Really nice dine in place! Love the set up, super fun they have crayons on all the tables so people can color and design their placemats. They even hang a lot of them up all over their walls. The food was okay. Got a chicken, spinach, and onion pizza as well as the chicken pesto calzone with spinach and onion added. The calzone looked great but you couldn't taste the pesto at all and there was a huge imbalance with the ingredients. We both felt like, for the pizza and calzone, way too much cheese. We both didn't feel the best afterwards but agreed this place is worth trying again, we will just request half the amount of cheese to be used on our order (: read more

See all

I am not a huge fan of the overly loaded heavy pizzas but if you prefer, absolutely go for Sella's. Loaded with chunks of chicken, cheese and peanut sauce oozing out; a single or two slice and I was full! Calzone was highly disappointing- just direct chunks of artichoke, marinara and extreme cheese squished in as a whole. The pricing is high going by the amount of portions. Staff is sweet and welcoming. Ambience - absolutely adored it! read more

See all

Great place! If you're coming to Pullman, you need to stop here and try the fantastic food. The Calzones are huge and delicious. The help was friendly and really cared about making you feel welcome and that everything was to your satisfaction. We will certainly be back! read more

Noelle was so amazing and attentive, definitely recommend this place. Food was great as always and such a nice place to sit and eat.

Sella's Calzone and Pizza is a solid restaurant in Pullman, Washington. The waitstaff is knowledgeable and listens well the customers questions! The atmosphere is fun and has a relaxed vibe! You will leave with your tastebuds satisfied and a smile on your face! A fabulous place to meet fellow Cougs read more

We found our new 'go to' for pizza! Delicious food, great customer service! We got a Large spicy sausage, pepperoni pizza, Birkenstock canzone, and cheesy bread - yummy! read more

See all

Incredibly solid college town Ital-Amer joint. With 'Calzone' in the name, you know they're foldin' those babies up right. Any visiting Spokanites who love Pete's Pizza will do naked cartwheels with these 'zone offerings. They were getting creamed with the Natl Lentil Festival going on and hundreds of parents dropping off their students at WSU, and were down a few items that I crave; but no matter, because I just asked our waitress to pick whatever protein they had left and add pickled Jalapeños. Eh Voila, delicious lunch! Wifey insisted on getting their Bread Twist appy, and I wisely refrained, thereby securing plenty of belly room for that great calzone. Was there plenty to take back to the RV? Indeed there was... read more

See all

Having a sign to let you know, you have to order at the counter! Food just ok. Pizza ok read more

Came here with a couple friends and we shared a large pie. The cheese pull was real and the crust was golden and chewy in the best way. I liked how the pepperoni got those little crispy edges. We sat outside and it was a nice chill evening. The staff checked on us a few times and refilled our waters without asking. Definitely a good local pizza spot I'd come back to. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

Most amazing calzone! The Cougar Calzone is delicious. Perfectly toasted with fillings that spill out in ooey-gooey goodness! And the cheese...OMG! Love the atmosphere and the coloring placemats are so fun. Beer in jars!?! So awesome. Best place ever read more

What an amazing spot! We were in town for parents weekend at WSU. I couldn't believe how big the beers were and the food was absolutely amazing! Great little spot to check out when you're in town or on campus and want some great food and a fun atmosphere. The service was quick and very friendly! read more

See all

I always love sella's we tried the gluten free crust and it was delicious. Thinner and a little crispy and was even better in day two.

The calzones are huge and stuffed full of cheese and toppings. It's almost too much cheese, really. But find you're inner strength and you can make it through. The only aspects of Sella's I don't love are the limited draft beer options and the fact that the salads are made of iceberg lettuce. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - tables and chairs - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

See all

Yummy! The piesan. This pizza was very, very filling! I ate two pieces and my brain said "yummy, you want another piece" but my stomach said "you are full and another piece will make you feel too full." Sadly, my brain won. The Piesan. Try it. Very delicious. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

Update from 9/20/24 This place has always been great but our last couple visits here were bad news. The pizzas are undercooked. When the crust is raw-ish dough.... that's not quality pie. And skimping on the shrimp salad is an unwelcome change. Still nice friendly service and good vibes but food has gone down hill. read more

We've been here many times but first review. Consistently great pizza. My wife loves their side salad too. We never pass up going here if we are in Pullman. I think it's a bit pricey for pizza but for the quality I'm fine with paying a little more. Only thing that is odd is that they solicit a tip just for taking your order. This is ass backwards. read more

In town for a campus visit and had this place recommended to us. Right across from the main entrance to campus. Relatively quiet but it was Tuesday afternoon. Had a great chicken pesto calzone. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Chicken pesto calzone and Italian calzone (back). - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

I love Sella's... maybe simply due to nostalgia, but I do enjoy stopping in when in Pullman or Moscow. Wheelchair accessible enough for me, but I can see it becoming uncomfortable if crowded. -so far I've missed a football weekend, or 1st day of classes scenario read more

This is my all time favorite food in Pullman and so glad it has survived all these years! The Best calzones! Yum!

Causal pizzeria close to WSU. Great food and the staff are very attentive. We ordered way too much food. We ended up with lots of leftovers for another day. Order at the counter and self serve fountain drinks. read more

Wish I had more time to embrace this place but it's special for sure. Stopped in late after a busy long day of move in so the gang and I were hangry! After hearing SO many good things about this place we finally had time to try it finally and it's definitely all true. We ordered 2 calzones (Canadian&build your own) and 1 12" Canadian pizza Everything was super delicious! Calzones are huge and packed with melty ouuuwie goooey cheesy goodness! Didn't have time to take any pictures but you can see from others here and get a good idea. Pizza tasted great to no surprise but one thing I didn't like if I had to choose is the bottom of the pizza was super wet and not dry and I'm not sure if that's because of the toppings? But if they could find a way to fix that with a crispy bottom it would be top tier pizza no doubt about that. Ambiance is nice with a lot of artwork drawings on the walls from past patron's. Energy here was great and the customer service had a huge part of it so shout out to all the employees because I bet it was super busy and tiring with all the people that were in town. Will definitely stop by whenever I get a chance to visit Pullman again so I highly recommend you to come and see what all the hype is about! read more

Wow, mega hearty portions for the money. Sella's is clearly a Pullman institution, and I'm so glad we got to visit and eat there. Looks very kid-friendly with paper place settings and drawing materials on the tables. Staffed by likely WSU students, who are friendly and know the menu. We got sodas and calzones. My friend got the regular size calzone with custom toppings and at the end of our meal she hadn't done much damage. I could not even finish my mini Coug calzone after having the house salad. It was savory and tasty. The contents were moist and generously covered in cheese, and the outside satisfyingly crusty. Would definitely come again! read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - mini calzone - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

We were in town for the 3rd time in 2 and a half weeks. Our Charlie was having test done at WSU and this isn't a WSU review but if you have a furbaby with serious illness or disease, please take them to the VTH at WSU. BUT back to this review, this place was incredible. The customer service was excellent. Professional and customer centric. The pizza was extremely good and irresistible to put down. So much cheese, delicious marinara and toppings of the highest freshness. The wife had the pasta Alfredo with Chicken. It was delicious but also the aromas and presentation were superb. Only wish I remembered to take a pic. The inside of this restaurant is very classy and inviting. If you are ever in the Pullman area, do yourself or/and your family a favor and order their pizza and pasta. Best pizza from Pullman to Spokane Valley! read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Best mushroom included pizza i have ever had! - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

This place kills it. I've been in the industry for 30 years and in Italian for about half of that. I don't need to type a bunch of words. Great job guys. read more

Good prices and excellent calzones. Casual atmsophere...perfect for kids and families. read more

ENTER AT YOUR OWN RISK!!!! Our club baseball team came in about 50m prior to closing. With 20 players and 40 supporting family members I estimate we spent roughly $1200-1500 that night on food and drinks. The food was good but after we completed our orders and many were seated while finishing meals, respectfully & well mannered I may add, the manager (a young woman) came out of the kitchen visibly angry and began shouting across the restaurant that they were closing and we needed to leave. Keep in mind that my order was last, and made just a few minutes after closing, I had also ordered a pint of beer. She said I needed to leave even though I had just sat down to eat and enjoy my beer. Our group probably covered their nut for two days of business and they were rude and disrespectful to us. I will never return to that restaurant, and will tell everyone I know about the awful staff at this place. BTW both woman behind the counter served me with smiles on their faces and 10m later after they served my food (in a box) they turned into angry elves. No presents from Santa this Christmas for them. Their treatment of another elderly group sitting next to us was the same story. AVOID THIS PLACE!!! read more

The food was delicious. I had the bread twist. The pesto chicken calzone a small salad and ice tea. Was way too much food for one person. Don't get the twist if ur getting a calzone it has so much dough you will be full too fast. The service was fine, I the center of the calzone was cold so probably too many ingredients luckily I was so stuffed I only ate the outsides part of the calzone. read more

Delicious. Order at counter. Seat yourself. Casual atmosphere. Fast service. Delicious. Gluten free pizza options. Lots of toppings. Flavorful. Relaxed. Self serve soda machine. Beer on tap. Cider in can. Highly recommended. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Gluten Create Your Own 12 inch Gluten-Free Crust Pizza Piesan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

See all

Delicious pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, and bell pepper along with bread twists. Loved the cheesy goodness, hot and fresh out of the oven, and made to perfection. Appreciated the promptness of our order being ready in 15 minutes for take out and the friendliness of the staff. Thank you Sella's! read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Mushroom bell pepper pepperoni pizza w bread stick - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

Delicious food and amazing service! Cute place right into Pullman! Got food super fast! read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Chicken Alfredo and twist bread stick! - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

Flying through to pick up some Cougar Gold (yes, it's really that good), stopped here for lunch. I used to come here 20 years ago when I went to school here. Menu hasn't changed, everything is just as excellent! We had the lunch special small calzones with salad and they were enormous! I was only able to eat half of mine. My husband said it was awesome! Thank you! read more

See all

Group of us came in two weeks ago after the WSU vs Oregon football game. It was crowded, but there was a very kind employee making sure everyone had menus and helping everyone in line find a table to sit at. Ordering went smoothly. For myself and one friend, our food came right away. Pizza was extra delicious and we comfortably shared a salad. In the meantime, my friends' pizza never showed up. Eventually they asked the same kind employee, who researched it and found it never got made. She went above and beyond to ensure that they got some money refunded and had bread twists to munch on while we waited for it. This was amazing, thoughtful customer service -- easily the best I've seen in a long time. Highly recommend the service and the food. If craving Italian in Pullman, this place should be your go-to!!! read more

My family and I were craving Italian food and wanted to give this place a shot. We were tired and didn't feel like going out to eat so we got our food to go. We googled the menu and places our orders. My spaghetti and meatballs was good and the onions gave it more flavor. It wasn't anything out of the ordinary for spaghetti. My uncle had the fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp and he couldn't really taste the shrimp. The calzones were filling but missing a sauce for moisture. The only sauce came from the meats. Overall, it was a decent experience but not really too impressed. read more

See all

Came here around 5pm and the food was good. A girl welcomed us in and told us to grab the menus to order. I ordered the Calzone Canadian which came with Canadian bacon, pineapple, mushrooms, marinara, and mozzarella. The dough was nice, but a little too cooked. It was a mistake ordering this (and I don't like pineapple on a pizza) because the pineapple combined with the mushroom oozed out their liquids making the calzone inside wet and full of liquids. I don't recommend their Calzone with Canadian for that reason. The presentation of the calzone was a letdown and could've been improved like better plating choice, but I'm not expecting that from this place. Overall, this is a decent place to eat it, but don't expect anything special. read more

See all

This place is a classic college town pizza and calzone spot. Unpretentious infancy vibe - lots of college kids and families. Have a beer and grab the crayons and placemats - see if you can make a drawing that lands you on the literal Sella's drawing wall of fame. It's good solid pizza with copious toppings. You pay more but you get more. I would definitely go again. read more

I had no expectations and was pleasantly surprised. Ordered a pesto calzone which was reasonably priced and tasted great. Cooked with a crispy crust and big enough to share for a tasty lunch. read more

I don't usually leave negative reviews... but I just want to make sure the owners know about our experience tonight. We came in at about 7:15 and were a little shocked to find absolutely no one there, since the only other time we've eaten there, the pizza was DELICIOUS. Alas, this time, we didn't even order and just left because the girl told us they couldn't do a half cheese, half pepperoni and jalapeño pizza for us. I found that rather ridiculous to turn away your only customers from an empty restaurant because you can't be bothered to put jalapeño on one side (which we would obviously pay for). Anyway just want to make sure the owner knows what's going on, and if that is your policy, then I guess that explains why the place was empty! Lol read more

Great food and great service. We came in here for dinner after a team baseball game and the staff were very accommodating and were able to seat the team and parents. Food came out quickly and it was hot and delicious! read more

Everyone in Pullman knows and loves Sella's. It is the best pizza joint around. Sella's does not just sell pizzas, they also have the usual staples of pasta and salads. They also have their famous calzones. Each pizza and calzone is loaded with cheese. Extra cheese is not necessary here as it is ample and more than enough to satisfy any cheesy pizza lover. My order is always a Pepperoni and Mushroom Large pizza. I only have a few slices that night and have leftovers for days. The leftovers are best heated up in the oven and taste as good as the night they were baked. The oven heats up and melts the cheese, which brings out the flavor. My pizza the other night had the benefit of being really saucy, which is my favorite. Their sauce is really good and really made the pizza even better. The one downside of all the cheese is the greasiness. The pizza tends to be on the greasier side. However, it is not really an issue unless it is an issue for you personally. If you are in Pullman, I would highly recommend stopping in to this pizza place. Whether you take your order to go, which I do the majority of the time, or eat in or whether you order a pizza, pasta, or calzone, you will love Sella's. If possible, get those leftovers and reheat them in the oven! Accessibility: Sella's is semi-accessible. The entrance is a set of three stairs. However, there is a ramp at the back door. An employee needs to open it to let you in. The seating inside is kind of tight. It should not be an issue during slower hours outside of events like WSU football. (Event week/weeks mean crowds.) The seats do not have arms. There are booth benches along the walls. Outside the chairs do not have arms. I cannot remember the washrooms from the last time I was in since I take out the majority of the time. I would recommend doing take out if possible if you have any mobility issues. The lighting is good and should not be an issue. I have not been in during an event, so I cannot comment on that, but during regular hours, the noise level should not be an issue. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Large Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

Came here the other night, I had to make a yelp account just to rate this place. Absolutely amazing. I got a house salad, croutons were great, lettuce was crunchy, fresh, and juicy, and the herbs and cheese on top really perfected it. The small was big enough as a large appetizer. As my main course, I got a calzone as my main course, it was delicious. I got one with just cheese, pepperoni, and Canadian bacon (cause I'm picky, haha) and it was just amazing. Lots of meat, and good bread. As for service, even though it was quite crowded, food came pretty fast! During the short waiting time, it's fun to look around at the drawings posted on the walls, you can tell the people who come really love this place. Definitely coming back, I was highly impressed! read more