My husband and I finally had the opportunity to visit Schultzy"s Restaurant not once but twice this…read morepast weekend! The first time we arrived without a reservation and we asked if Jimmy was there and was informed he wasn't - we shared our long history of his many backyard raw bars for our family parties. The staff was happy to help us and low and behold a cancelled reservation gave us our perfect table. I actually got teary eyed as a looked around the beautiful restaurant that truly compliments the amazing food. We returned the next day before a wedding to finally see Jimmy for amazing raw bar and a delicious lobster roll and cocktails. I will travel from NJ for Schultzy's again and again. This man is passionate about his craft and takes pride in serving his customers phenomenal food. Thank you Schultzy!

This place is good not great. Idk the vibes seemed a little off to me and the lunch wasn't that…read morememorable. Not 100% how good the seafood quality is either. Fries were rly good though

We returned to Birch Hill Bistro. When we first went it was more of a counter experience, but it…read morewent through an amazing transformation. Birch Hill Bistro is now an incredible visual, gastronomical, cozy sit down restaurant experience within a market. So great. We felt like we were in a small bistro in Paris. Great design to match marvelous food. The menu has appetizers, canapés, caviar, entrees, and desserts. We had caviar donut and steak tartar canapés and a short rib papardelle to start. Our entrees chosen were Dover sole, sliced roast chicken with mushrooms and truffles, salmon, and steak. Truffle fries , pomme pouree. and sautéed gailan. DELICIOUS. Please ask for the bread. Comes with homemade butter!!! Ended the meal with chocolate mousse. It is a pricey meal but well worth it...a Unique and enjoyable experience.

Birch Hill Market & Bistro is a Locust Valley classic - part gourmet market, part intimate…read moreFrench‑inspired restaurant. Fresh meats and prepared foods by day, cozy 32‑seat bistro with excellent steaks, seafood, and service by night. Located on Birch Hill Rd, it's the kind of neighborhood spot you recommend with, "You gotta go."

This was, without question, the worst experience my friends and I have ever had at a restaurant or…read morebar. Misleading, obvious misrepresentation and terrible attitude towards patrons. Seven of us after dinner, chose Valley Piano Bar because its website clearly advertises: "Thursday - It's All About Her. Thursday nights, first cocktail on us for all ladies." Refer to the snapshot here as proof to what I am saying. There were no disclaimers or fine print. Before ordering, I even asked our server to confirm the promotion, and she said yes. We stayed for about two hours, ordered appetizers, dessert and cocktails. When the bill arrived, all 7 "free" cocktails had been charged. The server told us her boss, Nico, instructed her to do so. When I questioned Nico, he first claimed the second drink was free, even though the website clearly says the first cocktail is complimentary. He then said, "Common sense, lady. You can't just come in, have a drink, and leave." That made no sense because we had ordered food not just cocktails. He followed that by saying, "People like you think you can come in, get free drinks, and leave. Don't even come back!" That comment was deeply offensive and made us feel singled out and unwelcome. Whether intentional or not, it left me questioning whether my ethnicity influenced how we were treated. This isn't about the cost of seven cocktails. It's about misleading advertising, dishonesty, and the disrespect shown by management. I had recommended Valley Piano Bar because I'd enjoyed it before, but my friends left shocked by the "boss Nico's" arrogance and unprofessional behavior. We will not be returning, and I hope ownership takes this complaint seriously. Customers deserve honesty, respect, and clarity from businesses that advertise promotions to draw people in. I will make sure all the relevant authorities are contacted. Do better!

I had an extremely disappointing experience. The ownership, management, security, and staff were…read moreall rude, disrespectful, and condescending. I attended during one of their weekend DJ events, and the atmosphere was completely out of control. There were multiple fights and overly aggressive behavior, and it felt like security was reacting rather than preventing problems. Honestly, someone is going to get seriously hurt if things continue this way. On top of that, the place felt dirty, the prices were excessive for what you get, and the overall experience was nowhere near worth the cost. I won't be returning, and I would not recommend it to anyone looking for a fun or safe night out

What an amazing authentic Italian Gem.... This one is truly the closest to eating in Italy w/o…read moreflying there. All pastas are handmade, Neapolitan pizza second to none, outstanding Italian wines with some Napa ones thrown in as well. The vibe is a very cozy and warm chalet feel, with fantastic background music to set the mood played at the perfect volume. Different levels of seating and a few round tables for the perfect dinner with friends or family. Price point perfect and what is coming out of the kitchen fantastic. Great cocktail menu and they have Moretti beer one of my favorites. Owners are from Italy and Two25 has been open for the past 3 years and they're working on another restaurant opening soon in Glen Head. Definitely will be back, highly recommend

I loved everything about this restaurant. It is so pretty inside. The food is fabulous and the…read moreservice was amazing. Jessica our waitress was so nice and super friendly. She made our first time dining here a great experience. I'll definitely return.

Always love stopping by for some wonderful fresh seafood. Oysters, fried shrimp, cold lobster…read moreroll, and pitcher of spicy margarita. It all hit the spot. Enjoyed a nice walk from oyster bay here. Well worth it. Staff is sweet and kind combined with a calm Long Island Bay View. Chill vibe!

The Clam Bar at Bayville Bridge. 40 Ludlum Ave. What a…read morewonderful experience today. Wanted Oysters so badly so we went to Teddy Roosevelt Beach for some and an ice cold pacifico from The Sand Box. Well for some crazy reason they were closed . So we took a ride across the causeway and landed up at Shultey's and upon arriving and waiting for 2 minutes with wait staff passing us by left and right finally barkeep says sorry we don't open until 5. Ummm couldn't you have told us that immediately?? Well anyway I decided we leave the car and walk to The Clam Bar @ the bridge and I am so glad we did. I haven't been here in forever. The kids who are out front running this are superb. Each kid was so polite and totally on point. Hot from the walk we were given two cups of ice water which hit the spot. We ordered 2 IPA's and they were delicious . To start we got the seafood sampler- 4 oysters, 4 little necks and 3 jumbo shrimp cocktails omg so good and fresh as can be. Next up were another 6 little necks with a cold seafood salad which was served ice cold in a lettuce boat with shrimp, baby scallops, calamari, celery and onion and that absolutely blew us away. To cap it off we got fish and chips and this might have been some of the best I've ever had. The fish was light, airy and the crust was perfect, not greasy and 3 huge pieces. The chips were beer battered and sprinkled with paprika imo and they were fabulous. We left for the walk back with full belly's, a little sun and a jar of fresh pickles from @Nickypickles and we couldn't be happier.

We had my mom's 80th birthday at the Mill Creek Tavern and had the best time. The food was…read moredelicious and exactly as we discussed in the planning, many choices and plentiful. The room was the perfect size for the party and had a nice nautical theme which we added our own party decor to. I can't say enough about the service. Vanessa was the easiest coordinator to work with planning the event, and did everything she said. She and Jeanne and the other servers at the party kept the drinks flowing, the food coming, and were so nice, it really made the evening. I highly recommend Mill Creek for any event you have or just for a delicious dinner and a fun night out

A suggestion. Instead of a large variety of poor-mediocre entrees, why not 4-5 well-crafted…read morechoices. Wife and I ate last night. Sauerbraten was " greasy", shrimp dish overly salty. Restaurant should concentrate on a menu with just a few well-prepared dishes. If I wanted a "diner experience", Long island has plenty of those!

4.8 star review…read more First time visiting. I love the environment, design, bar, and white table cloths. Only small issue was the music was a little too loud - hard to hear conversations. I had the wedge salad and asked for it to be chopped. Done. Then I had Chicken Marsala. My husband and friend had salad with salmon and the roasted chicken. Overall, the food was delicious! Service attentive. I'd go back but I'd take someone with whom I didn't want to have a conversation - too loud. Haha Otherwise it would have been a 5 star review. The food and friendly service were great.

Today the service was appallingly slow. We arrived after the lunch rush 1:30pm and after being…read moreseated waited at least 30 minutes for our water and lunch order. Bread baskets came out to 3 tables that arrived after us, we had completely empty water glasses and no one coming by to ask for more water. It took a long time for our food to arrive, meanwhile people who sat after us got served. There was also some confusion about which server was responsible for our table. We heard they were short a server but honestly, where was the manager? Every table suffered from a lack of service. We were down to our last bites of food when our server finally showed up to check on our meal. For the food: the salmon with the curry sauce was good, however the sauce had no sign of curry...more of a soy sauce flavor. I was disappointed as that was why I ordered it. Two of us got that. The 3rd person got the fried fish sandwich for $26 that Henry's could have done a better job. It's too bad that the man who appeared to be the manager seems to be doing nothing. Any restaurant with this kind of situation should have had a manager walking around, perhaps doing a small dessert or something that made customers feel better about the lack of service. Members of our family have been here many times but seriously rethinking coming again for a while.

First time at this restaurant and the food here is amazing. Me and my girlfriend were looking for…read moresomething to eat since were starving and just got off the train. Literally stumbled on this place by accident but very happy we found them. There was literally no wait time to be seated and we were serviced right away. We ordered burgers and they were phenomenal! Definitely hit them up if you're in the area for a amazing burger, you won't be disappointed.

Absolutely love it here. I grew up in this town and this business is consistently good. I have been…read moregoing there almost every day for lunch and I love it.

Exceptional meal at a reasonable price! I love this restaurant! Nice variety on the menu. Fabulous…read moreservice

Jeanine's is different kind of place. It is a family restaurant where you are are part of the…read morefamily. She has come into her own, cooking her menu her way. The service is good even on busy holidays. If possible they will accomdate your special needs.

Delicious food and truly staple here in Locust Valley I have…read morereturned many times. The food is always delicious and consistent.

All around amazing, the ambience is great and the location is beautiful, it makes you feel like you…read moreare in a cozy little cafe even though the location is quite big. The service was also 5 star and the food was super good! Weirdly they didn't have pizza on the day I was there, but no complaints aside from that.