fresh bagels and flavored cream cheeses. Eat breakfast here a couple times every summer when at the beach for a week.

Good place to grab breakfast throughout the morning and early afternoon. Nothing super special, basic bagels and sandwiches that will get you through a meal. Lots of college kids so prepare to feel old even if you really aren't :) read more

Very good bagels, nice people and cozy little store. I had the cinnamon bagel and it was delicious! Come early, they were almost sold at at twelve read more

Great bagels!! Open relatively early. Friendly staff. Offer lunch too which my boyfriend ordered off of the menu and loved his sandwich.

Great bagels, just get there while they are fresh. Recommendation: A bacon, egg, and cheese on a blueberry bagel with honey butter.

Really good bagels. Cinnamon crunch bagel and honey almond cream cheese was really good. Closest to New York bagels in a Florida location.

Good breakfast of ham, egg and cheese bagels for a family of four. Lots of bagels to choose from, fast service and nice people. Sit outside on the patio and enjoy. Great start to the day for less than $20. read more

Loved the food great small place with great service and good food. Centrally located. Would go back everyday! Ordered coffee and a bacon egg cheese sandwich on everything bagel. Yum:) read more

Yummy bagel with cream cheese! Next time I probably will ask for cream cheese on the side, though, because they really cake it on. Great way to start my morning! read more

Meh. I am from Maryland and we have some great bagels near us (not NY bagels, but Great). The bagels here were fine and breakfast sandwiches were inexpensive, but I don't need to go back. They offer hummus for the bagels but don't tell you that it is herbed hummus, not plain. Overall, very underwhelming. read more

Great Food at a Great Price. Staff is friendly and helpful. Food was fresh and made to order. Super cute patio!!

first time in st. augustine and i had this for breakfast, OH MAN, the BEST bagel sandwich i've ever had! i had turkey with honey mustard, i was in love after the first bite. very friendly staff, made it better. only downside is, it was my last day in st. augustine and i had to return for lunch before i left, and they were closed!! they close too early! it was maybe 2:10 and they closed at 2:00. really disappointing. so i only had it once and i can't wait to take another trip to florida and i'll definately be coming back here. until then, i'll just dream.. read more

I. Love. This. Place. Each and every location is extremely well stocked in every flavor of bagel you could ask for. The owner and his wife work at the locations, and you can really tell it's a family business. The service is always warm, and the bagels are delicious read more

I was skeptical when I walked in and saw t-sorts rather than bagels in the display cabinet. But, I was hungry, so. .. bummer, how do you get a bagel this hard and dry. My homemade bagels are way better than these. Come On yelpers, learn what a good bagel is! One star for being cute. read more

Who knew you could get a really good bagel in North Florida? This place is so good we had breakfast here two days in a row. The Nova, cream cheese with chives is wonderful. they make a really good onion bagel. The coffee is only so-so. The second day we got take-out coffee from Kookaburra on the plaza and brought it to the bagel shop. read more

good food...cashier seemed a little confused...she was pleasant though.

Bagels were terrible. They are dry and brittle. Difficult to eat. The service was poor. Many people standing around doing nothing. Ordered roast beef and the employee cooked it on the grill! I complained and she said it looked raw to her. When she fixed the sandwich, the roast beef, lox and cream cheese flavors were terrific but a bagel shop should have bagels that are at least on par with a frozen lenders bagel at minimum. read more

Found this little place on our last vacay and I must say I was pretty impressed. The bagels were really good and I'm not a big egg person but I got the bacon, egg and cheese on like a southwest bagel or something and it was seriously one of the best breakfast sandwiches I've ever had. This is a must and they're about the only ones open before 10am. read more

The iced coffee and my bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich were both great! I would like it if the bagels were a little lighter, but they are still better than most bagel south of NJ. My boyfriend had the cinnamon raisin with strawberry cream cheese which seemed really fresh. I'll go back :-) read more

Excellent bagel shop, homemade cream cheese flavors and and outstanding setting. We stop here every time we are in town and look forward to when we are gone. read more

Bagel was ok but the server lacked any social ability and probably shouldn't have been behind the counter taking orders.

Schmagel's Bagels has a great location located in downtown St. Augustine, right across from Scarlett O'Haras. from the outside you will see an outdoor dining area that you walk through to get to the doors that lead to the inside. They serve during breakfast and lunch hours and the food is great! The last time I went I got a sesame seed bagel with bacon, egg, and cheeses on it along with a water. I personally would rate the quality of the food a 8/10. Everything I have eaten there I have liked. the quantity I would have to rate an 8/10 as well if you are to get there after the breakfast rush because your choices of bagels are somewhat limited because they only make so many each day to serve to customers. on the other hand tho there are other things to order besides a bagel. The value for the dollar is 10/10, their prices are great! and that is coming from a college student. There prices cater to everyone because they are not outrageous. also their service is great, I've yet to get any wrong orders. The decor there is somewhat interesting it looks kind of like an old diner on the inside with its dull colored benches and tables but I find myself sitting outside more than inside when I dine there. I really liked that they have the option to sit outside and that they serve you your food fairly quickly, there is nothing that i do not like about this restaurant. read more

Love this place. Such a cute and cozy place. The bagels are awesome and reasonably priced.

Absolutely the worst bagel I have ever attempted to eat. Like biting a tire. Or an old shoe. They have surpassed staleness by dint of some special effort. Girlfriends cinnamon raisin had onion courtesy of an unwiped knife. read more

Great place for breakfast sandwiches. Had a bacon, cheese and egg in everything bagel. Coffee was lacking quality with the dry creamer.