Pizza was great. Prices were outrageous. We've got 5 pizza places around me that are as good or much better (Mount Dora area) for less than half the cost. Seriously, 2 large pizzas and a salad, delivered 3 blocks from St Augies, was $110. Ridic. read more

Great Cheesy pizza and soft and flavorful garlic rolls. Service was great and it was very quiet

First day arrival of vacation in St Augustine referred to St Auggies as "the best pizza and pasta" in town made a pizza and pasta order $$ waited an hour which was fine and then received a text message stating they canceled it due to miscommunication... called Saint Auggies only to be told they were sorry, but it was canceled. The driver picked up the order and stated it was delivered. They have refunded us, but it is now 8 PM and that is the best they could do and they are still open until 9 PM, very disappointed quite unprofessional establishment. read more

New York style pizza in Florida? Sign me up! This was the perfect place to grab a quick lunch and stretch our legs after our 4.5 drive from south FL. We got 4 slices - cheese, pepperoni, mushroom and spinach ricotta. My favorites were the OG cheese and pepperoni. They were large, thin and cheesy. Felt like I was back in NYC. My boyfriend loved the mushroom pizza and the spinach ricotta was heavy with toppings. This is a typical pizza joint, nothing fancy. A couple tables, a couple essential menu items and that's it. But really, that's how it should be. We'd definitely come back if we're in the area again. read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Wanted to go somewhere a little less touristy and off the main St. Augustine circle... LOVED the pizza here!! Great service, price and quality.. little hole in the wall but has great great pizza! Definitely recommend read more

See all

The Grandma Style Pizza is amazing. Top 5 pizza in the country for me and I love pizza and have traveled extensively.

Excellent New York style thin crust pizza. The best NY pizza in the entire St. Augustine area. You have to drop by for a slice, If you like thin crust that you can fold as you bring it to your pie hole.. You will love this. read more

See all

Ordered three pizzas and salad's to go. Ingredients were very fresh. Pizza crust very good. Ordering was simple. Pizza prepared right on time. Give it a shot. You'll enjoy. read more

I have really been craving New York style pizza since moving to St Augustine, Fl. Unfortunately, this didn't quite scratch that itch. The search continues. read more

Friendly service but pizza was a bit pricey for the slim amount of toppings we got. Typical pizza joint...got the pizza to go.

jersey girl here!! since moving up to st aug we have tried a bunch of pizza restaurants and haven't found pizza even nearly as close as jersey pizza...until today! my mom and i were driving around doing errands and passed by this pizza place and figured why not give it try. wow!! definitely THE BEST pizza around st aug read more

Totally false advertising. NY Pizza! Absolutely not!! Probably the worst baked ziti I've ever had. Near to zero sauce. Dried, brown cheese. See attached pictures. I had the pizza and ziti delivered via Uber Eats. I specifically asked for extra sauce on both items since often delayed Italian tends to dry up a bit. Threw out the ziti after 3 bites. The pizza was edible but not any where near NY pizza. Shame on you! read more

See all

You order at the counter, then they will bring the food to you. Garlic knots were outstanding. I would rate the pizza a 4.5. Now the bad. My wife asked twice for soap and paper towels in the bathroom. Didn't happen. The guy that took our order had gloves on. He also handled door knobs and food with the same gloves. I think the gloves were to protect his hands, not the food. If this is corrected, we would go again. read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Don't sleep on this pizza...closest thing to NJ NY pizza..absolutely delicious...I asked for a white slice & he made it on the spot. Even brought back 2 slices for breakfast. Best hands down.you don't find alot of places that slice the sausage thin like that read more

See all

I've always loved their pinwheels. The veggie one is just stuffed with healthy greens. Their pizza & wings are great too but... today I picked up a veggie & a meat one. I didn't open box until I got home & unfortunately the m at pinwheel was really over cooked. As you can see the cheese oozed out of the bottom & is burnt. I'm surprised they gave it to me like this. I will still go back & order pinwheels but will definitely check them before leaving read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Pinwheel - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I just wanted to again say how delicious the food is here . We are formerly from NY so we are somewhat of a snob when it comes to good pizza . This is the best pizza in Florida their Sicilian pie is amazing . We have also had their calzones and they are outstanding. If you are in the area give them a try you won't be disappointed read more

Best pizza in St Augustine, bar none. The pizza is always hot, the pinwheels are always hearty, and the crust is never floppy.

They weren't making whole fresh pies, only had slices available. So it wasn't that great. Salad was fresh. We ate here before and had a fresh pie and it was great. read more

Customer service, location and cuisine are all equally amazing! The stuffed veggie pizza is amazing and I cannot wait to go back! Keep up the great work! Good food is hard to find and your team has nailed it! read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great location! Fantastic service. The staff were friendly and service was quick. The pizza and garlic knots were wonderful! Thanks ;)

Pretty good pizza, came with 6 garlic knots too! i was told it would be ready in 20 minutes but it took them 40 to get it out to me & the workers weren't the most inviting but i would go back! Was a little pricey for pizza but not horrible read more

St. Augie's Pizza - 16" pepperoni - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

My fiancé and I ordered Friday for the first time. AMAZING! Closest to NYC style pizza I've had outside of NYC. Definitely will be ordering again! read more

The pizza is good my wife and I was on our anniversary stop by and grab a slice and the service was great also they were some nice that work there read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Stop for a slice of pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Soooooo good! We came in and had a spinach calzone and GREAT wings. They were roasted so they were super juicy and flavorful, even though I got them naked. The staff is super friendly and helpful, the food is delicious and reasonably priced, the ambience is beautiful, and the restaurant is clean. This is a great place to stop for lunch or dinner while in St Augustine. I highly recommend! read more

See all

Amazing Pizza! Just like thin New York pizza! Absolutely the BEST pizza in St. Augustine! Owners are very friendly, great prices! Excellent choices of pizzas and really great Italian food. Wow!! Amazing Calzone!! First time having their Calzone, it was awesome! Unbelievably amazing crust, cheesy and full of spinach. Definitely real deal!! Love this place!! Great owners! Great prices!! Best of all the food!!! read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Spinach Calzone - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

A pizza place without working A/C is an automatic one star. They should be forced to be closed down until they fix the A/C. Disgraceful.

After a very bad customer experience at nearby Pizza Time, we decided to try St. Augie's. The parking lot was empty. I began to question if they were really as good as their Yelp reviews. They were. As we walked in, I noticed that they didn't have a lot of pizzas made. Maybe they were slow (on a Saturday afternoon?). The staff was very friendly and nice. The Brooklyn-Born employee gleefully warmed up our pizza and garlic rolls. Reasonably priced, we had two slices of pizza and three garlic knots for $8.55. The crust was crisp and the pizza wasn't greasy. The garlic knots were a little dry, but their delicious, authentic marinara sauce made up for it. St. Augie's is very friendly...and deserving of a full parking lot. read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Had a craving for pizza while visiting Saint Augustine. Found this on Yelp, as highly rated. The place is small, but clean. We ordered a large pizza for 2799, asked them to not add meatballs to the supreme, of which we ordered, but replace it with garlic. We were up charged for the substitution, which I found frustrating. I mean come on, meatballs or a heck of a lot more expensive than garlic. The crust appear to be homemade. And stretched to order. It was good, but not great. The pizza itself, was again good, but not $30 for an 18 inch pizza. The sauce was average Maybe a little too much oregano. The toppings were scarce. There was a good amount of people in and out of the restaurant while we were there. So people must enjoy it. Honestly we will not return. read more

Sunday night 7pm the girl at the counter and the guy making pizzas said they dont have cheese pizza by the slice because they are running low on cheese? Really wanted to try their pizza but they didnt have enough cheese to make a cheese pizza. Must be super awesome good. Sucks we couldnt try it. Edit: thanks for the apology. Sucks i am from out of town bc i did hear good things about your pizza. Just wondering what would have happened if i ordered a whole pie? Yall would have said sorry no cheese left? Just odd thats all. Good luck to yall. Hopefully others can try yall pizza. read more

Sooooo delicious and super quick service. We got there early, so there weren't any garlic knots prepared but I'm sure they would have been just as delicious as the pizza If they had them ready for customers upon opening. read more

The pizza was ok, had definitely been sitting out on the counter for hours and the garlic knots were a complete miss, they was extremely dry and hard. read more

Super nice people and great (quality and priced) pizza. Cool indoor vibe that's would be wonderful for families. read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Long Island, NY has made it's way to St. Augustine, FL! Located on King Steet on the way to historic downtown, you will find them in the same storefront as the Grand Royal Escape Room and the soon-to-be opened Donut Experiment. The owners were very friendly, the establishment was clean and the pizza was perfect! We had the buffalo chicken pizza and the crust was thin and crunchy, the sauce no overly hot. Delicious!!! If your heading downtown or coming back after a long day of touring, you will definitely want to stop by to get a slice or a pie. Hours of operation: Monday-Thursday 11am - 9pm Friday and Saturday 11am - 10pm Sun 12 pm - 9pm Student and Military discounts. Daily lunch special until 3pm- buy 2 slices get a free 16 oz fountain soda. read more

See all

Good pizza, calzones and pizza by the slice. The food was very good, seating was limited but they do have extra tables outdoors.

Great place to get a slice. Not too many god places to get a slice that has parking. Got a meat lovers slice

Went to visit my boy at school and grabbed some pizzas from here. Very good pizza at about the price you would expect for good pizza.

By far the best NY style pizza south of the Ohio river I been driving a truck for ovy20 years and I've had good pizza alot of places up north east But while on vacation I found this place and I promise you its the best you will find in the south Place was very very clean the owner went out of his way to please my wife cooked her the exact pizza she ask for As for the rest of the family they was there an was also super friendly and willing to help or accommodate us in any way So i want to thank them all for a great pizza and a great memory for me and the wife on our vacation read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I live in California and I was visiting my niece that attends Flagler College and we ordered pizza from here. I am not a huge fan of pizza so I was very pleased with the pie we ordered. My niece likes pepperoni and sausage so that is what we ordered. I normally only eat one piece of pizza; I had three and enjoyed all of them so much. Great place to get food from. read more

Not sure if it was an off night or what, but our 2 pizzas were mediocre at best last night. Ordered light cheese on our meatball pie and it seemed like it had extra cheese. The crust on both pizzas were oddly uneven, perfectly thin in the middle and terribly thicker as it got to the edge. I hope this was a one time experience. read more

With 30 minutes left before closing time, we stopped by St. Augie's Pizza hoping to grab a pie on the way back to our weekend rental unit. We walked through the front door and there was not a single person around. No customers. No employees. All of the chairs were flipped up on to the table in preparation for closing. The pizza may have been delicious, unfortunately, we'll never know. * I changed my review from one to three stars after speaking with the owner. It seems that they had a rough Grand Opening week and we caught them at the worst time. Next time we are in the area, I will revisit St.Augies for another chance. read more