Soooo damn good! Sunday brunch yum! I can't eat eggs so I " settle" for lobster Mac and cheese or lobster grilled cheese! We went for dinner too! Amazing steak! Also had the freshest oysters ( local and from Canada), local clams and shrimp! The staff is attentive, fun and friendly! Our new local go to place! read more

Schultzy's Restaurant - Oysters, clams and shrimp Appetizers! - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

food was awesome , had baked clams , best I had in a long time and then the Monkfish Franchise on special ,loved it . Staff was friendly and attentive. Ambiance was very nice read more

Open for lunch! Google maps said closed, (found out later, website had corrrct hours!) but we stopped by anyway thankfully. Beautiful lunch menu. Perfect French onion soup, sandwiches, etc. Excellent service because down to earth, real, friendly. Shall I continue? Totally recommend. read more

I would say this restaurant has the best burger in town! I bring my kids here specifically for the cheeseburger and fries. The staff are wonderful. Everything we have tried on the menu we have really enjoyed, whether it's been the lunch or dinner menu. This is a wonderful restaurant! read more

New hot place in BayVille. Great place for lunch or dinner specializing in seafood. Its probably the best place in Bayville which is a quiet little town. read more

Delicious and fun fresh seafood restaurant in the village of Bayville! Thanks for bringing some good food to our little island! read more

100% REAL!! Do you want Fresh seafood?? Do you want REAL great service, REAL great food and REAL great people? Stop by Schultzy's! You will NOT be disappointed! Jim, the owner brings it 100%! The food is on-point. The brussel sprout/baby kale salad is a meal unto itself--- and DElicious!! Bartender, Corey, will make a fierce drink for you!! The vibe is warm, friendly and Fun!!. read more

100% will be coming back. my boyfriend and i got seated right away. the shrimp and grits stole the show. waitress was very kind and attentive. we also got a chance to meet the owner. definitely our new date spot! thank you :) read more

Schultzy's Restaurant - oysters / espresso martini / shrimp cocktail - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

A great experience! The owner talked to us for a while and was so nice and welcoming- even asked us what music we wanted the restaurant to play haha. The food was delicious: oysters were big and fresh, French onion soup was great, and my boyfriend loved the clam chowder. The grilled cheese was nothing special but still good! French fries were like super thin steak fries, so good. Check out this local gem!! read more

Schultzy's Restaurant - Grilled cheese and French onion soup - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

The food is spectacular, but what endeared me to the place more was how welcoming the staff was. Even though we obviously weren't part of the 'local' regulars, we felt totally welcomed and at home. My husband had the Seafood Fra Diavolo (perfect amount of heat), and I had a salad with the seared tuna. Tuna was like butter. Best meal we had in our trip to NY. read more

Grandsons and I had lunch yesterday it was fabulous service over the top! Make reservations great food & service pleasant folks. read more

See all

Very good, I will truthfully say, it is the best restaurant in the entire area. Service was very good, very attentive to our needs. We started off with calamari arrabbiata, my wife had Halibut and I had the french onion soup and the Ahi tuna. Food was prepared well, did need a little salt - but overall VERY GOOD read more

Oysters, clams, appys great. Halibut delish. I like this place. Oysters, clams, appys great. Halibut delish. I like this place. read more

A local restaurant with fresh seafood and other items to choose from. Went out with family and was not disappointed in the least . Service was very attentive and food was amazing to say the least . I had lobster classic lobster bake with corn which they happily changed to spinach for me and clams on the half shell . My daughter had shrimp scampi which she said she will be back The atmosphere was friendly and inviting Will definitely return to this little Gem on the North Shore of Long Island ... Bayville read more

Definitely one of my favorite seafood restaurants in Bayville . Besides the friendly staff, the excellent well prepared food, the laid back ambiance, the food is always fresh and on point. I travel quite a bit and always have my favorite restaurants around the world and Schultzys is a must go whenever I am in the area. Give it a try! read more

First off, great corner location and atmosphere. Place fills a void for an Oyster Bar that, embarrassingly, does not exist in Oyster Bay proper; at least now there's one over the Bayville Bridge. Oysters were fresh and properly chilled. Shrimp cocktail was also done right with nice sized shrimp. The New England Clam Chowder had a nice rich and creamy texture, but was lacking is seasoning/flavor (maybe add some Sherry, malt vinegar or bay seasoning?). Other glitch was the service. Owner (very nice guy) was trying to fill the roll of bartender/server/host), during a busy lunch crowd. It was week In between Christmas and New Year, so may have been short staffed. We'll be back regardless, just hoping they tighten up the service and flavor the soup! read more

Look no further if you Love Lobster Rolls. This is the place! Schultzy's in Bayville is a lovely restaurant. High top tables are in the front by the bar. Regular tables in the back and outdoor dining is available. My friend and I were on a mission to find the Best Lobster Roll on Long Island. Tasting the New England Style Lobster Roll was met with sighs of pleasure. The grilled bun in which it was served was crunchy adding to the delight of the tasty mouthful. Succulent claw meat filled the bun to overflowing. This cold version wasn't over chilled and that added to the flavor of the meal. The accompanying fries were sliced lengthwise and crispy. Even the Cole slaw which seemed homemade was delicious. A generous slice of pickle topped it all off. The server was attentive and the friendly manager who greeted us upon our arrival came over to check that we were happy with our meal. We both felt that we completed our mission. Schultzy's Lobster Roll is the Best! read more

I went to Schultzys this evening with four friends. The food was delicious...we started with the crab cake, calamari, Mexican corn, and New England clam chowder. The halibut and lobster rolls were excellent....the fries were divine! Unfortunately, our server Jennifer was obviously feeling overwhelmed...she was abrupt and brusque throughout the meal. We waited quite a long time between appetizers and entrees so I was surprised when she brought the check to the table and said "we have another reservation " as she and another woman frantically cleared our table. When she came to collect our credit cards I pointed out to her that we had waited a long time for our meals and we did not appreciate being rushed out because " there was another reservation". It is a shame that a restaurant with such good food has just lost good clients read more

We have been trying to get a reservation for a few weeks now. It was definitely worth the wait. Fresh seafood and great attentive service. I had the Connecticut lobster roll and it was delicious! Hubby had stuffed shrimp and he enjoyed it. Drinks were also great. read more

Schultzy's Restaurant - a plate of french fries and a drink - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

45 minutes between finishing app and main course arriving sucks the life out of a meal. Good food and a friendly owner - hope they can figure out the kitchen, or maybe have a waitstaff who is paying attention. read more

Food was great and the service was lovely EXCEPT!!! it seems that servers and bussers were actually told to make as much noise as possible with the dishes and silverware: stacking plates loudly while clearing right next to someone's ear, hurling them into the dish bins just behind the bar, rushing to throw silverware into glasses while gathering the mise en place. They need training in effective and pleasant service. The constant noise of dishes and silverware crashing all around us every few minutes really affected the enjoyment of our meal. As environment is important and these aren't diner prices, the noise means I probably would think twice about going again or would need to sit outside. read more

Favorite restaurant is town. Seafood is super fresh. Menu is dynamic. Owner is awesome and all the people working there too. Will definitely go back. read more

Great fresh seafood with a menu with something for everyone. Nice bar and wonderful staff.

We have eaten at Schultz's several times and will continue to! Excellent food, excellent service! The best food in Bayville! Thank You for never disappointing! Great Job to the kitchen staff, chef and wait staff. Great cocktails outstanding food. I'm stuffed read more

My wife and I had heard such good things about Schultzy's in Bayville that we decided to try it today From the friendliness of the servers to the modern chic decor it's a great addition to the north shore The onion soup was to die' for prepared like the finest French restaurants . The oysters were fresh and tasty , The surf and turf was on par with any top steak house The side of Brussel sprouts was done perfectly as were the garlic potatoes. The bread pudding and cappuccino was also superb All in all a great find !! A true winner read more

Loved this place. I don't even like seafood but the oysters and the fish were amazing. And great drinks. Great space. Great night.

Great food and service. Our friends want to know when we can go back. Freshest seafood, lobsters and more!

Can't speak to the actual restaurant - only the catering. Amazing! They catered a birthday party, the food and set up was outstanding, the guys were great, so helpful with everything. Great pricing to have lobster, skirt steak, clams, etc and not pay through the roof. Highly recommend, honestly I plan to use them consistently myself. read more

Schultzy's Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

Nice place. We had a great waitress as well. Baked clams top notch, raw little neck oysters were cold, fresh and fantastic. Out of the oven rolls with herb butter mmmm. Sea scallops over saffron risotto was perfection and the jumbo shrimp over linguini will fill you up and make you happy. Overall awesome place to eat. Make a reservation, not a large place. We didn't and they still accommodated. A+++ read more

We Love Schultz's ! The seafood is so fresh.. they have so many delicious dishes. Also a very comforting atmosphere!

So we were exploring Bayville and not how I remember it at all, almost everything was closed, abandoned of empty. We asked a local if there were any clam bars and he suggested Schultzy's. The waitress seemed surprised when we asked to be seated and then some jerk asks if we have a reservation!!! The place was almost empty!!!! We were seated at a lone table way in the back then ignored for 15 minutes. That was enough for me read more

went to Schultzy's today for lunch!!! Awesome! Shrimp tacos and Pulled pork sandwiches were amazing! The restaurant is new and beautiful ! loved everything about it! read more

Well there we were late afternoon going to a local place past there that we sometimes frequent or the marina by boat (in the summer, water view, sunset , , locals and crowd mainly bar and not too many eating So we left leaving back thru town ) and again said hey , we should try Schultzy's Looks new , freshened up , hmmmm just stop , seafood and raw bar , , high tables , regular bar ,Tv ,open kitchen , greeted right away , sat at bar , 5p, ice tray with huge oysters , fresh clams with an array of great seafood and color , bartender ,owners all pleasant and locals , nice afternoon ambience, ours , mew england clam chowder , so yummy , better than just your regular taste ,raw clams ( succulent , one instance of "just out of the water flavor taste and octopus grilled with a phenomenal simple sauce and taste , not tasty bread rolls crispy w butter , simple but so perfect !!! Peeking at other plates ! Well the scallops over risotto could win tops with shallots or onions but the delivery was great as well as the lobster Mac and cheese and a fish special next to me Making raves and waves !!! By the time we left 615 or so , more regulars and the place was getting packed ! A must go to !!!! Over the bridge , don't turn left or right at the light , it's right in front of you !!! Great service great cuisine , great local ! read more

Food and service were excellent. Scallops were delicious. Everything seems very fresh.

A great destination for a drive out from NYC! Bayville is a quiet seaside village and Schultzy's Restaurant is a wonderful place to enjoy lunch. Cory makes you feel welcome and is prompt with service. The shrimp and lobster bisque and French onion soup were delicious. My husband says the shrimp po' boy is the best he's had since being in New Orleans. Worth the trip! Good quality food and welcoming staff! its a hidden gem! read more

My husband and I stopped in for Brunch and definitely will be back. The best grits ever and every thing from the pancakes to the sausages were excellent. Owner very nice too . Friendly service n we gotta try dinner!Worth the drive from Brooklyn! read more

Best place in town. Love the food and the people working there. Have a great time every time.

Cool clean bright spot - fresh seafood with ample selections - good we'll crafted drinks - nice accommodating service staff - we liked Schultzy's. read more

Trust me you will enjoy this small little gem, with good food and people! Reservations a must and most dishes are seafood

Ok. Sorry to rank this low. But expensive. Especially for what you get. Service not good. It wasn't horrible but not good. Okay the food - not great. They need better oyster shuckers - had shell in almost every oyster. Lobster roll just blah (stew leonards grocery store has better). Dessert (pie) was warmed in microwave so that it could come out warm - came out dry. Drinks were good. I am not mentioning the "routine" things that happen like dirty utensil brought out, etc because those things happen and it's okay. But the food and service should carry the place. This did not and the price was just the last insult. read more