Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sitara Indian Restaurant

    4.1 (123 reviews)
    ModerateIndian

    Sitara Indian Restaurant Photos

    More like Sitara Indian Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - Sitara Indian Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Brad D.

    Service was fast and friendly, the food was excellent, and the atmosphere was very relaxed.

    Garlic Naan, Vegetable Samosas, Chicken Tikka Masala, Butter Chicken, and White Rice
    Chloe T.

    This was my first time ever trying Indian food - and it did not disappoint. The butter chicken, white rice, and garlic naan combo was amazing and so flavorful! We go ours to go, but didn't realize how nice and peaceful the inside of the restaurant was. Next time we will definitely eat inside. I wasn't a huge fan of the vegetable samosas, but some people really like them! I would go again for sure.

    Curried chicken with garlic naan
    Vicki E.

    Really delicious chicken curry and the garlic naan was so good I took the left overs with me. Service was nice and attentive. The ambiance was beautiful, especially for a strip mall location.

    Homemade crackers and sauces served to all tables.
    Amanda B.

    We love Sitaria. It's a great atmosphere. The owner runs the business with a cleanliness and professionalism like none other. The music, colors and design make for a great environment. Any questions we have on the menu are always answered truthfully and with good suggestions. So many options for meat eaters, vegetarians, or allergy accommodations. I always get something different. I got the Chicken Saag in medium and it was excellent. My husband got the chicken Korma, in mild and it was also excellent. We have never experienced poor service or food. It's a treat place for us to go without kids (there is not a kids menu if you're looking for nuggets and fries you won't find it). I've been told that outside of India itself Sitara has a great menu, selection, and flavors as everything is made by the family and uses their own family recipes. Try it out if you're in town! ((Check the hours before you go!)) Closed Mondays T-F 1130-2:30, dinner 5-9:30pm Sat: 1130-230, 5-9:30pm Sun: 11:30-230, 5-9pm

    Thali
    Holly G.

    We were in Muncie playing music and were invited to stop here for lunch by a colleague of ours. The food was delicious and the staff was super friendly. We had a combination platter that allowed us to sample several different dishes that they serve. We were happy with everything that we got and would not hesitate to return.

    See all

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Sitara Indian Restaurant Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Sitara Indian Restaurant

    Gulzar's Indian Cuisine

    Gulzar's Indian Cuisine

    4.6
    (181 reviews)
    40.3 mi
    $$

    We happened to pass by this Indian restaurant and noticed its sign advertising the buffet, so we…read moredecided to give it a try. We're glad we did! Everything we tried was delicious. The food tasted authentic, and every entrée was well prepared. They offer a great variety of curries, all of which were rich, flavorful, and satisfying! The lamb curry was especially good. The meat was tender and delicious. My only wish is that there had been a little more lamb in it! I also tried the garlic naan. It was good, but it wasn't quite as good as the best garlic naan I've ever had, which was served steaming hot, extra buttery, and packed with a strong garlic flavor. The complimentary mango drink was a nice touch and tasted great. They also offer ice cream for dessert. I tried the Campfire S'mores flavor as well as the Chocolate Brownie Pretzel flavor, and both were a perfect way to end the meal. The restaurant itself is nicely decorated and even has what appears to be a private dining area in the back. The weekday lunch buffet is available until 2:30 p.m., and on weekends it's served until around 4:00 p.m. The weekend buffet is $16 per person. The buffet is a great value considering the quality and variety of the food. Overall, we really enjoyed our meal and will definitely be back!

    I really enjoyed the buffet. Lots of variety and the food was fresh. The staff were very pleasant…read more I've also ordered of the menu and got lamb dish. There was really few prices of meat, I was a bit disappointed because the flavor was great.

    Photos
    Nice dining room at the back
    Nice dining room at the back
    Butter Chicken Special
    Butter Chicken Special
    Decor

    See all

    Decor
    Moon India Restaurant

    Moon India Restaurant

    4.8
    (71 reviews)
    46.3 mi

    This is a new Indian restaurant near where I live. There have been other Indian restaurants at this…read morelocation and next door to it, but this isn't them. If you are reading reviews, ignore older ones as they may apply to an earlier restaurant. I ordered take-out using an online app. Ordering was easy and the food was ready when I arrived. We started with the appetizer platter. Some were better than others, but the point of getting the platter was to see what we liked best. We shared a lamb with chickpea dinner and liked it very much. It came with rice and bread and 3 small portions of toppings. I also ordered the raita and a second kind of bread. One bread would have sufficed. We had a little of everything left over for lunch another day. We'll order from here again.

    I had dinner here with a friend on a weekday night and it was pretty quiet, but a few other tables…read morewere filled. The menu had a lot of variety including some dishes I hadn't seen elsewhere. I decided to try something new and ordered the Saag Bhartha which is eggplant in the familiar spinach sauce. The eggplant is cooked down so the dish is creamy and rich; it was very flavorful and a spice level of 3 was perfect for me. It had some heat but didn't result in a burning mouth. The garlic naan was delicious and the basmati rice that came with the entree was perfectly cooked. The serving size was very generous and I enjoyed the leftovers for dinner the next night. I definitely want to try more items on their menu and see some takeout orders in my future. Service was good, and the atmosphere was quiet and perfect for catching up with a friend.

    Photos
    Moon India Restaurant
    Garlic Nan
    Garlic Nan
    Garlic naan

    See all

    Garlic naan

    Sitara Indian Restaurant - indpak - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...