Slice of 48

The absolute STAR of our party!! We had the Nice Buns food…read moretruck at our home for a graduation party last Saturday night and our friends and family are still talking about it!!! Jamie is an absolute gem ...as is her husband!! The hardest part was picking from the tremendous list of former sliders. We narrowed it down to 5 and one was better than the next. Truffle fries were a big hit too.

Don't miss the food from Slammin Sliders if you get the chance. I'm very picky about food and…read moredon't eat meat or chicken. I had the Tuna sliders and they were outrageously good! These are not sliders in mini buns but came on 2 regular size buns. Great value as well as great quality.

Menu

Great truck food at Hallockville fiber and fleece festival

See all

Chicken Sliders

The North Fork Shack

4.1(131 reviews)

1.1 mi

Cheap and cheerful. This local spot is a gem. The menu…read moreoffers plenty of variety, no matter what you're in the mood for, and the drink selections are just as impressive. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and reasonably priced. I'll definitely be back to try more of the menu.

I had just gotten off the orient point ferry and was starving. I had a burrata and tomato sandwich…read morewith shallot dusted fries. It was delicious. The fries were wonderful. Will say I got a container of cole slaw and was not a fan. Would highly recommend

Spring Rolls

See all

Crab Cakes

Ellen’s on Front

4.4(183 reviews)

4.0 mi

Our family loves Ellen's! The food is creative and delicious. One of our favorites on the North…read moreFork!

So we wanted to give Ellen's a shot as they kept showing up as a recommended restaurant in GPO (we…read morelive in GPO every summer). We looked at the menu ahead of time and were excited by the pea salad with watermelon radish and the calamari with cherry peppers. Unfortunately the salad came out with regular radish (big difference from watermelon radish). Just tell us ahead of time and we'd change our order - they said after the fact that they are out of the watermelon radish (the toasted corn was also soggy - seemed bagged or made from frozen). The calamari was good but was missing the cherry peppers - instead they had what seemed like jarred banana peppers instead. Again, not what was on the menu. I guess we were just disappointed when we were changed $22 for each appetizer that wasn't what was described on the menu. This kind of stuff is just lazy to me - it's not hard to serve what's described on your menu and if something ran out, tell us - we'd change our order. I think we'll take a pause on Ellen's for now. I hope this is read and these easy small changes are made as we'd love to come back for what's described on the menu. Positive notes - appreciated the ambiance and the service was proficient, no issues with our server.

Their delicious friend chicken.

See all

Andy's

3.9(197 reviews)

4.0 mi

Nice restaurant in the heart of Greenport, food was good, service was quick, overall good…read moreexperience.

We had a great meal here- so family friendly with quick service. We ordered the crispy chicken…read moresandwich, chicken paillard salad and chicken tenders for my daughter. The vibe is casual and chill, and they have an outdoor seating option. Would recommend to others.

The bar

Dry burger

See all

Haywire Burger Bar

3.8(422 reviews)

14.3 mi

Very brown restaurant, but it works. Brown booths, brown tables, brown bar. The restroom (I don't…read morebelieve is brown) is in the back. Fries were fries, but the burger was well seasoned and cooked to temperature. The brussel sprouts app were well cooked without being burnt. Nice comfort meal overall, and they were very understanding with letting my party sit and chat after eating.

Their burgers would be amazingly awesome if they did something about the bun…read more Bun is not supposed to be cold sweetie learn how to warm it up. It tasted stale. That said the meat was flavored to perfection.

Taps

Steak bomb.

See all

Sag Harbor Tavern

2.8(57 reviews)

8.7 mi

I saw pics of the deviled eggs on Instagram and had to check out this restaurant and they did not…read moredisappoint! We had deviled eggs and oysters and it was a perfect lunch. Can't wait to go back !

We came as a group of seven, and they split us between two tables, saying there weren't any other…read moreseats available. However, the table right next to us remained empty for almost the entire time we were there. They could have easily accommodated our group but chose not to. The place also looks old and could use a good cleaning. The staff weren't wearing consistent uniforms, which added to the overall impression. Unfortunately, the food wasn't good either. The only positives from our experience were the location and the lady who helped us, who was very nice and friendly.

Cheeseburger as art

See all

Grilled prawns

First and South

3.7(323 reviews)

4.0 mi

•$$$

A wonderful dinner tonight. Front of the house was very organized and friendly. My favorite…read morerecurring special is the seared flute with couscous. Very nice. The lobster and shrimp sliders were delicious too. We didn't have an appetizer or desert tonight, but we each had a drink and an entree, and our total bill was just a tad over $100. We'll be back soon.

Best food outside of Brooklyn. I look forward to eating here whenever we visit Greenport. The staff…read moreare super nice, every thing is super clean, and you won't find a bad dish on the menu. Even my incredibly picky 7 year old adores the food here.

Moo!

See all

Watermelon margarita and Moscow Mule

Local Burger - Southampton

4.1(23 reviews)

12.4 mi

Stopped by Local Burger in Southampton with the family after a trip to the Montauk Lighthouse. The…read morefood was delicious. My nephew had the kids cheeseburger meal and a milkshake. I had my reliable grilled chicken without a bun. The hangover burgers were delicious per the rest of the party. There is a golf course on the premises that I want to come back for so my nephew can experience it. It was too chilly and rainy to try it today. The ambience and service were great.

Awesome golf amenities, but the head cook likes to save parking space for his friends I guess, with…read moreconstruction cones he keeps in his trunk. Ooh and don't try to move it! He'll give you the finger wag!

Cones

See all

The Halyard Greenport

3.3(296 reviews)

2.2 mi

•$$$

Beautiful view, friendly service and an excellent menu…read more Went for my birthday dinner. I had the Skate Shnitzel. Brilliant idea perfectly executed. My wife had the pasta, which was excellent. We skipped starters and ordered ALL of the side dishes. The sides stole the show. Every one, including the fries, could have severed as an entree for my vegetarian wife. (though I think there may be animal fat involved in cooking the fries. Dont tell her!) Definitely not the dreary, average place we remembered from years ago. The Halyard is a new instant favorite.

I go to Greenport every summer and this is officially a "must" going forward. Let me preface this…read morewith - I never stayed at the hotel but I did attend a summer ball there in 2023. Unfortunately, the 2025 ball was canceled but I was able to get a dining experience at the restaurant here. I loved the sunset views and the awesome service we received. The place is beautiful and the food is also delicious and very light. I would definitely recommend giving it a go. I tried various appetizers and entries, my favorites were fish and the fruit salad. A good mention is the cheese cake, which was very flavorful. One star off for small portions but it was perfect for our girl group. Definitely a Greenport staple.

The dining room - 10/14/2024

Kale Salad

See all

Gorgeous sunsets - 10/14/2024

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jilian D.

26

1

0

9 years ago

Great local Italian food & pizza. Favorite crust is with the sesame seeds. Margarita pie with the garlic knot crust is such a guilty pleasure. read more

Mark M.

0

4

10

3 years ago

Ordered pizza meatball and onion , avg at best and wings . Wings were disgusting and blue cheese dressing was spoiled . Won't go back !

Philip J.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Stoped there with some family and ordered a few pies. Best buffalo pizza i have ever had in my life. A very friendly atmosphere.

Alex G.

90

2

0

9 years ago

I got delivery tonight and the service was fast and product delicious! I will definitely recommend Pagano's to someone else.

Denise G.

6

99

5

8 years ago

Delivery to Greenport - everything was delicious! A little long wait but it was worth it. Thanks!!

Alexandrea P.

0

1

7

9 years ago

Best pizza in town! They have awesome specials every week, and the delivery in phenomenal

Kim R.

0

1

0

9 years ago

"THE" Best Pizza!!! Friendly and curtious, excellent service, consistent quality!!! read more

Slice of 48 - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Slice of 48 also viewed

1943 Pizza Bar

4.3

(269 reviews)

Really cool pizza spot tucked away off the main strip in Greenport. Its warm and inviting…read moreatmosphere with the brick oven is probably the best pizza spot in town! I would've loved to stay for dine-in but had to bring lunch back to our Airbnb. The pizza only took a few minutes to cook. And it was up there in delicious-ness with some of the best NYC pizza! Perfectly thin, crispy crust without being dry, overcooked or burnt. The cheese and sauce had perfect balance of salt and tang, and not dry, not too greasy either. Toppings were fresh and just the right amount of toppings so it wasn't too heavy and not stingy either.

Pizzas are made fresh to order and was so delicious. Pizzas cook quick inside the huge oven! Nice,…read morethin pies, and they are made as a personal size pizza (14"). The crust still had the perfect ratio of dough making it fluffy, thin, and not crunchy. The white pie with the truffled ricotta and roasted mushrooms is a must try if you love anything truffle. It was loaded with flavors of garlic, mushrooms and the perfect amount of truffle. I'm so glad I ordered this pie! This will definitely be a spot we will visit again in the summer time. Inside is small, but they have additional seating outside.

Fiocha Pizza

4.9

(28 reviews)

Amazing best pizza on the north fork…read more Best Diablo pizza in New York Best fungi pizza in New York Best arugula pizza in New York

Fiocha Pizza located on the North Fork of Long Island, is a nice place but geared mostly for take…read moreout. The pizza is made in a wood fired oven and it's exceptional. We went with a pepperoni and a funghi pie, both delicious. The service was great as well. The pie maker doubled as the waiter. The ambiance is bare because it's mostly geared for takeout orders. I believe the the pizzeria is affiliated with Paumonock Vineyards.

Roadhouse Brick Oven Pizza

3.4

(212 reviews)

I found this place on Apple Maps after searching for pizzerias and decided to give it a try. I…read morenormally do not come out to Riverhead and unfortunately had jury duty. The parking lot entrance is convenient to enter on a a somewhat busy road and there is enough ample spaces. The building however is quite small itself. When I entered, I walked into a well-decorated establishment with nostalgic decor and nice loft area with seating. I ordered a regular slice, two garlic knots, and a soda after being helped by a pair of very friendly staff. In total, it cost me about $8.50. The pizza was actually very good. It was perfect, tasteful and had consistency with cheese and sauce. The garlic knots were good but nothing to rave about. The inside was a little dry. Overall, I enjoyed my pizza and will come back for a specialty slice.

Never again. I never cared for this place too much growing up and I can't even less for it now…read more You're better off picking up a frozen pizza at the grocery store.. Very bready pizza, unremarkable sauce. Can't be bothered to throw in a side of marinara sauce with their garlic knots. Their pizza and their heroes are just slopped with a tasteless mozzarella. Meatball hero? Was there any meat in their at all? Consistency tasted of mostly bread crumbs. No thanks. 6 knots, meatball hero, chicken Parm hero, regular pie, half pepperoni $62 Really nice staff though and great parking.

The Pizza Place

3.5

(34 reviews)

Warning. Big change…read moreafter new owners took over the once reliable Pizza Place three years ago. One of the slices smelled way too fishy too eat for a calamari slice. Brought in to let them know. The som of the owner hid sheepishly by the ovens and .the manager came over to tell me he wouldn't exchange. They took it and Threw it out but no exchange or refund. Be warned. Food service requires trust that management will keep things fresh and stand behind their foos. Not here. Not meant to be in food service. Pies LOOKED good but Calamari was clearly not fresh and come to think of it the cheese seemed a little too white like some melting spread. There were lots of refrigerated rolls not selling but kept in the case. Pies were moving and tasted ok but would NOT return.

This place has a pizza oven but it is not pizza they are serving. Not even close and not good at…read moreall. I stopped here on my way out east for a slice and received an extremely hot slice of poorly prepared, cheap ingredients with an over abundance of flour. I had asked that the slices be just warmed, so my young daughter could eat it and the man nodded, and sent out these boiling hot slices. Also, I did not feel welcome here at all. I received no smiles from anyone, no hello, no goodbye or even a thank you for coming. Not recommended.

Wading River Pizzeria

3.3

(79 reviews)

I love this restaurant! I've been meeting up with my friends for months, their pizza is good,…read morecustomer service, and I love the vibe!

I ordered online for a pick up at a specific time. I happened to get there a little early & they…read moredidn't even start heating up the order until a little after I arrived. It was not ready for the pick up time, to say the least. No cutlery and plates included even though I asked for it in the initial order and when I first entered the store. The pizza was ok, a little heavily seasoned but that's much better than when it is under seasoned. I got a plain cheese and a pepperoni. The crust was crispy and crunchy from the cornmeal on the bottom. Garlic knots were good, not too doughy.

Francesca's

3.2

(222 reviews)

I've been coming to Francescas for years. The pizza and everything on their menu is always…read moredelicious and consistent. The staff always greets you with a smile and works hard to get everyone there orders as fast as possible. Oh...... they have homemade ice cream as well!

I came here to pickup food since one of my friend's friend lives close by and I have to say, I was…read morehappy with my meal except for one dish. It was a typical Italian American restaurant with all the classics. The food: Penna A la Vodka with Sausage- This was highlight of the meal, I thought the version here was excellent. The sauce was great, the sausage was a nice addition and the penne paired perfectly. This is a must order. Eggplant Parmesan- This was made well with a nice tomato sauce. The sauce has a bit of sweetness but wasn't over the top sweet. I would get this again. Lasagna- The lasagna was good, the sauce was nice, overall flavor was solid. Chicken Piccata- This was the only dish I didn't care for, while the flavor on the dish was fine, the chicken breast was cooked to death. Also, the artichoke heart they are using for the dish, they need to take out one outer layer because it makes the hear fibrous and chewy. Garlic Knots- I enjoyed the flavor on these but they were oddly a little too airy for me, I like my garlic knots to be crispy on the outside and have a nice chew on the inside.

La Bistro

4.4

(150 reviews)

The best service and food everyone is so nice an generous 100000% recommend anyone to come and eat…read morehere best pizza of Long Island ny

Good service, great pies...and a lot of them. While a big fan of traditional pepperoni pizza, the…read morebbq chicken pizza was my favorite! Dining area small but clean and comfortable!

Michelangelo Pizzeria

3.0

(101 reviews)

had a very nice waiter. I ordered a blackberry margarita and it was delicious. Food came out at a…read moregood time and was also very delicious. Very nice of them to box the food also for leftovers. Highly recommend this place. very nice inside too!

This place is a model of disorganization, and I will surely never return.. It's not hard to handle…read moresix customers, in the span of 5 minutes but somehow these people find a way to make it is difficult as they can.

Sergio's Pizza

3.6

(37 reviews)