Oyster and Shrimp Po' Boys are to die for ... Hurry the…read moreOyster Po' Boy sells out fast! Clam Chowder delights every sensation of the taste pallets!

I had such high hopes for this place a seafood market in Indianapolis? Yes please. As someone who…read moregrew up in Florida, I am always on the hunt for anything that scratches that coastal seafood itch, so I was genuinely excited to try it. We ordered the lobster hoagie and hush puppies. Both were... fine. Not bad, but nothing that wowed us or justified the anticipation. The flavors were there in a basic sense, but it all felt a little underwhelming for a spot that's billing itself as a seafood destination. What really got me was the market side of things. The seafood on display just looked sad not fresh, not vibrant, not the kind of stuff that makes you want to throw something in a bag and take it home to cook. I fully understand we're landlocked in Indiana and truly fresh seafood is a challenge, but if that's your entire concept, the product has to be able to hold its own. Left feeling more disappointed than anything. I so wanted to love this place and will be rooting for them to level up but for now, this Florida girl will keep searching.

The Fountain Room is expensive, but it's excellent. It's part of the old Coke bottleworks building…read moreand the design of the restaurant is exquisite. I laughed though because the bar was playing The Muppet Show on the TV. lol The dinner menu is expensive so I went for brunch. (I believe their brunch is from 10am-2pm on Saturday and Sunday.) I ordered brisket hash (crispy potatoes, cheddar cheese, braised brisket, chimichurri, eggs, toast) and it was outstanding, although expensive at $24. My server was wonderful - just a delightful soul. The customers at the table next to me ordered chicken and waffles and their food looked amazing.

Service was good here, although this place is definitely on the pricier side, even for lunch. We…read morewere told that without reservations there wouldn't be a table available until 9pm, so we decided to eat at the bar instead. Thankfully, there was an opening for us. The bar area itself was really nice with an elegant ambiance, comfy swivel bar seats, and a more upscale vibe. I also have to mention the restroom because it was impressive. Very clean with thoughtful extras like complimentary mouthwash, tampons, and a vanity area. Small touches like that stand out to me. I ordered the fried chicken with mashed potatoes and it was delicious. I would absolutely order it again. My husband got the meatloaf with mashed potatoes and broccolini. He said the meatloaf was okay but not the best he's ever had. I tried the broccolini though and really liked it. For drinks, I had the Wildfire Smash cocktail which I thought was good and my husband had the espresso martini, and he said it was decent. We enjoyed our experience at the bar and appreciated the friendly service. I'd definitely like to come back and experience a full dinner here sometime, noting that it's probably best to have reservations.

As always food is great. Was craving fish n chips and it was satisfied! Takes a while because it's…read morecooked to order. It's not sitting under a heat lamp waiting to be plated. Staff is always so nice. We even got some prepared crab cakes to cook at home, can't wait to see how those are! Ooh maybe I'll make crab cakes Benedict mmmm We got there before the dinner rush so had a pick of tables which were all clean!

The Great Lakes perch was too "fishy" tasting. The pieces of fish were very small. The sides (mac'n…read morecheese, yams, buffalo Fries) were perfunctory. Yams were out of a can, no coleslaw was available. Mac 'n cheese was like Velveta... The coconut shrimp was good. We won't be back.

Good Lawd this place is ahmazing.. no kidding. Dont cook , let Tiff do it. It's stupid goodread more

Great spot for some seasoned seafood!! The butter was phenomenal and the shrimp and crab legs were…read moregreat!

Situated on an unassuming block and in an unassuming building, you'd never know the amazing flavors…read moreyou'll find at Magdalena! After being recommended, we decided to visit on a Thusday evening. We were immediately greeted and seated as there were only a few other people in the restaurant. Our server, Shannon, was delightful! We decided on the crawfish Monica, the collard greens dish, and the waygu dish! I would go back just for the crawfish! Perfect amount of everything that I will dream about. I have read about different theme nights so we will definitely be back!

We dined here for a taste of Creole cuisine while staying in Indy last weekend. Upon entry the…read morebubbly hostess greeted us and sat us at our table, gave us an overview of the menu and specials, and our server shortly followed to take drink & apps orders. The restaurant has an intimate setting with beautiful soft tunes coming from the retro speakers. The staff are very friendly, drinks potent, and the food was divine! We appreciated the owner introducing himself and assuring us that they could make an order of chargrilled oysters. They were delicious!! We hope to visit again soon the next time we are in the city and catch an Uber to enjoy happy hour!

We came here for the first time and tried an 8 lb seafood boil. Wow!!!! It was delicious. They have…read moredifferent sauces we did the combination with had the right amount of spice.. At first we thought there is no way we could eat the entire two pans butt we did. My daughter chose here for her birthday dinner. They came out and sang and gave her a complimentary piece of cheese cake. This will be her birthday go to place from no on. They have paper towel on the table and give you a bin. Next to the soda dispenser is a large sink which is nice and easy to access since is messy even with the gloves. If you want good seafood this I the place on the Westside.

I decided to get carryout from the Ugly Crab because it was conveniently located on Rockville Road…read more I was in the mood for fish and thought it might be similar to another crab place I often visit, but it turned out to be different. The patrons in line spoke highly of the restaurant, which makes me want to return and enjoy a crab or shrimp boil. I will definitely give them another try. Check it out!

Food is hot and fresh. I love the Caplinger's Fish…read moresandwich Special. So good!! Food is prepared after you order, so it seems slow at times, food is Perfect. This is not a fast food place. The fish is worth the wait!!!

I haven't had a lobster roll since Caplingers closed the location north of Zionsville. I wanted a…read morelobster roll today so I drove over to the east side. This location is 1/4 or smaller the size the one was up north. It really could use a facelift and a deep cleaning of the floors and walls. They were busy since I arrived toward the end of lunch time. Sorry to say staff not overly welcoming or friendly. I ordered and waited. The Pepsi machine was out of co2 so I opted for tea. I was happy they had sweet and non sweet tea available. Got my Lobster Roll, it looked nothing like what I've got in the past. Much much more filler than lobster. Tasted like a mass produced lobster salad. Fries were ok, not waffle fries but crinkle cut chips. Over all just kinda disappointed. Just didn't have the same flavor I came to expect from Caplingers and a 30$ meal.

Ask for Brandin to be your server if possible…read more The food here is good. Everyone knows this. But Brandin is on another level when it comes to service. He treats you like you are family.

Okay so this review is solely based on a sample bite I got to try at Rev. it was a tuna dish and I…read morewent back for seconds. It was so good!!! And the staff working the event were super friendly. It very much made me want to come into the restaurant and try it out. Fingers crossed that happened sooner rather than later!