What a wonderful surprise! We stopped at Cafe Gia on our way back from the Tanger Outlets in…read moreRiverhead, just looking for a place to eat, and we ended up discovering a little Italian gem! The Italian owner, Dominic, was incredibly welcoming and made us feel right at home. The food was absolutely delicious. We had the pasta with shrimp, which was full of flavor, and the toasted bread with cheese was amazing -- the kids absolutely loved it! But the best of the best was the chicken soup. Oh my gosh! Seriously, some people can't even make chicken soup this good at home! It tasted homemade, comforting, rich and absolutely delicious. Mamma mia, che bontà! I would honestly drive another 40 minutes just to eat this soup again! Great food, warm Italian hospitality, and that wonderful feeling of finding a place you weren't expecting to love so much. Cafe Gia, we will definitely be back! Grazie, Dominic!

This place continues to get orders completely wrong. Besides that fact, I put that I have a dairy…read moreallergy and cannot have cheese. It was in the notes and we even called to make sure they saw my note online about the allergy and no cheese. Yet, for the THIRD TIME, there is cheese in my meal. None of the employees know what they're doing and clearly can't even read basic English. And the manger or owner, have no idea and genuinely don't care, is so rude and disrespectful. He always has an attitude when you call about an issue (which is literally all the time), and the first time we called about my allergy that was stated in the notes he said "all our pastas have cheese, it makes it taste better" even though it's not stated in ANY OF THE DESCRIPTIONS. I do not recommend this place at all especially if you have an allergy because they do not take proper precautions even when you do inform them multiple times.

The service was great - thank you Maria. Everyone was very attentive, filled up my water and my ice…read moretea. The food was excellent, had the shrimp parm with angel hair. The sauce was nice and thick, just like I like it. Price was right. I had nothing bad to say. It is in a slightly odd, 1/2 empty plaza, but that's why I'd call it a hidden gem.

We go here every year for my birthday! Lovely atmosphere and great food! The servers are sweet and…read moreattentive!

If i could give this "restaurant" 0 stars I would!!!! Don't waste your money and your time! The…read morepizza looked like chuck e. cheese pizza. I ordered half pepperoni half cheese thru grubhub arrived 10 minutes late and it was unedile and under cooked. I called the restaurant and the guy answered and said hello not even royal pizza how may I help you so rude. Anyways, the pizza guy as he called himself told me I suck and that the pizza was very cooked and that it was brown it was not brown it was super doughy. But the pizza guy told me I was lying 3 times and that I sucked and hung up the phone. I did get a refund thru grubhub.

Great food and service, fun and friendly place with plenty of parking and the food is always…read morefresh, plenty of seats to sit down and enjoy a good meal, a great pizza restaurant in lake ronkonkoma .

I just DESTROYED a Grandma's something or other Sicilian square slice, a white pizza with ricotta,…read moreand a garlic knot. I'm gonna need a minute before I hit up the cannoli. OMG I'm on Long Island visiting this week. I asked them where to get good pizza. I'm so glad they told me to come up here. Yum! Ugh...so stuffed now!

I ordered their special meal plan 19 meals for $50 (available Mon- Thurs ONLY & until May 31st) I…read morecalled my choices in and then headed down to enjoy a slice with my nephew while they made my order, their pizza is delicious my nephew had a meatball slice and I had a garlic knot slice while we waited. We ordered (2) Penne Ala vodka, (2) Chicken Parmigiana, (2) Chicken Frances, (1) Spaghetti & Meatballs, (1) Baked Manicotti and (2) Sausage and Peppers dinners for a total of 10 dinners all together, they have a lot more to choose from and they all came in those nice take out tins so you're getting a full meal portion not some skimpy small portion for $5 a piece!! How can you beat that price?? I brought them home and put them in the freezer an My family and I have defrosted them and eaten them over the course of 2 weeks and eat meal was absolutely delicious, it was very easy to defrost and eat each meal and the portions were large enough for us to share with each other so we each had a little bit of whatever we defrosted that night it was like eating out at an Italian restaurant without having to cook or cleanup afterwards and again for an AMAZING PRICE! Go check them out and make your dinner plans next week easy and enjoy Paisano's food in your home!

great place to eat! i had a good time staff was great there really i enjoyed the food it was fresh…read moreand it wasn't cold i would recommend coming here!!! come try this pizza its well money spent for this fresh warm pizza!!

Great pizza, clean place, nice people, great service. What more to explain?…read more Got half and half this crust pizza. Margherita is top of the notch. Just Great. BBQ chicken little salty or too much BBQ sauce. But taste great w a lot of chicken. Def coming back

The people in Manorville are rude and awful…read more These guys were very nice, and the food was delicious. Extremely overpriced though. Pizza used to be somewhat affordable. $45 for 3 slides of pizza and 3 sodas. Granted one bbq slice, one grandma and one deep dish, but $45? That's crazy.

SUMMARY: Mold can happen, but next time, REMOVE the spoiled items from the fridge once its brought…read moreto your attention!!! I usually go to the location in Manorville, but I went to this one after coming home from the beach. First, let's get the good part out of the way. The food at this location is comparable to the one in Manorville, and it's really good. They have ample seating in a comfortable enough dining room. They also have decent customer service. What they don't have, at least based on my last visit, are great hygiene practices. I was going to get a slice of cherry cheesecake from the fridge until I saw the cherries were very moldy. I waited until there were no customers around and signaled to the woman working that the cheesecake was, in fact, moldy and I didn't know what else in that case might have gone bad. She took it and threw it away. My food came out about ten minutes later, and it took me about 15 minutes to eat. I was sat pretty close to that fridge and in 35 minutes, neither she nor any of the staff went to check the food. That's concerning to me because I brought it to their attention that there was visible mold on one of the cherry cheesecakes, and there were at least ten other cherry cheesecakes in that refrigerator, plus other desserts and other things that could get people sick. To her credit, when I told her I didn't feel safe eating the produce and would like her to refund my salad because I didn't want it, she did so without complaint, and the Sicilian slice was good as always. But I don't feel great about eating at a place where, again, it's not even the fact that there was mold. Stuff happens. It's that they let so much time go by once it was brought to their attention. That's a great way to get people sick.

Good food, great service, with a spacious dining area. The calamari was really good. The penne was…read morereally good too, so much, I ended up with leftovers for work. Definitely is now my go-to spot.

This was one of my first good experiences at Sabina's in years. Although I've never dined in their…read moredining room, I've visited them for pizza a number of times over the years. Typically there is a lot of favoritism for the "regulars" which makes it difficult to have a good experience for those of us who are not a "regular". However this visit was different. The gentleman behind the counter was friendly and personable. He helped us order and pay for our food right away. The food was hot and flavorful and came out in a decent amount of time. The tables were clean for the most part and everything seemed to be operating smoothly. Although shared by other businesses, the lot out front had ample parking. Based on this most recent visit, I can say my mind has been changed by Savianos and will continue to come back in the future.

I love these local Pizzarias. I stopped on a damp, rainy April day. The owner works the counter and…read moreis very nice. I think he works with his wife--a real Mom & Pop business. Being that I live in North Carolina now and don't regularly see Veal Cutlet Parmesan on the menu (this is one of my favorites), I ordered it--it was delicious and a huge portion, priced very well. Other people in the restaurant, complimented the owners on the quality and taste of it. One by one people entered that seemed to be friends came in. It was great to watch the interaction. The restaurant is a pizza counter with a small dinning room with four tables. Seats about 16. If I am ever here again, I will make it a point to come here.

The pizza is very good here. We order from this place a couple times a month because we enjoy it so…read moremuch.