Slice Shack by Mary's in Sonoma, CA. If you find yourself near Sonoma Plaza and hankering for something to eat and not quite wanting a full sit down meal. Then check out the Slice Shack. It's walk up counter service with limited indoor seating. They have whole pizza pies and build your own pizza slices starting at $5-$6.50, they even have gluten free option of cauliflower crust. Other menu options are breadsticks, hot dog in a blanket, salads including Mary's signature, and meatballs. Get a solo meatball $4.75 and meatball & bread bowl $8.50. The concept of a custom slice is unique, not alot of places offer that. I luv their pizza. It's so oven baked with nice crust... not thin or thick. The Mary's signature salad is delicious. The place gets crowded. Jam packed. The wait isn't too long. If you are inclined to sit a spell and desire wait service, Mary's Pizza Shack restaurant is right next door. read more

I visited Mary's Pizza Shack while in town for a wine tour. I came with a very large group of friends. We had varied experiences but I will start with my own. I like to choose food options that I don't typically see other places. I ordered a seasonal item--the eggplant and artichoke sandwich. It was absolutely delicious! The bread was wonderful, the artichokes were big, the sauce was perfectly spicy and the crispy eggplant was very good. I ordered mine with a Cesar salad & I lovvvved the croutons. I wonder if they were made from the same focaccia as the sandwich. I would definitely recommend the place. My friends ordered pizza and said it was ok and someone else ordered the spaghetti with meatballs and said it tasted like it came out of a can. I still recommend the place! read more

This pizza pretty much sucks. When you have a beautiful big Pizza oven you really don't have an excuse to not make great pizzas. When I come in here, there's rarely fresh pizza on display. My last visit I was told a fresh one was coming out so I waited. Ordered and paid for it, but then when it was given to me, I noticed it really wasn't cooked enough. I didn't have the energy to deal with it. read more

Slice Shack By Mary’s - $8 for this measly undercooked slice. Not great. - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

Food, service *and* ambiance! You get it all in this little hole-in-the-wall pizzeria with super yummy slices. I'm quite pizza-picky and this has definitely had me return (& I even got a whole pie to go @next door)! In the heart of Sonoma Square where you can take your slices or pie and sit across the street in the park/Square and enjoy your day. Or people watch ;) I highly recommend!! read more

Great little spot for lunch and a quick glass of wine. Prices are reasonable. Ordering is quick and courteous. In downtown Sonoma Food has taken awhile (25 mins)to get a slice of cheese pizza & meatball sandwich- Hubby like the sandwich & the slice was delicious - surprisingly sauce was tasty Bathrooms are on the older side but have soap and towels for cleanliness read more

See all

Love Mary's salad. You have to know what to order. Some things are better than others. Linguini with clam sauce. Or chicken sandwich is great! read more

Stopped in during our tour of Sonoma downtown and the place was fantastic. Pizza was delicious. Staff were friendly. And the wine was excellent. What else do u need? Haha. Enjoy. read more

See all

I go here often . Usually pretty good . Yesterday was not good . They changed the pepperoni, not for the better . It resembles Costco pizza which would be fine if they charged two bucks but for seven dollars it's not good ... please go back to what you were doing before. read more

Never been disappointed by this little off-shoot of Mary's! They have my favorite things all within minutes, breadsticks, Mary's famous salad and pizza. If you aren't wanting a longer sit down meal, check this place out! Options include taking lunch/dinner to the park and enjoying it at the picnic tables or sitting on one of the three seats indoors. No matter where you have your food from slice shack, I can guarantee it will be good! read more

Slice Shack is a quick and affordable spot for a quick slice! They have all the basics and some more intricate pairings! I got one with artichoke hearts in it and it was delicious! They are doing pizza the right way here! read more

See all

After a few stops on a wine tasting tour around Downtown Sonoma, we needed a quick bite to eat prior to continuing the wonderful wine afternoon - And we stumbled upon Slice Shack By Mary's - The perfect mid-wine meal! I've never really been a huge pizza person but lately, that's been changing and I've been wanting pizza all the time - And Slice Shack By Mary's sure did hit the spot! Located right in the Sonoma Plaza, it is the ultimate location whether you are doing a day of shopping or wine tasting - This is a perfect break for a no-frills but delicious lunch! Since it's located in the Plaza, there is plenty of parking available as spots are located all around the square as well as the surrounding streets - and it's all complimentary parking! The team here is wonderful! They are super friendly, patient while folks are deciding on their pizza toppings and they were amazing while monitoring the amount of people in the shop while ordering and maintaining the proper social distancing protocol - Bravo! This made us feel so comfortable dining here. There are a handful of tables outside {as when we came it was outdoor seating only in CA} - It seemed like most folks were taking theirs to-go. If you are dining outdoors there may be a bit of a wait but tables are cleaned between guests and properly spaced apart. Onto the good stuff! The menu is vast so you are sure to find something to satisfy your tastebuds - Meatballs, Soups, Salads, Breadsticks, a Hotdog in a Blanket, Pizza as well as Desserts. We were here for the pizza - What's better with an afternoon of wine?! Nothing! You can order whole pies, signature slices as well as build you own pie/slice - Score! My husband went with the Hawaiian Luau Slice - Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Signature Pizza Sauce and Mozzarella and loved every bite! What are your thoughts - Do you like Pineapple on pizza?? We sure do! Me.. I'm a sucker for creating a slice depending on exactly what I'm feeling at the moment. When you are building your own slice, you have a plethora of options: Cheese only, Grilled Chicken, Salami, Italian Sausage, Meatballs, Bell Peppers, Onions, Jalapeños, Tomato, Olives..and so much more.. pretty much anything you can think of!! My go-to when building my own slice is typically Sausage, Mushrooms and Onions {with added Chili Flakes, of course}! And if I'm feeling saucy, I'll ask for a little dipping sauce - Ranch dressing {but only for the crust}. Do you like Ranch on your pizza?? We will be headed back to Sonoma in a few weeks for our annual Anniversary Wine Weekend and I can't wait to grab a slice - I am already thinking about what I'm going to get! If you are building your perfect slice.. What would you put on it? read more

See all

Perfect spot for a grab and go slice in Sonoma. After perusing through the historical downtown area, we were craving a little snack and followed our noses to Mary's Pizza Shack. Even better, next door to it was their to-go slice spot, or "Slice Shack." Ambiance was small but cozy, there were about 3-4 pizza flavors at the front. The one with the meat and mushrooms caught our eye. We decide to order one and the cashier offered to cut it in half for us. Waited for about 5-8 min for them to toast up the slice in their oven and when it came it looked freshly baked. Crisp crust, flavorful and fresh toppings, not too saucy. Polished it off in a few minutes. I was tempted to get another one, but I i held off- it was just a snack after all. Next time, I'll try the restaurant so I can sample more of the entrees. read more

Slice Shack By Mary’s - They split the big slice in two for us - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

See all

Pizza - 4.0 stars - Luau Hawaiian Slice - $5.50 and good! My husband got the Italian Hawaiian slice and he was happy with it too. Hits the spot after wine tasting very big slices. Honestly I wish they heated mine through just a tad bit more, but it was fine (it was just kinda warm). Seating - 3 stars - I would say don't count there on being seating at this place. There are 5 seats inside and two seats outside. It should be called a carry out or just at least expect to stand outside. Good service and they were friendly. Fast, cheap, easy! read more

Slice Shack By Mary’s - Outside of slice shack - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

The food was pretty good although I have 2 gripes. First of all, my boyfriend and I entered the building and went up to the front counter and he wanted to know if they had any pizzas coming out of the oven considering they were looking a bit bare. The baldish 50-something man at the counter replied with an annoyed almost offended look and paused (it's a simple question it could receive a simple response) and said um no this is the pizzas we have. The question being asked is if they had any pizzas currently cooking, not new flavors or styles of pizza or anything. Pretty weird to confuse this simple question. Anyways, he lacked any decent customer service skills which was quite unpleasant. The food was pretty good the other gripe I had is the music. I mean this is pretty minor but it's just a suggestion to maybe choose a better music selection. Maybe that's why the cook man was feeling sour. read more

Pizza was okay. It's by the slice so that means you order which ever slice you want from the ones already made and they place it back in the oven to heat up. Staff consisted of two young teenage boys and while we were eating inside, the manager from the main restaurant came over and started scolding the boys. He's tired of this and that and this needed to be done and all that... unprofessional to do that scolding while customers are in the lobby within hearing distance but whatever. read more

Slice Shack By Mary’s - Big slice of pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

Don't expect the best pizza you've ever had, because not happening. It's thick crusted doughy pizza and priced at $5-$5.50/slice, they're actually only slightly over priced, since they're huge slices. I couldn't even finish two slices and I was beyond full and I can eat pizza. This is the take out version of the sister restaurant. They do have a few tables and a few window bar seats, but for the most part, you're taking this to go. And heads up, their online menu is outdated. They do full pies. They don't have the whole caesar salad with chicken. Let's get the negative out of the way: the young dude taking my phone order and then was at the front at the cash register just wasn't helpful. He mixed up my phone order, I ordered 8 slices since their online menu didn't show full pies. He could have told me: "why don't you order a full pie?" instead of charging me for 8 individual slices. We arrived and I saw that, and thank heavens the manager ok'd it, we ended up saving $20. He quoted us 10 minutes, it was close to 30. Granted, we were talking to the manager about the mix-up, but still. He was not the most customer service oriented as we were waiting for our food. I don't blame him, since he looked all of 16, but he needs some customer facing training, for sure. The pizza was solid. If this was in the Bay or anywhere else I'd put it at 3 stars, but for Sonoma it did the trick. They make cheese pizza and then just add the toppings after. If I knew that, I wouldn't have ordered onions (which were huge cuts, so don't order onions). The meatball topping was sad. While we ordered the actual meatball which was delicious. The side caesar was just romaine with a hard boiled egg. Where was the chicken, croutons that the menu told us about? The dressing was good and the salad was fresh, so there's that. Overall, it's pizza. It's good. It's easy. Would I go out of my way for it? No. Would I eat it again if I was in downtown Sonoma and needed pizza to go? Yes. read more

Pizza was fine. Not especially great, but not bad. The server could not possibly have been less interested in helping us. Literally acted like our mere presence was a massive inconvenience. If you want it be treated like a serf for spending your money at a local establishment, be my guest and bring your money here. All others should look elsewhere. read more

Slow Slow Slow! 30 minutes of waiting just for a menu. No one even acknowledged us. Once we did get our food. I did love my food read more

I'm so glad I found this place! After experiencing really bad service at The Swiss Hotel, I dropped in here for some pizza and a meatball. Alex was super helpful and really went out of his way to make sure I had everything I wanted! read more

Slice Shack By Mary’s - Inside the Pizza By The Slice portion of the business. - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

See all

The food was good. The ambiance was chill. The service was nice. I would definitely go back if I'm in the area.

It hides behind the pizza shack by Mary nextdoor. Cute little pizzeria. Really good pizza, fresh ingredients. Service was pretty fast. The person at the counter looked overworked but was generous with sachets of chili flakes and Parmesan cheese. Definitely enjoyed the pizza! read more

Grab a slice to go and have a mini picnic in the park. Sonoma's town square could be shaped like a heart with the feeling it gives. Mary's Pizza Shack has aways been quality pizza in Sonoma and remember it from growing up and living in the neighborhood. The new slice shack is easy and convienant, get a few slices or a whole pizza to enjoy in the square. We ordered two slices, got them cut in half since they were large and took them to go. We ordered them a little crispy, so they came extra toasted. They were really good, dare I say that the artichoke pizza was better then the meat pizza? OMG, I loved it. read more

See all

By far the best pizza I have had . Great pizza would give 10 stars but sadly only 5 are given !

Pizza was delicious, however, guy working as I'm posting this was a total jerk. Very rude.

Slice Shack by Mary's is in a cute spot right off the center of the park in Sonoma. The service was friendly and the restaurant was very clean. I asked for a slice of the Mary's special which is basically a meat lover's dream for $5.50. (Salami, pepperoni, cotto salami, mushrooms, Italian sausage, mozzarella, pizza sauce.) We also ordered a slice of the pepperoni pizza which was available in slices at the counter. The slices themselves are quite large and the value is good for the price! My slice was bland tasting which surprised me considering how much meat was on it! The crust had a heavy taste of flour and there wasn't much sauce. I guess it did the job and that's about it. I'm still full 2 hours later. read more

See all

The meatball in a breadbowl awesome. It's a monster size but manages to not be dry in the middle. Sauce surprised me - not sweet, not too acidic, and overall great flavor. I don't think I could bring myself to eat pizza in California but if I came back I might try it on the strength of the sauce. Three teenagers were running the shop when I came in about 5pm on a Thursday, and one was training the other two. They had everything under control from my point of view. read more

Amazing service and amazing food! A freshly heated, crispy, phenomenal slice of classic pepperoni pizza. Joshua helped us, and was absolutely AMAZING (needs a raise or promotion). He was so hospitable and nice. Such a great experience after some wine tasting. Quick service, great food, 5 stars! read more

Quick & tasty - Great grab and go to take into the Plaza Park for a family picnic! Also serving Soft Serve ice cream which was a bonus treat for the family! read more

Although I had been inundated With Tom Tolbert commercials about the Shack on KNBR over the years, I never felt compelled to try it. He just never sounded very convincing and it really just seemed like a paid advertising situation. But I was dead wrong! I was very hungry after taking visitors on a day of wine tasting and so I decided to pop into Slice by Shack to get a slice of pizza. Man oh man, I'll tell you this, these people know how to make a good slice of cheese pizza! Absolutely classic - - perfect distribution of high quality cheese and sauce, incredible crunch, lovely aroma, and delicious, pleasing aftertaste. Forgive me, Tom Tolbert, for not believing you! I highly recommend this place, especially this location because I can't speak about the others. First rate pizza! If you like a classic slice, come here, no doubt! read more

I was at a bachelorette party weekend with 19 girls. I repeat. 19 girls I was in charge of making things go well (Of course) and after doing my bridesmaids duties for over 30 hours, your girl was starving. I needed carbs. We pulled up at a nearby winery and was told that they'll allow take out from surrounding joints to be eating along with our juice. Say no more, says I! I Yelp-ed the nearest slice and this was it. I ordered two slices and they were A-ok, as my Yelp rating suggests, good, but not exceptional. A star for sheer size though, as this were some of the biggest by the slice options I'd ever ordered. The price per slice makes sense when you see the amount you get. Temperature wise, mine was a bit on the lukewarm side, but I enjoyed it overall. Service was also backed up and slow. A note - they do make custom slices, so if you don't eat dairy or what to make your own that is possible with a bit more of a wait. read more

Mediocre pizza, charged for about 4 little crumbled pieces of sausage and iced tea served with no ice. So many better places to eat!

Had a slice of New York Pizza in Sonoma! Really enjoyed this slice. They even have gluten free options but it's personal size. I had the veggie pesto. Really good stuff. Cali rarely has good pizza imo but this was great! You can get pizza by the slice and a whole pie. ProTip; Picnic in the park across the street with your favorite beverage? Yes you can! read more

Slice Shack By Mary’s - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

Covid- open for takeout. First off, let me just say the staff was so so nice! We literally showed up 15min before closing time and they were extremely nice. The slices are huge and worth every penny. I customized mine with chicken, jalapeños, and pineapple, it was really good despite them just adding the topping to a pre cooked cheese slice. The pesto sticks are a MUST try as well. My friends got meatballs on the side with meat sauce and they all seemed to like it a lot. read more

The pizza is spectacular and there's enough craft beer to make a choice --but the guy who took our order was so depressed and unfriendly that I decided not to eat inside but take it to go. He brought the ambience of the whole place down to a dull gray. Either give the guy a raise to be happier or keep him away from customer service. Really. read more

Do yourself a favor and just skip this place. The pizza is wildly mediocre. The Hawaiian pizza should be called a just a ham pizza. Slice places should live and die by their cheese pizza and it really seems like they're not interested in it, it's not even on display. Price-wise, it's a good quantity of pizza but quality is sacrificed. I also don't know what they do differently to their pizza but when we got home my wife had an awful stomach ache and I ended up with food poisoning all night long. It was nice to see that the employees are local teenagers though. read more

After a day of wine tasting, we decided we wanted to have a quick dinner that was close by to the hotel we were staying on. As we were pretty full from wine and cheese platters, we felt a few slices of pizza would suffice. We arrived on Saturday in November around 7pm with no wait. This is an order at the counter then sit down type of place. The workers were very friendly and patient as we decided which pizza we would have. We both decided on Mary's as we enjoy meaty/combo type pizzas. One of ours came from a tray that was on display and the other came straight from the oven. They warmed the slices up for us which took just a few minutes. You could tell which one was fresher, but none the less it didn't affect us much. Overall it was a tasty, hearty pizza and we were satisfied. There are a few spots to sit inside (maybe 5?) and about 2 tables outdoors. Lucky for us, 2 people were leaving when our pizzas were ready to eat. This is a great place for a quick and simple meal! read more

I was playing at the park with my 10 day old and my 20 month old when I got really hungry, so I stopped in for a slice, the pizza was delicious but what really touched me was the customer service. Everyone who worked there was so sweet and inviting, asking me questions about my life and congratulating me on my baby. The food can be good at a lot of different places, but what can really mark a person is the kindness that they receive at an establishment. Whoever owns this pizza place should be very happy with the employees who were working on Saturday afternoon at 3:45 2/05/22 read more

Just finished having lunch with my friend. The food an service was very good. The only problem I have is this particular location, on downtown Sonoma does NOT SANITIZE the tables. They wipe it down with a wet towel. Not good!!!! read more

Went in this place with high hopes was disappointed with the food as it was not fresh and the Tall gentleman that I guess works in the morning who is very rude and unprofessional but besides that the food was just not good read more

Pros: -Family friendly. My toddler talked about building his own kids pizza for days after we came here. - Fantastic pizza (buffalo wings mediocre) -Fantastic Service. - Complimentary French bread. Cons: - Over priced pizza. I feel like I can get similar pizza at Mod pizza, or other wood fire quick type food places elsewhere for a fraction of the cost here. I couldn't believe a size small pizza with meat, a kids build your own pineapple and ham pizza, and wings with no drinks came to about $50. Overall, I'd recommend. It's yummy, but just know it's a bit pricey for what it is! read more