We had my mom's 80th birthday at the Mill Creek Tavern and had the best time. The food was…read moredelicious and exactly as we discussed in the planning, many choices and plentiful. The room was the perfect size for the party and had a nice nautical theme which we added our own party decor to. I can't say enough about the service. Vanessa was the easiest coordinator to work with planning the event, and did everything she said. She and Jeanne and the other servers at the party kept the drinks flowing, the food coming, and were so nice, it really made the evening. I highly recommend Mill Creek for any event you have or just for a delicious dinner and a fun night out

The staff is friendly and the food is delicious at this neighborhood treasure. Check out their prix…read morefixe menu and their daily specials. On Wednesday they offer bottles of wine at half price. Come here to meet friends and relax.

EXCELLENTTTTTTT!!! Between the views and service plus the food was phenomenal!the lobster melted in…read moremy mouth OMG THE BEST SEAFOOD I EVER HAD IN MY ENTIRE LIFE! I'm a seafood foodie and I kid you not this will be my ONLY place I will go have seafood from now on! Luv luv luv

Great decor, good food, nice view and service. Not sure why so many dock it…read more Taste: 4/5 Ambiance: 4.5/5 Service: 5/5 Value for money: 3.5/5 We had: 1) Calamari: great way to start 2) Oysters: nice and fresh 3) Connecticut lobster roll: done right 4) Firecracker burger: this was firecracker rock shrimp, a sweet paste on deep fried shrimp that was placed in a burger. It was okay! 5) baked fish 6) grilled shrimp with risotto: pretty good!

Very fresh fish! Amazing service and nestled along a great street! Great place to get fresh fishread more

We have been using Bayville Seafood for many years whenever we want to entertain using seafood or…read morejust adding seafood to our menu. We rely on them for their outstanding quality and fair pricing. We love having them cook lobsters as a special treat for family and friends. We have never been disappointed in their product or service.

Wonderful atmosphere. Really good food and customer service…read more Nice bar. Parking is usually easy to get.

The lower star rating is for the service. The food was delicious…read more We had a reservation for 7:30 on a Friday. We arrived and the host went to walk us to the table. He stops and points at a table in the back, gesturing for me to squeeze between two customers. I choose to walk around a different way and the host is still gesturing for me to squeeze between to chairs when the host himself wouldn't even walk through. It was beyond strange. We sit down and have some time and order our drinks and my friend knows we need to order the rest of our meal at the same time. We order baked oysters and I ordered the special- lamb My friend orders the flounder with risotto because it never disappoints We ordered the cappuccino heath bar ice cream pie and that was incredible! May have been my favorite part of the meal We received the ice cream pie and not even a minute later, a server, who was different than our original server, put the check down. And not even 10 minutes later, he came to check if we had put down a credit card It was not even 10pm yet (mind you, they close at 11pm) I can understand if it was past closing and we were the only ones left but it wasn't even close and there were still other patrons. As we were wrapping up, you could feel them circling our table and staring us down. By the time we left, it wasn't even 10:30pm. Despite the good food, this left a sour taste in my mouth.

At the end of the day --the food was hot ---the food was tasty and good --the service was pleasant…read moreand relatively fast --so why not a five ? Because we could not give a 4.5. The decor was dated ---gray panel walls and old ceilings. If that stuff doesn't bother you -we would give it a five. Sometimes atmosphere does matter. A quick rip down of the panels and a coat of white paint would freshen the place up and since this is by the beach it would fit right in. The service we experienced was excellent Charlie the waiter was terrific

Food is horrible I can't even believe I took my family to this place. The inside is so dark the…read morefood was so dry I ordered the pork chop my husband order the chicken parm. I have to say the worst food i have ate in my life!!!! The worse part I got a house salad found a bug in it I asked to speak to the owner some short bald guy came up to me drunk and very rude told me if I didn't like this food I can leave. I couldn't believe the disrespect I got from this man. I will never again come to this place so I'm warning all you now. I'm gonna try the restaurant down the road hopefully that place will be better. 0 STARS FROM ME IF I COULD!!!

Great food, service and views! Lobster roll was great - Connecticut Style. Definitely will be back!read more

Stunning view!!! This restaurant is located right on the beach and offer outdoor seating that…read moreoverlooks the beach. It's absolutely gorgeous! The staff here is very friendly and attentive! Drinks are amazing! They use to have a frozen rose but it's been replaced with a marg. We prefer the frozen rose haha! The food here is great. Will def be back!

Decided to eat here for my anniversary dinner on a Sunday night. Nice atmosphere in a side street…read morejust off the main drag in oyster bay. We opted for the 4 course pre-fixe for $105 which includes two appetizers, entree and dessert. We had oysters, bucatini with clams, cheese board and roasted mushrooms for apps, all good. Branzino and pork chop were up next, also quite tasty. Apple strudel was good tho the banana pudding was skippable. They comped us a champagne toast which was nice. Only ding is very limited wine by the glass menu. Otherwise, a solid choice for a special occasion dinner.

Was going with friends to a book reading/signing in the area. When they asked what place to go too…read moreprior to our book event, I knew I had to come back here. 2 Spring is special. Is it the delicious food? Maybe the sophisticated yet sleek ambiance. I don't know what it is, but they got it and I love it. And I love showing them off to others. On a cold Tuesday night, it was pretty empty. I really hope the summer months are better to them. The table-side bread basket was amazing. We each got to pick which sort of bread we wanted. There was sourdough, focaccia and others. I went with the focaccia and never looked back. Burrata and beets, Brussels sprouts and salmon that was cooked perfectly was enjoyed while the specialty cocktails were sipped. We had all the attention of the staff being the only diners in there. It was such lovely time I'm going to make sure I don't wait to long to go back.

Always a great meal. And especially great service from the…read morewonderful server Mariana! Today we enjoyed a delicious lunch, seated out front with our lovely Sadie. I enjoyed a warm lobster roll. My other half enjoyed a super fresh and tasty salad. No room for dessert but we both enjoyed a refreshing hot coffee, on a sunny autumn day, enjoying conversation with other customers and passersby. We look forward to returning!

Came here for Spring Restaurant Week 2025 to celebrate a birthday…read more The main dining room has real high ceilings, wooden tables with placemats, linen, and plate setting with wine glasses. It was comfy that you felt like its a living room. Our server was funny, diligent, checked in on us and making sure we had everything we needed. The food service was prompt, good portion size and food was at the perfect temperature (not extremely hot nor lukewarm) for each dish. We ordered: Appetizer: Chickpea Fries Duck Tacos Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice Entree: Grilled Faroe Island Salmon Soy Glazed Cod Short Rib of Beef Dessert: Ricotta Donuts Tahiti Vanilla Crème Brûlée Everything was delicious. Afterwards, we were enjoying the wine and beverages after our meal. Go check them out.