This place knows how to make a shake!! The ice cream is so good and so many flavors. Best ice cream on the island. I see why they have long lines. Delicious!! read more

This place was such a good stop after a long day at the beach. The ice cream was so creamy and they had a large selection of flavors. They also had vegan and sugar free options which was helpful for us. We also picked out some other candy's that they sell and those were also delicious! read more

We went after supper every evening. There is a wide variety of yummy ice cream choices. With Covid, you might after to wait outside to open up space for social distancing but the line moves along quickly. read more

One of the couple ice cream spots my family had tried out on AMI. A little bit expensive compared to other spots on the island but ice cream was great and the flavor selection was extensive. Cute spot to bring kids and their fudge and roasted nuts all looked great. Would definitely go back. read more

We tried 4 ice cream places in AMI/Bradenton and Small Town Creamery was by far the best in our opinion. The flavors are indulgent and authentic (you don't have that gacky artificial taste you get with some ice creams). We went twice, tried 6 flavors in total and were thoroughly impressed by all 6. It's worth the wait in line outside! read more

Enjoying a relaxing day at Anna Maria Island and came upon this little gem! It's a feast to the eyes with the beautiful colors....but let's get down to the nitty gritty! The icecream was amazing! So many flavors I didn't know which to have. I finally settled for Purple Daze and Butterscotch Bomb, but don't you worry if you want to try more they do have a cup that can serve 4 scoops! Delicious! But what made the experience even better was the staff. Very hospitable, sweet and PATIENT! I did sample a few flavors...lol! Highly recommend. read more

See all

Fantastic local ice cream joint - seems this and only few places stay open late (10pm), perfect place to go after dinner. A lot and lot of choice for ice cream! They had vegan and other choices. I loved my garbage can a lot. I'm usually not an ice cream kinda guy but I just had to try it after a long day in the sun! Located in small shopping plaza, lots of parking. Night time the line gets long here but moves fast. Owner is a nice dude! read more

So so yummy!! Staff was super helpful and kind. The inside of the store was clean and very cute. Will definitely be coming back!

Such a cute place with unique flavor offerings including Dairy Free and Vegan options. We will be going back to try more flavors for sure!

Great selection of flavors, must have had 25 plus flavors. Little pricey but your on vacation and it's was a after dinner treat. 2 dipped cone with 2 scoops was about 13$ read more

Good ice cream. Fun touristy place. Lacks cleanliness as far as seating goes. Cashier struggled but the person who helped us was super nice.

Fantastic ice cream. Huge selection. Great service! Perfect après-beach snack!!!!!

Oh MY! We went twice while on vacation. The tin roof was yummy. Carrot cake ice cream was INCREDIBLE!! We had several other flavors and none disappointed. We did have to wear our masks in and only a certain number were let inside but it was very quick. read more

best cookies and cream EVER!,Staff super friendly. great prices!! and a wide variety of flavors and options. Definitely be back again when in town read more

Went in today for the first time. The two people behind the counter were so friendly and helpful! Will definitely go back. Oh and the Chocolate cookie cheesecake ice cream was delicious. read more

Small Town Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

As I a fourteen year old I can I say I LOVED it, they had my favorite (kinda hard to find) flavor- bear claw and the place is filled with stuff to make a kid run around. The entrance has a large lego-like Ferris wheel which immediately drew me in with my family. The downside is that they had a pic of there mermaid milkshake which they no longer have (my little sis was excited) but otherwise it was AWESOME. read more

Cute little place on the island. Definitely worth the trek out here! Came here from brandenton and don't regret it at all! I completely recommend their purple daze I think it was called. It was black raspberry ice cream and it was AMAZING!! I really enjoyed it. Their homemade cones are more expensive than the bought ones but worth it. Yummy and better closed at the bottom so it doesn't drip on you. I also tasted their coffee ice cream. Very good. Didn't love their carrot cake ice cream but I'm sure someone would love it. And my mom enjoyed her strawberry ice cream. She said it wasn't artificial so it had good flavor. It's a cute little store with more than just ice cream. They have fudge and fun things like avengers toys for kids. read more

Cutest ice cream and sweet treat shop! Recommend popping in here for the nostalgic feel of candies and toys. And the staff is so sweet. read more

Small Town Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Loved how many flavors there were! So so yummy on a hot summer night. The also have no sugar added options as well.

Best ice cream on the island in my opinion! Great selection of flavors. Delicious shakes, malts, and floats, including a cold brew float which was ridiculously good. Very friendly staff. Clean bathroom. They have wine pops for sale in the freezer case and a small selection of candy and toys. Nice location with a very large parking lot. Several souvenir shops right around - within easy walking distance. Seating inside and a couple of benches outside. Just down the sidewalk is Sun and Surf, a cute clothing/beach/souvenir shop with several macaws in cages outside if you want some entertainment while you're eating. If you are going to hit ONE ice cream parlor on AMI make sure it's this one!! read more

Great Place for Ice Cream or Sweets! VERY friendly Crew, welcoming and Clean Interior. Tried different ice cream shops on the island but this one has authentic flavours and tastes very good! Kids wanna go back before we head home to Switzerland! read more

Very cool spot !! First of it's so cool when you walk in and see the ferris wheel on to the left (which was built by a 9-year old) extremely impressive. We were automatically greeted to try all kinds of fudge and it was impossible to make a decision (DELICIOUS!) the ice cream, there were so many choices and all delicious (we also got to sample any flavor) staff was super friendly! Fudge was delicious! And ice cream off the wall! Definitely recommend, will be back here every time we visit Anna Maria island read more

See all

Good ice cream! They don't make the ice cream in house but said a friend makes it. But they do make their fudge in house. You can't sample any flavors right now but did recommend what flavors would pair well together. My husband and I got different flavors of fudge and our favorite was the candy corn. Friendly customer service too. read more

Honestly amazing ice cream served up by the friendliest of people. I stopped in after dinner for a sweet treat with visiting family. Everyone was impressed and tickled both with the decor and service. But when we finally had our first bites, the talking stopped and silent, tasty joy set in. It was so good I even forgot to snap a picture of our actual ice cream! Highly recommend the toasted coconut and Kahlua flavors - but really you can't go wrong with any option. read more

See all

Best ice cream I have ever had. We live in West Virginia and we don't have to best ice cream where I live so it was really good we came back 2 times read more

Pretty good ice cream - clean store and friendly staff. However -- the ice cream flavors were EXTREMELY deceiving. They had around 10 vanilla ice cream "flavors" all just colored differently. For example, one was colored to look like super man ice cream and was just vanilla. We were fairly disappointed considering how expensive it was. The price point was very high for how little ice cream you receive. I would not recommend coming here unless there are no other options. read more

The ice cream here was amazing. I also lived the service provided by the staff. Certainly a must do after a day at the beach!

Great flavors. My favorite is birthday cake with bear claw. I nothing like staying one flavor and then moving to the second one Go next door for dinner then walk over for a dessert. read more

Soooo many ice cream flavors to choose from. Went here like 4/7 nights on our vacation. The employees work quickly to keep the line moving and they were all so kind and friendly. read more

Deserves 10Stars! High quality ice cream and candy with fresh made fudge to die for! Excellent friendly service with fantastic prices!!! A local hidden gem everyone should know! read more

I love love love this place! What an adorable shop. It was the cleanest ice cream store I have ever been to. The flavor selection was awesome, the staff was super friendly and knowledgeable - a great bunch of kids. All the nut ice creams are separated from the other ice cream flavors, which was super helpful for people with nut allergies. Their decor is incredibly fun and their photo booth was awesome! Now to the product - wow. My whole family was so happy with their ice cream. We will absolutely head back next time we visit AMI! read more

Great icecream and fudges. Great prices. Great staff. Glad we found this place, really needed cooling down.

BEST PLACE EVER !! we go every year and it's a must !! C is for cookie is the best flavor by far

Great ice cream! My boyfriend never finishes his ice cream cones because they can be too sweet but he got one here and it was gone in no time! Loved the atmosphere and the employees were so friendly! read more

I come to the same place in Florida every year and I've been to more ice cream shops that i can count. This one by far has the BEST ice cream! It's very thick and the flavor is so strong and sweet. The homemade waffle cone is amazing as well as the sherbet. The atmosphere is very cute and fun! The line was super long, but the employees kept it moving very fast. I will definitely be coming back here!! read more

Wonderful ice cream - awesome service! You can have so many tastings, owners are so kind- must go here

Pros: Clean, friendly staff, many ice cream options and other treats. Cons: Price point high for the amount of ice cream we received. I know we are on AMI, but it seemed the amount scooped for the small and medium were the same, but $1.50 more for the medium. Also, ingredients in ice cream on certain flavors ordered were sparse. read more

Great place to bring the family at the end of a hot beach day on AMI. Delicious ice cream and fudge with sugar free options available. Service was outstanding. we will be back read more

Small Town Creamery - Great place for the family to wrap up a hot beach day in AMI delicious ice cream and fudge, including sugar free options - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

I've tried the majority of the ice cream places on AMI and this is my new favorite. I tried the carrot cake which I didn't expect to like but it was delicious and somehow tasted just like carrot cake. We will definitely be back next time we visit the island! read more

This is the best ice cream place on Anna Maria Island hands down. Ice cream is extremely high quality and there are just a ton of really good flavors. Also great fudge and a bunch of toys and other goodies for the kids. read more

Small Town Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida